Should the constitution be amended to deny illegal foreigners access to public health care?
The SAHRC said all South Africans, including documented and undocumented migrants, have a right to access health-care facilities, citing section 27(1) of the constitution, which states that: 'Everyone has the right to have access to health-care services, including reproductive health care.'
The commission emphasised denying foreigners access to clinics and hospitals is unlawful and unethical, despite challenges faced by the public health system.
This sparked outrage among social media users. ActionSA condemned the 'abuse' of South Africa's public health-care system by illegal foreigners, citing stricter laws in other countries that require proof of medical insurance before entering. It said the constitution must be rebalanced to put South Africans first while honouring basic humanitarian obligations in a lawful manner.
'It is unconscionable that a public clinic in Johannesburg can report that more than 70% of its patient records belong to foreign nationals,' ActionSA MP Lerato Ngobeni said. 'South Africa's constitution must reflect the reality of our limited capacity and place the wellbeing of its citizens at the centre.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
10 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Non-South Africans don't qualify for entire health-care package: Dhlomo
'When we look at the preamble of our constitution, it talks about South Africa belonging to all who live in it. That part is important and ought to be respected. But the conclusion from the National Health Insurance public hearings was that the country should provide emergency services to all — that is binding in terms of UN rules. Comprehensive health care is for South Africans.' he said. Dhlomo said a streamlined approach is needed to deal with the matter because Operation Dudula's approach of door-stopping people at public health-care facilities is not the right way. The health department has been engaging the organisation and other stakeholders in recent weeks, he said. 'These concerns can't be ignored, but we must find another approach to handle them.' He confirmed discussions have extended to the home affairs department with proposals to review and possibly repeal sections of key legislation such as the: South African fCitizenship Act; Refugees Act; Identification Act; and Immigration Act. 'Some of these acts are wide and encompassing. Maybe they should have limitations. It's not possible for us to have unlimited resources to deal with what is there in the world,' Dhlomo told the committee.
The Citizen
11 hours ago
- The Citizen
Avela Foundation and Smile Foundation unveiled the new Pixel CO₂ laser at the Nelson Mandela Children's Hospital
Avela Foundation and Smile Foundation unveiled the new Pixel CO₂ laser at the Nelson Mandela Children's Hospital Avela Foundation and Smile Foundation unveiled the new Pixel CO₂ laser to transform burn treatment for children at the Nelson Mandela Children's Hospital on August 20. The milestone was made possible through the generosity of Jacaranda FM's Good Morning Angels and their community of supporters, who raised funds to purchase the groundbreaking device for children affected by burns. The hospital's Dr Pinky Chirwa said the unveiling of the new machine spoke to the ethos of the hospital. Read more: Smile Foundation urges South Africans to step out in style for Socks for Smiles campaign 'This hospital was built on donor money, and everything that you see in the hospital was made possible through public and private partnerships, and as the hospital, we welcome that partnership because we realise that as the public sector alone, we cannot achieve certain milestones alone. Chirwa added that the hospital was open to more partnerships so that the staff was able to continue to make a difference to children. The Alma iPixel CO₂ laser is recognised worldwide as the gold standard for scar treatment. It works by resurfacing damaged skin and stimulating natural healing, helping to soften thick, tight scar tissue, improve skin texture and restore movement. The new device also allows for faster treatment times, shorter recovery periods, and reduced anaesthetic use. This means that more children can be treated, giving them the chance to heal more quickly and with less discomfort. Cami Palomo, founder of Avela Foundation, said, 'Avela Foundation's mission has always been to restore dignity and confidence to young burn survivors. This partnership with Smile Foundation and the incredible generosity of Good Morning Angels' supporters will ensure that children not only heal physically but also emotionally, empowering them with brighter futures.' Jacaranda FM's CSI and purpose lead, Dianne Broodryk, added that the station and its listeners were proud to be part of the good work done by Avela Foundation and the Smile Foundation. General surgeon Dr Ronell Parkhurst, who works closely with Avela Foundation through their burns supportive programme, expressed her excitement for the new machine. 'This laser machine is the best new Pixel CO₂ laser in the world, and not only is it precise, but it can also perform different tasks. It is a fantastic asset to have in burn care, because the real struggle in burns comes once the acute burns are healed.' Follow us on our Whatsapp channel, Facebook, X, Instagram and TikTok for the latest updates and inspiration!
The Citizen
12 hours ago
- The Citizen
‘SA doesn't have unlimited resources' – Parliament told certain immigration acts must be repealed
The committee chairs emphasised that the lack of documentation does not always mean the person is illegally in the country. Chairperson of the Portfolio Committee on Health, Dr Sibongiseni Dhlomo, has told parliament that South Africans' concerns about undocumented foreigners cannot be ignored. However, South Africans should mind how they approach these matters. The social services cluster on Thursday briefed parliament on the progress made in addressing concerns raised regarding their respective portfolios. Organisations such as Operation Dudula and March to March were the subject of presentations from two chairpersons, who, although acknowledging the organisations' concerns, cautioned against criminality in their operations. The organisations have been removing foreigners, said to be undocumented, from public healthcare centres and diverting them to private institutions. They argue that public hospitals and clinics are meant to serve South Africans. 'Concerns cannot be wished away' Dhlomo said he recently discussed the matters with Minister of Health, Dr Aaron Motsoaledi, and came to the conclusion that 'these concerns cannot be ignored, brought in by these citizens. These concerns cannot be wished away'. 'While there are concerns coming in from this background, it's true that there are sometimes clinics and hospitals where there's not enough medication and long queues.' However, Dhlomo urged a different approach in dealing with these matters, apart from removing people from clinics and hospitals. 'Maybe we should find an approach to handle them and, going forward… to address those issues,' said Dhlomo. ALSO READ: Will undocumented foreigners get free healthcare under NHI? – Motsoaledi responds 'Fortunately, I was speaking to the minister who had previously served as the Minister of Home Affairs in the previous administration. And he mentioned that there are certain acts that need to be repealed, by bringing a bill into Parliament from the Home Affairs ministry. 'One is the Citizens Act. I won't go into details there. But it means that part of that Act talks about citizens being a very wide spectrum. You can't have citizens of the world accessing services in the country in that way. So, that part must actually be looked into. The other two, one of which was in 1998, and the Refugees Act of 1998, also need to be repealed through the bill. 'Some of these acts are very wide and encompass what some of the people are saying. Maybe they should actually have a bit of limitation. It's not possible for us as a country to have unlimited resources to deal with what is there in the world.' 'Approach unacceptable' Both Dhlomo and Chairperson of the Select Committee on Education, Sciences and Creative Industries, Makhi Feni, called on Operation Dudula and March to March to refrain from preventing undocumented foreigners from accessing healthcare and education. They opened the door for engagements among South Africans to raise their issues. ALSO READ: SA healthcare system can't afford to ignore migration 'We are convinced that there is nothing that can be gained through those forms of action. But there must be ways of ensuring that there is cooperation. It is informed by our understanding of what becomes the role of a civil society organisation,' said Feni. 'Because if you are identifying yourself as a civil organisation, you must be able to understand your footing so that you do not violate the rights that have been entrenched in the Constitution of the Republic. 'That is why we are saying that we do not agree with this approach. How are you identifying a child who is not documented or is undocumented in this country? Because an undocumented child… is not automatically illegal in this country.' 'Undocumented does not mean illegal' The committee chairs raised concerns about South Africans falling victim to the organisations' operations due to a lack of necessary documents. According to Feni, there are about six million undocumented South Africans. 'There are various issues that led to those kids not to be able to have those necessary documents. Not because they are not South Africans, but they do not have these documents. How are you going to separate them? 'We believe that there must be processes, there must be engagements, so that we come to a proper solution. The six million we're talking about is about 11% of the population of this country. I'm not talking about those who are here for different reasons. I'm talking about only South Africans now. So it tells you that we have challenges, but the government is dealing with those challenges.' READ NEXT: Are South Africans given priority free health care over foreign nationals? Minister clears the air
