CAP proposals to hit the most productive farms hardest
For example, aid would be reduced for half of the farmers, and three quarters of the farmland in France, which is the EU's top food producing member state.
The analysis was carried out by Farm Europe, a group of experts on agriculture and rural economies, many of whom previously held high positions in the EU Commission and Parliament.
They looked at public data on the distribution of aid in 2022 to farmers in the EU, France, Italy and the Czech Republic, and how this aid would be affected by the commission's new post-2028 plan to significantly reduce the budget for the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), while capping aid at €100,000 per farm, and radically redistributing the aid from farmers paid more than €20,000 to lower paid farmers.
Farm Europe found that in France, more than 50% of farmers now receiving more than €5,000 a year would have their aid reduced. These farmers have about 73% of the total agricultural area in France.
Farm Europe said: "Such a formula would further increase the economic pressure on farms, which currently account for the bulk of EU production. There is no doubt that this approach would accelerate the process of agricultural restructuring across Europe, encouraging expansion and making it particularly difficult for young farmers to set up traditional family farms.
It could also encourage EU farmers to focus their efforts on reducing costs rather than optimising production, which would seriously undermine the objective of agricultural sovereignty.
Farm Europe found that in the Czech Republic, aid would be reduced for 85% of the productive sector.
In Italy, the owners of 57% of hectares would be adversely affected by redistributing aid from farmers paid more than €20,000 to lower paid farmers.
Farm Europe said: "On various scales, all member states would be severely affected by this proposal, which seems to be dictated more by a desire to save money than by a genuine desire for fairness or a vision for the future of the sector."
Across the EU, more than half of the utilised agricultural area would be affected by the reduction in aid, rising to two-thirds when the smallest farms are excluded (those receiving less than €5,000 in aid).
At EU level, one third of farmers with more than 12 hectares would see their subsidies reduced by redistributing aid from farmers paid more than €20,000 to lower paid farmers, according to the analysis by Farm Europe.
If farmers respond negatively to the new CAP, annual production could fall from the 2024 level of €532.4bn, of which half is crops, and about two-fifths is animals and animal products.
FoodDrinkEurope, which represents Europe's food and drink manufacturers, the buyers of 70% of EU agricultural output, said the European Commission's proposal to fold the CAP into a new cross-sectoral fund risks weakening one of the EU's most important strategic policies.
FoodDrinkEurope said a proposed ring-fenced €302bn envelope for farmers marks a significant decrease from the current CAP budget of €386.6bn. "Member states are expected to provide additional national contributions, which risks creating unequal levels of support across the EU".
The new CAP plan is part of the commission's proposal for the seven-year EU budget starting in 2028, of almost €2trn.
The proposal will be negotiated with the European Parliament, and the Council of the EU, representing EU countries, before final adoption.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Trump tariffs of 15pc create ‘serious uncertainty' for Tipperary's pharma sector
'The confirmation of a 15pc tariff on Irish and EU pharmaceutical exports to the US has introduced serious uncertainty for key sectors in County Tipperary,' said Michelle Aylward, chief executive of County Tipperary Chamber. 'While it replaces the threat of even higher tariffs, it marks a major shift from the previously tariff-free status and creates concern across our pharmaceutical and supply chain members. 'Tipperary is uniquely exposed due to the presence of major multinational employers and local suppliers. Any increase in cost or disruption to trade could have direct consequences for jobs, manufacturing output, and long-term investment decisions in the region. 'Right now, the biggest challenge is the lack of clarity. Behind the headline figure lies a complex and still-unsettled deal with many unanswered questions. 'When will the tariffs actually take effect and how will they be applied? Will there be exemptions or carve-outs for specific drug categories? 'The fact that tariffs could increase again if the US deems the EU to have fallen short of broader targets is especially concerning,' said Ms Aylward. 'This is not a balanced or stable trade structure. We urge the Irish Government and European Commission to demonstrate clear leadership in seeking timely, detailed answers. 'Business needs certainty to plan. It is essential that Ireland not only protects existing trade but also supports companies in exploring alternative markets particularly given the likelihood of prolonged volatility in US trade policy. 'This is more than a trade issue. We are now entering a new era of strategic competition one that demands foresight on trade, energy security, digital regulation, and defence policy. 'Ireland and the EU must be proactive in securing our industrial base and protecting jobs in communities like Tipperary. Clarity isn't just desirable - it's essential,' added Ms Aylward.
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
We dodged a bullet this week & Ursula must have been bricking it, now here's what we need to do for Trump's last 3 years
6 WE dodged a bullet this week. Advertisement Taoiseach 6 Trump and Von Der Leyen met in Scotland to agree a 15 per cent tariff deal Credit: Reuters Sitting opposite him was The Before they headed off to knock their heads together in private, Von Der Leyen said of Trump, 'He's tough, but fair,' while Trump said of himself: 'I'm a tough negotiator and dealmaker.' Advertisement Poor old Ursula. She must've been bricking it. Trump put the chances of a deal at '50-50', adding 'I'm not in a good mood.' Which must've made Ursula doubly petrified. Back in But after little more than an hour, the pair emerged and announced they'd struck a deal. It wouldn't be as good as the 10 per cent deal the Advertisement We'd be hit with across-the-board tariffs of 15 per cent, HALF of what Trump had vowed to impose today had a deal not been achieved. Trump triumphed: 'We have reached a deal. It's a good deal for everybody. "It's going to bring us closer together.' Von der Leyen hailed it too, as a 'huge deal', won after 'tough negotiations'. Micheal and Simon could pinch their jocks free from their a**e cheeks again. Phew. Advertisement The taoiseach said: 'In essence, we have avoided a trade conflict here which would have been ruinous, which would have been very damaging to our economy, and to jobs in particular.' NOT A POT TO PISS IN He was spot on. Had a deal not been thrashed out, Ireland, more than any other EU nation, would have been thoroughly banjaxed. Why? Well, our economy has been ridiculously over-reliant on revenue from US multinationals for decades. Before the IDA began the process of attracting the big US corporate giants to Ireland with the promise of low We hadn't a pot to piss in as a nation. In 1984, just four per cent of Ireland's tax revenue came from foreign multinationals. Advertisement The economy was a basket case. But throughout the 1980s, 1990s and early noughties, Ireland's economy boomed thanks to huge multinational tax revenues. WORRIED SICK By 2024, almost a third of all tax revenue (29 per cent) came from foreign multinationals. Some 75 per cent of them Without the Yanks and their tax dollars, we'd soon be back in the dark days of the 1980s. Advertisement No wonder Micheal and Simon and Think of the many tens of thousands of jobs that would have disappeared overnight. It would have meant economic armageddon. GOOD NEWS FOR IRISH Now, 15 per cent tariffs will hurt Ireland's coffers. But it's not as ruinous as might have been expected. The nitty gritty of this week's US-EU tariff deal still has to be worked out. Advertisement The While, pharma is not explicitly mentioned in the deal, Ursula Von Der Leyen said clearly that the 15 per cent rate WILL apply to the export of drugs to the US. Which is great news for us. It will save many jobs here. And Irish government officials deserve a pat on the back for ensuring a deal on pharma. Without it, we'd have been goosed. PIPE DREAM Remember, as many as 90 pharmaceutical companies operate in Ireland, with around 50,000 people employed by US pharma firms across the country. Advertisement To give you an idea of just how much Ireland relies on pharma taxes, last year they contributed €10 billion to the exchequer — about 10 per cent of all the tax Ireland raked in. We exported €78 billion worth of goods to the US last year. Pharma made up €58 billion of that total. All of which had riled Trump, who has been adamant since assuming power that he wants US pharma companies to manufacture back in the US. It's a pipe dream however, like his entire Make America Great Again fantasy. US multinationals are here not just because of our low corporate tax rates. Advertisement HEEL OF THE HUNT They're here because of our educated workforce, because we work hard and are reliable, because of Ireland's location on the edge of Moving back to the US would be complex, costly and time-consuming. In the heel of the hunt, just not worth it. And anyway, Trump will be gone from office in three years, by which time sanity will hopefully have prevailed in US politics and someone who doesn't want to destroy world trade will be in the Oval office. We can only hope and pray for that day. Advertisement Until then, we just keep the head down, roll with the 15 per cent tariffs, and hope a Trump bullet — and he will fire more, for sure — never hits home. RADICAL PRIEST INFAMOUS Ryan grew up on a farm in 6 Father Patrick Ryan gave money to the IRA and earned the nickname 'The Padre' Credit: Photocall Ireland He entered the Pallatine order aged 14, famously saying later in life that nothing confirmed the social status of a Advertisement He was posted as a young priest, aged 24, to East In 1969 he was posted to a parish in East He managed to get out of it by convincing his superiors that he needed to go home to care for his sick mother. Back home, as a disaffected priest he'd collect for the poor, but some of the donations he siphoned away for the IRA. His superiors noticed and he confessed to 'giving it to another organisation' without naming the Provos. Advertisement He became invaluable to the IRA, earning the moniker 'the Padre'. The British press were less romantic, calling him The Devil's Disciple and The Terror Priest. He would go on to become one of the IRA's biggest fundraisers. He personally helped bring money and guns from Gaddafi's Libya to the IRA in the 1980s. He also honed skills he learned in Africa to build detonators for IRA bombs, one of which was used in the Brighton bombing that almost killed Advertisement His devices were also used in the Hyde Park bombing in July 1982 and in the August 1979 Warrenpoint bombing that killed 18 British soldiers. He told his biographer, Jennifer O'Leary: 'The only regret I have was that I wasn't more effective, that the bombs made with the components I supplied didn't kill more.' Her book The Padre: The True Story of the Irish Priest Who Armed the IRA With Gaddafi's Money was published in 2023. It's a fine read. He was arrested in Belgium in 1988 in connection with the murders of three off-duty British soldiers in the Netherlands. Margaret Thatcher requested his extradition. Ryan responded by going on hunger strike and was repatriated to Ireland. Advertisement Thatcher demanded Charles Haughey, then taoiseach, hand him over, telling him, 'He's a really bad egg.' Haughey refused. He broke off ties with the IRA shortly afterwards, saying he had been compromised by British agents. He died in Dublin on June 15. LEGEND LOST THEY gathered in their many thousands this week to say goodbye to the king of heavy metal, 6 Icon Ozzy Osbourne passed away suddenly on July 22 Credit: Getty Images - Getty Advertisement 6 Thousands turned out for the Black Sabbath singer's funeral Credit: PA Outside Ozzy's boyhood home, which sits in the shadow of Villa Park stadium, fans and wellwishers laid wreaths and ballons plus drawings, posters and paintings to honour the Prince of Darkness. Despite his notoriety and his wealth, Ozzy, left, remained a humble man right up until his death. He preferred to take people down a peg or two and laugh at the world. He was a salt-of-the-earth Brummie, that's why. Farewell buddy. Advertisement SUBHUMANS CAGED I USED to cover the courts. Many moons ago now, but they were an important hunting ground for any reporter wanting to get to grips with reality. Drunks, domestic abusers, Gougers these days are far more violent; to wit, the five subhumans caged for 60 years this week for the barbaric three-hour Back in my day there were no people like that. REGULATION NEEDED THE online ghouls were at it within minutes of a cop being stabbed on Dublin's Capel street on Tuesday evening. Far-right accounts that flourish on Elon Musk's sewerpit, 6 Elon Musk's X platform allows people to spread lies without intervention Credit: Reuters The authorities call it 'misinformation' and 'disinformation'. Instead, they should just brand it all for what it is, plain and simpl. Advertisement LIES. If the same crap that appears on X were printed in a newspaper, it would be rightly sued and forced to pay out a substantial sum in reparations. But X claims it's not a publisher – it bloody well is – merely a platform and has no obligation to fact check anything that is put up. Not only is that argument balderdash (X is a publisher, just like a newspaper or a broadcaster and should be treated as such) it is morally repulsive. But just one look at Advertisement The state is scared to get tough with the tech giants, but if free speech and truth is to mean anything, X and Meta and the rest of them need to be regulated just as newspapers and broadcasters are. CASH GRAB ONLY in Ireland. A few years back the HSE paid a medical supplies company €720,000 TWICE for the same invoice. The right arm not knowing what the left arm is at is a core feature of how the state operates. Has been and will forever be thus. Well, new HSE boss, Bernard Gloster, to his credit, is shaking things up. Keep at it. The HSE is trying to recoup the €750k it overpaid. Good luck with that seeing as the company, PMD Device Solutions is in liquidation. Only in Ireland.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Dawn Meats eyes NZ co-op deal and what tariffs mean for the Border
Waterford-based Dawn Meats has emerged as the front-runner to take a controlling stake in New Zealand's Alliance Group, a farmer-owned co-operative that describes itself as the world's biggest exporter of sheep meat. Nigel Stirling has the details. Some Irish whiskey exporters may be forced 'to reorientate their focus away' from the US if a 15 per cent tariff rate applies as part of the recently agreed EU-US trade deal, the head of the Irish Whiskey Association has warned. Eoin Burke-Kennedy reports. Staying with tariffs, in Agenda, Paul Colgan assesses the fallout of the EU-US trade deal for Ireland and the impact of having a different tariff on either side of the Border. Did the EU bend the knee to Donald Trump in agreeing the bones of what appears to be a lopsided trade deal? In his column, Eoin Burke-Kennedy writes that Commission president Ursula von der Leyen may have taken a leaf out of Keir Starmer's book. READ MORE Former Sherry FitzGerald chief executive Steven McKenna has set up a consultancy to advise Irish SMEs on their digital strategies, mergers and acquisitions, and succession planning. Ciarán Hancock has more. Rising costs and a slow down in new business failed to halt manufacturing growth this month, figures published on Friday show. Irish factories boosted production for the seventh month in a row in July, according to AIB's Ireland Manufacturing Purchasing Managers' Index. Barry O'Halloran reports. Joe Brennan has details of a deal that sees Goldman Sachs acquire key economic interests to more than €1 billion of mortgages written by Finance Ireland before it exited the home loans market this year, according to sources. World of Work sees Margaret E Ward look at the changing role of fathers in the workplace and what that means for working life today. Inheritance tax is set to be reformed , but in Smart Money, Cliff Taylor warns that the changes inevitably won't please everyone. Irishman Mark Bourke wants to remain chief executive of Novo Banco after the Portuguese lender's acquisition by French banking group BPCE is completed next year. The Workplace Relations Commission has ordered Tesco to re-employ a worker it sacked last year for calling his manager 'useless' in a performance review meeting – after ruling the supermarket's management went over the top in dismissing him. Stephen Bourke has the story. Food prices in Ireland are rising at three times the rate of overall inflation, the latest data from the Central Statistics Office (CSO) show. Eoin has the details. If you'd like to read more about the issues that affect your finances try signing up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.
