Review: Rethinking the Stanford Prison Experiment (opinion)
The Stanford Prison Experiment: Unlocking the Truth, a three-part National Geographic documentary, casts doubt on that gloss by interviewing academics and former subjects who say Zimbardo misrepresented his methodology and the implications of his results. Although Zimbardo claimed he gave very little direction to the "guards," for example, recordings show that he and his colleagues encouraged harsh treatment of the "prisoners."
The documentary suggests the so-called experiment is better understood as an improv game in which the subjects acted in ways they thought Zimbardo expected. Yet after torture at the Abu Ghraib military prison in Iraq came to light decades later, Zimbardo, a relentless self-promoter, glibly argued in media appearances and in his book The Lucifer Effect that his research anticipated such abuses by showing "how good people turn evil."
Director Juliette Eisner gives Zimbardo (who died last October, after the documentary was completed) ample opportunity for rebuttal. To some extent, his answers reinforce the impression of slipperiness. But his defenses also highlight an ambiguity at the heart of his experiment: Were the subjects just play-acting, as some now claim, or is that description a self-deceiving rationalization for mortifying behavior?
In the end, Zimbardo loses patience with Eisner's inquiry, declining to answer follow-up questions on the grounds that he has already thoroughly refuted his critics' arguments. Viewers can judge for themselves whether that is true.
The post Review: Rethinking the Stanford Prison Experiment appeared first on Reason.com.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time Magazine
3 days ago
- Time Magazine
Returning to Iraq to Bury My Brothers
On July 9, the Iraqi government released a list of twenty-two people whose remains had been identified nearly 11 years after ISIS militants carried out genocide against the Yazidi community, a religious minority in Northern Iraq. Over the course of two weeks, ISIS invaded Sinjar, including my once peaceful village of Kocho, sewing fear and chaos, before killing nearly every Yazidi man in my village and taking women and children into captivity. I read the list as I have so many times over the past decade, expectantly, hoping to see the names of my mother, brothers, and nieces—all lost to war and not yet returned. Like so many other daughters, sisters, and mothers in my community, I am desperate for an end to the waiting. I long for the chance to say goodbye, to honor my loved ones, and to give them a dignified burial so that those of us who survived may finally have some closure. For families torn apart by war, this is what 'lucky' looks like. So there was a strange tinge of relief in the grief I felt when I got to numbers 11 and 12 on the list. Two of my brothers, Elias and Jalo, side-by-side as they so often were in life. I continued to read the list, still hoping to find the names of my mother, my niece, Kathrine, and the rest of my siblings. But they were not there. This is what genocide does. It reduces human beings to lists and numbers. But my brothers are not numbers. Elias Murad, born in 1973, was the eldest of 11 children. He was my mother's first born and best friend. He was a self-taught mechanic who did everything he could to provide for our family. He made sure we had new shoes for winter and when one of us was sick, he found money for the doctor. He was a loving husband and a father of five, with another child on the way. Jalo Murad was just two years younger than Elias. He was a welder who worked hard every day. He was a son, a brother, a husband and a father of three. He was fascinated by nature and wildlife and during the rare times we had electricity in our village, he was always glued to our old television watching National Geographic. When ISIS invaded in August of 2014, his wife was also pregnant. Both of my brothers were self-taught. They never had any education in their trades or even the resources and tools they needed to thrive. But they worked hard to create a peaceful life for their families. My brothers were not involved in politics, and they never harmed anyone. Despite the poverty, discrimination, and difficulties we faced as a family and a community, my brothers were joyful and their eyes were full of love. And yet, on exactly this day in 2014, ISIS gave them two options: to convert or be killed. We never even discussed these options because we all knew the answer. My brothers would not convert. They would not let ISIS erase thousands of years of history and culture and tradition. We also knew that both options would lead to death. So we prayed and we waited. As we waited, the world watched. The world knew that approximately 1,700 innocent people were surrounded by ISIS and facing genocide. This gave us hope, especially after hearing on television that President Barack Obama had given a speech about helping Yazidis. But that help never found our village. For three days, with Elias and Jalo in their white robes, their Iraqi identification cards in their pockets, we prayed and we waited. On our last night together as a family, the night of Aug. 14, we slept as we always had on the rooftop of our mud house to escape the scorching August heat. We could speak and pray only in whispers. Jalo whispered to God that he would rather be killed than become a prisoner of ISIS. The next day, he and Elias were killed. And I, along with so many other women and girls, including my brothers' pregnant wives and their daughters, became a prisoner of ISIS. In captivity, I thought many times of my brother's prayer, how his death was a form of mercy compared to the evil he would have suffered. Not a day has passed that I have not thought about those whispers and how I must raise my own voice to fight for peace and justice. This conviction led to my becoming an activist and I have dedicated my life to this work because it is personal. Not only was I a witness to one of the most horrific crimes in modern times, but I am also a daughter, a sister, and an aunt faced with how to explain to my brothers' children why they will never know their fathers' love and protection. I do not know the answer. All I know is that today, I will bury my brothers. I will say my goodbyes. I will watch as their remains are covered in the flag of the country that failed to protect them. I will pray that my brothers' stories, their full joyful lives, will stand as a reminder for all of us to see past the numbers of war to the families forever changed. To all the lives lost in waiting. Eleven years have passed and still not a day goes by without my thinking about their last moments. As they were rounded up to be executed, I know they were thinking of their sisters, daughters, and mother. They were thinking of their pregnant wives who would be forced to give birth in captivity to children they would never meet. Today, I can't help but think of how our fellow Iraqis, our neighbors, and people from all around the world joined ISIS and came to destroy these innocent lives, shattering families forever. They killed men, enslaved women, and took young girls into sexual slavery. They forced young boys into training camps. All in the name of "God" and a radical ideology that spread viciously. I fear how easy it would be for this same painful pattern to happen again. Conflicts are raging all over the world and the shadow of these wars is longer and darker than we can imagine. In order to prevent these atrocities in the future, we must try to understand their full cost. With moral failings on a global scale must come a moral reckoning on a global scale. I will continue to advocate for a world in which we are all human beings first; a world where we accept our differences, and no one is denied the right to exist. I will advocate for a world in which no family is sacrificed at the altar of war. I will wait for the next list, and the one after that, until I see the names of my mother, my nieces, and the rest of my siblings.
San Francisco Chronicle
07-08-2025
- San Francisco Chronicle
Dave Franco responds to being fan-cast as Luigi Mangione: ‘I'm open'
After nearly a year of online buzz, Dave Franco has finally weighed in on potentially playing Luigi Mangione on the big screen. Fans on the internet wasted no time pointing out the uncanny resemblance between the Palo Alto native and Mangione, the primary suspect in the murder case of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, since the 27-year-old was arrested in December. Many suggested that Franco would be a great candidate to play Mangione in any future movies or made-for TV shows reenacting the crime. When asked about the discourse during a recent appearance on Bravo's 'Watch What Happens Live,' hosted by Andy Cohen, he admitted he wouldn't be opposed to the idea. "No one has approached me about it yet," he told one viewer via video call during a Q&A portion of the episode, which aired on Tuesday, Aug. 5. "Let's just say I'm open if it's the right people, and let's leave it at that." Franco, who was on the late-night talk show to promote his new body horror film ' Together,' in which he stars opposite his real-life wife Alison Brie, also mentioned that this is far from the first time he has heard about being compared to Mangione. 'More people in my life reached out about this exact thing than anything else that has ever happened,' he said. Mangione, who has ties to Stanford University, was taken into custody on Dec. 9, in connection with the killing of Thompson. Police found several handwritten pages expressing a 'disdain for corporate America' and frustrations with the United States' healthcare system on Mangione when he was arrested. He has pleaded not guilty. From the moment his name and mugshot were released, social media users dug into Mangione's online presence, from Linkedin to Spotify and Letterboxd accounts. A vocal subset of the internet has viewed Mangione as a martyr, urging for his release, making fancam videos of him and even dubbing him 'America's Sweetheart.' In addition to advocating for Franco's involvement in a potential on-screen project, several online have suggested that television writer and creator Ryan Murphy should be involved. Murphy has a history of creating series and film adaptations based on real-life headline news, from 'American Crime Story,' which chronicled the death of Gianni Versace and earned San Francisco native Darren Criss a Golden Globe; O.J. Simpson's murder trial, which starred Stanford alum Sterling K. Brown; and the Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinsky scandal, to 'Monsters,' which has run through the stories of serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer and the Menendez Brothers murder case. But while Hollywood may not have jumped in yet, the case has inspired several documentaries and a San Francisco play, ' Luigi: The Musical.' Earlier this week, the production announced a run at Edinburgh Fringe Festival from Aug. 19-23, its first set of shows outside of San Francisco.
Yahoo
05-08-2025
- Yahoo
What a background check might reveal about your online date
What a background check might reveal about your online date Summer flings. Rooftop drinks. Last-minute getaways. There's something about this season that makes romance feel a little more spontaneous, and a lot more exciting. Whether you're swiping poolside or lining up coffee dates, summer is prime season for online dating. But while the vibes might be casual, how you handle your safety doesn't have to be. A little curiosity can go a long way when it comes to vetting someone new. And in the era of catfishing, ghosting, and mismatched intentions, running a quick background check might be one of the smartest moves you can make before you get swept off your feet. PeopleFinders dives deeper. Why Even Consider a Background Check? Let's be real: Not everyone is who they claim to be online. Maybe they're vague about their job. Maybe their stories don't quite add up. Or maybe you're just getting a gut feeling that something's off. These days, it's less about being suspicious and more about staying empowered, especially when meeting someone new. A study from Stanford found that around 7% of messages on dating apps were less than honest, with most deceptions aimed at making the person seem more appealing. With dating scams and fake profiles on the rise, doing a little digging isn't overreacting—it's a safety measure. Think of it like checking restaurant reviews before a first date. You're not assuming the worst; you're just being smart about your time and who you spend it with. What a Phone Lookup Might Actually Reveal If you're picturing a formal investigation, don't worry. It's a lot simpler (and more discreet) than that. All you need is a name, address, phone number, or email to start uncovering key details about that person you met online. A quick check can confirm their real name, age, and residence—all things people can easily fudge on dating apps. It might also show if they've been married before, have criminal records, or have used aliases in the past. In some cases, it could even give you insight into past addresses or public employment records. Only have their number? A quick reverse phone lookup can tell you who that number is really linked to. It's a low-effort way to see if what they've told you lines up with the facts. What It Won't Tell You (And Why That's Okay) Of course, a background check isn't a crystal ball. It won't reveal emotional availability, relationship intentions, or whether you'll actually click in person. Those things still require old-fashioned chemistry and some in-person time together. But when it comes to ruling out major red flags or just confirming the basics, having a little extra context can give you the confidence to move forward or gracefully step back. Discreet, Quick, and Totally Normal Here's the good news: Running a background check is a lot more common than you might think. With how much of our lives takes place online these days, you can look someone up in minutes, privately and without alerting them. Whether it's your first match of the summer or someone you've been chatting with for weeks, it's a simple step that keeps you in control. Summer's Short, But Smart Choices Last There's nothing wrong with falling a little fast when the nights are warm and the conversation flows. But before you invest your time and energy into someone new, make sure their story checks out. You don't need to give up on summer romance—far from it. You just need to go into it with open eyes and a little extra online dating savvy. A quick background check won't ruin the magic. In fact, it might just help you feel a little more secure and open to the possibilities ahead. After all, the best kind of summer love? The kind that's real. This story was produced by PeopleFinders and reviewed and distributed by Stacker. Solve the daily Crossword
