Predictive policing has prejudice built in
Re your article ('Dystopian' tool aims to predict murder, 9 April), the collection and automation of data has repeatedly led to the targeting of racialised and low-income communities, and must come to an end. This has been found by both Amnesty International in our Automated Racism report and by Statewatch in its findings on the 'murder prediction' tool.
For many years, successive governments have invested in data-driven and data-based systems, stating they will increase public safety – yet individual police forces and Home Office evaluations have found no compelling evidence that these systems have had any impact on reducing crime.
Feedback loops are created by training these systems using historically discriminatory data, which leads to the same areas being targeted once again. These systems are neither revelatory nor objective. They merely subject already marginalised communities to compounded discrimination. They aren't predictive at all, they are predictable – and dangerous.Ilyas NagdeeAmnesty International UK
The 2002 movie Minority Report was about a police unit that arrested people before they could commit crimes. Science fiction may be coming true. The unit's head, played by Tom Cruise, was accused of 'future murder' and had to go on the run. As we are finding out with AI tools, these programs have built-in limitations and errors.Bruce HigginsSan Diego, California, US
Reading about the government's 'sharing data to improve risk assessment' project calls to mind the Thought Police in George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four.Geoff WalmsleyWirral, Merseyside
Do you have a photograph you'd like to share with Guardian readers? If so, please click here to upload it. A selection will be published in our Readers' best photographs galleries and in the print edition on Saturdays.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
39 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Home Office may be forced to cut police numbers as result of Treasury deal
The Home Office could still be forced to cut the overall number of police officers after lengthy spending review negotiations with the Treasury. Whitehall sources said the department had been asked to look at all options including limiting officer recruitment, which would mean an overall cut in the headcount. The home secretary, Yvette Cooper, was the last minister to reach a deal with the Treasury, with reports suggesting greater police spending would mean a squeeze on other areas of her department's budget. A source said that cuts to police numbers remained 'a possibility'. Officials will also be expected to look at reducing the cost of the government's accommodation for asylum seekers, which is expected to rise to £15.3bn. But ministers have few levers to control the rising costs, which have largely been driven by an increase in the number of asylum seekers housed in hotels. The Home Office had argued privately that police numbers must be maintained for the government to deliver its policy commitments on neighbourhood policing. Police chiefs including Sir Mark Rowley, the commissioner of the Metropolitan police, had publicly lobbied the government for more money in recent weeks. Speaking to reporters on Monday afternoon, the prime minister's official spokesperson said negotiations over the spending review were over. 'The spending review is settled, we will be focused on investing in Britain's renewal so that all working people are better off,' they said. 'The first job of the government was to stabilise the British economy and the public finances, and now we move into a new chapter to deliver the promise and change.' The government has committed to spend 2.5% of gross domestic product on defence from April 2027, with a goal of increasing that to 3% over the next parliament – a timetable which could stretch to 2034. Rachel Reeves's plans will also include an £86bn package for science and technology research and development. Last week the chancellor admitted that she had been forced to turn down requests for funding for projects she wanted to back, amid the Whitehall spending wrangling. Sadiq Khan's office is concerned that Wednesday's announcement will include no new funding or projects for London. The mayor had been looking to secure extensions to the Docklands Light Railway and Bakerloo line on the Underground, along with the power to introduce a tourist levy and a substantial increase in funding for the Met. A source close to the mayor said on Monday that ministers 'must not return to the damaging, anti-London approach of the last government', adding this would harm London's public services and 'jobs and growth across the country'. They said: 'Sadiq will always stand up for London and has been clear it would be unacceptable if there are no major infrastructure projects for London announced in the spending review and the Met doesn't get the funding it needs. 'We need backing for London as a global city that's pro-business, safe and well-connected.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Man who was spotted fleeing Heathrow airport staff on the tarmac was 'being deported from Britain on a commercial flight' 
A man who was filmed being chased across the tarmac Heathrow Airport, was an illegal migrant who was set to be deported from the UK. The man had escaped prior to boarding a commercial flight which was due to depart to India, MailOnline understands. He was being escorted to the UK by contractors Mitie Care & Custody on behalf of the Home Office. However the man managed to get away from his security escorts and made it out of the airport. He was then captured on video by a member of the public, who shared the footage on social media. The man was spotted being chased by at least four other men as he raced across the airport grounds near Terminal 2. He was pursued for around a minute before he is eventually stopped. After managing to evade airport staff on foot, a van appears and two men jump out to capture the runaway man. He was escorted away from the planes by the two men. The police were later seen arriving. The man was pinned to the ground as he was arrested by the police. The man was then returned to the flight and deported from the UK. A spokesperson for Mitie said: 'An investigation into the incident is underway. The individual was quickly apprehended, re-boarded the flight, and was handed over to the relevant authorities on landing.' The Home Office are understood to be investigating the incident. During the video, the narrator becomes increasingly frustrated by the bizarre situation unfolding in front of him. He said: 'What is going on here. Why would there be people running? That geezer is running from someone, they are chasing him. 'What is going on? Isn't there anyone fit enough to take him down.' Becoming more frustrated by witnessing the man still not caught, he said: 'They are going to have to stop the operations, they are going to have to stop aircraft moving, he is running straight towards them.' After the man was stopped, the narrator added: 'What the hell was that all about. 'They are stopping aircraft taxiing as well. 'If that was America there would be 50 vehicles there by now, 700 police. One bloke.' A Heathrow spokesperson said: 'Working with partners, we have quickly resolved an incident at the airport involving an individual who accessed the airfield taxiway. 'The individual has been removed from the airport.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Footage shows immigration detainee running across Heathrow runway
A man was apprehended on the tarmac at Heathrow airport after he managed to free himself from restraints and started running away near Terminal 2 on Sunday. He was reportedly about to be deported to India when he managed to escape. A spokesperson for Mitie, which holds a Home Office contract for removing people from the UK, told the Guardian: 'An investigation into the incident is under way. The individual was quickly apprehended, reboarded the flight, and was handed over to the relevant authorities on landing'
