Orgreave papers destroyed by police thought to include report on notorious truncheon beating
In the ITV News at 10 report on the violent scenes at Orgreave, the officer, PC Martin of Northumbria police, was seen hitting the miner, Russell Broomhead, several times with his truncheon.
Northumbria police have been widely criticised since confirming that in April last year they destroyed two boxes of documents relating to the strike and the Orgreave operation. That was just months before a general election that the Labour party, which had a longstanding pledge to hold an inquiry into what happened at Orgreave, was expected to win.
The timing led to accusations that the force had destroyed the documents to avoid scrutiny of its officers' actions.
At the Orgreave coking plant on 18 June 1984 an estimated 8,000 miners assembled for a mass picket called by the National Union of Mineworkers, met by 4,500 police officers from forces nationwide, led by South Yorkshire police.
The violence that took place, with police charging on horseback and hitting miners with truncheons, is remembered as a landmark confrontation of the bitter 1984-85 strike. A criminal prosecution of 95 miners for riot and unlawful assembly collapsed a year later after the miners' barristers repeatedly accused police officers of lying and malpractice.
The Orgreave Truth and Justice Campaign (OTJC) has for years called for an inquiry into the police operation and the failed prosecutions. Northumbria police previously confirmed that they held documents relevant to the policing at Orgreave, including a report by a superintendent who was the liaison officer for 92 officers sent to South Yorkshire.
In 2016 Northumbria's then chief constable, Steve Ashman, wrote to Yvette Cooper, then the chair of the home affairs select committee, explaining that the superintendent's report detailed an incident involving a police constable.
'This officer was believed to have been involved in striking a 'picket' with his truncheon,' Ashman wrote. 'This incident is identified as been [sic] the subject of television news reporting … the superintendent's report details how [the PC] was 'reported' for the offence of assault to the director of public prosecutions (DPP). The report further outlines that the DPP subsequently decided there would be no criminal prosecution in the case.'
Joe Diviney, a historian at the University of Sheffield who is researching a PhD on the Orgreave events, pointed out that this appeared clearly to be the PC Martin incident. Martin was identified, including in police documents, as the officer who struck Broomhead, and a report was sent to the DPP who decided, on the same day Martin was interviewed, not to bring charges.
During an interview under caution, Martin denied wrongdoing, and said of the Orgreave policing: 'It's not a case of me going off half cock. The senior officers, supers and chief supers were there and getting stuck in too – they were encouraging the lads and I think their attitude to the situation affected what we all did.'
Broomhead told the Guardian: 'I would still like truth and accountability for what happened. If something is wrong, it stays wrong. I never knew in all these years that a superintendent had written a report on the incident that involved me. It's unbelievable that the police can throw that document away, without asking me and people it affects.'
Kate Flannery, secretary of the OTJC, said: 'It now seems highly likely that one of the documents destroyed by Northumbria police could relate to the PC Martin attack. Any destruction of important information relating to violent police attacks on striking miners means that crucial evidence is no longer available to an Orgreave inquiry.
'This all adds to the many concerns we have about police cover-ups and justice being denied.'
A Northumbria police spokesperson said last month that the documents had been 'disposed of … in line with force policy and the Data Protection Act 2018'.
After criticism, including by the Labour MP Ian Lavery, the force has since said it is investigating its own decision-making. 'We very much recognise the strength of feeling and concern within our communities at the disposal of information relating to the miners' strike,' a spokesperson said. 'We can confirm, we are carrying out an investigation into the circumstances around the disposal of the material.'
The Archives and Records Association is calling for police documents to be preserved by law. The association's chair, Ruth MacLeod, said: 'Many people have no idea that police records, which are important for accountability, can be so easily destroyed. There needs to be legislation to protect them, and prevent the kind of destruction that has happened in Northumbria.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
3 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Opinion: Britain is at the mercy of bond markets
It took the British government more than three centuries to rack up debts of £1trillion. That milestone was reached in 2010, in the wake of the financial crisis. It took just ten more years for our debts to hit £2trillion. They now stand just shy of £2.9trillion – and will hit £3trillion either this fiscal year or next. So that's another trillion racked up in less than a decade. Yes, there's the impact of inflation . And the triple-whammy of the financial crisis, the Covid-19 pandemic and the energy shock after the invasion of Ukraine , all of which pushed the debt higher as the government borrowed to support households and businesses. But as the Office for Budget Responsibility warned in a recent report highlighting the parlous state of the nation's finances, successive governments have failed to take the action required to bring the debt back under control in the wake of those crises. And the government's annual borrowing bill has hovered around 5 per cent of GDP a year since the pandemic – levels only previously seen during recession or war. This is a major headache for Rachel Reeves ahead of the Budget this autumn. And that spells yet more pain for households and businesses – because however the Chancellor spins it, another round of tax rises are coming. They will be big. And they will be painful. This is because, far from being a 'beacon of stability' in an uncertain world, as Downing Street would have us believe, Britain is at the mercy of the bond markets. One only has to look back at the Liz Truss debacle to know that twitchy bond markets matter. And twitchy they are. To such an extent that UK gilt yields – a key measure of how much it costs the British government to borrow – are the highest in the G7. In fact, the UK has the third-highest borrowing costs of any advanced economy after New Zealand and Iceland. This is because international investors look at Britain – with its soaring debts and lack of political will to do anything about it – and do not like what they see. So they charge the UK government more to lend it money than almost every other similar economy in the world. To understand what that means one only has to look at the today's figures from the Office for National Statistics that show the UK paid £16.4billion of interest on the national debt in June alone. This was £8.4billion more than in the same month last year and the second highest June on record, amounting to nearly £550million a day and more than £22million an hour. So we are now in a situation where we are forecast to spend £111billion this year servicing the national debt – and just £62.2billion on defence. With the economy slowing, fears are mounting that the fiscal situation is getting worse not better. The scene is set for another punishing Budget this autumn.
Daily Mail
3 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
DJ 'beaten to death' during a party at his home in Ibiza as his heartbroken father accuses Spanish police of 'messing up'
The passing of a well-known Italian DJ in Ibiza has become shrouded in mystery after his heartbroken father accused Spanish police of beating him to death. Michele Nochese, better known by his stage name DJ Godzi, was reportedly 'tied hand and foot' before being 'punched' by officers who broke up a party at his house after neighbours complained about the ruckus. He was 35. Michele's grieving family have called for his death to be treated as a 'voluntary homicide' after his father Giuseppe Nochese, a retired doctor from Naples, revealed in an interview with Italian newspaper Corriere del Mezzogiorno that there are obvious 'signs of the beating' he endured. As the results of his autopsy are awaited, Guiseppe pleaded for answers while accusing the Spanish authorities of 'trying to keep everything quiet' - despite growing scrutiny of the circumstances around Michele's death. 'They can't beat up a young man for no reason,' he said. '[Michele] was a resident of Ibiza, and therefor a citizen of Ibiza.' Michele, who had moved to the Balearic island from Naples 10 years ago to pursue his dream of becoming a DJ, reportedly died on July 20. According to media reports, Michele was hosting a party when neighbours called the Civil Guard to complain about the noise. Witnesses said the DJ got into a 'physical altercation' with the cops before his 'lifeless body' was taken straight to the morgue. This account is reportedly being contradicted by the Civil Guard that claimed Michele was 'suffering from hallucinations' while under the influence of drugs, Spanish newspaper Ara reported. Officers reportedly arrived at his house to find Michele 'holding a knife' and threatening his elderly neighbour. When they tried to restrain Michele, he started convulsing, collapsed and lost vital signs. Emergency services attempted to revive Michele before he was declared dead, the Civil Guard has reportedly claimed. Their version is being challenged by Michele's family members as Giuseppe told the outlet that people present at the house party had told him how his son was beaten to death by the officers 'for no reason'. Michele was reportedly punched thrice and 'not taken to a hospital but directly to the morgue', he told Italian newspaper La Repubblica. Giusepe is waiting for the results of the autopsy to confirm a cause of death but, to him, it is clear the 'police messed up'. 'My family are not looking for are looking for justice,' he told Italian TV channel Tg1. 'We simply want to understand how the event unfolded and why my son, who was in excellent health, died so tragically. 'We are asking for a plausible explanation. After that, we will be a little more at peace than we currently are,' he continued. The family has sought an independent forensic medical report. He has decided to have Michele's body cremated because 'I can't bring my son home in a coffin like this' Giuseppe expressed his horror at the condition of Michele's body. 'My wife would die, I don't think she'll be able to cope with this situation.' Along with Michele's family, Italian politicians are also demanding answers from the Spanish government as Fulvio Martusciello, MEP for the Forza Italia political party, said: 'We want to know the truth about Michele Noschese's death. 'We want to understand what happened and what the Civil Guard's responsibility is. The sudden death of a young, successful and well-liked Neapolitan, an internationally renowned DJ, cannot remain in the shadows.' Before he created his music alter ego, DJ Godzi played football for Napoli Primavera and studied economics and commerce in Naples. His death was first reported by Italian news outlets before it was confirmed by his record label Mood Child Art on Monday. In a statement shared on Instagram, Michele was remembered as a 'sincere and colourful' artist who made 'music from the heart' as fans paid tribute to him online. Godzi - whose stage name is inspired by Godzilla - made Ibiza his home 10 years ago but frequently travelled to London, Paris, Barcelona, and New York for shows. However, the musician was happiest when he returned to the 'magic island' as Michele often expressed gratitude for his life in Ibiza on social media. Last September, Godzi shared a series of snaps featuring outtakes from shows - including videos of him performing at parties in Ibiza, and captioned it: 'I'm really blessed to live on this magic island and share moments like these.' He noted how Ibiza 'connects people' in a post uploaded last August and celebrated his return to the city after a two-month tour in the US earlier this year. 'After two months in America and a month and a half with my family and friends, it's time to return home - to my island, Ibiza,' Godzi wrote alongside a series of snaps, including photos of him recording music in his studio. He teased the release of his new project Gojira - an events company - at the time, as Godzi appeared excited and hopeful for his future. However, his life was tragically cut short on the night of July 19 when officers of the Civil Guard broke up the house party that would mark Godzi's last time behind the decks.
Telegraph
3 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Police force at centre of migrant hotel protests holds press conference
The police force facing scrutiny over its handling of protests outside a migrant hotel is set to hold a press conference. Senior figures from Essex Police are expected to answer questions about the decisions they have taken after days of volatile demonstrations. The force admitted overnight that it had escorted pro-migrant protesters to the Bell Hotel in Epping. It had initially denied that it had brought activists from the group Stand up to Racism to the site amid claims by anti-migrant protesters that the arrival of counter-demonstrators sparked violence on July 17. It backtracked after being shown footage of the protesters being escorted by officers from a nearby station to the hotel. Nigel Farage, the Reform UK leader, said 'heads must roll' at Essex Police. There have been a series of protests outside the Bell Hotel after Hadush Gerberslasie Kebatu, a 38-year-old asylum seeker, was charged with sexual assault. The migrant, who denies the charges, is alleged to have attempted to kiss a 14-year-old girl.
