Lower judiciary treated like ‘shudras', ‘les misérables', High Court judges like ‘savarnas': Madhya Pradesh HC quashes termination of district judge
The French term, 'les misérables', translates to 'the miserable ones' in English and is commonly used to refer to the poor and marginalised, as in Victor Hugo's French novel of the same name.
A Division Bench of Justices Atul Sreedharan and Dinesh Kumar Paliwal made the observations on July 14 while quashing the termination of former Additional District and Sessions Judge Jagat Mohan Chaturvedi. He was dismissed in 2014 after passing divergent bail orders in cases linked to the Vyapam scam.
The court said the judicial officer had suffered 'gross injustice' and ordered the restoration of his pensionary benefits. It also imposed a cost of Rs 5 lakh on the state for the 'hardships he and his family were subjected to' and 'the humiliation in society that he had to face, only on account of passing judicial orders, without an iota of material coming on record to even establish corruption even on the anvil of preponderance of probability'.
Speaking on the entrenched hierarchy in the judiciary, the Bench observed, 'The relationship between District Judiciary and the High Court in the state is not based on mutual respect for each other, but one where a sense of fear and inferiority is consciously instilled by one on the subconscious of the other. At a subliminal level, the penumbra of the caste system manifests in the judicial structure in this state where those in the High Court are the savarnas and the shudras are the les misérables of the District Judiciary.'
Describing the dynamic between the High Court and the lower courts, the judges said, 'The dismal relationship between the Judges of the High Court and the Judges of the District Judiciary is one between a feudal lord and serf.'
'The body language of the Judges of the District Judiciary when they greet a Judge of the High Court stops short of grovelling before the High Court Judge, making the Judges of the District Judiciary the only identifiable species of invertebrate mammals,' they said.
The Bench further added, 'Instances of the judges of the District Judiciary personally attending to Judges of the High Court (as desired by them) on railway platforms and waiting on them with refreshments, are commonplace, thus perpetuating a colonial decadence with a sense of entitlement.'
Judges of the district judiciary deputed to work at the High Court registry 'are almost never offered a seat by the Judges of the High Court, and on a rare occasion when they are, they are hesitant to sit down before the High Court Judge,' the Bench said.
The court also observed that the 'subjugation and enslavement of the psyche of the Judges of the District Judiciary is complete and irreversible, so it seems'.
'An overbearing High Court, ever willing to excoriate the District Judiciary for the most innocuous of its errors, ensures that District Judiciary is kept under perpetual and morbid fear of punishment,' it said.
'The fear of the District Judiciary is understandable. They have families, children who go to school, parents undergoing treatment, a home to be built, savings to be accumulated and when the High Court terminates his service abruptly…he and his entire family are out on the streets with no pension and the stigma of facing a society that suspects his integrity,' the court said.
The court observed that a 'District Judiciary which is compelled to work perpetually under this fear cannot dispense justice and instead shall dispense with justice'.
It added, 'All this adds up to the passive subjugation of the District Judiciary, leaving it psychologically emaciated, which ultimately reflects in their judicial work where bails are not granted in even the most deserving cases, convictions are recorded in the absence of evidence… All this in the name of saving their job, for which the Petitioner in this case suffered, for thinking and doing differently.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Print
28 minutes ago
- The Print
Rajasthan: MDMA worth over Rs 3 crore seized in Jaisalmer, 2 held under anti-drug crackdown
The team intercepted an SUV allegedly being used to transport 336.4 grams of MDMA by the accused — Prakash (28) and Prem Prakash (28) — residents of Phalodi district. A joint operation was carried out by a district special team (DST) along with local police led by Superintendent of Police Abhishek Shivhare. Jaisalmer, Aug 1 (PTI) Two persons were arrested here and synthetic drug MDMA valued at Rs 3.5 crore in the international market has been seized from them, police said on Friday. Police said the two intended to sell the MDMA in smaller quantities within Jaisalmer town. Shivhare said the crackdown was part of a statewide anti-narcotics drive. The suspects are being interrogated to uncover further links in the supply and distribution chain. According to police, Prakash has a previous case under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act registered against him at Mandore police station. Further investigation is underway, they added. PTI COR AG OZ OZ This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
The Hindu
28 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Here's why enrollments are falling in govt schools and how that can be fixed
Government schools in India offer numerous student-friendly benefits: free education, qualified and better-paid teachers, mid-day meals, free textbooks and uniforms, and low or zero fees. These should make them the natural first choice for most families, especially in rural and low-income communities. Yet, enrollment in government schools has been steadily declining, particularly in urban and semi-urban areas. Parents, even from modest backgrounds, are increasingly choosing private schools over public ones. Why is this happening despite the generous support extended to the public school system? The answer lies in a complex combination of perception, policy gaps, structural inequities, and, most importantly, an entrance exam system that unintentionally favours private institutions and urban students while leaving rural, government school students at a disadvantage. Government schools are often perceived as outdated, poorly managed, and meant for the underprivileged—regardless of their actual strengths. In contrast, private schools are viewed as disciplined, modern, and aspirational, even when many lack qualified faculty or sound infrastructure. This perception gap, amplified by advertising and peer influence, has convinced many parents to invest in private education, even when it stretches their household finances. The National Education Policy 2020 recommends mother tongue instruction until Grade 5, preferably Grade 8, to ensure better comprehension and conceptual clarity in the early years. Government schools generally adhere to this policy. However, many private schools advertise English-medium instruction from Class 1, often without qualified English teachers. Parents, hoping to secure early language advantage for their children, are easily persuaded. As a result, government schools are seen as less modern—even when they are following sound, evidence-based pedagogy. Without uniform enforcement of NEP across both public and private schools, this divide is bound to widen. Private schools, particularly those in cities and towns, market themselves as pathways to engineering and medical careers. Many introduce IIT or NEET-focused programmes from the primary school level, branding themselves as 'Techno Schools' or 'Junior Academies.' This premature focus on Maths and Science sidelines equally important subjects like languages, social studies, the arts, and ethical education. While this narrow approach may benefit students in competitive exams, it comes at the cost of emotional, civic, and holistic development. Government schools, by contrast, follow a more balanced curriculum, giving due importance to all subjects. Yet in a system where only STEM marks matter for college admissions, this comprehensive approach is undervalued. The national entrance exam structure reinforces this imbalance. Most entrance exams for engineering, medicine, and even some general degree programs test only Physics, Chemistry, Biology, and Mathematics. Core subjects such as languages, history, geography, political science, and ethics are excluded entirely. This format is inherently biased toward private school students who are coached intensively in these few subjects, often from a very young age. Urban students benefit further from mock test series, foundation programmes, and English-medium content. Rural students attending government schools, however, study a broader syllabus aligned with national curricular frameworks. Their preparation, while more holistic, does not align with the narrowly focused demands of entrance tests. This systemic mismatch lowers their chances of success and further reinforces the notion that public schools are inadequate. The result is a social and academic injustice. Entrance exams, in their current form, help private schools thrive—by rewarding early coaching and selective learning. At the same time, they penalize children from public schools who have received a full, balanced education. In a country where nearly two-thirds of children rely on public education, this situation is neither fair nor sustainable. How the imbalance can be corrected To correct these imbalances, India must act decisively. Entrance exams must be reformed to test across all key school subjects, including languages, humanities, ethics, and reasoning. This would ensure that children are not penalized for receiving a broader education. NEP guidelines should be uniformly enforced in both private and public schools, particularly with regard to medium of instruction and curricular scope. Misleading early branding by private schools—such as IIT and NEET training from Class 1—should be regulated to protect the integrity of childhood education. Public school infrastructure must be upgraded to reflect the aspirations of a changing society. Teacher support, digital tools, and community participation through School Management Committees should be strengthened. Above all, success stories from government schools should be celebrated to rebuild public trust. Government schools remain the backbone of India's educational equity. But unless entrance exams, admission policies, and public messaging are aligned with the values and structure of public education, families will continue to shift away. It is time to change the narrative—from 'free and last-resort' to 'free and first-choice.' That can happen only when every subject is valued, every child is supported, and every school is given the opportunity to succeed. (The writer is Professor (retired), IIT Madras. He writes on education policy, curriculum reform and rural equity)
NDTV
33 minutes ago
- NDTV
"Big Headload Fell...": Railway Minister On What Led To Delhi Station Tragedy
New Delhi: A big headload that "fell from one of the passengers" led to the tragedy at New Delhi Railway Station that killed 18 people, Union Railway Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw said today in response to a member's query. It resulted in the "tripping of passengers on the stairs", said the minister. In response to a query by Samajwadi Party MP Ramji Lal Suman in Rajya Sabha, Mr Vaishnaw shared details from the report by a high-level inquiry committee that was constituted to examine the circumstances leading to the "unfortunate incident". Mr Suman had asked the Railway Minister about the status of the report of the committee constituted to investigate the stampede and the corrective steps taken by the government. Eighteen people were killed and 15 were injured on February 15 at the New Delhi Railway Station, which witnessed a surge of passengers waiting to board trains for Prayagraj -- where the Maha Kumbh was underway at the time. In a post on X that night, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said that he was "distressed by the stampede". However, in the Railway Minister's statement, there was no mention of the word "stampede". On the day of the tragedy, around 49,000 general tickets were sold at the railway stations, 13,000 more than the daily average, Mr Vaishnaw had informed the Lok Sabha in March. In his response today, the minister stated that sufficient crowd management measures were in place that day to manage the high number of passengers at the station. There was a "gradual increase of passenger density on the foot over bridge (FOB) after 8.15 pm", mentioned the written reply. "Many of the passengers were carrying big headloads, affecting smooth movement on the FOB. There was a big headload falling from one of the passengers, and the pressure was passed on to the stairs of platforms 14 and 15, resulting in the tripping of passengers on the stairs. This led to an incident at 8.48 pm on FOB-3," the minister said. "Consequently, passengers fell on each other," he said. Compensation of Rs 10 lakh was given to the families of each victim, Rs 2.5 lakh to those seriously injured, and Rs 1 lakh to those with simple injuries. "A total amount of Rs 2.01 crore has been paid to 33 victims and their family members," Mr Vaishnaw said. To manage large crowds better, the railways have put new measures in place. These include permanent holding areas, access control for confirmed ticket holders at 73 stations, wider foot overbridges, CCTV cameras, and war rooms at major stations. The Maha Kumbh Mela, the 45-day event that ended in February, led to record ticket sales, emphasising the importance of solid crowd management during such events.
