Manitoba collects only 17 per cent of monetary value of COVID-19 fines
In total, 3,723 tickets worth $9,529,317 in fines were issued for violations of provincial and federal pandemic restrictions that limited gathering sizes, for example.
As of May 31, $1,616,408 had been collected for tickets issued under the Provincial Offences Act for provincial statute offences, federal contraventions and municipal bylaw offences. More than half of the tickets have been dealt with or dismissed and 1,512 tickets were unpaid and sent to collection agencies.
In April 2021, when Manitoba was averaging more than 150 COVID-19 deaths a day, then-Tory premier Brian Pallister promised that rule-breakers would pay a financial penalty.
'I will say to those folks: you will pay your fine, and if you do not, you will not be driving your car,' Pallister said after beefing up enforcement of pandemic rules intended to reduce the spread of COVID-19, including the threat to take driver's licences away.
While the province dropped nearly all pandemic response restrictions in March 2022, those unpaid fines remain on the books.
Manitoba Public Insurance said Tuesday the registrar of motor vehicles can refuse to issue or renew a driver's licence, vehicle registration or permit and refuse to accept payment on a person's driver's licence or vehicle registration if that customer has unpaid provincial fines.
The Crown corporation spokesperson could not say how many licences or registrations have been refused specifically because of outstanding COVID-19 fines because MPI doesn't track the type of unpaid tickets.
Patrick Allard, an outspoken violator of the public health orders, who was given seven years to pay his fines, said the province should forgive them and refund people who've already paid their tickets.
Allard said the public mood has shifted and many moderate Manitobans now believe the orders were too stringent and had penalties that were too harsh.
'I think, now, we're far enough away from what was happening and the majority of people are looking at it in a different way,' Allard said Tuesday. 'They may realize that the government was too heavy-handed — ticketing people (for) going to church, as an example.'
'I will say to those folks: you will pay your fine, and if you do not, you will not be driving your car.'–Then-Tory premier Brian Pallister
Allard was one of five Manitobans convicted of repeatedly violating public health orders intended to curb the spread of the virus.
They organized, attended or spoke at anti-lockdown rallies in Winnipeg, Steinbach and Winkler — which was a breach of restrictions on outdoor gatherings — between November 2020 and May 2021.
'Just because you lose a court case doesn't mean you should just give up and sell the farm,' said Allard, whose fines total around $35,000 and are due in 2029.
He called on the NDP government to declare an 'amnesty' on COVID-19 fines.
'I think it would be a small price to pay to turn the page.'
Allard said the public health orders were deeply divisive and made a stressful time even worse. Now the fines are adding to financial pressure faced by many Manitobans, he said.
'I think it would be a small price to pay to turn the page.'–Patrick Allard
Failing to comply with a public health emergency order in Manitoba, for example, resulted in fines of $1,296 for a first offence and $2,542 for subsequent offences for individuals and $5,000 for businesses.
Failing to wear a mask in a public place netted fines of $298 for a first ticket and $486 for subsequent tickets.
Violations of the federal statutes under the Quarantine Act included a $1,453 fine for failing to present oneself to a screening officer at the nearest entry point. Failing to comply with an order regarding a treatment or a measure to prevent the introduction and spread of a communicable disease netted a fine of $5,150.
Allard said it's time for the provincial government to forgive them.
'People are looking back and saying 'maybe it was a little bit stupid, putting on a mask to walk into a restaurant just to sit down and take it off.' I think everybody — besides your hard-core holdouts — are looking back now and saying 'Yeah, that was kind of ridiculous',' he said.
'I don't think it would be a bad political move for the NDP to do this because I don't think they would lose any fans. They would gain some moderates,' said the aspiring politician who has vowed to run in the 2027 provincial election.
Tuesdays
A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world.
In late 2023, the NDP was elected to government, replacing the Tories.
On Tuesday, Justice Minister Matt Wiebe was not available for an interview to discuss COVID-19 fines. A spokesperson for the minister said the fines issued during the COVID-19 pandemic will not be forgiven.
Of the 3,723 tickets issued, 2,129 were disposed because the ticket had been paid, or it was disputed and the court dismissed it, or a Crown attorney stayed proceedings.
In total, 1,512 were not paid on time and were forwarded to collection agencies.
Eighty-two are considered 'active,' where a defendant may be in a time-to-pay period following an admission or conviction.
The legislation states that the amount of an unpaid fine for provincial offences or federal contraventions is a debt due to the government. Payments on fines as a result of collections activities may occur for months or years following a conviction.
carol.sanders@freepress.mb.ca
Carol SandersLegislature reporter
Carol Sanders is a reporter at the Free Press legislature bureau. The former general assignment reporter and copy editor joined the paper in 1997. Read more about Carol.
Every piece of reporting Carol produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Ottawa Citizen
12 hours ago
- Ottawa Citizen
City of Ottawa four years behind in releasing greenhouse gas emissions reports
Article content In a July 29 email statement to the Ottawa Citizen, Capital ward Coun. Shawn Menard, who is chair of the city's Environment and Climate Change committee, said he would also like to see the updates of the emissions figures and has been asking city staff to provide them. Article content 'I understand they went back to ensure consistency with how they collected the data and that these should be released soon,' Menard said. 'I have been steadfast in requesting this information.' Article content Coun. Marty Carr, who represents Alta Vista ward, said the reports would be tabled with the committee sometime this fall, ideally before budget discussions. She said the committee would be conducting a 'high-level overview' of advancements on climate change-related projects. Article content Carr, who is also vice-chair of the Environment and Climate Change committee, said the department responsible for climate change-related reports and initiatives had been reorganized after dealing with 'temporary resources.' Article content Article content Nichole Hoover-Bienasz, the city's director of Climate Change and Resiliency, said the delay in releasing updated greenhouse gas inventories since 2021 was due to a 'comprehensive third-party review of the 2020 data to ensure accuracy and alignment with best practices. Article content 'Dillon Consulting Ltd. was engaged to review the methodology and calculate the 2021 and 2022 inventories,' she said in a July 30 email. 'City staff are now finalizing the 2023 and 2024 inventories based on these recommendations.' Article content Hoover-Bienasz also said that Ottawa's community emissions had been trending back to pre-pandemic levels due to 'resumed in-person activities.' The 2020 emissions inventory report found that the COVID-19 pandemic significantly reduced emissions, with a 30-per-cent drop in gasoline use between 2019 and 2020. Article content 'The city continues to advance work to address emissions through the implementation of Climate Change Master Plan, including key priorities such as the Energy Evolution Strategy and Climate Resiliency Strategy,' she said. Article content Article content Carr said these reports would also be crucial for making budget and financial decisions from an 'environmental point of view. Article content 'That'll be really important for us to be able to measure to see what's actually happening because we obviously set a lot of targets that we've not been able to see if we've met at all,' Carr said. 'We know of steps that the city has been in different initiatives that they put forward, but we haven't been able to have staff see that, to be able to analyze the data and come to conclusions.
Winnipeg Free Press
13 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Army secretary directs West Point to rescind appointment of Biden-era cybersecurity director
NEW YORK (AP) — The Secretary of the Army on Wednesday directed the U.S. Military Academy at West Point to review its hiring practices, bar outside groups from choosing employees and remove a newly announced hire who led the nation's cybersecurity agency under President Joe Biden. The directive, shared on the social platform X by Secretary Dan Driscoll, came just a day after Jen Easterly was announced as the Robert F. McDermott Distinguished Chair in West Point's social sciences department. It demonstrated how vigorously President Donald Trump's administration has sought to wield control over the ideology and leadership of higher education and the military during the president's second term. It also highlighted how deeply concerns about censorship have seeped into the Republican Party and the Trump administration. As the director of the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, or CISA, Easterly faced harsh criticism from Republicans who argued that her work to counter misinformation about elections and the COVID-19 pandemic amounted to censorship. CISA secures the nation's critical infrastructure, including the nation's dams, banks and nuclear power plants. It also secures voting systems — work that became controversial as Trump has made false claims to create doubt about the integrity of elections in recent years. Easterly has denied claims that her agency censored anyone and said last fall that 'allegations against CISA are riddled with factual inaccuracies.' She said in January she hopes the agency will be allowed to continue its election-related work despite 'contentiousness' around that part of its mission. Driscoll's directive came after far-right activist Laura Loomer posted about Easterly's new role on X, saying 'Biden holdovers' at the Defense Department were 'undermining' Trump's administration. Loomer has frequently urged Trump's administration to purge staffers she deems insufficiently loyal to his agenda, and on multiple occasions, they have been fired. The memo directs West Point to terminate Easterly's agreement with the institution and 'immediately pause non-governmental and outside groups from selecting employees of the Academy, including instructors, professors, teachers and shaping academic or developmental lectures.' It also requests an immediate review of the military training academy's hiring practices. Asked for a reason for the memo, an Army spokesperson said in a statement that ahead of the new academic year, 'we are crafting a deliberate approach to ensure that our future officers are best prepared to meet the demands of the modern battlefield.' Pentagon spokesperson Sean Parnell was more blunt about the reasoning in a post on X. 'We're not turning cadets into censorship activists,' he said. 'We're turning them into warriors & leaders. We're in the business of warfighting.' Easterly, an Army combat veteran and West Point graduate, didn't immediately respond to a request for comment on Wednesday. ___
Winnipeg Free Press
13 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Another Trump administration figure who met Laura Loomer's ire is out. A look at her influence
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — President Donald Trump has downplayed the influence of Laura Loomer, a right-wing provocateur known for her incendiary social media presence, in his administration's decision-making. But the list of administration officials who have drawn Loomer's ire and swiftly thereafter gotten the ax from Trump has been growing. The latest was Dr. Vinay Prasad, the Food and Drug Administration's polarizing vaccine chief, who announced this week he was leaving the agency after a brief tenure that drew the ire of biotech executives, patient groups and conservative allies of Trump. Prasad had recently become a target of right-wing activists, including Loomer, who flagged Prasad's past statements criticizing Trump and praising liberal independent Sen. Bernie Sanders. Loomer, who has publicly encouraged Trump to purge aides who she believes are insufficiently loyal to the 'Make America Great Again' agenda, has taken credit for some of the ousters, tearing into some of Trump's allies and advisers and calling out what she calls a 'vetting crisis' within the White House. Trump, meanwhile, has long praised Loomer while distancing himself at times from her most controversial comments and downplaying her direct impact on his choices. Here's a rundown on connections between Loomer's criticism and Trump administration departures: Vocal opposition to Health and Human Services appointees Two people familiar with the situation told The Associated Press that Prasad was ousted following several recent controversies. The people spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss internal personnel matters. Last week, Loomer posted on X of Prasad, 'How did this Trump-hating Bernie Bro get into the Trump admin???' Prasad did not immediately respond to requests for comment Wednesday morning. He joined the FDA in May after years as an academic researcher at the University of California, San Francisco, where he frequently criticized the FDA's approach to drug approvals and COVID-19 vaccines. Loomer was also vocal in opposition to Trump's first choice for surgeon general, whose selection was ultimately withdrawn. Trump pulled the nomination of former Fox News medical contributor Janette Nesheiwat just before Senate confirmation hearings in May. Loomer had posted on X that 'we can't have a pro-COVID vaccine nepo appointee who is currently embroiled in a medical malpractice case and who didn't go to medical school in the US' as the surgeon general. Prompting departures at the National Security Council On April 3, Loomer presented 'research findings' to Trump, Vice President JD Vance, chief of staff Susie Wiles and others including then-national security adviser Mike Waltz, during an Oval Office meeting, according to people speaking on condition of anonymity to discuss personnel matters. A day later, Trump said he had fired 'some' White House National Security Council officials, downplaying Loomer's influence on the moves. The departures included the director of the National Security Agency, Air Force Gen. Tim Haugh, who also oversaw the Pentagon's Cyber Command, along with Haugh's civilian deputy at the NSA, Wendy Noble. When reached for comment, Loomer referred The Associated Press to an X post, saying she was not going to divulge any details about her Oval Office meeting with Trump 'out of respect' for the president. In a subsequent X post, Loomer appeared to take credit for the firings, writing, 'You know how you know the NSC officials I reported to President Trump are disloyal people who have played a role in sabotaging Donald Trump?' She noted, 'the fired officials' were being defended by Trump critics on CNN and MSNBC. Loomer called for Waltz's ouster in the weeks following revelations he had mistakenly added The Atlantic's editor-in-chief to a Signal chat being used to discuss military plans. As reports began to circulate that Waltz could be leaving the administration — he was ultimately nominated as United Nations ambassador — she appeared to take credit, writing 'SCALP' in an X post. A 'pressure campaign' targeting the Justice Department Adam Schleifer, an assistant U.S. attorney in Los Angeles, received an email in March saying he was being terminated 'on behalf of President Donald J. Trump,' according to a person familiar with the matter. The email came exactly an hour after Loomer called for him to be fired in a social media post that highlighted Schleifer's past critical comments about Trump while Schleifer was running in a Democratic primary for a congressional seat in New York. Earlier this month, Loomer took a victory lap after the Justice Department fired Maurene Comey, the daughter of former FBI director James Comey and a federal prosecutor in Manhattan who worked on the cases against Sean 'Diddy' Combs and Jeffrey Epstein, three people familiar with the matter told The AP. Comey's ouster, Loomer said on X, followed her two-month 'pressure campaign.' Has Loomer spoken out about others? Yes, chief among them Attorney General Pam Bondi. Loomer has called for Bondi's resignation over failure to keep promises to release more files from the Justice Department's sex trafficking investigation of Epstein, branding her a 'total liar.' Earlier this month, following DOJ's revelations that no Epstein 'client list' existed and no more files would be released, Loomer posted on X that she was told that FBI Deputy Director Dan Bongino was 'seriously thinking about resigning' amid his ongoing clashes with Bondi over the case. Weeks later, both Bondi and Bongino were still on the job. What has Trump said about Loomer's role? In April, Trump denied that Loomer had anything to do with aides being ousted from their jobs at the National Security Council, calling her a 'very good patriot and a very strong person' who only made recommendations. 'Sometimes I listen to those recommendations, like I do with everybody,' Trump said then, adding: 'She's usually very constructive. She recommended certain people for jobs.' Loomer was seen traveling with Trump during last year's campaign, accompanying him on a trip to New York and Pennsylvania as he commemorated the 9/11 attacks. She also traveled with Trump to Philadelphia for a debate against then-Vice President Kamala Harris. Loomer said she never officially joined the campaign after Trump's allies preferred he would keep his distance. After a Harris-related post on X in which Loomer played on racist stereotypes, Trump called Loomer 'a supporter of mine' with 'strong opinions,' but denied knowledge of her comments. He later posted on his Truth Social account that he disagreed with what she had said. ___ Kinnard can be reached at
