‘Citizens must know the value of freedom of expression': SC flags divisive social media content
'The citizens must know the value of the fundamental right of freedom of speech and expression. The State can step in case of violations… Nobody wants the State to step in (sic),' Justice Nagarathna said.
The statement, appearing to be aimed towards regulating offensive posts on social media, was made while a bench comprising Justices B V Nagarathna and K V Viswanathan was hearing a plea of Wazahat Khan, whose complaint, for allegedly making communal remarks in a video, led to influencer Sharmistha Panoli's arrest on May 30.
Khan himself, is also booked in FIRs in several states, including West Bengal, Maharashtra and Haryana, for his objectionable posts on X against a Hindu deity, and was arrested on Jun 9.
Following this, he moved the supreme court. The FIRs were in retaliation to a complaint filed by him against Panoli, who was arrested and later released on bail, he countered.
"I have deleted all of them and apologised," his counsel said, submitting Khan was perhaps "reaping what he has sown".
Offensive comments should not be made in response to similar posts, his lawyer said in court.
On June 23, supreme court granted him interim protection from coercive action till July 14, i.e. tomorrow.
Does 'self regulation' mean censorship?
The bench clarified that the statement did not imply censorship.
"There should be fraternity among citizens," the bench said, as it considered framing guidelines on freedom of speech and expression for citizens.
The bench underlined the reasonable restrictions under Article 19 (2) of the Constitution on freedom of speech and expression, saying they had "rightly been placed".
What will happen to Wazahat Khan?
The court extended Khan's interim protection from arrest till the next hearing of the case.
The bench also asked the counsel to address larger issue of self regulation of freedom of speech and expression of citizens.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
19 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Shah to move resolution in RS for extension of President's rule in Manipur
Rajya Sabha is set to take up significant legislative and procedural business, including a statutory resolution seeking the extension of President's Rule in Manipur and the consideration of the Carriage of Goods by Sea Bill, 2025. Union Home Minister Amit Shah will move a resolution for approval of the continuance in force of the Proclamation dated February 13, 2025, in respect of Manipur, issued under Article 356 of the Constitution by the President, for a further period of six months with effect from August 13, 2025, according to the List of Business issued by the Rajya Sabha. The President's rule was imposed in Manipur on February 13, days after N Biren Singh resigned from the Chief Minister's position. Rajya Sabha will also take up the further consideration for the passing of the Carriage of Goods by Sea Bill, 2025, moved by Union Minister for Ports, Shipping and Waterways, Sarbananda Sonowal on July 23. The Bill, which has already been passed by the Lok Sabha, seeks to provide for the responsibilities, liabilities, rights and immunities of carriers in relation to the carriage of goods by sea, and for matters connected therewith. Additionally, Union Minister Chandra Sekhar Pemmasani and Ravneet Singh are expected to make statements regarding the status of implementation of recommendations made by various Parliamentary Committees, particularly in departments of Rural Development and Railways. Union Minister L Murugan will make a statement regarding the government business for the coming week, according to the list of business. Meanwhile, in Lok Sabha, Union Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal moved the Readjustment of Representation of Scheduled Tribes in Assembly Constituencies of the State of Goa Bill, 2024, for further consideration and passing. Additionally, Sarbananda Sonowal will move the Merchant Shipping Bill, 2024, to update and unify existing law to align with international maritime treaties. Both Houses of Parliament have witnessed heated exchanges and adjournments during the initial days of the Monsoon Session, but are expected to proceed with key legislative business today. The session is scheduled to continue until August 21.
Hans India
19 minutes ago
- Hans India
Rahul to protest 'theft of votes' at Freedom Park
Bengaluru: Top Congress leader Rahul Gandhi will lead the party's protest meeting at the Freedom Park here on August 5, against the alleged incidents of 'theft of votes', Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister D K Shivakumar said on Thursday. Following the protest, a select group of party leaders will go to the Election Commission office here and submit a memorandum. Amid the raging row over the revision of electoral rolls in Bihar, Rahul Gandhi, Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha, had alleged that elections were being 'stolen' in the country and that his party had figured out the modus operandi of the 'votes' theft' by studying a parliamentary constituency in Karnataka. 'On August 5, we are organising a protest meeting. Chief Minister Siddaramaiah, myself, AICC general secretary Randeep Singh Surjewala, all our Ministers, legislators have discussed on how and where to organise it. It is the opinion of everyone that we organise this protest meeting at the Freedom Park,' Shivakumar said. Speaking to reporters, he said a memorandum will be submitted to the EC officials in the state. 'We will organise this protest within the framework of law and rules laid down, abiding by the directions of the court. We will not violate. We don't want to disturb anyone,' he said, as he called on the party workers and leaders from across the state to participate in the protest. Shivakumar, along with Surjewala and other leaders, held deliberations regarding the nature of the protest and the venue, considering 'technical issues' and court directives for holding such events in the city. Later they inspected the protest meeting venue -- Freedom Park. Clarifying that there won't be any mega foot march, the KPCC chief said, 'we will gather at the Freedom Park and after the protest meeting and address by leaders, a select five to six leaders will go to the Election Commission office here and submit a memorandum.' Asked if the leaders, who will submit the memorandum, would march to the EC office from Freedom Park, he said, 'we may go by foot or by vehicle, we will abide by the police instructions based on the situation.' Noting that there were lots of examples for 'votes theft', and the Congress had done research on this, Shivakumar said. 'Our leader (Rahul Gandhi) will inform you about all this.' 'This protest is to safeguard -- the right to vote, the Constitution and the democracy,' he said, adding, Rahul Gandhi was coming for this cause, despite the Parliament session. 'We had earlier identified several faults (in the election process) during the Assembly elections and then during the parliament polls. We are doing this protest to inform people about it,' he added. Responding to BJP's questions as to why the Congress did not approach the Election Commission when the draft rolls were issued, Shivakumar said, 'We had objected but the Election Commission did not accept it. In Mahadevapura constituency, Congress candidate Nagesh and his son produced documents. The same thing happened in Dinesh Gundu Rao's constituency in Gandhinagar, where around 7,000 voters were added in one are so many examples. We have documents to prove...'
Hans India
19 minutes ago
- Hans India
‘Big drama': BJP on Rahul Gandhi's protest plan
Bengaluru: Calling the Leader of the Opposition (LoP) in Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi's plan for protest against alleged election fraud in Bengaluru a 'big drama', the Karnataka BJP said on Thursday that the Congress introduced irregularities in elections, asserting that such a party cannot make allegations about election irregularities. Karnataka Leader of the Opposition R. Ashoka claimed that it was proven in court that former Prime Minister late Indira Gandhi herself committed election irregularities. 'Rahul Gandhi's visit to Karnataka on August 5 is a big drama. There is no government functioning here. Instead, there is a fight for the Chief Minister's chair. To cover that up, the issue of election irregularities is being raised,' he claimed. Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar has announced that a protest against alleged voter fraud will be held under the leadership of the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, at Freedom Park in Bengaluru on August 5. Ashoka said that allegations were being made so many years after the election, without going to court when they happened, adding that this was being done to cover up zero development in Karnataka. 'If there was evidence, they would have gone to the court. Since there is no evidence, they are taking to the streets and protesting. When the Lok Sabha elections were held in the state, Congress was in power. They should specify which official did this,' he said. On the honey trap, Karnataka LoP said that the case created a ruckus in the Assembly, and the government had given a report saying that this incident never happened. 'The Minister's words have no value. Whatever a Minister says becomes the government's statement. Such statements have been put into a washing machine and cleaned. It is not known whose pressure is on the police. This government is covering up irregularities,' he said. Ashoka further stated that the drug mafia had grown in Mysuru, the native of CM Siddaramaiah. 'The Home Department is not taking any action. As a result of all this, such a drug peddling network had come to light. Maharashtra police coming here and making arrests is an insult to our police department,' he said. On fertiliser crisis claims, Ashoka asked, "How much fertiliser has come to the state every month? How much stock is there? How much has been allocated to which district? The state government should provide information. Instead of delivering the stocked fertiliser to farmers, the government has handed it over to middlemen." On the Malegaon blast case, Karnataka LoP said that the Congress government imposed the case on Hindus and coined the term Hindu terrorism. 'By portraying Hindus as terrorists to appease Muslims, Congress has faced embarrassment,' claimed Ashoka.
