Attacked West Midlands ambulance paramedics hope for swifter court justice
Mr Hoy said the assault meant he could could not do his job for eight weeks. "I had to wait for time to heal because I wouldn't have been able to lift or carry. I wouldn't be able to do CPR for any patients," he said. But Mr Hoy said it was not an isolated incident as he had been attacked a number of times before. "If you speak to any of my colleagues that have been on the ambulance service for a year or more, they will have at least one case where they have been assaulted by a patient - either verbally, physically, sexually or racially," he added.The man who attacked him was cautioned under a scheme targeting alcohol-related violence. WMAS has 30 cases involving 37 front-line workers either waiting for a court date or with such a date not set until August 2026.
Dan Knight, WMAS' head of security and safety, said: "We're seeing more cases going through the legal system, which is a positive for us."But unfortunately, because of that, we are now seeing a delay in the number of cases seen in court and getting an outcome on those cases - which is having an impact on staff morale." Steve Raven, who was assaulted while on duty as a paramedic in Leominster, Herefordshire in 2022, told an anti-violence campaign by the Association of Ambulance Chief Executives it had a huge impact on him. "I thought I was going to die," he said, adding the attack "broke my jaw, caused facial nerve damage and affected me mentally as well".The man who punched him was jailed for two years in February 2024, after admitting grievous bodily harm and criminal damage.
Earlier this month, the CPS issued new guidance with the hope of getting faster justice for emergency workers assaulted while on duty. The move means prosecutors will now be able to pick a charge which best fits the seriousness of the case, including those that can be dealt with more quickly in magistrates' courts. A spokesperson said they hoped it would help reduce backlogs in the court system.The news has given some workers who have been attacked, including Mr Hoy, more optimism. "A lot of the time me and my colleagues don't generally report [assaults] because we don't have faith that the prosecution will happen," said Mr Hoy."But after hearing the new CPS guidance, that they're pushing to get more people through magistrates' court rather than having to wait for crown court, it makes me more hopeful."
Meanwhile, the Ministry of Justice announced an independent review to address court backlogs.'It is clear there are many cases taking far too long to be heard," a spokesperson said.
Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Urgent hunt for men with a pushchair after £1,000 worth of goods is stolen from Curry's
Police are urgently hunting for two men who have been pictured with a pushchair after £1,000 worth of goods was stolen from a Curry's shop. A locked cupboard was apparently forced open at the store in Hereford Retail Park at around midday on Friday. A white van was later seen being driven away from a Pizza Hut car park at speed. Now officers are looking for two men who they believe might have information about the theft. A spokesperson for West Mercia Police said: 'Officers would like to speak with these two men as they believe they can help with their enquiries into a robbery in Hereford on Friday 8 August. 'Around midday two men went into Currys on Hereford retail park, forced entry into a locked cupboard, and stole items worth over £1000. 'One of the men was seen leaving the area in a small white van which was driven at speed out of the Pizza Hut car park. 'It is believed the men pictured had been in the area at the time of the robbery.'
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Home Office was warned about ‘flawed' domestic violence tool
The Home Office was warned about a 'deeply flawed' domestic violence screening tool that failed to protect more than 50 high-risk women who were later murdered. An assessment in February warned the department and advisers to Bridget Phillipson, the minister for women and equalities, that the tool was 'as helpful as flipping a coin'. For 16 years, officers and social workers have used a risk assessment called Dash – short for Domestic Abuse, Stalking and Honour-based violence – to decide which victims get urgent protection. The checklist – which assesses the risk to women based on answers to a list of 27 questions – is still used by 24 of Britain's police forces. That is despite 55 women being killed after being wrongly categorised as only being at 'low' or 'medium' risk since its introduction in 2009. A data scientist behind a rival tool claimed that the true toll could top 400 deaths. In February, a document warned the Home Office: 'In the most recent analysis of Dash's performance (2023), accounting for over 300,000 cases, Dash performed poorly, labelling 96.3 per cent of high-risk victims, some likely at risk of femicide, as standard (low) or medium risk.' But despite the findings, the department went on to commission SafeLives, the charity behind Dash, to review how police and social services assess risk in domestic abuse cases. Women reporting abuse are asked 27 questions by Dash to gauge the likelihood of imminent harm or death at the hands of their abuser. The checklist asks whether the perpetrator has ever used a weapon, threatened to kill, or attempted to strangle, choke, suffocate or drown the victim. SafeLives says victims must answer 'yes' to at least 14 questions to be classed as 'high risk' and guaranteed urgent intervention. Scores of nine to 13 mean 'medium' risk, while fewer than nine is 'standard' – but neither of these lower gradings guarantees women specialist support. Standing Together, a domestic violence charity, found that domestic homicide reviews showed victims had been killed after scoring an average of eight ticks, not the 14 needed for urgent support. Practitioners can use 'professional judgment' to override low scores and are instructed to escalate cases after three or more police call-outs in a year. Bethany Fields, 21, was denied support before being killed by her former partner because she had been graded only 'medium' risk using a Dash checklist. On August 9 2019, Fields told police that Paul Crowther had threatened to kill her. She gave a statement and an officer completed a Dash form. He ticked 'yes' to only nine questions, grading her at 'medium' risk. A month later, Crowther stabbed her to death in the street. Natalie Saunders, 33, was murdered by Stephen Charlton in October 2018 after Cleveland Police repeatedly graded her as being at medium risk. Her parents told The Telegraph they believe earlier intervention could have saved her life. Barbara Saunders, 67, said: 'She's never been medium risk, in none of them. In not one assault, she's not been medium.' Bereaved families have likened the scandal to Horizon, the Post Office IT system that destroyed lives while officials looked the other way. Alicia Kearns MP, the shadow safeguarding minister, has demanded ministers order an 'urgent' review of Dash. SafeLives maintains that Dash has saved many lives. 'The problem is not the Dash,' said Ellen Miller, its chief executive. 'The problem is police officers' values and behaviours.'
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Crown Princess of Norway's son charged with four counts of rape
The eldest son of the Crown Princess of Norway has been charged with four counts of rape. Marius Borg Høiby, 28, was charged with 32 offences including domestic abuse of a former partner, assault, breaches of the peace and violation of restraining orders against another former partner, the state prosecutor of Norway said on Monday. He has also been charged with filming the genitals of women without their knowledge or consent, prosecutors said. He faces up to 10 years in prison over the combined offences. Mr Borg Høiby is the stepson of Prince Haakon, the Crown Prince of Norway, but withdrew from public life and royal duties at the age of 20. His mother, Mette-Marit, the Crown Princess, was a single parent when she met and married Prince Haakon in 2001. In June, prosecutors charged Mr Borg Høiby with two counts of rape, four cases of sexual assault and two cases of bodily harm. It is not clear if Monday's announcement was an updated tally of those charges or related to an entirely separate set of alleged offences. According to Aftenposten, a Norwegian newspaper, Sturla Henriksbø, the state prosecutor, said: 'This case is very serious. Rape and violence in close relationships can leave lasting traces and destroy lives.' Mr Henriksbø added that equality before the law meant that Mr Borg Høiby should not receive any lenience or special treatment as a result of his royal connections. Police have investigated 18 alleged victims and reviewed thousands of messages and media files as part of their investigation into the Norwegian royal, Mr Henriksbø said. Mr Borg Høiby has been arrested several times in recent months over cases involving multiple women, including at least two former girlfriends, and one man. In the assault case involving a former girlfriend, the victim was discharged from hospital the day after the alleged attack with a concussion. Local media have also reported that a knife was stuck into one of the walls of the victim's bedroom. Mr Borg Høiby's lawyers declined to comment on Monday's announcement of new charges. In June, a lawyer representing the Norwegian royal told the Associated Press that their client was 'absolutely taking the accusations very seriously, but doesn't acknowledge any wrongdoing in most of the cases – especially the cases regarding sexual abuse and violence'. Mr Borg Høiby admitted to assault and vandalism following an arrest in August. He said in a statement that he acted 'under the influence of alcohol and cocaine after an argument', having suffered from 'mental troubles' and 'substance abuse'. The scandal surrounding Mr Borg Høiby poses a significant problem for the Norwegian royal family and is the most high-profile sexual offence case in the country's modern history. According to Nettavisen, another Norwegian newspaper, Mr Borg Høiby was recently stripped of his diplomatic passport, a special privilege afforded to certain members of the royal family. The fact that Mr Borg Høiby was initially issued with a diplomatic passport has in itself caused controversy because he is not a working royal. The spokesman for the foreign ministry confirmed the lack of passport, but did not explicitly link its confiscation to the criminal charges.
