'We told you' – Residents' warning before popular Nelson road closed after slip
Photo:
Supplied/LDR
A landslide has indefinitely closed a popular recreational road in Nelson just months after residents raised red flags.
Glider Road in Marsden Valley had provided access to the top of the Barnicoat Ranges but heavy rain late in May caused a slip which prompted Nelson City Council to close it.
The area around the road had been left bare following the harvesting of pines in the area from 2021.
Preliminary investigations show that the land above and below the steep road was unstable.
Alec Louverdis, the council's group manager infrastructure, in late June said the situation was "complex" and so the council had closed the road indefinitely.
It was now commissioning a geotechnical report to get a better understanding of the challenges and potential way forward.
The closure comes just four months after a newly-formed group of Marsden Valley residents publicly raised concerns about deforested hills in the valley increasing the risk of landslides.
The reforestation of the area around Glider Road had been a specific priority for the group.
Friends of Marsden Valley member Kathryn Richards had seen "significant damage and cracks opening" on the road since the May rains and thought the council made the "right call" closing it.
However, she said there was an element of "we told you".
"Having said that, trees that were only three years old in the ground - which they would have been, best case scenario - I don't know if they would have stopped this."
Kathryn Richards (front left) and the Friends of Marsden Valley had warned that a slip around Glider Road was likely after pines had been harvested.
Photo:
LDR/Max Frethey
Richards said the situation showed the "inevitable" consequences of clear-felling pine on steep slopes.
"We've definitely seen an increase of slipping since the trees have been removed. It illustrates the point that, when it's in pine trees it might be fine and dandy, but you've got to think about, when they're taken away, what's going to happen, and we've now got to deal with that."
Also a member of the Marsden Valley Trapping Group, Richards said the closure will add more than four hours to some of their trap lines.
The closure has also put more walkers on the Involution trail, an advanced downhill mountain biking track, she said.
"It'd be great if they could come to a safe solution, in the meantime, for recreational use, for bikes and walkers."
Kevin Rooke, president of the Tasman Hang Gliding and Paragliding Club, said the Barnicoat Range was the "jewel in the crown" of regional gliding sites and had been used by gliders "nearly ever fine day" before it was closed, attracting gliders internationally.
However, he added that the club had "seen the writing on the wall" after the road was repeatedly damaged after heavy rain and anticipated an eventual closure.
The slip has cut off access for gliders to the Barnicoat Range - the "jewel in the crown" of regional gliding sites.
Photo:
Supplied/Peter Allison
The club was negotiating with the council in the hopes of reinstating glider access in some way before the national paragliding championship is hosted in Nelson in January.
"We do need Barnicoat access, if possible. We are looking at a few options. Nelson City Council have been pretty helpful in a lot of ways."
Louverdis said a decision about the future of the Glider Road would not be made until the council understood the issues, potential works, and associated costs.
Planting around Glider Road, as part of the council's transition away from clear-fell pine forestry, is still scheduled to go ahead this winter.
Louverdis added that the council is actively engaged with the Friends of Marsden Valley and will continue working alongside the group to support the future of the area.
On Thursday, Nelson City Council also agreed to a new track linking Involution to the Jenkins Hill summit.
LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 minutes ago
- RNZ News
If La Niña takes control of summer there could be heavy rain or a 'heat dome'
The heatwave that struck Europe during the Northern Hemisphere summer is not necessarily in store for New Zealand. Photo: AFP / Dimitar Dilkoff The heatwave affecting Europe won't be a precursor for New Zealand's summer, according to Earth Sciences New Zealand. Large swathes of Europe are experiencing yet another heatwave, with record temperatures and wildfires burning in several countries. The heat is pegged to a weather phenomenon known as a 'heat dome', where an area of high pressure traps the warm air underneath it. But Chris Brandolino, a forecaster at Earth Sciences New Zealand (formerly NIWA), told Morning Report Europe's summer weather did not offer any insight into what our summer might look like. '"Europe is a long way away. The climate drivers that affect their weather are different from ours. "We're an island nation surrounded by water. We can get high-pressure domes that can cause extended periods of warm to hot weather during the warm season. But it's tempered by the ocean. "We tend to get really hot temperatures when a heat dome forms over Australia, for example, and that air gets shifted to the east over New Zealand." As to what our summer would bring, Brandolino said it was a bit too far out to know exactly. But the weather forecaster had some long-range predictions for the North and South Islands. "When we're making a super long-range outlook, we're trying to identify what the expected climate drivers are, who's going to be driving Mother Nature's car? "Right now, La Niña is emerging as a contender to be driving that car," he said. "Historically, when we have La Niña, we tend to have high pressure that can produce a heat dome over south-eastern New Zealand "That would mean areas in the South Island, particularly the western South Island, have the best chance of dry weather, perhaps too much dry weather. We'll potentially have to be mindful of a lack of rainfall and the implications that come from that. "For the North Island, it depends on where the high pressure sets up. If it sets up closer to New Zealand, it will shield much of the country from northerly winds that will bring heavy rainfall and humidity. "If the high pressure is further east, towards the Chatham's let's say, that opens the door for winds to come from the North and east, and areas in the northern and eastern North Island will have higher odds for big rainfall." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Weather damage causes power outages in Auckland's Mangere
Parts of Mangere have been without power for several hours this morning due to weather damage. Photo: Vector Parts of Mangere have been without power for several hours due to weather damage. Vector's online outage map says power is out due to network or equipment damage. It said crews are working to find the cause of the outrage and the estimated restoration time is not until after 11:30am. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
Cyclone Gabrielle one of most extreme landslide-triggering events globally
A new report shows Cyclone Gabrielle was one of the most extreme landslide-triggering events ever recorded globally. RNZ can reveal the findings of an Earth Sciences New Zealand analysis of Cyclone Gabrielle landslides, which estimated more than 800,000 landslides were caused by the extreme weather event in 2023. Cyclone Gabrielle killed 11 people nationwide and destroyed thousands of homes. Several large scale investigations into the cyclone revealed major failings by local authorities and Civil Defence in Hawke's Bay. Earth Sciences New Zealand engineering geologist Chris Massey told RNZ an extensive analysis of Cyclone Gabrielle landslides revealed an astonishing picture of its impact to the land, believed to be the worst of its kind in world history. A gully of pine forestry near Gisborne that slipped in Cyclone Gabrielle. Photo: ALEXA COOK / RNZ "It was shocking to see the huge areas affected, it went all the way from the Wairarapa to Hawke's Bay, Gisborne - then across to Auckland and Northland." It took a large team of scientists months to analyse all the data. "We think it's the largest number of landslides that's ever been mapped from a single storm event in the world." Researchers identified landslide patterns, finding that because Auckland had been hit with flooding several weeks before Cyclone Gabrielle, larger and deeper landslides were activated there. While in Hawke's Bay and Gisborne, the land was pockmarked with numerous shallow slips. Massey said in those areas the ground was so saturated by heavy rainfall, over 500mm in just 24 hours in some cases, that the huge number of landslides was inevitable. The scarred hillsides of Tutira after Cyclone Gabrielle. Photo: ALEXA COOK / RNZ "The sheer intensity of the rain seems to have overprinted the soil moisure conditions - meaning it didn't matter what the soil moisture levels were before Gabrielle," he said. However, what did make a difference to if land moved or not, was if had vegetation growing on it. Land with pasture and scrub was more susceptible to landslides, whereas areas covered in forest and bush were better off. "The differences were pretty significant with up to 330 landslides per kilometre square in grassland and scrub, but those densities were much lower in indigenous and exotic forests," he said. A number of landslides caused by Cyclone Gabrielle closed State Highway 2 between Napier and Wairoa for weeks. Photo: ALEXA COOK / RNZ Although the type of forest growing on the land also made a difference, with native bush performing better than pine trees. "It supports the concept that indigenous forest is good from a preventing landslide perspective," Massey said. And with the intensity and frequency of weather events increasing due to climate change, he said this landslide mapping research is a valuable tool for future land use decisions. "We're going to start losing larger portions of soil, which causes issues not just for agriculture, but for people living downstream of these places. It's not just the landslides, but the debris they generate and the cascading effect," he said. The data sets would be used for forecasting landslides. "We're saying 'hey look how many landslides we've got, let's use the models we can develop from these to help us anticipate where they may occur again'," he said. He hoped the data set would be used by many people for many years to come. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
