NFL defeats lawsuit over alleged monopoly on team merchandise
Manhattan-based U.S. District Judge Andrew Carter Jr on Monday said, opens new tab retailer Casey's Distributing Inc had not provided enough evidence to support the proposed class action, which claimed that the NFL's tight distribution rules left consumers with fewer options and higher prices.
Casey's buys NFL merchandise from licensed manufacturers and resells it. The Nebraska-based company in 2022 sued the NFL and its 32 teams, accusing them of illegally monopolizing the licensing of trademarked team products.
Casey's claimed it and other online retailers were being denied the opportunity to sell on some platforms such as Amazon.com.
'While plaintiffs have been harmed by the actions of the defendants, the law protects competition, not competitors,' Carter wrote. He said there was nothing in Casey's lawsuit that adequately alleged consumers were forced to pay higher prices due to the alleged scheme.
The NFL and attorneys for Casey's did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Casey's also named as a defendant the sports merchandise giants Fanatics. Casey's said its products were removed from Walmart after it chose Fanatics as its exclusive seller. Fanatics did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The NFL and Fanatics had denied any wrongdoing. Walmart and Amazon were not defendants.
In its lawsuit, opens new tab, Casey's said Amazon's online marketplace is the most important platform for small businesses like Casey's to participate in the market for licensed NFL merchandise.
The NFL in asking Carter to dismiss Casey's lawsuit said, opens new tab its online distribution policy was flexible, and that retailers that want to sell on Amazon must first seek approval by NFL Properties, which licenses the intellectual property for the league and its teams.
In a court filing, the NFL defended its distribution rules as lawful, saying they focus on brand and consumer protection and do not impose restrictions or rules on price or output.
Carter said Casey's will have a chance to refile its lawsuit by the end of the month to try to persuade him to allow the claims to move forward.
The case is Casey's Distributing Inc v. National Football Club et al, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 1:22-cv-03934-ALC.
For plaintiffs: John Balestriere of Balestriere Fariello and Justin Nematzadeh of Nematzadeh PLLC
For NFL: Bradley Ruskin, David Munkittrick and Jeffrey Warshafsky of Proskauer Rose
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
3 hours ago
- Scotsman
TIME names East Scotland housebuilder among world's most sustainable Ccompanies
Barratt Redrow, which owns local housebuilder Barratt and David Wilson Homes East Scotland, has been named as one of TIME magazine's World's 500 Most Sustainable Companies for 2025. Sign up to our daily newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The recognition for the developer, who is responsible for developments such as David Wilson Homes at St Andrews, Merchant Quay in Leith and Bangour Village in West Lothian, underscores its industry-leading commitment to preserving and enhancing the natural environment and building great places that promote healthy and happy living for customers. This accolade places Barratt Redrow amongst a select group of companies across the globe recognised for their leadership in sustainability, and they are on the only UK-based housebuilder to feature on the list. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Andrew Morrison, Managing Director at Barratt Homes and David Wilson Homes East Scotland, said: 'We are immensely proud that our work here in East Scotland contributes to a national legacy of building not only high-quality homes, but a more sustainable future. This achievement reflects the dedication of our teams to reducing our impact, innovating and creating communities that last.' Andrew Morrison, Managing Director at Barratt Homes and David Wilson Homes East Scotland David Thomas, CEO of Barratt Redrow, said: 'We are incredibly proud to be recognised by TIME magazine as one of the world's most sustainable companies. 'Sustainability is at the heart of everything we do - from driving carbon emission reductions across our value chain to creating communities that thrive for generations. Being included on this global list is both an honour and a powerful motivation to keep pushing the boundaries of what responsible homebuilding can achieve.' Only 32 UK-based companies received the accreditation in 2025, all of whom are setting the benchmark on sustainability performance, transparency and innovation. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad TIME and its research partner, Statista, used a transparent, multi-stage methodology to identify the world's most sustainable companies. The process began with a pool of over 5,000 of the world's largest and most influential companies. Following a rigorous four-stage assessment, the final ranking excluded unsustainable industries and considered factors like external sustainability ratings and commitments, corporate reporting practices, and environmental and social performance indicators. This comprehensive approach produced a ranking of 500 companies from over 30 countries. Leading sustainable housebuilding Prior to the merger with Redrow to form Barratt Redrow, Barratt Developments was the first major housebuilder to set science-based emission reduction targets and is a signatory of the UN Global Compact, reflecting ongoing commitments to its Ten Principles for Corporate Sustainability. Working with highly skilled partners in the sector, the business is driving change across the organisation and its value chain to meet society's most pressing challenges, including climate change, diversity and inclusion, and human rights. Barratt Redrow is committed to being transparent on sustainability plans and performance with independent assessments and accreditations. As Barratt Developments, the Leicestershire-based company was ranked the highest national housebuilder in the NextGeneration sustainability benchmark last year, and was awarded the Crystal Award for being the most transparent housebuilder. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad At the University of Salford, Barratt Redrow and scientists are working together to rigorously test how climate change will affect the homes of the future. The research from Energy House 2.0 is being shared with housebuilders around the world to support their own transition to zero carbon. Already, the learnings from Energy House 2.0 are being transferred to customer homes. According to HBF data (January 2025) a brand-new home could be up to 65% more energy-efficient than an older home.* Barratt Redrow is committed to all homes being zero carbon in regulated energy use from 2030. As part of this, over 1,200 Air Source Heat Pumps have so far been installed into homes and we gather customer insight on perceptions and experience with a range sustainable technology to inform our future roll out strategy. On site, Barratt Redrow is taking steps to reduce our operational footprint, with a major focus on eliminating and reducing diesel use. This includes trials of hydrotreated vegetable oil as a lower-carbon fuel alternative, and trialling hydrogen telehandlers. Alongside this, we're improving site energy efficiency, expanding the use of renewable electricity and introducing tools to monitor emissions from construction activities. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A focus on driving down waste has led to 97% of waste being diverted from landfill in 2024. A decade-long partnership with the RSPB has changed the way in which nature and wildlife is incorporated into communities. A transformational year The past year has been transformational with the combination of Barratt Developments and Redrow in October 2024. The combination is focused on tackling the country's housing shortage by growing towards delivering 22,000 new homes a year and leading the industry on quality, customer service and sustainability. Another milestone has been the creation of the MADE Partnership, a joint venture between Barratt Redrow, Homes England, and Lloyds Banking Group. MADE was established to provide the expertise, vision, and financial capacity to deliver large-scale and complex regeneration projects. Barratt's impact as an employer is far reaching, generating almost 43,000 jobs both directly and through our supplier chain, contributing £4.16 billion to the national economy and £536m into local communities through infrastructure, affordable housing, community facilities and environmental improvements. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Barratt Redrow's determination to be a quality, sustainable builder was recognised by the NHBC's Pride in the Job Quality Awards with 115 site managers given awards in 2025, including 11 in Scotland – more than any other housebuilder for the 21st year running. Also, the housebuilder was awarded Five Stars by customers for the 16th year in a row.
Time Out Dubai
3 hours ago
- Time Out Dubai
Wizz Air Abu Dhabi launches cheap flight deals from Dhs204 as it prepares to exit
There's still time to snag a bargain. Wizz Air is officially pulling out of the UAE capital on Monday September 1, but before it goes, the low-cost airline is offering a final flurry of ultra-cheap fares that have sparked a booking frenzy across the UAE. Flights to popular destinations in Eastern Europe and Central Asia are currently going for as low as Dh204 one-way, making this a fab moment for a spontaneous summer escape. While Wizz Air Abu Dhabi will cease operations in September, the airline's wider network will continue to fly to the UAE, including a couple of DXB-based routes. You may like: How you can still fly with Wizz Air from the UAE Some of the standout deals for August departures include: Kutaisi, Georgia – Dhs204 Yerevan, Armenia – Dhs264 Baku, Azerbaijan – Dhs254 Tashkent, Uzbekistan – Dhs314 Almaty, Kazakhstan – Dhs404 Baku (Credit: Adobe Express) These low fares are among the last available before the airline shuts down its Abu Dhabi hub, marking the end of an era for the budget airline from the capital. The deals are especially appealing for families making the most of school holidays or anyone looking for one final wallet-friendly break before Wizz Air officially stops flying from Abu Dhabi. If you've ever thought about ticking one of these destinations off your list, now's the time – these flights are going fast and they might not come around again at these prices. Final boarding call: book now or miss out. Jetting off soon? Everything you need to know about Al Maktoum International Airport A deep dive into the big project When is the next UAE public holiday? Your public holiday questions, answered Dubai flights: When will flydubai start operations in Al Maktoum International Airport? The budget airline will open at Al Maktoum International Airport sooner than you'd think
Scotsman
4 hours ago
- Scotsman
STV Group to slash costs after profit warning: shares fall by a fifth
'The deteriorating macroeconomic backdrop continues to lower business confidence impacting both markets in which we operate' – Rufus Radcliffe, CEO Sign up to our Scotsman Money newsletter, covering all you need to know to help manage your money. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... STV Group is taking the axe to £2.5 million of costs this year, raising the spectre of possible job cuts, after a deterioration in the commissioning and advertising markets in recent months. The Glasgow-based broadcaster, which holds the Scottish Television and Grampian Television licences, warned investors that its full-year revenue and adjusted operating profit are now expected to be 'materially below consensus'. Shares tumbled by more than a fifth in early Monday trading. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad In a trading update ahead of September's results, the group said incremental cost savings of £750,000 have been identified bringing its 2025 target to £2.5m, compared with the £1.7m or so previously outlined. Rufus Radcliffe took up the post of chief executive at STV Group last November. 'We continue to assess the cost base in its entirety and expect to provide an update on further initiatives at our interim results, with further cost savings expected to be realised in 2026,' it added. At the firm's flagship studios business there has been a 'significant commissioning market deterioration' in recent months as the UK macroeconomic backdrop has worsened, STV warned. This has impacted its unscripted labels with some projects in advanced development not being green-lit and some commissions being delayed to next year. While STV Studios is developing an international business, most customers remain UK-based, the group noted, meaning the division has been 'disproportionately impacted' by the recent slowdown in the domestic market. The forward order book is now £54m, compared to £66m at the end of April. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Rufus Radcliffe, chief executive of STV Group, said: 'The deteriorating macroeconomic backdrop continues to lower business confidence impacting both markets in which we operate. The Blue Lights drama came out of the STV Studios stable for the BBC. "We're making good progress in combining and streamlining our broadcast and digital businesses into a new audience division, and launch plans for the creation of our radio station are going well, with key appointments made and infrastructure plans forging ahead. 'STV Studios delivery schedule for the remainder of 2025 has been impacted by the UK commissioning market, which has further weakened at the end of [the first half] and into the second half of the year. However, in addition to winning new and repeat business in H1, we have completed production on key titles with international appeal, including high-end drama Amadeus for Sky and a third series of Blue Lights for BBC One, with the second series of The Fortune Hotel airing on ITV and STV this summer - and our development pipeline is strong.' He added: 'We are proactively responding to market conditions through a combination of investing in targeted future growth initiatives aligned with our long-term strategy and identifying efficiency and cost saving opportunities across the business. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'There continues to be strong long-term growth potential within our business despite the short-term challenges, and we remain laser focused on delivering on the strategic plan we outlined earlier this year.' The Hit List is one of the programmes to come out of the STV Studios business. Analysts at Panmure Liberum noted: 'The company has offset some pressure with immediate cost reductions and will guide on more in September. 'Looking further out we would expect to see the commissioning market pick up again and the successful studios business to gain the benefit as well as the expanded World Cup to provide a lift to advertising in 2026. The shares are likely to feel immediate significant pressure,' they added. In its update, STV said group revenue for the full year is expected to be in a range from £165m to £180m at an adjusted operating margin of about 7 per cent, with £10m of the revenue range driven by updated studios guidance. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad At the time of March's full-year results, the group said its 2024 performance demonstrated the 'benefits of diversification against a challenging market backdrop'. At the top line, revenues grew by 12 per cent, year on year, to £188m, driven by acquisition-related growth in the STV Studios business - responsible for the likes of Amadeus (Sky) and Blue Lights (BBC) - as well as Euros-related advertising during the year. The studios division racked up revenue growth of 26 per cent, to £84.1m, while adjusted operating profit rose 18 per cent to £6.1m. Digital sales - before commission - were up 8 per cent to £21.8m, while total advertising revenue was up 5 per cent before commission. It meant that group adjusted operating profit nudged up 3 per cent to £20.6m, with statutory operating profit more than doubling to £13.2m. A group adjusted operating margin of 11 per cent was slightly down on 2023, which had been expected, while the board proposed a final dividend of 7.4p, making a full-year payout of 11.3p per share, in line with 2023. Number one On the audience front, the group said STV and STV Player combined were still the 'clear number one' for commercial audiences in Scotland. It highlighted a 19 per cent share of total peak commercial audience in 2024 (versus Netflix at 13 per cent, Sky 10 per cent and Channel 4 to 6 per cent). STV was the most watched commercial channel in Scotland on 363 of the 366 days in the leap year of 2024, bosses noted. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad STV aired the best-watched quiz show (The 1% Club), drama (Mr Bates vs The Post Office), and soap opera (Coronation Street) across all channels in Scotland during 2024.
