‘Why do people leave early…' NHAI lawyer's shocking remark after 3 die amid 40 hr traffic jam in MP stirs debate
"Why do people even leave home so early without any work?" a report by NDTV quoted the NHAI lawyer. Both judiciary and the public were surprised by his statement.
The lawyer's comments come during the hearing of a case regarding a massive traffic jam stretching more than eight kilometres, where over 4,000 vehicles were stranded on Friday, June 27. Three people lost their lives. Kamal Panchal, 62, from Indore, reportedly died of a heart attack caused by the heat inside the vehicle. The other two deceased were identified as Balram Patel, 55, and Sandeep Patel, 32, the report said.
Sumit Patel, nephew of Balram Patel, expressed his disappointment on the NHAI lawyer's comment. "No one has the time to roam the streets without reason. We were on the road trying to save a life — my uncle's. If an NHAI official had been stuck like us, they'd understand the trauma," NDTV quoted him.
Following the lawyer's remark, advocate Anand Adhikari filed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) in the Madhya Pradesh High Court. He was also stuck in the same traffic on June 27.
On Monday, June 30, the Bench consisting of Justice Vivek Rusia and Justice Binod Kumar Dwivedi heard the case. The court ordered that several parties be added as respondents, including NHAI (Delhi and Indore divisions), the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, the Indore Collector, the Indore Police Commissioner, the road construction company, and Indore Dewas Tollways Ltd, the report stated.
The court reiterated a September 2024 order, telling NHAI to complete the diversion road within four weeks. However, the road remains unfinished. NHAI attributed the delay to a 10-day strike by crusher units despite having previously requested up to four months for the project. The report stated that the judges seemed unsatisfied by this explanation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
Female teacher sexually assaults teen
Mumbai: The Mumbai Police have arrested a female teacher under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act for allegedly coercing a minor male student into a sexual relationship, as per officials. The accused has been taken into custody, while another teacher, who allegedly assisted her, is currently absconding. A case has been registered in connection with the incident. According to a NDTV report, the accused woman is an English teacher in a school and taught the student when he was in Class XI. She told police that she got attracted to the teenager during various meetings to set up a dance group for the annual school function in December 2023. She also made sexual gestures to the student in January 2024. According to the report quoting a police officer, the teacher asked one of her female friends for help to pursue the victim.
The Print
12 hours ago
- The Print
CM Sukhu should resign on moral grounds: BJP
In a press statement issued by Nanda, he said that if CM Sukhu is not able to run the government then he should step aside and let the BJP run the government in the state. Nanda said that the law and order in the state is in doldrums and CM Sukhu, who is also the Home Minister of the state, should resign on moral grounds. Shimla, Jul 2 (PTI) BJP state media in-charge Karna Nanda on Wednesday lashed out at Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu-led government over Rural Development and Panchayati Raj Minister Anirudh Singh allegedly beating up National Highway Authority of India (NHAI) official. Nanda further said that a government employee of NHAI, Jindal, was allegedly assaulted by the panchayati raj minister of Himachal Pradesh along with six other associates which is a highly condemnable act. 'When the employees' union raised the issue with Union Minister Nitin Gadkari, he wrote a letter to the CM seeking an appropriate action. Although an FIR was lodged against the minister, it was under minor charges. As a result, the minister, who is now agitated, is making baseless statements,' he said. He further said, 'The actions and statements of the minister are more like those of a thug or a local panchayat head. The minister doesn't even seem to trust the state's law and order, which is why he took the matter in his own hands. If there was any truth to the allegations made by him, he should have filed a complaint in the first place.' PTI/COR MNK MNK This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
New Indian Express
15 hours ago
- New Indian Express
PIL filed in MP HC after three die in 32-hour traffic jam; notice to advocate over 'why leave early' remark
BHOPAL: The deaths of three men, aged 32 to 65, after reportedly being stuck in an over 30-hour, 8-km traffic jam on Indore-Dewas Highway have prompted a PIL in the MP High Court's Indore Bench. The PIL was recently filed by Dewas-based advocate Anand Adhikari. While the High Court issued notices to the respondents, including the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) asking to file their replies in the matter before July 7, during the course of the hearing on Monday, the counsel representing the NHAI (which is tasked with maintaining the nation's network) left everyone shell-shocked by casually questioning, 'Why do people even leave home so early without any work?' While confirming that the bizarre comment was made by the NHAI counsel during Monday's hearing, the petitioner's counsel Girish Patwardhan said, 'Yes, the comment was made verbally by the advocate. The HC responded that the reasoning was not acceptable, as it would mean that citizens could no longer step out of their homes.' Coming to know about the NHAI counsel's casual comment in open court, Sumit Patel, the nephew of one of the deceased men, expressed shock and anger. 'How can such an insensitive statement be made by a responsible person before the court?' he asked, speaking to journalists on Wednesday. Sumit said they had not left home a pleasure trip, but to save the life of his critically ill uncle, 55-year-old Balram Patel, who died after both oxygen cylinders in their vehicle were exhausted due to the long traffic jam. He questioned whether the NHAI counsel would have made the same remark had the tragedy involved the kin of someone from the NHAI. "We condemn the casual comment made by the counsel for the NHAI in the court,' he said. d service roads and absence of adequate traffic diversion plan.
