New municipalities under Greater Bengaluru Authority to disrupt reservation rotations, undermine equity: Former IAS T R Raghunandan
'Their (government's) aim is to prevent rotation of reservation from proceeding logically,' he said, claiming that such tactics violate the 74th Constitutional Amendment's equity mandates. He made the remark while speaking at a seminar organised by CIVIC Bangalore on the Greater Bengaluru Governance Act (GBGA).
Raghunandan also urged Bengaluru to adopt the 'Manila and Brussels model', stating that decentralised municipalities with clear roles foster accountability. He, thereafter, argued that frequent delimitation creates new electoral cycles, allowing political actors to dilute the representation of marginalised groups.
Raghunandan further noted that GBGA's devolution of 18 subjects is 'vague and ineffective', pointing out the lack of specific tasks for representatives. 'That means nothing,' he said, criticising the 'PowerPoint knowledge' approach that renders corporations symbolic. He stressed the need for precise role delineation to counter bureaucratic resistance and ensure functional governance.
Raghunandan also flagged centralised control, with the GBA's state-appointed officials and initiatives like Smart City Private Limited bypassing elected bodies, creating 'elected monarchies'.
Calling devolution a 'political battle,' Raghunandan urged engagement with ex-corporators to counter elite dominance.
'Karnataka's Panchayat Raj empowered marginalised groups through clear roles, but urban governance lags. The GBA needs to be challenged by ex-corporators' engagement to fight elite dominance. Devolution is a political battle requiring accountability to ensure Bengaluru's corporations serve all communities equitably,' he said.
Kathyayini Chamaraj, Executive Trustee, CIVIC Bangalore, argued that the recently passed GBGA undermines the 74th Constitutional Amendment by centralising control under the state-led Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA), headed by the chief minister.
She then contended, 'The state, not BBMP, failed by delaying elections for years, weakening local self-governance and depriving citizens of responsive urban governance.'
'Splitting BBMP into seven corporations hinders equitable resource distribution, ignoring Delhi's re-merger lesson. The state's failure to activate the Metropolitan Planning Committee caused Bengaluru's 'ruined' growth, violating the 74th Amendment's mandate for vibrant local self-governance,' Chamaraj said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
2 days ago
- Indian Express
SC suggests converting Noida into a metropolitan corporation. What does this mean?
The Supreme Court on Wednesday asked the Uttar Pradesh government to consider converting the Noida authority (NOIDA) into a metropolitan corporation to make it more citizen-centric. Noida is currently the only major city in India to not have an elected local government. The Court also asked for a probe into the Authority, based on an apex-court constituted SIT which flagged its various flaws and shortcomings. It was hearing the bail pleas of two NOIDA Authority officials accused of allowing excess compensation payouts. It was created during the Emergency when Sanjay Gandhi, son of then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, wanted to move industries out of Delhi. The Authority comes under the purview of the UP Infrastructure & Industrial Development Department. Its day-to-day activities are run by an appointed IAS officer in his role as its Chief Executive Officer. It covers 81 revenue villages and a total of about 20,316 hectares of land. How is it different from other cities? Noida does not have a separate municipal body that performs daily civic functions, like dealing with garbage, street lighting, sewerage and public health, among other issues. It is an anomaly in that the development authority, which is supposed to be responsible for the acquisition of land, planned development, and infrastructure creation, is also undertaking civic functions here. For instance, in Delhi, these services are provided by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) and in Mumbai by Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), whereas Delhi Development Authority (DDA) and Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA), respectively, are responsible for planned development in these cities. What is a metropolitan council? The Constitution (74th Amendment) Act, 1992, recognised three different types of urban local bodies or municipalities: Nagar Palikas for areas transitioning from rural to urban; municipal councils for smaller urban areas; and municipal corporations for larger urban areas. A metropolitan area was defined in the Act as an area having a population of above 10 lakh. Noida had breached the 10 lakh-population mark way back in 2010. Municipalities are supposed to be elected directly by the people and are the third tier of government in urban areas after the Union and state governments. They are the equivalent of Panchayats, but in urban areas. They are supposed to look after public health, waste management, sanitation, provide urban facilities like parks and playgrounds, as well as amenities like street lighting, parking lots, bus stops and public conveniences, among other functions. What are the benefits of having a municipality? Proponents argue that having a self-governing local body leads to more effective, responsive, citizen-friendly, transparent, and accountable governance, in contrast to having an appointed bureaucrat in charge of local governance. Not having a municipality has a huge negative impact on the area, according to Srikant Vishwanathan, CEO of Janaagraha, an organisation that works on urban governance. 'An elected municipality is the bridge between people's aspirations and the government's priorities and policies, especially for the urban poor,' Vishwanathan says. In 2017, then District Magistrate BN Singh of Gautam Buddha Nagar (under which Noida falls) had recommended withdrawing municipal functions from the Authority and the formation of a separate municipal corporation. However, the NOIDA and the Greater NOIDA bodies, later that year, concluded that they did not need municipal bodies.
The Hindu
3 days ago
- The Hindu
Karnataka govt. to set up one delimitation commission for all five corporations
The State government is set to constitute a single ward delimitation commission for all five municipal corporations, which is likely to be led by the Chief Civic Commissioner. The exercise will not be carried out separately for each of the five corporations, even as the Cabinet cleared an amendment to the Greater Bengaluru Governance Act, 2024, to prepare a separate voters' list for the corporations. Deputy Chief Minister and Bengaluru Development Minister D.K. Shivakumar recently said that the final notification of the five corporations will be issued on September 2 and delimitation will begin on September 3. The final ward list will be notified by November 30. Similar ward size or same number of wards? As per the Greater Bengaluru Governance Act, 2024, each corporation can have up to 150 wards. However, the population of these corporations vary, from 1.3 million in the East to 4.5 million in the West. 'We can say we will carve out the same number of wards in each corporation, somewhat closer to 150, which will give us wards in each corporation of different sizes. The other approach is to fix the average size of a ward in terms of population across the city, which will give us a different number of wards of similar size in each corporation,' explained a senior civic official. Civic activist Ashwin Mahesh argued that each area should be allowed to have its own trajectory and the delimitation exercise should be done separately for each corporation, fixing an ideal ward size for that corporation. However, N.S. Mukunda, of Bengaluru Praja Vedike, argued that the corporations were already uneven in terms of their revenue and making uneven wards in terms of population would perpetuate more inequity. 'If the ward delimitation is done separately for each corporation, in the East corporation, the size of the ward would roughly be around 8,000, while it would be over 40,000 in the West, which is unfair. Equal representation is key in the city.' A senior Urban Development Department official told The Hindu that the way wards will be carved out is the prerogative of the commission. However, given that the government will set up only one commission, this indicated that the commission will fix an average range for ward size and carve out wards to ensure the sizes are roughly around this, the official added. Another official involved in the exercise said that the number of wards in these corporations may be in the range of 70 to 150, and the size of the ward may also vary between 15,000 and 30,000. Delimitation based on 2011 census Meanwhile, as per statutory rules, ward delimitation can be done only on the latest census data, which in the present case will be the 2011 data, according to which Bengaluru's population is 85 lakh, while the projected population today is 1.44 crore . The spatial distribution of this population growth is also skewed more towards South-East Bengaluru, which was relatively lower in 2011. 'The wards delimited based on the 2011 census would mean wards that would be dead on arrival. They would be completely divorced from the ground reality. But there is no way out of this as this is a legal requirement and we haven't had our decadal survey in 2021,' an activist said.
The Hindu
3 days ago
- The Hindu
Bill tabled to give more clarity on functioning of Greater Bengaluru Authority
The Greater Bengaluru Governance (Amendment) Bill, 2025, was tabled in the Legislative Assembly on Wednesday for providing clarity regarding the functioning of the Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA) and the relationship between civic authorities in the Greater Bengaluru Area. The Bill said that GBA should discharge the role of coordinator among all the city corporations and other agencies in the Greater Bengaluru Area. The GBA would discharge several functions, including finalisation of its common cadre and recruitment rules, and for the city corporations to submit to the government for approval. The Bill would empower the GBA to make appointments of Group A (junior level) and Group B officers in accordance with the common cadre and recruitment rules. The GBA would also make rules for the chief commissioner of GBA and for the Group C and D posts. The government notified five corporations carved out of the existing city civic limits.
