Nottingham attacks: Victims' families 'gagged' over watchdog report
The mother of one of the three people stabbed to death in Nottingham says the families have been "gagged" by the police watchdog over findings of a report into the contact officers had with killer Valdo Calocane.Emma Webber, mum of Barnaby Webber, said she, alongside the families of Grace O'Malley-Kumar and Ian Coates, had been forced to sign a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) by the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC).The NDA concerns a probe into the way Leicestershire Police officers dealt with alleged assaults by Calocane weeks before the attacks.The watchdog said an agreement was "needed" in order to share the report with the victims' families at the earliest opportunity.
It added it anticipated being able to publish the findings and outcomes of the investigation "in the coming weeks".
Calocane, who had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, was sentenced to an indefinite hospital order in January 2024 after admitting three counts of manslaughter on the basis of diminished responsibility and three counts of attempted murder.The IOPC previously said three Leicestershire Police officers - two constables and a sergeant - were told they were being investigated over how inquiries were progressed.It has been claimed Calocane assaulted two colleagues at an industrial estate in Kegworth in May 2023.Mr Webber, Miss O'Malley-Kumar, both 19, and Ian Coates, 65, were killed by Calocane on 13 June 2023.NHS England (NHSE) published a full report into the mental health care received by Calocane prior to the attacks, after initially intending to only publish a summary.Mrs Webber said: "We were forced to sign NDAs by NHSE to promise that we would not disclose their investigation into Calocane's care."Under pressure from us, they were forced to U-turn and disclose the report in full themselves."As [Health Secretary] Wes Streeting himself said, sunlight is the best disinfectant - the same principle applies to the IOPC investigations into the numerous police failings in our case."
Mrs Webber added: "Like the NHS, the IOPC have also sought to gag us from speaking publicly and have forced us to sign NDAs saying we will not reveal their reports and findings."I now call on the IOPC to do the right thing like the NHS did and disclose their reports to the public so that full scrutiny can take place."It is the only way that real lessons are going to be learned and lasting change put in place so that no other family should have to endure the torture that we are."Radd Seiger, an adviser to the victims' families, said the IOPC's decision to impose an NDA was "inexcusable".He said: "It is inexcusable for any watchdog to seek to gag families of victims of serious crimes in this manner."That practice must be stopped."The watchdog said it anticipated being able to publish the findings and outcomes of the investigation "in the coming weeks".Derrick Campbell, director at the IOPC, added: "We completed an investigation into Leicestershire Police contact with Valdo Calocane prior to the killings and in particular the actions and decisions of officers investigating alleged assaults by him."In order to share our report and underlying evidence with the families of his victims at the earliest opportunity, a confidentiality agreement was needed."It remains in place until an appropriate time when the investigation findings and outcomes can be published, which we anticipate being able to do in coming weeks."The IOPC is also investigating the prior contact Nottinghamshire Police had with Calocane before the killings.The force previously admitted it should have done more to arrest him sooner, revealing that an arrest warrant was issued in September 2022, over the alleged assault of a police officer in 2021.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
14 hours ago
- BBC News
Police suspect cannabis farm caused fire to homes in Leicester
Cannabis was found after a fire damaged four houses on a street in services were called after a fire broke out across the roof space of four houses in Stuart Street, Westcotes, at about 12:30 BST on Road was closed for around five hours while 18 firefighters worked to bring the blaze under left the scene at about 09:00 on Wednesday, with Leicestershire Police now investigating. The fire service said an aerial ladder platform was deployed to reach unsafe areas and said it was supported by police, the ambulance service, Leicester City Council and the Red Cross to resolve the incident and to assist affected residents. The police said the fire has left four houses with "extensive damage" but no injuries were reported and all properties were safely evacuated.A police spokesperson said: "From initial inquiries carried out, the fire is suspected to have resulted after cannabis was being cultivated in the loft space of one of the properties."The force added that a cordon remains in place around the scene and there have been no arrests.
The Guardian
16 hours ago
- The Guardian
Natalie Shotter killing: officers face proceedings over alleged safeguarding failures
Two Metropolitan police officers are facing misconduct proceedings over an alleged failure to safeguard a woman raped and killed in a park, after a watchdog overruled a decision not to hold a disciplinary hearing. The family of Natalie Shotter have welcomed the decision by the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) as 'another step on the road in the fight for justice for Nat'. Shotter, 37, was found dead on a bench in Southall Park, west London, just before 6am on the morning of 17 July 2021. In October 2024, Mohamed Iidow was convicted of the NHS worker's rape and manslaughter, in a highly significant ruling that found oral rape as a cause of death. He had pleaded not guilty but chose not to give evidence in his defence. It is alleged that the evening before Shotter was found dead, one of the officers now facing disciplinary proceedings was approached by a member of the public who told them that a woman in the park was in a vulnerable situation. The officer and a colleague were nearby dealing with a separate incident. The officer advised the member of the public to call the police for additional support. The IOPC director David Ford said: 'After careful consideration of the evidence, we have decided two Met police officers should face a misconduct meeting for allegedly failing to safeguard Ms Shotter. On the previous evening, one of the officers was notified by a member of the public that a woman was in a vulnerable situation. The following day, Ms Shotter was, sadly, found dead in the park. 'The constables – who were both probationers – are alleged to have failed to properly risk assess, document or to take any real action in relation to the information reported to them.' Shotter's family made a complaint to Scotland Yard about the actions of the two officers. The Met investigated the complaint and concluded that both officers should be subject to unsatisfactory performance procedures rather than face disciplinary proceedings. Ford said: 'We were asked by Ms Shotter's family to review the force's handling of the family's complaint and, in June 2025, we disagreed with the Met's decision. We have directed them to arrange a misconduct meeting for the two officers, who have a case to answer for an alleged breach of the police professional standards of behaviour relating to duties and responsibilities. 'It will now be for the panel to consider the evidence and determine if the case is proven and, if so, decide on the most appropriate outcome.' Shotter's mother, Dr Cas Shotter Weetman, a lead advanced cardiology practitioner for the NHS, welcomed the IOPC decision. 'We are enormously happy about this decision. Common sense has been shown here. I know Nat would be delighted about this. It's another step on the road in our fight for justice for her,' she said. Sign up to First Edition Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion In a separate case, PC Adam Aspinall Da Encarnacao, 32, pleaded not guilty to two charges of misconduct in public office at Westminster magistrates court in August 2024. He is due to stand trial at Southwark crown court later this year. The charges relate to the inappropriate possession and sharing of images concerning the alleged rape of one woman and the rape of another. One of the women was Shotter. The officer was suspended from duty after his arrest in September 2022.
Daily Mail
3 days ago
- Daily Mail
Father of Nottingham attack victim complains after 'offensive' meeting with police watchdog which was started with a prayer
The father of a Nottingham attack victim has complained about a police watchdog boss who began a meeting with grieving families with a prayer. Dr Sanjoy Kumar, whose daughter Grace was one of three people killed by paranoid schizophrenic Valdo Calocane during a rampage in June 2023, described the meeting as 'patronising and offensive.' A two-year inquiry into the killings of students Ms O'Malley-Kumar and Barnaby Webber, both 19, and caretaker Ian Coates, 65, will scrutinise the role of prosecutors, police and medical professionals. And it has now emerged that Dr Kumar believes a regional director of the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) behaved inappropriately when he met with the bereaved families nine months after the attack and started the meeting with a prayer. 'I found it patronising and offensive,' he told the Times. 'I didn't want a prayer, I wanted answers. I've lost my daughter and it was his job to give me the truth, not a prayer. 'There are plenty of places to pray and the IOPC isn't one of them.' The regional director is understood to be Derrick Campbell, the watchdog's director of engagement. A spokesman said: 'We can confirm we've received a complaint about one of our directors and we are dealing with it in line with our complaints and feedback procedure.' The IOPC had previously issued a report which concluded that police failed to properly investigate an assault on warehouse workers by Calocane a month before his killing spree. In a statement at the time, Mr Campbell said: 'Those who are closely impacted by our decision, including the bereaved families and the officers involved, have been notified and we will complete this work as quickly as possible.' Calocane was sentenced to an indefinite hospital order in January 2024 after admitting manslaughter by diminished responsibility and attempted murder. The prosecution decision not to pursue murder charges has been widely criticised by the victims' families. Barnaby's mother Emma Webber said in February last year that relatives had a lot of concerns 'that were in the most part wholly ignored' by the Crown Prosecution Service. Senior retired judge Deborah Taylor will chair the inquiry, which aims to report back within two years, with recommendations to prevent similar incidents.
