Ajay Devgn and box office clashes: Some hits and some misses
When the makers of Son of Sardaar 2 recently announced the film's release had been pushed by a week—from July 25 to August 1—industry watchers were quick to point fingers at the stunning box office performance of Mohit Suri's Saiyaara.
Trade exper Taran Adarsh while announcing the postponment on social media called it a 'Wise Decision'. The romantic drama, featuring debutants Ahaan Panday and Aneet Padda, raked in a whopping Rs 83 crore over its opening weekend, surprising trade experts and reshaping release calendars.
This move — to avoid clashing with a film riding high on word-of-mouth and strong weekend numbers — is not new to Bollywood, especially in recent times. Auron Mein Kahan Dum Tha was similarly shifted from its initial release window to avoid competing with the juggernaut that was
Nag Ashwin
's Kalki 2898 AD, which starred Prabhas and continued dominating the box office for weeks. With Saiyaara now threatening to follow the same path, it's no wonder that Son of Sardaar 2 opted for another date and this time he would be clashing with
Karan Johar
backed film Dhadak which is led by
Siddhant Chaturvedi
and Triptii Dimri.
This will be the second time Ajay and Karan would be clashing, first being Shivaay and Ae Dil Hai Muskhil.
But what makes this story more interesting is that the man at the centre of Son of Sardaar 2 —
Ajay Devgn
— is no stranger to box office clashes. Over the years, he has stood toe-to-toe with some of Bollywood's biggest stars and films, and more often than not, he's emerged victorious or at least held his ground. A deep dive into his past clashes reveals a fascinating pattern of risk-taking, mixed results, and surprising resilience.
The Clashes Through the Years: Ajay Devgn vs The Box Office Odds
2022: Thank God vs Ram Setu
Ajay Devgn's Diwali comedy Thank God went up against
Akshay Kumar
's Ram Setu. The result? Ram Setu took the lead with Rs 74.7 crore, while Thank God managed Rs 36.35 crore.
2022: Runway 34 vs Heropanti 2
This was a rare example where Devgn's directorial gamble Runway 34 (Rs 35.49 crore) outperformed Tiger Shroff's action sequel Heropanti 2 (Rs 21.5 crore), proving that solid storytelling can still pull through over formulaic stunts.
2020: Tanhaji vs Chhapaak
Perhaps the most resounding example of Devgn's box office dominance came with Tanhaji: The Unsung Warrior, which crushed
Deepika Padukone
's Chhapaak. While Chhapaak closed at Rs 34.93 crore, Tanhaji stormed past with Rs 279.59 crore, becoming one of the biggest hits of that year.
2017: Golmaal Again vs Secret Superstar
During Diwali 2017, Golmaal Again (Rs 205.69 crore) clashed with Aamir Khan-backed Secret Superstar (Rs 63.4 crore).
Though the latter was appreciated critically, the box office numbers told a different story. Devgn's mass entertainer comfortably dominated.
2017: Baadshaho vs Shubh Mangal Saavdhan
This clash was closer than expected. Baadshaho managed Rs 78 crore, while
Ayushmann Khurrana
's Shubh Mangal Saavdhan earned Rs 42.79 crore. Devgn's star power kept him ahead, although the latter received better reviews.
2016: Shivaay vs Ae Dil Hai Mushkil
The Ajay Devgn-Karan Johar Diwali duel became infamous for its off-screen drama as much as its box office showdown.
Shivaay earned Rs100.45 crore — a commendable figure — but it was Ae Dil Hai Mushkil that had the edge with Rs 113.19 crore, thanks to its music and youth appeal.
2012: Son of Sardaar vs Jab Tak Hai Jaan
This was another explosive Diwali face-off — Devgn's Son of Sardaar clashed with Yash Chopra's swan song Jab Tak Hai Jaan. Despite the odds, Son of Sardaar collected a solid Rs 105.10 crore against JTHJ's Rs 120.87 crore, holding its own and winning big in single screens.
2011: Rascals vs Love Breakups Zindagi
A relatively easier contest. Devgn's Rascals managed Rs 32.6 crore, while Love Breakups Zindagi fizzled out with just Rs 2.25 crore.
2010: Aakrosh vs Knock Out
In a clash of thrillers, Aakrosh (Rs 13.64 crore) led Knock Out (Rs 6.24 crore). Neither was a hit, but Devgn's film fared better.
2010: Golmaal 3 vs Action Replayy
The Diwali weekend once again favoured Devgn. Golmaal 3 (Rs 106.64 crore) emerged a superhit while Akshay Kumar's Action Replayy faltered with Rs 29 crore.
2010: Toonpur Ka Superhero vs Tees Maar Khan
Even in this quirky clash, Tees Maar Khan dominated with Rs 60.96 crore, while Toonpur Ka Superhero struggled at Rs 3.5 crore.
2009: All the Best vs Blue / Main Aur Mrs. Khanna
A triple Diwali clash in 2009 turned out surprisingly well for Ajay. All The Best earned Rs 41.41 crore, surpassing the big-budget Blue (Rs 38.65 crore) and demolishing Main Aur Mrs. Khanna (Rs 7.40 crore).
Ajay Devgn, just like most actors, has had a long and checkered history with clashes — sometimes winning spectacularly (Tanhaji, Golmaal Again), sometimes just falling short ( Shivaay). But what stands out is his consistent willingness to compete head-on. Rarely has he moved away from a clash, which makes the delay of Son of Sardaar 2 notable.
Ajay Devgn may be one of Bollywood's most seasoned warriors when it comes to box office clashes, but the rise of unexpected competitors like Saiyaara shows how the industry is evolving.
In today's market, where content and music-driven youth films can disrupt traditional star power, even veterans like Devgn must choose their battles carefully.
The decision to shift Son of Sardaar 2 is not a sign of weakness — it's a mark of strategic thinking in an unpredictable box office era. And if history is anything to go by, expect Devgn to bounce back — solo release or not — with the same grit and gusto that's defined his 30-year career.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
Kaun Banega Crorepati 17: Amitabh Bachchan recalls how he would gatecrash weddings during his college days; says 'hum dhoondhte the kahin shaadi toh nahi horaha, phir khaa peeke aaramse bahar aate the'
The latest episode of Kaun Banega Crorepati 17 starts with host Amitabh Bachchan welcoming the audience. He resumes the game with rollover contestant Shruti Jain from Mumbai, Maharashtra. He teases her that since she has not invited him to her wedding, he won't come. Later, Big B asks her about how she plans to tie the knot and Shruti reveals that she is going to opt for court marriage because she doesn't want to spend money on wedding. She says, "Mujhe apni wedding nahi marriage acchi chahiye." Mr. Bachchan gets impressed after knowing about her thoughts and calls her sorted. He says, "I have learnt a new term these days, 'she is very sorted." The megastar then recalls his college days and shared a hilarious anecdote about gatecrashing weddings. He says, "Hum jab college mein the toh rupaya paisa toh hota nahi tha humare paas, shayad 2 rupaya pocket money milta tha.. toh jab bhook lage shaam ko toh samajh mein nahi aata tha kya karen? Toh hum log dhoondhte the ke kahin shaadi byaah toh nahi horaha... hum log aise jaate the jaise baarati jaa rahe ho andar. Toh darban humko poochta tha, toh hum peeche aarahe hain aise bol ke aage chale jaate tha. ..(laughs). Khaa peeke aaramse bahar aajate the. Agar aap court marriage karengi toh hum jaison ka kya hoga..." (Back then, we hardly had any money, maybe just ₹2 as pocket money. So, whenever we felt hungry in the evenings, we would look around to see if any wedding was happening nearby. We would sneak in pretending to be part of the baraat. If the gatekeeper stopped us, we'd say we were coming from behind and walk right in,' he shared with a laugh. 'We would eat to our heart's content and walk out happily. That's why I say, if you go for a court marriage, what will happen to people like us?') His hilarious anecdote left the audience in splits. Shruti admitted feeling extremely nervous, adding that it still hasn't sunk in for her that she is sitting on the hot seat, playing the game of Kaun Banega Crorepati. Big B starts the game and reads the question for Rs 3,00,000. Which saltwater lagoon, located along the Coromandel Coast, is shared between Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu? As Shruti is not aware of the answer, she uses her lifeline 'Audience Poll' and selects Option D) Pulicat Lake. Shruti next faces the question for Rs 5,00,000 and she again uses a lifeline. She uses her last lifeline 'Sanket Suchak'. The flag of which ofthese countries features a seven-pointed Commonwealth Star, symbolising its six states and its territories? Even after getting the hint, Shruti is not able to guess the answer and she decides to quit the game. After quitting the game, Big B asks her to take a guess and she selects Option C) New Zealand. The correct answer is Option B) Australia. Shruti takes home Rs 3,00,000. Amitabh Bachchan Breaks Silence on His 'Changed' Look in KBC 17 | Here's What He Says
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
Big banner films still fail to deliver bang for the buck
Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads The disappointing performance of big-budget and multilingual films War 2 and Coolie on their opening weekend, especially after the unexpected and extraordinary success of the low-budget Saiyaara, has reignited concerns about the box office revival, said producers, exhibitors and 2, the sixth offering of the Yash Raj Spy Universe , released across more than half of India's total screens (including IMAX), recorded the lowest opening of ₹29 crore for the Hindi version in the Spy Universe, according to data from Sacnilk. Similarly, Coolie recorded a 45.8% drop in its collection across languages on Monday, compared to that on Sunday, the data in the first four days, War 2 and Coolie collected ₹165 crore and ₹195 crore respectively in India. Both films were made with a budget of ₹350-450 crore each."The disappointing performance of War 2 and Coolie is a reminder that hype and stars cannot guarantee longevity to films," said Suniel Wadhwa, co-founder and director, Karmic Films. "This tendency to create pan-India offerings through stars merely provides a high opening day collection. But sustained success is dictated only by content."Industry executives said one of the factors responsible for the progressive decline in collection on the opening weekend was the lack of freshness and entertaining elements in the scripts of both films."I cannot differentiate one film from the other in the six films of the Yash Raj Spy Universe. It is the same story which is repeated with different stars. Dialogues are dull. There is no thrill or engaging quality to the confrontation between the two central characters in War 2," said Ameya Naik, founder, Fantasy Films, an event management company. "Coolie has benefited considerably from Rajnikanth's stardom. Though Coolie may be better than War 2, its screenplay falters and it does not entertain you."Audiences and distributors also mentioned the glaring lack of visual richness, especially in War 2, as another disappointing factor."A large portion of War 2's budget is invested in actors' fees. The film's visual effects do not justify its budget at all. This makes the viewing experience even more dull as the story lacks freshness and conviction. The film has benefited more from the holiday period," said Shaaminder Malik, a film distributor and trade on the other hand, said they were concerned about the increasing tendency among producers to treat films as "projects"."These films would recover investments. In recent years, things have become so formulaic. Makers are making 'projects'. "We have lost our model of success. Today, big producers with large distribution networks are interested in recovering money through sale of rights and other assets," said Yusuf Shaikh, CEO and founder, Janta Cinema, an exhibitor which showcases films at affordable prices."Producers will recover their money as the formula is working. But the audience is disappointed."
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Big banner films still fail to deliver bang for the buck
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel The disappointing performance of big-budget and multilingual films War 2 and Coolie on their opening weekend, especially after the unexpected and extraordinary success of the low-budget Saiyaara, has reignited concerns about the box office revival, said producers, exhibitors and 2, the sixth offering of the Yash Raj Spy Universe , released across more than half of India's total screens (including IMAX), recorded the lowest opening of ₹29 crore for the Hindi version in the Spy Universe, according to data from Sacnilk. Similarly, Coolie recorded a 45.8% drop in its collection across languages on Monday, compared to that on Sunday, the data in the first four days, War 2 and Coolie collected ₹165 crore and ₹195 crore respectively in India. Both films were made with a budget of ₹350-450 crore each."The disappointing performance of War 2 and Coolie is a reminder that hype and stars cannot guarantee longevity to films," said Suniel Wadhwa, co-founder and director, Karmic Films. "This tendency to create pan-India offerings through stars merely provides a high opening day collection. But sustained success is dictated only by content."Industry executives said one of the factors responsible for the progressive decline in collection on the opening weekend was the lack of freshness and entertaining elements in the scripts of both films."I cannot differentiate one film from the other in the six films of the Yash Raj Spy Universe. It is the same story which is repeated with different stars. Dialogues are dull. There is no thrill or engaging quality to the confrontation between the two central characters in War 2," said Ameya Naik, founder, Fantasy Films, an event management company. "Coolie has benefited considerably from Rajnikanth's stardom. Though Coolie may be better than War 2, its screenplay falters and it does not entertain you."Audiences and distributors also mentioned the glaring lack of visual richness, especially in War 2, as another disappointing factor."A large portion of War 2's budget is invested in actors' fees. The film's visual effects do not justify its budget at all. This makes the viewing experience even more dull as the story lacks freshness and conviction. The film has benefited more from the holiday period," said Shaaminder Malik, a film distributor and trade on the other hand, said they were concerned about the increasing tendency among producers to treat films as "projects"."These films would recover investments. In recent years, things have become so formulaic. Makers are making 'projects'. "We have lost our model of success. Today, big producers with large distribution networks are interested in recovering money through sale of rights and other assets," said Yusuf Shaikh, CEO and founder, Janta Cinema, an exhibitor which showcases films at affordable prices."Producers will recover their money as the formula is working. But the audience is disappointed."
