DeSantis sued by ACLU over missing deadline to appoint new Tallahassee-area judge
The civil-rights group says it filed what's known as a petition for writ of mandamus with the Florida Supreme Court on July 3. It's a court order that compels an elected official to perform a certain action.
Nicholas Warren, a staff attorney with the ACLU of Florida, told the Tallahassee Democrat that DeSantis blew a constitutional deadline of June 29 to appoint a new circuit judge in the Big Bend's 2nd Judicial Circuit, replacing Robert Wheeler, who retired.
Maite Garcia, a Tallahassee-based attorney, is the petitioner in the lawsuit.
'Judges have the power to shape our lives, ruling on everything from custody disputes to serious criminal cases to violations of our constitutional rights," Garcia said in a statement. "This vacancy must be filled without delay to ensure access to justice and protect our community's right to elect a judge of our choosing.'
Because of election deadlines, the governor's delay may create extra time before his appointee has to run for the seat, the petition says. Circuit judges who are appointed must run as no party-candidates in the next general election. They then serve six-year terms.
"Had the Governor complied with his duty, his appointee's term would end on January 4, 2027, allowing voters to elect their candidate of choice at the 2026 election," it says. "If the Governor fails to fill this vacancy by August 18, 2025,his appointee may evade the electors until the 2028 election."
A request for comment is pending with the governor's office; state government was closed July 3 because DeSantis gave state workers the day off for a 4-day holiday weekend.
Among other things, circuit judges handle felony and juvenile cases and civil lawsuits worth $50,000 or more.
A judicial nominating commission has already sent DeSantis six finalists:
James A. Beville, an assistant state attorney based in Quincy.
C. Ian Garland, a lawyer in the Medicaid Fraud Control Unit of the Florida Attorney General's Office.
Jason Jones, a Leon County judge.
Stefanie Newlin, another Leon County judge.
Carlos Rey, general counsel for the Florida Senate.
Steven Sellers, an attorney with Tallahassee's O'Steen & O'Steen law firm.
'The governor's failure to comply with this clear constitutional deadline is just another example of him flouting our Constitution's clear mandates," said Nicholas Warren, a staff attorney with the ACLU of Florida. "We're suing ... to make him do the job he was elected to do.'
The 2nd Judicial Circuit, based in Tallahassee, includes Franklin, Gadsden, Jefferson, Leon, Liberty and Wakulla counties. According to the Office of the State Courts Administrator, as of the 2024-25 budget year, circuit judges were paid $196,898.04 per year.
More: Florida Gov. DeSantis to appoint new circuit judge for Tallahassee-area court
If you can't view the above document, click here.
Information on the applicants comes from The Florida Bar and online searches. This story contains previously published material. Jim Rosica can be reached at jrosica@tallahassee.com. Follow him on X: @JimRosicaFL.
This article originally appeared on Tallahassee Democrat: DeSantis sued for delay in filling 2nd Judicial Circuit seat
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Al Lawson says David Jolly lacks statewide support to win Florida governor
David Jolly is on notice: He has three months to prove he's built a coalition capable of winning the governor's mansion or Jolly will face a challenge from Al Lawson Jr., the Democratic dean of North Florida politics. Jolly, a former Republican Congressman turned Democrat, is seeking to revive a lifeless Florida Democratic Party that has lost seven consecutive gubernatorial races. The 52-year-old from St. Petersburg seeks to unify the Democrats' different factions. His candidacy so far helped pushed state Sen. Jason Pizzo to leave the party and mount an independent bid. It has Democratic mega-donor John Morgan waiting until next August to decide whether to run a self-financed campaign. And, in recent weeks, two of the Democrats' most significant voting blocs – women and Blacks – have pushed back at the Jolly campaign, revealing potential potholes for him on the campaign trail. Lawson, 77, represented Tallahassee and North Florida at both the state Capitol and in Washington for 32 years until Gov. Ron DeSantis and the Legislature redistricted his panhandle seat out of existence in 2022. He recently cast shade on a Jolly announcement that 60 elected and former elected Democratic officials endorsed his candidacy. Lawson said he too was asked to sign the endorsement but that he wanted to wait to see if anyone else would enter the race; the election is more than a year away. 'All these officials call me and tell me he might be our best shot, but your best shot does not mean you are going to win,' Lawson told the USA TODAY Network – Florida. A week ago, a Lawson email surfaced indicating Lawson thinks Jolly is failing to unify the Democratic base. The former Florida Senate Democratic leader wrote that African Americans were not 'happy' with the Jolly campaign. African Americans are 16% of Florida registered voters and gave more than 85% of their votes to the Democratic candidate in the last three presidential elections. The Lawson email emerged a week after a score of female Democratic influencers and elected officials quickly patched over concerns about Jolly's commitment to abortion rights. The Florida Women's Freedom Coalition political committee painted Jolly as a threat to abortion access. Women are 62% of Florida voters and 56% of the total Democratic base. Now nearly a week after his email surfaced, Lawson said he was still fielding calls from across the state, asking what was going on with the race and what his intentions are. He did not mention racial politics or follow up on his criticism that Jolly used to be a Republican in an interview, but he now has the impression that Jolly lacks statewide name recognition, such that 'nobody outside of Tampa knows who he is.' 'And that's a steep incline to climb. Maybe we need a good primary,' Lawson said. Lawson said he is still taking calls from supporters, talking to party officials and elected Democrats and watching the Jolly campaign. Come November, depending on what the polls indicate, he will make a decision whether to enter the race. It could set up an interesting scenario about whether Al Lawson could force David Jolly out of the Democratic primary. When Jolly launched his campaign earlier this year, he said he had benchmarks for polls and fundraising to meet by February 2026. Those numbers, he said, will determine his campaign's fate. Lawson's entrance into the race could affect polling and fundraising. Jolly said he has 'great respect' for Lawson and took the opportunity to smooth over the criticism from the veteran leader. 'My job as the candidate leading the Democratic coalition is to gain the support of Floridians across the state, including Al Lawson, to win the governorship,' Jolly said. James Call is a member of the USA TODAY NETWORK – Florida Capital Bureau. He can be reached at jcall@ and is on X as @CallTallahassee. This article originally appeared on Tallahassee Democrat: Al Lawson signals '26 bid for governor if Jolly can't unite Democrats
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Here are the top House Democrats at risk from GOP redistricting
House Democrats in red states across the country are at risk as the redistricting arms race heats up. Texas Republicans' proposed redraw, a President Trump-backed plan that could net the party five more House seats, has led to other red states moving forward with their own redistricting plans. Florida, Indiana and Missouri are among the Republican-led states now weighing whether to redo their congressional maps — putting a number of Democratic incumbents at risk. Here are the House Democrats most likely to be targeted across the country: Greg Casar, Texas 35th Republicans already control 25 of the 38 congressional seats in Texas, but the proposed changes could give them a 30-8 edge by slashing Democratic-controlled seats in Houston, Dallas and Austin-San Antonio. One of the biggest proposed changes affects Rep. Greg Casar's (D-Texas) 35th Congressional District, which went to former Vice President Harris by 33 points in November. The map would create a new +10 Trump district outside of San Antonio, according to analysis from Cook Political Report. Casar has called the would-be destruction of his district 'illegal voter suppression of Black and Latino Central Texans.' Lloyd Doggett, Texas 37th The Austin base of Casar's current district would be pushed into the 37th Congressional District, now held by Rep. Lloyd Doggett (D-Texas). The changes could set up a potential primary matchup between Casar and Doggett, who has accused Trump of 'taking a hatchet to chop up Austin and our state with the sole objective of maintaining his one-man rule.' Julie Johnson, Texas 32nd The Texas plan would reshape the 32nd Congressional District, currently based in Dallas and held by Rep. Julie Johnson (D-Texas). By stretching the district into East Texas, it would become a +18 Trump seat, according to the Cook Political Report. Johnson has been among the voices heralding Texas state House Democrats for fleeing the state to break quorum and stall 'a rigged map.' Marc Veasey, Texas 33rd Rep. Marc Veasey's would see his 33rd Congressional District likely remain blue, but the longtime lawmaker would probably lose his hometown and political base in the redrawing. This could create a primary between Veasey and Johnson as the latter's seat is reshaped, analysis from the Texas Tribune suggests, if they both decide to try and stay in the House. Henry Cuellar, Texas 28th Rep. Henry Cuellar's (D-Texas) seat in Texas's 28th Congressional District would shift rightward, from a +7 Trump district to a +10 post. The Cook Political Report says that Cuellar could 'conceivably survive' the midterms, though he's currently grappling with an ongoing criminal casethat could complicate any reelection prospects. Cuellar and his wife were indicted by a federal grand jury in Houston last year on charges of participating in a bribery scheme. Vicente Gonzalez, Texas 34th Like Cuellar, Rep. Vicente Gonzalez (D-Texas) would see his 34th Congressional District seat get even redder, according to the Cook Political Report. Gonzalez won reelection by just three points last year, so even a slight move toward the right could imperil reelection prospects. In a statement after the map's release, however, Gonzalez pointed to Trump's approval rating as he promised 'we will win again.' Al Green, Texas 9th Rep. Al Green's (D) seat in Texas's 9th Congressional District would merge with the empty blue seat vacated by the late Rep. Sylvester Turner (D), yielding a more conservative 9th district in the suburbs of east Houston. Al Green 'almost certainly wouldn't run' in the new 9th, the Cook Political Report forecasts, but he could run for the vacant 18th seat. Meanwhile, a special election is ongoing to fill the vacancy for Turner's former seat. Marcy Kaptur, Ohio 9th Ohio is the one state that's required to redistrict this year, after its 2022 maps failed to receive bipartisan support. Republicans boast a 10-5 majority in the current congressional delegation, and redistricting could mean a handful of Democrats see their districts get tougher. Rep. Mary Kaptur (D) in Ohio's 9th Congressional District is considered among the most vulnerable after winning a highly competitive race in 2024. Her district went to Trump by roughly 7 points last year, according to The Downballot. Emilia Sykes, Ohio 13th Like Kaptur, Rep. Emilia Sykes (D) in Ohio's 13th Congressional District won a tight race in 2024 and has been targeted by the GOP as a potential pickup opportunity. The district was effectively tied between Trump and Harris in November. 'It's no surprise that special interests in Washington and Columbus want to ignore the voters and rig the game,' Sykes campaign spokesman Justin Barasky told The Hill last month. Rep. Greg Landsman (D) in the 1st Congressional District around Cincinnati could also be impacted, according to the Columbus Dispatch, though anti-gerrymandering rules approved by voters in 2018 prevents redistricting from breaking up the city. Emanuel Cleaver, Missouri 5th Missouri's Republican Gov. Mike Kehoe has indicated he'll look at the possibility of redistricting in the state, where Republicans control six of eight districts. The Kansas City Star reported last month that Trump's political team had expressed interest in trying to gain another Show Me State seat, which would likely be Rep. Emmanuel Cleaver's 5th Congressional District in Kansas City. Cleaver, who has been in the seat for two decades, won reelection with 60 percent of the vote last fall, after line changes in 2022. He told St. Louis Public Radio that the push for mid-decade redistricting is 'very dangerous.' Frank Mrvan, Indiana 1st Republicans appear to be eyeing Indiana, where Democrats hold just two House seats, as another opening. Amid redistricting chatter, Vice President Vance met on Thursday with Gov. Mike Braun (R), who would need to call a special session of the state General Assembly to initiate redrawing. If Indiana were to redistrict, changes would likely squeeze the 1st Congressional District in the northwest, where Rep. Frank Mrvan (D) has already been named as a national GOP target for 2026. 'It is no surprise that some believe redistricting is the only option to cling to power when they know the American people are rejecting the damage done by the House Republican Majority,' Mrvan said in a statement. A redraw could also affect Mrvan's fellow Democrat, Rep. Andre Carson (D-Ind.), though the 7th Congressional District around Indianapolis may be somewhat safer, since breaking up blue voters in the area could make other Republican House districts more vulnerable. Republicans hold the other seven House seats in Indiana. Florida Democrats Florida's state House Speaker this week announced he'll form a redistricting committee after Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) signaled the Sunshine State could follow Texas's lead. There are just 8 House Democrats to 20 Republicans in Florida, and multiple blue seats could be endangered if a redraw moves forward. Republicans are hoping to gain at least three seats in the Sunshine State, Punchbowl News reported this week. One of the potential South Florida targets is Rep. Jared Moskowitz, who won reelection in November by five points in a district that went to Harris by just two points. Fellow South Florida Reps. Debbie Wasserman-Schultz and Lois Frankel could also be vulnerable, along with South Florida. Rep. Kathy Castor (D) in the Tampa area and Rep. Darren Soto (D) outside of Orlando. All five of these Democrats won their 2024 races with less than 60 percent of the vote. Moskowitz and Soto are already on the GOP campaign arm's target list. 'It's called corruption when the only reason to redraw the maps is to hold onto power cause y'all are going to lose in '26,' Florida Democratic Party Chair Nikki Fried said on X. Other lawmakers Amid the Texas drama, chatter is percolating about redistricting possibilities in still more states. An analysis from Sabato's Crystal Ball forecasts there could be room for changes in North Carolina, where a new 2024 map netted the GOP three new seats, and in Kansas, which has just one blue seat — though it's all but guaranteed that Kansas Gov. Laura Kelly (D) wouldn't call a special session to initiate talks. Republican Rep. Ralph Norman in South Carolina has suggested a redraw that could target longtime Rep. Jim Clyburn, the state's lone Democratic congressman, but the move is seen as unlikely given the already favorable 6-1 delegation split. With the exception of Ohio, it remains unclear which states will ultimately go through with redistricting, as Texas Democrats' dramatic quorum break stalls progress even in the Lone Star State. And even for those who do, it's not a guarantee that change could clear in time take effect before next fall's high-stakes midterms. Meanwhile, Democrats are looking to counter would-be GOP gains by weighing redistricting in blue strongholds, including California, where Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) has said he's moving forward with a plan to put redistricting before voters this fall, which would be triggered by what happens in Texas. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Solve the daily Crossword
Fox News
7 hours ago
- Fox News
Ghislaine Maxwell prison transfer called 'highly unusual' by former federal prison official
The former assistant director at the Federal Bureau of Prisons says that Jeffrey Epstein's accomplice's move to a minimum security prison is "highly unusual." Ghislaine Maxwell was transferred from a federal prison facility in Tallahassee, Florida, to a Federal Prison Camp in Bryan, Texas, her attorney previously told Fox News Digital. Neither the Bureau of Prisons nor Maxwell's attorney gave a reason for the move. Others at the female-only faculty, FPC Bryan, include Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes and celebrity housewife Jen Shah. The prison primarily houses white-collar criminals convicted of non-violent crimes. The move sparked criticism from the family of Virginia Giuffre, who said in a statement to Fox News they oppose the treatment Maxwell has been given. "It is with horror and outrage that we object to the preferential treatment convicted sex trafficker Ghislaine Maxwell has received," Giuffre's family wrote in a statement. "Ghislaine Maxwell is a sexual predator who physically assaulted minor children on multiple occasions, and she should never be shown any leniency. Yet, without any notification to the Maxwell victims, the government overnight has moved Maxwell to a minimum security luxury prison in Texas. This is the justice system failing victims right before our eyes." Judi Garrett, former assistant director at the Federal Bureau of Prisons, told Fox News Digital the transfer of Maxwell to FPC Bryan is "highly unusual." Garrett said it's "very rare" for a sex offender to be transferred to a minimum security facility like FPC Bryan, adding that traditionally, individuals designated as a sex offender cannot be placed inside a camp. "I am sure there were more than one, but it was very rare, and it required a tremendous amount of work to convince us at the Bureau of Prisons that that information initially contained in the pre-sentencing investigation report was somehow inaccurate, mischaracterized, etc," Garrett said. At federal prison camps like FPC Bryan, Garrett said that there's no fence, and prisoners aren't watched constantly. "Being that camps are minimum security, the notion is we don't have fear that the people are going to run off because they are unrestricted essentially," Garrett said. "You could leave whenever you want, there's no fence. We don't fear that you are gonna harm one another, and we don't have fear that you are going pose any kind of risk to the community. Minimal staffing so that people are not watching you all the time, supervising you all time." Since Maxwell is at a minimum-security prison camp, Garrett said it's not likely prison guards will be able to keep a closer eye on Maxwell versus other inmates. "Really hard to do in a camp, you just don't have staff there," she said. "I don't know, honestly, that there's a lot they can do, and I think that's probably what is giving them some heartburn, given her connection to Jeffrey Epstein." Dave Aronberg, former Palm Beach County State Attorney, previously told Fox News Digital Maxwell's new facility is more of a "dorm-style housing situation, rather than a cell." Maxwell's move to FPC Bryan comes a week after she met with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche at a courthouse in Florida to discuss her involvement with Epstein, whom she helped procure underage girls for him to abuse. A senior administration official previously told Fox News that "Any false assertion this individual was given preferential treatment is absurd. Prisoners are routinely moved in some instances due to significant safety and danger concerns."
