
Red Wings depth chart 1.0: Detroit has flexibility, but which option is best?
When general manager Steve Yzerman met with the media last week, he still alluded to the possibility of trade opportunities that could arise in the wake of free agency. He even mentioned there were 'a couple teams looking to do some things that we do have some interest in and are possibilities.'
Advertisement
In the days (and possibly weeks) to come, we'll find out whether any of those will materialize into anything more than tire kicking. If not, perhaps a 13th forward or third goaltender will come into the mix instead.
But as of now, as the dust begins to settle, Yzerman and the Red Wings have a roster in place. And that means the rest of us have a chance to start imagining how the pieces could fit together.
Granted, coach Todd McLellan doesn't have to pick just one arrangement. Throughout the long NHL season, there are all kinds of combinations he can experiment with — more than we can realistically project here. And the new lineup players the Red Wings added — wingers James van Riemsdyk and Mason Appleton, defenseman Jacob Bernard-Docker — give McLellan plenty of flexibility.
So today, even acknowledging the possibility of one more move, it's worth examining what kind of options Detroit is looking at with its new depth chart.
I'm calling this the default because when I look at the names on Detroit's roster, it's the one that makes the most sense to me. But rather than start at the top, I want to start in the middle of the lineup, because the rest of the decisions ultimately flow out from there.
We know Yzerman views Appleton as a classic checking-line winger who can contribute offensively as well. That makes it easy to slot him onto the third line at right wing. The first question, though, is whether Andrew Copp or J.T. Compher will center that checking line — and the answer might turn out to be both.
When I asked Yzerman after the draft how he saw his center situation playing out after Marco Kasper's great finish to the season as the team's No. 2 center, he noted the possibility of Compher and Copp's playing on the same line together, determining who takes faceoffs by which side of the ice the draw is on. Yzerman is ultimately going to leave those decisions to McLellan, so he's not tipping a hand or anything here, but keeping both players higher in the lineup in a matchup role that would give Detroit a real advantage on faceoffs is an interesting idea.
Advertisement
So, for Scenario 1, let's go with that as the construction for the third line. From there, the question is who will move into the top-line left-wing role. And there are a lot of options, with no clear choice. But looking at it on paper in early July, I found myself homing in on two players: veteran van Riemsdyk and young winger Elmer Söderblom.
My gut, though, is to give the close call to van Riemsdyk, who had 16 goals last year and is as proven a net-front presence as you'll find in the NHL. He's no longer in his prime, at 36, but being able to dig pucks out of a scrum or bang home a rebound? That's still right in his wheelhouse, and it makes a lot of sense to put him with two players who funnel plenty of pucks into that area.
There is a question of pace, but none of the alternatives answers that question any better. The biggest issue might be workload, as van Riemsdyk averaged just 12:24 of ice time last season. But there were games van Riemsdyk got as high as 17 minutes, and if he can give 15 good minutes at even strength, that might be enough. It's not ideal, but no top-line option is, and van Riemsdyk's size and touch around the net make him an interesting option.
That leaves a fourth line of Söderblom, Michael Rasmussen and Jonatan Berggren, which is admittedly a bit of a mishmash of skills. But it still has a solid defensive center in Rasmussen, a nifty playmaker in Berggren and a skilled stickhandler with a big shot in Söderblom. That could work, even if the line feels like it lacks a real identity.
Meanwhile, on defense, there's not a lot of analysis needed because it's basically what Detroit went with when Jeff Petry was out last season. In that time, Albert Johansson broke through and earned a lot of trust from McLellan and assistant coach Trent Yawney, although some of the underlying numbers weren't as encouraging. For a young defenseman, though, Johansson can continue to grow into being a steady puck-mover, and his ability to play either side is a real asset.
Advertisement
Going into the season like this would once again ask a lot of Johansson and Ben Chiarot, but absent an upgrade from outside, this looks like the obvious top four.
As for the third pair, some will be itching to see new addition Bernard-Docker on the right side, and I'll get to that later in this piece. But in sheltered minutes last season, Justin Holl did turn in an expected goals share of 50 percent for the season, and it was even better under McLellan. That goes against a lot of the narratives around him. The actual goals share was a different story, which is where the frustration stems from — and of course, that is the number that counts on the scoreboard.
But I wouldn't be quite so quick to write off Holl as an extra. He'll still be in plenty of games for Detroit this year.
Here's a different way of approaching those same decisions, and there's a real argument to be made that this could be a better overall construction.
For starters, van Riemsdyk goes from the top line into a depth role more in line with his average ice time last season with the Columbus Blue Jackets. He was effective in that kind of role, and for a big body of his age, maybe it will turn out to be the best way to use him.
That leaves a hole up top, and in this scenario, it's Söderblom who will get that look. I did have some pace questions when Söderblom got some limited run with Dylan Larkin and Lucas Raymond last season, but like van Riemsdyk, he brings a needed size element to that line and does so with considerable skill to boot. If the 24-year-old can take a step in the skating department over the summer, he might even offer a little higher upside because of his combination of size, hands and shot.
The big difference, here, though, is in how Detroit will use Compher and Copp. I struggle with the idea of the Red Wings' top three centers all being left-handed, but we saw how effective Copp, Rasmussen and Christian Fischer were as a checking line in recent seasons, and Appleton could offer a similar look with the potential for a touch more offense, too.
Advertisement
That would free up Compher to center the fourth line, still keeping van Riemsdyk with a veteran center who has offense in his game. I could have left Berggren on the right wing here as the playmaker on the line, but I also wanted to acknowledge that Mazur could make this team out of camp. He's had some rotten injury luck in recent years, but is still an intriguing young player who (when healthy) probably better suits a fourth-line identity than Berggren does and still brings scoring touch in the hard areas of the ice.
This bottom six would have a clear checking line plus a fourth-line trio that has real scoring potential, and the bottom six as a whole would be harder to play against on paper.
On the blue line, Bernard-Docker gets into the lineup in this scenario, and I am curious to see what he can do in new surroundings. He's had some decent underlying numbers in limited action thus far in his NHL career, and Yawney has a great track record for developing young defensemen. Maybe Detroit can tap into something there.
All right, now let's get a little more wild.
In the first two scenarios, I've assumed Detroit would stick with Kasper as the 2C, since that's where he projects long-term. But it's worth noting he was also excellent as a top-line left wing for a stretch last season, and Copp showed pretty well between Patrick Kane and Alex DeBrincat under McLellan. So, absent a clear answer at top-line wing before camp, who's to say the coach doesn't go right back to that to begin the season? It would give Larkin and Raymond a great high-paced complement who can mix it up down low, and Copp has the size and hockey sense to work with the two smaller skilled wingers on line two.
Ideally, Rasmussen would probably be the checking line winger in that scenario, but with no other center options left, he instead stays at 4C. The question then becomes who gets the bump up to third-line left wing among van Riemsdyk, Söderblom, Berggren or even Carter Mazur.
Instead, though, what about Nate Danielson? Yes, Danielson is also a natural center, but it's not uncommon to break in young centers on the wing, and his mature defensive game could fit right in next to Compher and Appleton — while also bringing great skating and some playmaking flavor to the line. I can't see Detroit bringing Danielson up to play on the fourth line, and frankly, even this third-line wing role might be stretching it. But if Danielson has a great camp, this would be one way to get him top-nine minutes, and he could move up the lineup by season's end, like Kasper.
Advertisement
I'd be fascinated to see Danielson play with Kane and DeBrincat — though that seems like more of a March consideration than an October one.
In this scenario, too, the fourth line would have a lot of size but also some real offense, with van Riemsdyk plugging into a new version of the old 'Redwoods' line that used to feature Ramussen, Söderblom and Oskar Sundqvist.
There are other options to work with beyond what we've laid out here. It wouldn't be unthinkable for Berggren — who finished last season on the top line — to get another look there. It also wouldn't be unreasonable to give Copp or Compher a look in that spot. Would it be unheard of to even see Danielson there at some point, after how well that worked for Kasper?
Though Detroit's offseason left plenty to be desired in terms of sizzle, it has also left McLellan plenty of options in how he can arrange his lineup — regardless of whether one really sticks or whether he instead cycles between them throughout the year.
(Photo of Andrew Copp and Ben Chiarot: Brett Holmes / Imagn Images)

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Rams rookie Terrance Ferguson says he has some similar traits to Travis Kelce
After the Los Angeles Rams drafted Terrance Ferguson, Sean McVay made some bold comparisons for the rookie tight end. He sees similarities between Ferguson and Travis Kelce, as well as former Pro Bowl tight end Chris Cooley, whom McVay coached in Washington. McVay isn't the only one who sees Kelce's game in Ferguson's because the rookie tight end himself feels the same way. During an interview on ESPN LA, Ferguson was asked which tight end he plays like and he immediately mentioned Kelce. 'I take a lot of things from everybody's game,' he said. 'I try to be a student of the game and learn a lot from different people. I feel like some of the running routes and things at the top of the routes, I feel like I have some movements like Travis Kelce and that's one of the best ever. I definitely model my game and watch a lot of his tape just because he's so special at the top of his route and after the catch and I feel like I have similar movement patterns as him. But then there's other guys like Mark Andrews and George Kittle that are workhorses. You can learn something from a wide receiver out here on a release. You can learn from everybody, so I try to pick a little bit of everything but I would say definitely Travis Kelce, Mark Andrews.' Ferguson and Kelce are both around 6-foot-5 and 250 pounds, so their frames are akin to one another. Kelce has been arguably the best tight end of this generation, so Ferguson has a long way to go before he reaches the All-Pro's level. But it's never a bad thing to model your game after a superstar. Both players are savvy route runners and incredibly dangerous after the catch, which the Rams are sure to take full advantage of his skill set this season. If he becomes anything like the player that Kelce is, Los Angeles will have hit a home run in the second round. This article originally appeared on Rams Wire: Rams' Terrance Ferguson says he has similar traits to Travis Kelce
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
USC women's basketball lands another No. 1 recruit in Saniyah Hall
First it was JuJu Watkins. Then it was Jazzy Davidson. Now another of the nation's top women's basketball recruits is on her way to USC. Saniyah Hall, the nation's No. 1 prospect in the 2026 class, committed to USC on ESPN on Friday, shortly after her official visit to campus. She's the third No. 1 prospect in four years to commit to Lindsay Gottlieb and USC. That's a staggering feat given where the program was when Gottlieb took over in 2021. But since landing Watkins in November 2022, arguably no coach in women's college basketball has been better at recruiting top talent like Gottlieb. "Going there, it felt like home," Hall said on ESPN's NBA Today. "I loved all of my future teammates. The girls there are just so fun to be around. And then definitely Lindsay [Gottlieb], she's definitely there to support me and I've built a relationship with her. She's a great coach." Read more: The Times of Troy: USC women's basketball team deals with transfer portal losses Hall, who hails from Ohio, is a fitting addition to that star-studded lineage and a major victory for USC after a disheartening end to last season. She was recently named the most valuable player of the women's FIBA World Cup U19, despite, at just 16 years old, being one of the youngest players competing in the field. Playing alongside her future Trojan teammates this month — Davidson and rising sophomore Kennedy Smith - on the U19 national team, Hall scored nearly 20 points per game to lead all Americans. She also contributed 6.4 rebounds, 2.9 steals, two assists and a block per game, flashing a skillset that already looks primed for top competition. When Hall joins USC next fall, she'll round out a roster that ranks among the most touted in the history of the sport. After missing most of next season, Watkins will return, while Davidson will only be a sophomore. Smith, the No. 6 recruit in the 2024 class, will still presumably be a fixture in the lineup. Add Hall to that equation, and the Trojans, with four five-stars in tow, could very well enter the 2027 season as national title favorites. Sign up for more USC news with Times of Troy. In your inbox every Monday morning. This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Bears aren't sweating slow offensive start at training camp
Rome wasn't built in a day and the Bears' 2025 offense isn't going to be built that quickly either. That was the message from offensive coordinator Declan Doyle after Friday's training camp practice. All eyes are on the Bears offense after the arrival of Doyle, head coach Ben Johnson, first-round tight end Colston Loveland, and several offensive linemen arrived to help quarterback Caleb Williams put up better results in his second NFL season. Those eyes have seen a lot of scuffling through the first three days of practice and Johnson pulled the first team from one drill, but Doyle said that is not any reason for alarm. "No, I wouldn't say that right now," Doyle said, via Courtney Cronin of "This whole thing is a progress, and for the next six weeks we're going to get a ton of reps on all of these plays. We're going to try to master these things. The first time you guys did anything, you know, you're not quite a master at it yet. It takes a little bit of work and progression to get there." Doyle said it will be an issue for the coaching staff if the team repeats mistakes, but that the expectation is that it will take time for everything to run as smoothly as the team wants it to be come September. If that's what happens, all of the summer errors will be chalked up to necessary growing pains in Chicago.