What will Ireland's costly five-year schools abuse inquiry achieve?
Government
has announced the establishment of an
inquiry into sexual abuse in all schools, primary and second level
. Now people who suffered physical abuse are asking, 'what about us?'
Four categories of abuse are used in classifying abuse – sexual, physical, emotional, and neglect. In the legal world, a
claim of sexual abuse
appears to have top billing when it comes to redress, but that should not take from the fact that the effects of any abuse, experienced as a child, can be difficult to measure.
When we consider the hurt caused by verbal abuse, mockery, classroom humiliation, exclusion, we realise that these experiences can have lifelong consequences for the individual and society.
Social class played a part in the abuse in
schools
.
READ MORE
Noted Brazilian educator Paulo Freire, writing about oppressors versus the oppressed, made the point that very few, if any, are capable of overcoming the views and prejudices of the class into which they were born.
Teachers in schools, be they religious or secular, tended to come from middle class origins and many took the view that it did not matter if one treated the children of the poor differently from the those whose parents were better off, parents with whom the teachers could more easily identify.
This was relevant from the foundation of the primary school system in the 19th century, though it began to change gradually in the 1960s and with the introduction of free education.
It is questionable what a five-year, costly Government inquiry, which will divert financial and personnel resources from the educational budget, will achieve. If the net of inquiries of past abuses continues to be widened, will a point of closure ever be reached?
We know that abuse happens in families. Will future governments trawl through every family in the land so that every child who was ever abused in any setting is going to have a voice?
[
'I'm angry that my abuse as a child does not count' – State must pay for school sexual abuse
Opens in new window
]
Minister for Education Helen McEntee said institutions and religious orders involved in historical sex abuse in schools will be "held accountable" for the "awful" crimes. Photograph: Cate McCurry/ PA Wire
Presumably the inquiry will identify those who allege abuse. Will it then have the task of assessing the truth of any allegation? Will it presume that all allegations are true? There is the question of natural justice, whereby the accused has the right of reply to his/ her accuser. Having verified whether an allegation is credible (and there is a difference between credibility and truth) there is the question of who will bear the cost of redress. And we need to ask ourselves, and those who represent us in Government, if 'giving a voice' actually brings healing. It may – but being the public voice that represents all those who suffered could also serve to lock one into the hurt.
Tánaiste Simon Harris has insisted that the religious organisations will have to pay and the Opposition are adamant that they have 'got away' with not paying.
Religious organisations have already paid some money and handed over buildings. There has not been any calculation of the money and salaries that wereploughed back into schools. This might be as immeasurable as the degree of abuse.
The reality of child abuse within and without the churches has been revealed and openly debated for the past 30 years. It has shattered the institution of the Catholic Church and, in many ways, has been as transformative as the Reformation was in the 16th century. The credibility of the Church of Rome has been marred, possibly beyond repair.
But there may come a point where we are in danger of ignoring present abuses in favour of scrutiny of the past.
Finally, questions must be raised about school management. The greater number of our schools are under the management of the Catholic Church. The pay back in terms of church practice and adult belief seem minimal. The passing on of faith is primarily the role of the family.
This is the time for the Catholic hierarchy to hand back the schools to the State.
Margaret Lee is a retired Principal Social Worker with experience in Child and Family Services, as well as on Child Protection Committee.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
10 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Man (49) with injuries found dead in Co Tipperary house
A man with a number of injuries has been found dead in a house in Carrick-on-Suir in Co Tipperary early on Monday morning. The man (49) was found by gardaí and family members in a house in the Ravenswood area of the town. He was pronounced dead at the scene by a local GP. Gardaí have begun an investigation. Gardaí immediately cordoned off the area and requested the services of the State Pathologist's office and crime scene examiners from the Garda Technical Bureau. READ MORE Gardaí have begun door-to-door enquiries to try to establish when the man was last seen alive and whether anyone heard any disturbance at the house in the 150-house estate. They have also begun canvassing houses in the area to see whether there is any CCTV footage that would help them identify anyone who may have entered the house. Gardaí say the investigation will be guided by the postmortem that is expected to take place at University Hospital Waterford later today.
Sunday World
15 minutes ago
- Sunday World
Electronic data to be analysed in triple murder-suicide probe
Ms Whyte (45) and her two children, James (14) and Sara (13), died from gunshot injuries inflicted at their Maguiresbridge home on July 23 The coffins of murder victims Vanessa Whyte and her children Sara and James Rutledge are carried from St Mary's Church in Maguiresbridge, Co Fermanagh, following a service of removal. Photo: Liam McBurney/PA Wire Vanessa Whyte with her children Sara and James Rutledge. Photo: PSNI/PA Northern Ireland authorities believe triple murder suspect Ian Rutledge moved back into the Fermanagh home of his wife Vanessa Whyte and their two teenage children after his family became aware of his deteriorating eyesight. PSNI detectives are investigating whether the suspected triple murder-suicide had been planned in advance by the former truck driver – or whether it was triggered by a dispute in the family home. Ms Whyte (45) and her two children, James (14) and Sara (13), died from gunshot injuries inflicted at their Maguiresbridge home on July 23. The only suspect in the triple shooting, Rutledge (43), was discovered by PSNI officers at the property with gunshot wounds. He died in hospital last Monday from his injuries. The former agricultural contractor had suffered catastrophic brain injuries. He was Ms Whyte's husband and the father of James and Sara. Ian Rutledge A legally held firearm was recovered from the scene. The PSNI believe Rutledge shot his wife and children before turning the firearm on himself. Ms Whyte – who is survived by her mother, Mary, and her siblings, Geraldine, Regina, Anita, Ivor and Stephen – was buried alongside her two children in her native Clare last Saturday. Friends and family hailed her as a kind-hearted and caring individual who was devoted to her family. One friend said that trying to help someone in need was second nature to Ms Whyte. Thousands attended the funeral in Barefield, Co Clare. There were emotional scenes as the three coffins were carried into the Church of the Immaculate Conception, the church where Ms Whyte made her holy communion and confirmation. The University College Dublin veterinary studies graduate had planned to travel back to her native Clare for the August bank holiday weekend with her children to visit her family and attend some Clare hurling championship matches. The only comfort we have is that Vanessa, James and Sara are together and finally safe She was a lifelong Clare hurling fan and attended the 2024 All-Ireland final with her children. The funeral had guards of honour from GAA clubs in Clare, Galway and Fermanagh. Ms Whyte's sister, Regina, said she had been taken from the world and her loving children in a cruel and vicious manner. 'For us, as a family, the only comfort we have is that Vanessa, James and Sara are together and finally safe,' she said. The coffins of murder victims Vanessa Whyte and her children Sara and James Rutledge are carried from St Mary's Church in Maguiresbridge, Co Fermanagh, following a service of removal. Photo: Liam McBurney/PA Wire The Bishop of Ferns, Ger Nash, who was previously a cleric in Killaloe, noted that the Whyte family had asked people to wear bright colours in tribute to Ms Whyte and her two children. Outside the church, three flagpoles had the Irish, Clare and St Joseph's- Doora Barefield colours flying at half mast. Dozens of balloons in the saffron and blue colours of Clare surrounded the three coffins, with Ms Whyte's coffin covered by the maroon and white colours of St Joseph's-Doora Barefield, the club her late father and two brothers proudly played for. 'We need that light,' Bishop Nash said. He told mourners that darkness cannot overcome light for those of faith. 'It is hinted at in the bright colours that Vanessa, James and Sara's family have asked people to wear.' 'The darkness will not conquer.' Dozens of mourners attended from Fermanagh, where a special memorial service for the mother and children was held last Wednesday evening. The PSNI are now trawling through all electronic data from mobile phones and computers to determine the precise sequence of events that led to the deaths. Detectives are aware that Rutledge had been experiencing depression over recent weeks and months.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
E-scooter driver dies following late-night collision
A man in his 30s has died following a collision between his electric scooter and a car in Dublin on Sunday night. Gardaí said they attended the scene of the two-vehicle collision, which occurred at about 10.50pm on the Old Navan Road in Blanchardstown, Dublin 15. The e-scooter driver was taken to James Connolly Hospital where he was pronounced dead. No other injuries have been reported. A Garda spokesperson appealed for witnesses or anyone with camera footage of the area at the time to come forward. READ MORE The road was closed for a period for examination but has since reopened.
