Edinburgh safety fears over pro-Palestine protest planned for city centre
Questions have been raised over whether a pro-Palestine protest in Edinburgh should be banned on public safety grounds.
A Support Palestine rally has been scheduled for 19 July, but officers have said past events run by the same organiser have had inadequate stewarding and management.
The council's public safety department objected to the procession going ahead, with an officer saying: 'The reason for our objection is based on recent experience with this applicant, with serious concerns about the applicant's ability to deliver a safe and controlled procession of this scale in the city centre.
The officer said the organiser of the planned demonstration was also behind demonstrations on 29 March and 5 April, which saw 'serious public safety risks'.
He continued: 'On the 29th of March, the procession caused severe congestion at the junctions of Princes Street, Hanover Street and the Mound.
'This resulted in large groups of pedestrians and vehicles competing for space. Police Scotland had to intervene to expedite the parade's movement across the junction, which was necessary to avoid the deterioration of public safety conditions.
'On the fifth of April, participants in the procession entered the tram route. This created an uncontrolled crowd environment and introduced serious hazards to life and safety.
'Despite assurances from the organisers in advance, no effective stewarding or containment was in place to prevent this.
'Bus and tram services had to be turned around, and participants and the public were placed at considerable risk.'
The officer said that the council's public safety department had concerns over whether the organiser could handle the estimated 2,000 attendees safely, given that the previous demonstrations had been smaller.
A Police Scotland representative followed up to say: 'This is a very difficult event to police continually. There's a public safety risk that concerns us.
'While ad hoc it is manageable, it is becoming a regular occurrence which is becoming logistically challenging for us.'
Earlier in the meeting, SNP councillor Norman Work said: 'I just wondered if there would be concerns about safety?
'I think it should be a rare or special vein for [a procession across Princes Street to occur.] It can cause a lot of disruption.'
Later on, Conservative councillor Neil Cuthbert also questioned what could be done about the parade, saying: 'The applicant for this has also applied on other dates, but they've been withdrawn. Is there anything we should draw from that?
'And is it possible to say, great, it can go ahead, but in a different location?'
Council officer Andrew Mitchell explained to councillors the legal test required for a protest to be banned, saying that it would require the event to 'place an excessive burden on police'.
Conservative councillor and committee convener Joanna Mowat asked the Police Scotland representative if the bar for a ban had been reached.
She said: 'In your opinion, were the issues caused by the previous protests, did that place an unreasonable burden on the police?'
The police officer replied: 'We've had to invoke our emergency powers in order to manage traffic, which we shouldn't have to routinely do.
'But as we look at the burden of the police, we'll ultimately just stop traffic, we will absolutely stop everything in order to maintain public safety. Ultimately, we have the police officers to do that.'
A decision on the protest was delayed to the next Licensing Sub-Committee meeting, set to take place on Tuesday, 17 June, which can be viewed here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
31 minutes ago
- The National
Scotland's trade unions need to mobilise against the far right
The SSP were proudly present, as we have been since day one, arguing for an end to the genocide, to Labour's arms sales and SNP arms subsidies, supporting mass struggle for peace through socialism in the Middle East. By stark contrast, those of us in the SSP who joined the peaceful protest – initiated by Falkirk Trades Union Council – outside the Cladhan hotel housing refugees and asylum seekers in Falkirk, were faced with an ugly mass of racist bigotry across a narrow street. READ MORE: I went to Glenfinnan to see Harry Potter tourism chaos. Here's my verdict. At a peak, we had around 250-300 anti-racists protecting the 'hotel', its workers, and those who have sought sanctuary from wars and civil wars, from attack by a crowd whipped up into a frenzy by fascist and other far-right groups. The alarming fact is that at their peak, those screaming 'send them home', 'stop the boats', and singing 'Rule Britannia' numbered 800 to 1000. It was allegedly called as 'a peaceful protest' after an asylum seeker was convicted of rape and jailed. This inexcusable, heinous crime was latched on to to brand all asylum seekers, refugees and people of colour as rapists and paedophiles by unscrupulous far-right actors – including 'Tommy Robinson' – real name Stephen Yaxley-Lennon – Ukip's Nick Tenconi, and grouplets like Great Britain National Protest. Some of the local people who joined this demo may well have concerns about women's safety, but where were they when Women's Aid and other services were being cut? Where did they protest against the most common of all crimes against women – rape, assault and murder by men in their own family, usually a husband or partner? At the very start of the demo, a few shouted about Grangemouth and the threatened closure of Alexander Dennis – issues the SSP has spearheaded campaigning on in the streets of Falkirk, calling for nationalisation under workers' control to build clean electric buses for free public transport. The full weight of the trade union movement has yet to take action on this and by doing so could answer the genuine concerns some locals were expressing. But yesterday, they were part of a baying mob, some of them giving Nazi salutes, chanting the fascist National Front's slogan of the 1970s, 'there's no black in the Union Jack'. In among this crowd were banners with a skull pierced by a bloodstained dagger, saying 'Kill Them All, Let God Sort 'em Out' – hardly a peaceful message or one of concern for women and children's safety. The lumpenised sections of this demo screamed abuse at women stewards on the entirely peaceful anti-racist demo, calling them 'c**ts', and described all of us as 'paedos'. It took great courage by all those of us who stood for hours, holding the line against likely attacks on the Cladhan hotel, but we did – despite the paltry police presence, with at first only half-a-dozen officers separating the rival crowds. If we hadn't held the line, the hotel and people within it would have been attacked, with unthinkable human costs. Tinderbox of anger This was a harsh reminder of the deep damage done by capitalist crises – including housing shortages, service cuts, job losses in Grangemouth and Alexander Dennis, and grinding poverty – and the unforgivable scapegoating and racist incitement, not just by Reform UK, Ukip and fascist grouplets, but also Starmer's Labour. They've created a tinderbox which flares up with the likes of a horrible rape incident, targeting all those fleeing wars and persecution for racist attacks and potential injury and death, as angry mobs are incited to target the 'hotel' they're cooped up in for ages, as the government fails to deal with their asylum applications. READ MORE: Reform councillor shares stage with 'neo-Nazi' at protest in Falkirk Saturday's events in Falkirk were possibly the ugliest I've witnessed since our battles against the fascist street fighters of the 1970s. However, the fact Saturday's crowds didn't just overpower the substantially smaller anti-racist demonstrators is further evidence they were overwhelmingly not fascist street fighters, but an angry, downtrodden crowd who have had their anger channelled into racist bigotry; blind hatred of people who had nothing to do with shoddy housing, benefits cuts, totally inadequate services and other privations. As we chanted a few times, 'Profit is the enemy'. A warning to the workers' movement Falkirk should be treated as a wake-up call to all trade unions (the STUC included) and socialists. We need to build a positive, working-class socialist alternative in communities ravaged by capitalist attacks, regardless of which 'mainstream' party is in office. Otherwise they'll be prey to the baying mobs and racist slogans of far-right outfits. The SSP will continue to help resist the poisonous antics of the far right, and call on the full power of the organised trade union movement to be mobilised in demonstrations in the likes of Falkirk, to build unity against poor housing, service cuts (including those for women and children), against the closure of Alexander Dennis, and for a positive socialist alternative, with massive wealth redistribution away from the millionaires who hoard it to the millions who need it. We need a sharp, socialist class appeal to people most affected by the crisis of capitalist rule, to break them from the millionaire demagogues of the far right, who want to divide us and rob us of even more wealth.
Wales Online
an hour ago
- Wales Online
SNP promise to close attainment gap ‘in ruins', say Lib Dems
SNP promise to close attainment gap 'in ruins', say Lib Dems The party's education spokesperson Willie Rennie said that the SNP has "betrayed a whole generation of young people from poorer backgrounds" The Liberal Democrats have said the SNP's promise to close the attainment gap "lies in ruins" after Scottish exam results showed "minuscule progress". (Image: PA Archive/PA Images) The Liberal Democrats have said the SNP's promise to close the attainment gap "lies in ruins" after Scottish exam results showed "minuscule progress". The party's education spokesperson Willie Rennie said that the SNP has "betrayed a whole generation of young people from poorer backgrounds" and called for urgent action to drive up performance. He pointed to comments by then-first minister Nicola Sturgeon in 2016 when she said her government would push to substantially reduce the attainment gap by 2026, writing in that year's programme for government document that elimination of the gap was "a yardstick by which the people of Scotland can measure our success". Latest exam results published this month show that the poverty-related attainment gap – the difference between the A-C rate for those from the 20% of the most deprived areas of Scotland compared with the most affluent – has shrunk narrowly. The National 5 rate dropped from 17.2% to 16.6% while Highers saw a small dip from 17.2% to 17.1% and Advanced Highers from 15.5% to 12.8% compared with last year. Meanwhile, figures from the Scottish Funding Council show that in 2023-24, 16.7% of Scottish-domiciled full-time first degree entrants to university were from the 20% most deprived areas, up from 16.3% in 2022-23. Article continues below The Scottish Government has a target that by 2030, 20% of full-time, first-degree entrants to higher education should be from Scotland's 20% most deprived backgrounds. Mr Rennie said: "The SNP's promise to close the attainment gap lies in ruins. By Nicola Sturgeon's own yardstick, her party has betrayed a whole generation of young people from poorer backgrounds. "The minuscule progress that they have made is nowhere near good enough. On the SNP's watch, Scotland has tumbled down the international rankings, and parents are hugely worried about what that means for their children's futures. "In schools, there are lots of issues that need addressed, from behaviour challenges to teachers stuck on supply lists and fundamental problems with the curriculum, but all of them have gotten worse under the SNP. "We urgently need a plan to drive up education performance and improve outcomes for our young people." A Scottish Government spokesperson said: "Substantial progress is being made on widening access to higher education. The latest UCAS data shows the number of Scots accepted to a UK university from deprived areas increasing by 11% since 2023. Article continues below "Ministers remain resolute in meeting the goal of 20% of all entrants being from the 20% most deprived communities by 2030, and will continue to work constructively with the sector to achieve this. "We are determined to drive continued improvement, which is why the curriculum improvement cycle is underway and we are progressing with qualifications reform. "We will continue to engage with our school and local authority partners as part of the annual review of the national improvement framework, to ensure we continue to drive up standards for all our children and young people, and our investment in the Scottish attainment challenge is ongoing to tackle the attainment gap."
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Queensland police go to court in bid to stop Story Bridge pro-Palestine protest march
The Queensland police service will take protest organisers to court in an effort to halt a planned pro-Palestine march over Brisbane's Story Bridge this weekend. Justice for Palestine Magan-djin (Brisbane) have advertised plans to march over the bridge at 1pm on Sunday – replicating similar protests that occurred earlier this month in Sydney and Melbourne. Spokesperson for Justice for Palestine Magan-djin Remah Naji said the group is expecting at least 7000 people to attend the rally. The Queensland police oppose the march on public safety grounds. 'Under provisions of the peaceful assembly act, police will lodge documentation with Brisbane magistrates court for a decision to be made with respect to the notice of intention to hold a public assembly,' a spokesperson for the Queensland Police Service said. The matter is yet to be given a date of listing. A cycling group was denied the right to march or ride over the bridge earlier this year at a hearing at the magistrates court on public safety grounds. Naji said the march organisers had already briefed lawyers and were ready for a legal fight. 'We're very much willing to defend our fundamental right to peaceful assembly. If they want to go down this path, we're ready,' she said. Police in New South Wales sought to deny legal protection to a planned protest over the Sydney Harbour Bridge earlier this month – but that bid was overturned by the NSW supreme court at the 11th hour. Police say 90,000 people marched across that iconic structure, organisers put the figure at closer to 300,000 – regardless, the scale of the turnout ranks the protest as historic and the day went ahead without major incidents. In Melbourne on the same day, in contrast, pro-Palestine protesters were met by a wall of police in riot gear behind barricades and backed by a row of mounted officers and riot squad vans when they sought to cross the King Street Bridge. Justice for Palestine Magan-djin conducted mediation with Queensland police on Monday morning. QPS presented two options to the protest group for locations other than the bridge. A spokesperson for the QPS confirmed that mediation had taken place on Monday morning 'however an agreement could not be met'. Naji didn't rule out violating a court injunction if the magistrates court ruled against them, saying it would be a decision for the group collectively. She said the bridge is a central part of the protest because the urgency of the situation in Gaza 'This ongoing livestreamed genocide demands visibility. It is not enough for us to do the usual routes,' Naji said. She said the aim of the march was 'to apply the maximum pressure on our government'. Justice for Palestine Magan-djin has been holding regular protests in Brisbane for the last 22 months since the escalation of the conflict in Gaza after Israel responded to Hamas' attack on 7 October 2023 with a full-scale invasion, bombardment and blockade of aid in the Gaza Strip. More than 60,000 people have been killed in Gaza - mostly women, children and elderly people – since the war began, according to Palestinian health officials. -With additional reporting by Joe Hinchliffe
