Felling of protected tree opposed
Belleknowes property owners Adam and Anna O'Byrne have applied for resource consent from the Dunedin City Council to remove a protected silver beech tree. PHOTO: GERARD O'BRIEN
The felling of a protected Dunedin tree in "undisputed" good health has been opposed by a council planner.
Belleknowes couple Adam and Anna O'Byrne have applied to the Dunedin City Council for resource consent to remove a 17m-tall silver beech tree from their Preston Cres property.
The tree is protected by the council's Second Generation District Plan and 16 of 21 submissions were against removal — one submitter called the tree a taoka (treasure).
Its fate will be considered at a committee hearing later this week and council graduate planner Finn Campbell recommended the application be declined.
However, he said there was a "pathway available to the committee to consider granting consent".
In their application, Mr and Mrs O'Byrne said their tenants living in a consented garage and studio unit below the tree felt unsafe, particularly in high winds when they saw branches dropping.
During the October floods last year, the tree's root system prevented water draining and contributed to flooding of the unit and "a large insurance bill".
Their plumber suggested a surface sump, the couple's preferred option, or a sump and pump to manage drainage.
In his section 42a report, Mr Campbell said it was "undisputed" the tree was in good health and posed no immediate threat to people or the unit below it.
Submissions opposing the application consistently mentioned the tree's visual amenity and removing the tree would have a "moderate" negative effect on local amenity values.
The proposed drainage works would compromise the health and integrity of the tree and while Mr Campbell agreed a drainage solution was needed, he said the options had not been exhausted.
More investigation was needed before consent to remove the tree was granted.
The hearing will be held on Friday in front of a panel made up of commissioner Kirstyn Royce and councillors Sophie Barker and Steve Walker.
ruby.shaw@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
2 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Founding member calls time
Weston Volunteer Fire Brigade chief fire officer Bevan Koppert stepped down last month after 51 years with the brigade. PHOTO: SUPPLIED For the last 51 years Bevan Koppert has been a mainstay of the Weston Volunteer Fire Brigade. He was one of four founding members that started the brigade back in 1974 and has now called time on his firefighting career. Mr Koppert stepped down as chief fire officer at the end of last month, a role he had held for nearly 40 years. "I'm bloody proud of what we've done," he said. "You've got to be. We serve the community. That was the main reason for [starting] it, serving the community and the surrounding districts. "I'll miss the comradeship. "I certainly won't miss getting out of bed in the early hours of the morning." He received his 50-year Service Medal last year. Mr Koppert was the last remaining founding member of the brigade. "When we started we had nothing, absolutely nothing. "We had a house fire and the fire engine had to come from Oamaru, which took a while. So, it was discussed then and we looked at whether it would be possible to have a fire brigade out here. It just grew from there. "We'd probably turned out to about 20-odd calls for the first 12 months. Last year, we did 137 calls." It took them 12 months to get the brigade started, which explains how he has 51 years of service despite the brigade only being 50 years old. Mr Koppert still recalled the brigade's first callout. "It was to a property on Argyle St where people had left a pot on the range and went to work. "It steamed up and people thought it was smoke, which you naturally would think." Fire and Emergency New Zealand Waitaki group manager Mike Harrison said Mr Koppert has been "the heart and soul" of the brigade since day one. The brigade's former station officer, Richard Cranston, has been appointed as the new chief fire officer.
RNZ News
13 hours ago
- RNZ News
Dunedin Gasworks Museum to reopen after repairs
The chimney at the Dunedin Gasworks Museum, with machinery nearby. Photo: RNZ / Tess Brunton New Zealand's only gasworks museum will reopen after repairs to its 25-metre high chimney. The Dunedin Gasworks Museum was closed in April after cracks were discovered in the chimney stack due to possible earthquake damage. The category-one historic place, owned by the Dunedin City Council, was last month found to be in a worse condition than first thought . The damaged chimney stack at the Dunedin Gasworks Museum. Photo: SUPPLIED / DUNEDIN CITY COUNCIL The council's property services group manager Anna Nilsen said contractors spent three weeks removing about 4000 bricks from the top of the chimney, lowering its height by about four metres. "The expert advice we've received is that the chimney is no longer an imminent risk to the safety of those around it, so the dangerous building notice issued last month has now been lifted and the exclusion zone around the chimney has been removed," she said. The museum could return to almost normal operations without the use of the chimney for now, she said. An affected building notice issued to the neighbouring Woolworths supermarket had also been lifted. The total cost of the repairs had not been confirmed. The council had requested a full condition assessment of the chimney and that would determine what further work would be needed and whether it could be used safely. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Felling of protected tree opposed
Belleknowes property owners Adam and Anna O'Byrne have applied for resource consent from the Dunedin City Council to remove a protected silver beech tree. PHOTO: GERARD O'BRIEN The felling of a protected Dunedin tree in "undisputed" good health has been opposed by a council planner. Belleknowes couple Adam and Anna O'Byrne have applied to the Dunedin City Council for resource consent to remove a 17m-tall silver beech tree from their Preston Cres property. The tree is protected by the council's Second Generation District Plan and 16 of 21 submissions were against removal — one submitter called the tree a taoka (treasure). Its fate will be considered at a committee hearing later this week and council graduate planner Finn Campbell recommended the application be declined. However, he said there was a "pathway available to the committee to consider granting consent". In their application, Mr and Mrs O'Byrne said their tenants living in a consented garage and studio unit below the tree felt unsafe, particularly in high winds when they saw branches dropping. During the October floods last year, the tree's root system prevented water draining and contributed to flooding of the unit and "a large insurance bill". Their plumber suggested a surface sump, the couple's preferred option, or a sump and pump to manage drainage. In his section 42a report, Mr Campbell said it was "undisputed" the tree was in good health and posed no immediate threat to people or the unit below it. Submissions opposing the application consistently mentioned the tree's visual amenity and removing the tree would have a "moderate" negative effect on local amenity values. The proposed drainage works would compromise the health and integrity of the tree and while Mr Campbell agreed a drainage solution was needed, he said the options had not been exhausted. More investigation was needed before consent to remove the tree was granted. The hearing will be held on Friday in front of a panel made up of commissioner Kirstyn Royce and councillors Sophie Barker and Steve Walker.
