Schoolboy who killed fellow pupil had become ‘obsessed' with weapons, trial told
The 15-year-old is on trial accused of murdering Harvey Willgoose, also 15, who was killed at All Saints Catholic High School in Sheffield on February 3.
The defendant, who cannot be named, has admitted manslaughter but denies murder, saying he lost control and does not remember what happened.
Giving his closing speech to jurors on Thursday, prosecutor Richard Thyne KC said the stabbing was 'purposeful aggression, likely explained as an act of retribution, getting back at Harvey for something'.
The trial has heard the two boys fell out several days before Harvey's death after taking opposite sides in a dispute between two other boys.
Mr Thyne said the defendant had ordered the hunting knife he used to kill Harvey before that incident, and was someone with an 'unhealthy interest in weapons' who had talked about 'shanking' someone when he was 13 years old.
He told jurors the boy's internet searches showed 'not just someone with a growing fascination with weapons, but someone who really wanted to own them'.
Mr Thyne said: 'You may think the searches aren't conducted by someone who has a specific and deep rooted fear of someone, but by someone who's become obsessed.'
He told the court the defendant had also researched rage rooms and, just over a week before the fatal stabbing, searched 'waiting for someone to swing so I can let out my anger'.
Mr Thyne said this was echoed in the defendant's behaviour on the day he stabbed Harvey, and showed CCTV clips from the school which he said showed him trying to provoke Harvey, who remained 'peaceful'.
The trial has heard evidence from another pupil who said Harvey told him the defendant had been acting like he had a knife under his jumper that morning, but Harvey had thought he was bluffing.
Mr Thyne said: 'It's just a tragedy Harvey didn't realise (the defendant) reaching for, or indicating he had, a knife in (a science lesson), was genuine.'
He told the court that in footage of the fatal attack on Harvey, the defendant could be seen unzipping his coat, putting his hand in his pocket, and taking out the knife.
'He was acting with thought, with purpose and knew exactly what he was doing,' he told jurors.
The prosecutor said the school's headteacher had told police that after the stabbing, the defendant had told him he knifed Harvey 'once, maybe twice'.
Mr Thyne said: 'This proves the lie when he says he can't remember. He knew then, just as he knows now, exactly what he'd done.'
The prosecutor added the defendant was 'motivated by wanting to show he was hard, sending out a message about who he was, someone not to be messed with'.
Starting his closing address to the jury, Gul Nawaz Hussain KC, defending, said the defendant 'snapped' after years of bullying and 'an intense period of fear at school'.
He told jurors: 'Tragically, Harvey was a combination of being the final straw that broke (the defendant) and the unintended face of a series of threats of violence and bullying he had suffered in recent months.
'We say he suffered a loss of control which resulted in horrific and tragic consequences.'
he trial continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
30 minutes ago
- The Independent
Man appears in court accused of murdering woman, 21, found dead in house
A man has appeared in court accused of murdering a woman who was found dead in a house in West Yorkshire. Courtney Angus, 21, was discovered at an address in Norfolk Street in Batley on Saturday. On Friday, Michael Moore, who uses the name Michael Doherty, made his first appearance before a crown court judge. The 37-year-old, of Norfolk Street in Batley, appeared at Leeds Crown Court via video link from prison, and spoke only to say his name was Michael Doherty rather than Michael Moore – the name used by the police. He was not asked to enter pleas during the hearing, and was remanded in custody until his next appearance for a plea and trial preparation hearing at Leeds Crown Court on September 5. Judge Tom Bayliss KC set a date of January 26 for the trial, which is expected to last five days. Officers were called to reports of an armed robbery at Asda in Dewsbury at 9.20pm on Saturday. They arrested a man, who told officers about a woman who he believed to be dead inside a house on Norfolk Street in Batley. A knife was seized at the scene, police said. Officers attended the address in Batley and found Ms Angus, from Dewsbury. Moore/Doherty is charged with murdering Ms Angus, and with possession of a bladed article, affray and two counts of threatening a person with a bladed article in a public place. Police said these charges relate to incidents in Dewsbury on the same day. After her death was confirmed, Ms Angus's family released a statement which said: 'Our lives have been shattered and turned upside down with the news that no parent wants to hear – that our gorgeous daughter and sister is no longer with us. 'Courtney had a beautiful soul. She was a lover of music, socialising and having fun. Her whole family is heartbroken over the loss of such an amazing woman.'
The Independent
30 minutes ago
- The Independent
Ten men arrested in Bradford police probe over historic child sex abuse
Police have arrested ten men in Bradford as part of a probe into historic child sex abuse. The suspects, aged between 49 and 71, were brought in for questioning over offences involving six victims aged between 13 and 15 and date back from 1994 to 1997, West Yorkshire Police said. All ten men have been bailed pending further enquiries, according to the force. They said safeguarding and protecting children was a 'top priority' for them, adding they are 'committed' to the investigation of both recent and historic sexual offences involving children. A statement from the force said: 'Police investigating non-recent reports of child sexual abuse in Bradford have arrested ten men as part of an arrest operation. 'The individuals were arrested from addresses in Bradford. Ten men, aged between 49 and 71 have been interviewed and bailed pending further enquiries. 'The allegations relate to offences, which are reported to have occurred in the District between 1994 and 1997 and relate to six victims who were aged 13 to 15 at the time.' Detective Chief Inspector Vicky Greenbank of Bradford District Police, added: 'Safeguarding and protecting children remains the top priority for West Yorkshire Police. This investigation demonstrates the Force's ongoing commitment to the investigation of both current and non-recent sexual offences against children. 'Child sexual abuse and exploitation is an abhorrent and heinous crime and one which affects some of the most vulnerable people in our society. 'Tackling child abuse is not something that any one agency can do in isolation; we work closely with our partners and charities to support victims, bring perpetrators to justice and to make our communities safer. 'I would urge anyone who has been a victim of sexual abuse, whether recent or non-recent, to report it to the police. Please be assured that you will be listened to, taken seriously and supported by professionals with experience of dealing with these kinds of offences.'
Daily Mail
30 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
9/11 mastermind could be freed in days despite confession
A 'despicable' terrorist who confessed to his role in 9/11 and the July 7 bombings is set to be freed from prison within days despite officials declaring him a 'risk to national security'. Haroon Aswat (pictured), 50, could be released from a secure hospital unit in the UK without a full risk assessment due to his mental health treatment. He was jailed in 2015 in the US for 20 years having admitted trying to start a terrorist training camp in Oregon. Aswat was visited by a British psychiatrist in America before he was deported back to Britain in 2022 where he declared: 'I'm a terrorist.' Now newly surfaced US court documents show Aswat also confessed to being a 'mastermind behind the [9/11] attacks and a 2005 attack in the UK', The Sun has reported. In addition to his connection to the 7/7 London terror bombings, which killed 52 people, Aswat has also threatened to kill Jews, Christians and certain groups of Muslims. Shadow Justice Secretary Robert Jenrick said he feared Aswat's return to the streets of Britain and said: 'He should never experience freedom again.' Despite officials admitting their concern and the High Court's Mr Justice Robert Jay previously saying there was 'evidence of an ongoing risk', Aswat will only be subject to a notification order upon his release. It means Aswat must continually notify the police about certain information and keep them up-to-date. These details include his address, foreign travel details and vehicle registration. Earlier this year Mr Justice Jay concluded: 'These were very serious offences and there is evidence of ongoing risk. A risk assessment in relation to terrorist offending is always inherently uncertain and in the present case is compounded by the mental instability of the defendant. Overall, I am satisfied for the reasons that I have given that a notification order should be made in all the circumstances of this case. A psychiatrist has deemed his treatment as being effective and his release from detention is expected in the relatively near future, with the understanding being that he will return to his family in Yorkshire.' He added: 'No formal terrorist risk assessment has been carried out since the defendant's return here. The circumstances of his detention have precluded that. However, on the basis of the material which is available the defendant has been assessed by various police officers — including the senior officer dealing with this case — that he remains a risk to national security.' A document from the US District Court, which has been released for the first time, described Aswat as a terrorist and foot soldier of al-Qaeda, and revealed he openly admitted to his involvement in terrorist activities. 'In March 2017 the defendant stated, 'if you think I am a terrorist, I don't shy away from my responsibility' and also stated he was a mastermind behind the 9/11 attacks and a 2005 terrorist attack in the UK.' The papers show that Aswat revealed his associations with Osama bin Laden (pictured) and that he had spent time training in al-Queda camps in Afghanistan just months before the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, which claimed more than 3,000 lives. His name was also found on a ledger discovered in a house in Pakistan where Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the 'architect' of 9/11, had been staying. Other activities included helping hate preacher Abu Hamza establish a US terror camp in 1999, staying at a house in Pakistan in 2002 - where he met two of the 7/7 bombers - and possessing a terror manual and alleged bomb materials. Police also traced 20 calls made by the 7/7 bombers to a phone connected to Aswat. Det Chief Supt Gareth Rees, head of operations for the Met's SO15 Counter Terrorism Command, said of Aswat in a witness statement: 'Based on my experience, this is conduct which gives me grave concerns about the risk which the defendant poses to the UK's national security and to the public.' A report compiled by Dr Richard Taylor, who travelled to America in the summer of 2022, found Aswat still posed a risk to the public. The report states that in 2017 Aswat made remarks to prison staff in support of Al Qaeda and threatened violence towards them. In 2022 he sent letters which made demands and death threats, seemingly motivated by a terrorist ideology. Dr Taylor concluded that he openly endorsed an extremist ideology, but there was no evidence that Aswat was mentally ill. However he had had limited opportunity to address the extremist mindset and showed traits of glibness, superficial charm, charisma, intelligence and elements of manipulativeness and narcissism. Even when mentally stable he continued to express violent, extremist Islamic ideology, Dr Taylor found. The diagnosis showed a schizoaffective disorder with symptoms showing unpredictable and aggressive behaviour. Dr Taylor did not complete a full terrorist risk assessment, but identified 15 of the 22 relevant factors in the government's extreme risk guidance. He concluded: 'There remains the risk of Islamic violent extremism motivated targeted terrorist offending behaviour given his threats to kill Jews, Christians and certain groups of Muslims. There is also a risk of him influencing other vulnerable individuals, as when he is in an abnormal mental state his religious extremist rhetoric is amplified by mental illness.' A senior police officer, Detective Inspector Karen Bradley, who was involved in the case, concluded that Aswat remains a risk to national security. Aswat was born and grew up in Yorkshire but moved to Wood Green in north London where he fell under the spell of hate preacher Abu Hamza - and together they planned a terror training camp in Oregon with Aswat moving to Seattle to organise it. He also spent time in Afghanistan and in Pakistan - where he met and associated with fellow Yorkshire terror sympathiser Mohammed Sidique Khan and his accomplice Shehzad Tanweer. They would go on to carry out the deadly 7/7 bombings in London which killed 52 people on underground trains and a bus in July 2005. Aswat served most of his sentence in America and was deported back to the UK in December 2022. He is currently detained at Bethlem Royal Hospital in Bromley, south east London.
