Defence lawyer accuses retired police officer of 'playing cop' before alleged Geraldton axe attack
Jack Seelander and Justin Troy Ernest Little allegedly assaulted former WA police sergeant Adrian Barker during a confrontation in Geraldton in March 2024.
The pair faced trial over three days in the Geraldton Magistrates Court this week.
The court heard Mr Barker was returning to his home in Wandina around 3am on March 17, 2024 when he passed a group of eight Aboriginal boys and men.
Under cross-examination by defence lawyer Lauren Roycroft, Mr Barker admitted he thought the group would "be trouble".
Mr Barker said once in his Wandina home, he sat near his front door, which was slightly ajar behind a locked flyscreen.
He initially said it was left open for the breeze, but later Mr Barker admitted it was because he thought the group would attempt to break into nearby houses.
Ms Roycroft put it to Mr Barker that he heard "a barely audible click", saw figures running away, then followed and confronted them.
However, Mr Barker said he confronted members of the group, including Mr Seelander and Mr Little, after they attempted to break into his house.
The confrontation saw Mr Barker allegedly hit Mr Little in the back of the head, knocking him to the ground.
After initially running away, the court heard members of the group attacked Mr Barker, with Mr Little allegedly hitting him in the side of the face with an axe before fleeing the scene.
In his closing statement on Wednesday, police prosecutor Sergeant Thomas Potts said the group had "fairly laid into Barker with a pick to the back" without being provoked.
Sergeant Potts said Mr Barker "pre-emptively" struck Mr Little due to his path to flee being blocked by other members of the group.
He said Mr Barker's decision to confront the group was honed by his 15 years of experience as a WA police officer.
But the defence questioned Mr Barker's conduct, arguing he had pre-emptively formed "a negative view" of the group without cause.
"There is a wealth of evidence that Mr Barker was the aggressor," Ms Roycroft told the court.
She pointed to Mr Barker's inconsistent accounts of the incident, and his conduct immediately after the attack, as detrimental to his credibility as a witness.
The court was told that after the incident, Mr Barker got into his car, pursued a car carrying a group of Aboriginal people unconnected to the attack at speed, flashed his headlights, pulled them over, and interrogated them at the side of the road.
When the car's occupants asked if he was a police officer, Mr Barker answered "yep".
Magistrate Matthew Walton reserved his decision, telling the court the matters were difficult, with "complexities often forgotten" in closing statements.
He agreed that Mr Barker was "getting brutalised" by people in the group.
The matter will return to court next month for the verdict.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
11 hours ago
- Sky News AU
'Still on a call with someone': Details emerge in mysterious death of Australian tourist found 'with a mobile phone resting on his chest' in Thai hotel room
A 23-year-old Australian tourist has been found dead inside a hotel room in Thailand, just one day before he was due to return home. The man, who held Australian citizenship and was born in India, was discovered by housekeeping staff at a hotel in the Thepkrasattri district of Phuket on Wednesday morning. The shocking discovery prompted hotel staff to immediately alert Thai police. 'I saw him lying there with a mobile phone resting on his chest. He was still on a call with someone. The line hadn't been disconnected, and he had died like that. There were no signs of struggle or anything suspicious,' said Police Lieutenant Colonel Thanom Thongpaen from Thalang district station. 'It appeared he had been on the call for about 12 hours. The phone screen had gone dark, but we could still see the call duration and confirm he was on a call. 'We don't know who he was talking to. I tried speaking into the phone, but there was no response. The line remained active, but there was no voice on the other end. The phone was locked, so we couldn't examine it further.' The man was found wearing a black T-shirt and lying motionless on the bed. Bandages were visible on his elbow and wrist, believed to be from a motorcycle accident he had suffered the day prior. Police said there were no signs of forced entry, assault or theft in the room. There were no illegal drugs or alcohol present, only blister packs containing around 10 over-the-counter painkillers and anti-inflammatory tablets, which hotel staff had purchased for him at his request following the crash. 'He likely took the medication before he passed away,' Thongpaen added. 'There is no clear cause of death at this stage, but there are no signs of foul play in this case.' Security footage showed the man had been travelling alone, although friends, also Australians, had reportedly crossed paths with him in Phuket during their separate trips. One friend had dropped him off at the hotel the night before. Hotel staff were able to contact that friend using details provided at check-in. 'One of the hotel staff had a phone number for his friend, who had helped him check in, so the hotel contacted that friend to inform them of his death,' said Thongpaen. The man's family has reportedly requested that no autopsy be conducted and expressed a wish to repatriate his body to Australia as soon as possible. The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade confirmed it is assisting the family. 'The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade is providing consular assistance to the family of an Australian who died in Thailand,' a spokesperson said. Thai police say the investigation remains open pending further medical examination, although at this stage, there is no indication of suspicious circumstances.
Daily Telegraph
21 hours ago
- Daily Telegraph
Apology to Angus Bendall
Don't miss out on the headlines from NSW. Followed categories will be added to My News. On July 21, 2025 The Daily Telegraph published an article about Hugo Phipson who has been charged with wounding a person with intent to cause grievous bodily harm at a pool party in Mosman. A photo published with the article identified Angus Bendall (pictured) as the accused man. This was incorrect. Mr Bendall has no association whatsoever with the allegations described in the article and was not present at the party. We offer our sincere and unreserved apology to Mr Bendall for the distress and harm caused by this error.
News.com.au
a day ago
- News.com.au
Rebel Wilson accused of false allegations in new lawsuit
Hollywood actress Rebel Wilson is facing another lawsuit from the production company she accused of being 'absolute f**kwits' involving claims she falsely outed a young actress as a victim of sexual harassment. Just a year after she faced legal threats over her memoir Rebel Rising and was forced to redact an entire chapter containing claims about Borat star Sacha Baron Cohen, a new legal battle has erupted. The new lawsuit lodged in the NSW Supreme Court by the production company behind her directorial debut The Deb is alleging serious breaches of contract and director's duties, misleading and deceptive conduct, and injurious falsehood. Ms Wilson was sued for defamation in the United States last year by producers Amanda Ghost, Gregory Cameron and Vince Holden who allege she falsely claimed they had embezzled funds from the movie and had behaved with 'absolute viciousness and retaliatory behaviour'. That matter is ongoing. The new lawsuit in NSW has been lodged by Mr Holden's production company A.I. Film and is being handled by an Australian-based legal team – Patrick George, Jeremy Marel and barrister Sue Chrysanthou, SC. It accuses Ms Wilson of blocking the film's release though legal threats and making false claims that the lead actor in the film, Charlotte MacInnes, was the target of 'inappropriate conduct'. In the new legal submissions, A.I.'s legal team insist that Ms MacInnes denies she was ever harassed, and states that Ms Wilson's claims are baseless. The blow up follows a video Rebel Wilson posted on Instagram in July 2024, where she made a number of misconduct claims about the movie producers to her 11 million followers. '[T]o have the business partners that are involved in that movie turn around and say that no, the movie can't premiere, is just beyond devastating,'' she said. 'And so I said, reported, I guess you would say, their bad behaviour when I found out not minor things, big things, you know, inappropriate behaviour towards the lead actress of the film, embezzling funds from the film's budget, which we really needed because we're a small movie, you know? So kind of really important things. Since I reported that behaviour, I have been met with absolute viciousness and retaliatory behaviour. 'And yet every step of the way, these people who I complained about then tried to make my life hell. 'And this behaviour is absolutely vile and disgusting. Now these people you know, Amanda Ghost in particular, has a history of doing this kind of thing, mainly to music artists but also to people in the film business. So, the thing is, these people are forced to sign NDAs or, you know, otherwise threatened or bullied to not speak out. 'I will speak the truth, and, you know, warn people about these people in the industry. Who are just not behaving ethically ... if the movie doesn't play in Toronto, it's because of these absolute f**kwits.' Ms Ghost is now suing Ms Wilson for defamation in the United States. In the NSW lawsuit, the production company's legal team argued these statements conveyed that one of the producers had made 'inappropriate sexual advances to an actress in the film'. 'In fact, none of the producers had made inappropriate sexual advances to an actress,'' the legal documents state. The lawsuit alleged Ms McInnes categorically denied Ms Wilson's claims telling media outlets 'there is no truth to the allegations made involving me.' 'I love this film and I can't wait for it to be released. It would be wonderful if these proceedings can help make that happen,'' she said in a statement to She previously told media outlets: 'Making false accusations undermines real victims and I won't be the subject of a fabricated narrative.' After the actress was subsequently cast as Daisy in Florence Welch's musical Gatsby: An American Myth, Ms Wilson is alleged to have made the following statement on Instagram stories accusing her of 'changing her story.' 'When an actress on her first feature film is asked by a producer to stay in the same apartment as them, and then makes a complaint to me as the director saying said producer 'asked her to have a bath and shower with her and it made her feel uncomfortable' – what am I supposed to do of course I reported it,'' Ms Wilson said. 'There is no world where this is acceptable. The fact that this girl has been employed now by this 'producer' in the lead role of a production called GATSBY (ART Boston) and given a record label – should be all the proof you need as to why she has now changed her story.' During the Cannes Film Festival, Ms Wilson allegedly posted more Instagram stories, suggesting MacInnes had 'lied by denying the allegations of sexual misconduct by the film's UK producers'. 'Charlotte MacInnes in a culturally inappropriate Indian outfit on Len Blavatnik's luxury yacht in Cannes – ironically singing a song from a movie that will never get released because of her lies and support for the people blocking the film's release. So glad you got your record deal Charlotte at the expense of the 300 people who worked on The Deb and really wanna see it released.' In the new lawsuit, it is alleged Ms Wilson 'threatened the Australian distributor of the film that she would obtain an injunction to prevent its release, when the contractual documents plainly prevented her from obtaining an injunction.' No stranger to defamation battles, Ms Wilson won a record payout from Bauer media but was later forced to repay the majority of her record defamation payout from a magazine publisher. Ms Wilson had received A$4.7m in damages and interest from Bauer Media over articles that she said portrayed her as a serial liar. But a court reduced the sum to A$600,000 following an appeal by the publisher. She was then ordered to pay back A$4.1m and A$60,000 in interest. A subsequent bid to have an appeal heard in the High Court of Australia was rejected, bringing her legal battle 'to a definitive end'.
