MTA honcho Janno Lieber brushes off concerns over subway price hike as New Yorkers rip failing transit system: ‘Vultures'
'Welcome to the second MTA public hearing on the proposed fare adjustments,' Lieber said at the top of the forum — one of three that the transportation agency is holding this week — about the new $3 rate, which would go into effect as soon as January.
More than two dozen frustrated commuters showed up in person and via video to testify about the 10-cent increase for subway and bus fares, which would come on the heels of the hike to $2.90 in mid-2023 and the MTA's $9 congestion pricing scheme.
Advertisement
'While a small increase may seem like nothing to you at all, it makes a big difference,' fumed Hannah Reed, a Bed-Stuy resident who learned about the hearing the night before.
4 MTA Chairman and CEO Janno Lieber tried to rebrand fare increases as 'fare adjustments' during a public hearing. 'Welcome to the second MTA public hearing on the proposed fare adjustments,' Lieber said.
Luiz C. Ribeiro for New York Post
'It's a bit laughable to have anyone on this panel talk about accessibility and affordability when talking about a price hike,' she told the Metropolitan Transit Agency honchos gathered, including Lieber, Chief Customer Officer Shanifah Rieara, CFO Jai Patel and other board members and top officials.
Advertisement
'With additional streams of revenue like congestion pricing, I cannot understand why it is necessary to add additional strain to New Yorkers when we're already struggling so much with the cost of living,' she noted.
Camilla Sims, an artist who performs under the alias Convict Julie, accused the panel of top execs of being out-of-touch.
'You drive blacked out SUVs. Some of you don't even live in the city at all,' the songwriter and producer said. 'You're not working class people. Maybe actually listen to the people who are struggling.'
But Lieber seemed amused by Sims' concerns, chuckling as he chewed gum.
Advertisement
'You can laugh all you want,' she told him. 'I'm reclaiming some of my time then.'
After the hearing, Sims told The Post that the MTA officials, including Lieber — whose salary is a whopping $400,000 a year — don't care about the little guy.
4 MTA officials claimed the fare increase would come with improved service.
Helayne Seidman
'They're more concerned with upholding their own bureaucratic interest than they are helping the people,' she said.
Advertisement
As New Yorkers became increasingly heated throughout the nearly two hour-long hearing, Lieber twiddled his thumbs and stared ahead as he sat and listened.
'There are times where I had to choose between having a lunch and taking the subway back to my house in Kew Gardens,' frustrated student, Emmanuel Rafael, testified.
When he called members of the panel 'fascist dogs' — to cheers from the audience — the moderator threatened to mute his microphone.
'You're nothing but vultures,' Rafael charged. 'It's ridiculous that you think it's an appropriate time to increase the fare.'
4 MTA CEO and Chairman Janno Lieber, pictured on the right, appeared bored at times during a public hearing Wednesday.
Luiz C. Ribeiro for New York Post
Promised from the MTA officials present that more frequent and better service will come with the fare increases fell flat on those in attendance, most of whom vehemently opposed the hikes.
Even a Queens high school student — whose rides are mostly covered by the city — showed up to protest the fare increases on behalf of his family.
Weihong Chen worried his parents, who both commute to work, won't be able to afford the extra cost.
Advertisement
'It could be an extra $50 or more per month,' Chen said. 'That may not sound like a lot, but we need every cent to be able to pay for groceries, utilities and other essential expenses.'
4 Rafael, who said he goes to John Jay college, called the panel 'fascist dogs' and 'vultures.'
MTA
If the MTA board approves the new rates as expected later this year subway and bus rides would cost $3 a ride by Jan. 4, 2026. Long Island Rail Road and Metro-North riders would face a 4.4% increase for one-way, weekly and monthly tickets.
Advertisement
Deborah Greif, Chairperson for the Brooklyn Families Support Advisory Council, testified that she was excited to pay more — for the sake of rounding.
'I'm poor and it's easier for me to budget when the ride is three dollars,' Grief explained.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
‘Fare adjustment'? Sorry, Janno Lieber: New Yorkers know a fare hike when they see one
Luiz C. Ribeiro for New York Post 'Fare adjustment': That's what MTA boss Janno Lieber laughably calls the next subway-fare hike. Give us a break: A hike is a hike. And every New Yorker knows it. Lieber is resorting to Team Hochul's Orwellian-naming schtick for papering over bad news and rotten policy. Advertisement As in the faux-wonk term 'congestion pricing' for a $9-per-trip tax that's still headed back to the originally-planned $15 — which will doubtless rise on in what Lieber can call 'a congestion pricing adjustment.' More mush: Don't forget that Gov. Kathy Hochul bragged about 'saving' New Yorkers money by starting with only $9 when she socked them with that tax, not the full $15?) Advertisement OK: The subway hike is just a dime, to $3 (for now). But it comes atop countless other taxes that hit New York residents with the nation's heaviest state- and local-tax burden. 'While a small increase may seem like nothing to you at all, it makes a big difference,' one resident, Hannah Reed, told MTA board members. Get opinions and commentary from our columnists Subscribe to our daily Post Opinion newsletter! Thanks for signing up! Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Never miss a story. Check out more newsletters Advertisement Yet the brass won't admit the truth: 'I would not call this a hike,' board member Neal Zuckerman huffed. It's 'a very gradual raise, and I think very respectful of the inflation and affordability issues.' What arrogance. As one straphanger, Emmanuel Vasquez, fumed, 'There's always flooding, there's always a brake emergency, there's always a power outage' on the subway, but officials never stop zapping riders with hikes. And that's despite the billions the agency collects not just from fares but city, state and federal tax revenue, corporations, individual taxes and, yes, 'congestion pricing.' Advertisement And while it diverts money to politically-driven projects like Second Avenue Subway expansion: On Monday, the board OK'd a $1.9 billion contract for just a part of project; the final tab will run at least $7 billion for just three new stations. Lieber & Co. know darn well their repeated dips into New Yorkers' pockets sting; they just don't care to admit it. Why else hide behind weasel words?
New York Post
4 hours ago
- New York Post
$7.7B Second Avenue subway expansion will put NYC store out of business after 30 years, owner claims: ‘I'm getting a raw deal'
It's the last stop for this East Harlem business. A construction supply firm will be forced to shutter after more than three decades as the Metropolitan Transportation Authority moves to seize its property to make way for the long-awaited Second Avenue Subway expansion. Lu Nicaj, owner of Tile Stone, told The Post he'll have to close up shop because the MTA is commandeering the business' lot at 2244 Second Avenue under eminent domain. 'I'm getting a raw deal,' Nicaj, 59, said. 'They are pretty much running me into the ground. I'm closing the door. That's the end of my business.' Advertisement MTA board members this week approved a $1.9 billion contract for the Second Avenue subway's phase two — which involves a blitz of legal seizures to clear the way for planned new subway stations at 116th and 125th streets. The properties are largely along Second Avenue and 125th Street, and include 33 apartments, officials said. 3 Lu Nicaj said his store Tile Stone will be put out of business by the Second Avenue subway project. Georgett Roberts/NY Post Advertisement Tile Stone's storefront at 2250 Second Avenue — which had a 'Liquidation Sale' sign up Tuesday — is too small to hold his contracting inventory, so Nicaj had been renting a nearby vacant lot from the same landlord to keep the building supplies. While the storefront is not on the eminent domain list Nicaj said he'll nonetheless be seriously affected because that lot at 2244 Second Avenue is up to be seized by the MTA. 'I can't stay in business. I've been here for 32 years,' said Nicaj, addign that he has already shifted 75% of his inventory to a warehouse upstate. 'That puts me out of business pretty much,' he said. 'When contractors come to buy instead of saying, 'Come back in a few days,' I have the stock right here. My store is small, that's why I lease the lot. It's like a warehouse.' Advertisement 3 The MTA is seizing several properties along Second Avenue under eminent domain. Stephen Yang for the New York Post 3 The seizures will clear the way for new stations along the long-awaited Second Avenue subway. MTA The dozens of New Yorkers who'll be displaced by the project will receive help from the MTA, which spent $10 million on relocations for similar eminent domain actions during the subway extension's first phase, officials have said. Nicaj said he met with the MTA and told officials that relocating his makeshift warehouse elsewhere won't work. Advertisement 'We are going to have another meeting to see what's the next thing they can do. I'm looking for some kind of compensation,' he said. 'I've told my lawyer to be prepared to go to battle with MTA.' Nicaj is also not hopeful that he can find affordable rent anywhere else, especially below East 106th Street. 'I can't have my store here and my warehouse 10 blocks away,' he said. MTA officials didn't return a request for comment. — Additional reporting by Haley Brown
New York Post
5 hours ago
- New York Post
MTA honcho Janno Lieber brushes off concerns over subway price hike as New Yorkers rip failing transit system: ‘Vultures'
MTA boss Janno Lieber tried to rebrand the looming spike in subway ride costs a 'fare adjustment' Wednesday — laughing, chewing gum and twiddling his thumbs as New Yorkers ripped him and other transit officials over the plan. 'Welcome to the second MTA public hearing on the proposed fare adjustments,' Lieber said at the top of the forum — one of three that the transportation agency is holding this week — about the new $3 rate, which would go into effect as soon as January. More than two dozen frustrated commuters showed up in person and via video to testify about the 10-cent increase for subway and bus fares, which would come on the heels of the hike to $2.90 in mid-2023 and the MTA's $9 congestion pricing scheme. Advertisement 'While a small increase may seem like nothing to you at all, it makes a big difference,' fumed Hannah Reed, a Bed-Stuy resident who learned about the hearing the night before. 4 MTA Chairman and CEO Janno Lieber tried to rebrand fare increases as 'fare adjustments' during a public hearing. 'Welcome to the second MTA public hearing on the proposed fare adjustments,' Lieber said. Luiz C. Ribeiro for New York Post 'It's a bit laughable to have anyone on this panel talk about accessibility and affordability when talking about a price hike,' she told the Metropolitan Transit Agency honchos gathered, including Lieber, Chief Customer Officer Shanifah Rieara, CFO Jai Patel and other board members and top officials. Advertisement 'With additional streams of revenue like congestion pricing, I cannot understand why it is necessary to add additional strain to New Yorkers when we're already struggling so much with the cost of living,' she noted. Camilla Sims, an artist who performs under the alias Convict Julie, accused the panel of top execs of being out-of-touch. 'You drive blacked out SUVs. Some of you don't even live in the city at all,' the songwriter and producer said. 'You're not working class people. Maybe actually listen to the people who are struggling.' But Lieber seemed amused by Sims' concerns, chuckling as he chewed gum. Advertisement 'You can laugh all you want,' she told him. 'I'm reclaiming some of my time then.' After the hearing, Sims told The Post that the MTA officials, including Lieber — whose salary is a whopping $400,000 a year — don't care about the little guy. 4 MTA officials claimed the fare increase would come with improved service. Helayne Seidman 'They're more concerned with upholding their own bureaucratic interest than they are helping the people,' she said. Advertisement As New Yorkers became increasingly heated throughout the nearly two hour-long hearing, Lieber twiddled his thumbs and stared ahead as he sat and listened. 'There are times where I had to choose between having a lunch and taking the subway back to my house in Kew Gardens,' frustrated student, Emmanuel Rafael, testified. When he called members of the panel 'fascist dogs' — to cheers from the audience — the moderator threatened to mute his microphone. 'You're nothing but vultures,' Rafael charged. 'It's ridiculous that you think it's an appropriate time to increase the fare.' 4 MTA CEO and Chairman Janno Lieber, pictured on the right, appeared bored at times during a public hearing Wednesday. Luiz C. Ribeiro for New York Post Promised from the MTA officials present that more frequent and better service will come with the fare increases fell flat on those in attendance, most of whom vehemently opposed the hikes. Even a Queens high school student — whose rides are mostly covered by the city — showed up to protest the fare increases on behalf of his family. Weihong Chen worried his parents, who both commute to work, won't be able to afford the extra cost. Advertisement 'It could be an extra $50 or more per month,' Chen said. 'That may not sound like a lot, but we need every cent to be able to pay for groceries, utilities and other essential expenses.' 4 Rafael, who said he goes to John Jay college, called the panel 'fascist dogs' and 'vultures.' MTA If the MTA board approves the new rates as expected later this year subway and bus rides would cost $3 a ride by Jan. 4, 2026. Long Island Rail Road and Metro-North riders would face a 4.4% increase for one-way, weekly and monthly tickets. Advertisement Deborah Greif, Chairperson for the Brooklyn Families Support Advisory Council, testified that she was excited to pay more — for the sake of rounding. 'I'm poor and it's easier for me to budget when the ride is three dollars,' Grief explained.
