logo
Trump's America could mean a crossroads for Australia and Canada's political futures

Trump's America could mean a crossroads for Australia and Canada's political futures

When Australians went to the polls in May, the Labor party achieved a result that didn't seem possible at the beginning of the year.
They won in a landslide, and the Liberal party not only lost the election, but opposition leader Peter Dutton lost his seat in parliament.
Canada's opposition leader met a similar fate only a matter of weeks before.
Just before both the Canadian and Australian elections, Donald Trump was reinstated as the United States' president.
His return to power was thought to influence the outcomes of those two elections, leading commentators to coin the term, "the Trump effect".
Leo Crabe, a lecturer and independent researcher who specialises in international policy and global affairs, believes voters didn't like what they saw happening in the US from afar.
"Voters in both countries saw Trump's nationalism and unpredictability … and instead chose to support different leaders who promised a different approach," he told ABC Radio National's Future Tense.
As two current centre-left governments, Australia and Canada share many common features.
They're both large countries with geographically dispersed populations, and have a shared British colonial history.
So, in a time of global uncertainty, does it make sense for the two nations to build a closer bond for future prosperity?
It's been a turbulent time following Trump's return to power, and Crabe says that Canada and Australia have been given a "wake-up call" regarding their countries' relationship with the US.
"Canada and Australia are now at a crossroads," he says.
"In Canada's case, Trump's tariffs presented an existential economic risk for key sectors of the economy.
"Australia, likewise, experienced economic pressure and threats of tariffs from Trump and, for both countries, these threats aren't merely financial."
Crabe says they also highlight "the danger of an over-reliance on a partner that has unfortunately become unpredictable".
This might be the cause, he suggests, for both countries to re-evaluate their relationship with the superpower.
"Neither Canada nor Australia can disregard that partnership [with the US] entirely. But there's a key difference: strong ties don't have to mean subordinate ties," Crabe says.
"Canada and Australia can strengthen their own positions by actively building new partnerships."
He proposes that by coming together, the nations can step into a greater united leadership and have a bigger footprint on the international political stage, protecting themselves from a less predictable US force.
"This will make us less vulnerable to US policy and position them [Canadians] to engage with the US from a point of strength," Crabe adds.
Based on their similarities Canada and Australia are natural political partners, but when it comes to trade, they're competitors.
The insidious nature of our algorithmic feeds
Both countries prioritise the export of raw materials, which could be an issue when relying on US trade.
Enter "Ozanada" a fictional country coined by The Economist Magazine in 2023 to make a point about the way both nations have developed and what could spell problems for them in the future.
The University of Sydney's special innovation advisor, Roy Green, says an over-reliance on raw exports and an under-fed innovation sector threatens to hold "Ozanada" back.
"It's partly because we have smaller populations that can't sustain as much competition, but it does stifle the prospect of greater innovation because competition is essential to that," Professor Green says.
"We have made ourselves the victims of the resource curse, which is not a naturally occurring phenomenon. It's a political choice."
Canada and Australia are already partners in many military initiatives, including intelligence.
Both nations are currently members of the Five Eyes intelligence alliance, along with New Zealand, the United Kingdom and the United States.
It represents a long-standing agreement for cooperation in intelligence gathering and analysis, primarily focused on signals intelligence.
In comparison, the idea of CANZUK (Canada, Australia, New Zealand and the UK) has been around since the late 1960s, and proposes a stronger political and economic alliance between the countries.
Critically, it wouldn't include the US.
"The idea really would be to identify each other as best mates in the world and to draw closer together over time," says economist Andrew Lilico.
When Canada recently purchased Australia's Jindalee Operational Radar Network (JORN), a vast radar system that lets Australia monitor the sky and sea thousands of kilometres away, it shocked international security experts.
"It was something that kind of came out of left field," says Wesley Nicol, a foreign policy expert from Carleton University in Canada.
"The reason why this matters so much is not only because it's Australia's largest defence export ever, but because one of the pressures that Canada has been facing from the United States is to not only spend more on defence, but specifically to increase capabilities in the Arctic."
Dr Lilico agrees that the swift purchase of JORN by Canada's new Prime Minister Mark Carney may relieve some of the pressure the country is receiving from the US.
It's another example of the two nations working together for future benefit, and excluding the US.
CANZUK supporters, like Dr Lilico, believe this could be an ideal moment for the alliance to be realised.
He says that Trump's behaviour and policies have led many to see that the US "isn't similar in its outlook" and "isn't really a reliable partner".
#newsletter:abc-radio-national_optin
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘The opposite happened': Economic roundtable could dissuade Australians from investing
‘The opposite happened': Economic roundtable could dissuade Australians from investing

Sky News AU

time6 hours ago

  • Sky News AU

‘The opposite happened': Economic roundtable could dissuade Australians from investing

LNP Senator James McGrath discusses Labor's economic reform roundtable, urging that it will dissuade Australians from investing in the 'productive part of the economy'. 'What the Labor Party doesn't realise is that if people start to cotton on to the fact that Labor is going to come after the money they've worked so hard for, people will no longer invest in the productive part of the economy,' Mr McGrath told Sky News host Steve Price. 'You only have to look at what's happening in the UK at the moment, with the Labour Party there, taxing what's called 'non-doms'. 'They thought they were going to bring billions of pounds of revenue … the opposite happened.'

Four Aussie residents, including two citizens, now facing Hong Kong arrest warrants, bounties
Four Aussie residents, including two citizens, now facing Hong Kong arrest warrants, bounties

SBS Australia

time6 hours ago

  • SBS Australia

Four Aussie residents, including two citizens, now facing Hong Kong arrest warrants, bounties

Four Australian residents are now facing overseas arrest warrants issued by Hong Kong's national security police, after a fresh announcement concerning support for a pro-democracy party in the state's parliament. Australian citizen Chongyi Feng and resident Wong Sau-Wo are accused of having launched a referendum or run as candidates in the unofficial "Hong Kong Parliament" group. They are among 19 activists who are are accused of organising or participating in the group that authorities in the Asian financial hub say aims at achieving self-determination and drafting a "Hong Kong constitution". Authorities say the group aims to subvert state power, under the law Beijing imposed in 2020 following months of pro-democracy protests in 2019. There is a bounty of at least HK$200,000 ($38,807) for each of the activists. Yam, who is a legal scholar, and Hui, a former Hong Kong Democracy party MP, were among eight overseas-based activists who authorities accused of national security offences, including foreign collusion and incitement to secession. At the time, the police also offered rewards of HK$1 million ($194,000) for information leading to each possible arrest. Foreign Minister Penny Wong has reacted to the announcement, saying "Australia strongly objects to Hong Kong authorities issuing arrest warrants for pro-democracy advocates in Australia." "Freedom of expression and assembly are essential to our democracy," she wrote on social media platform X on Saturday "We have consistently expressed our strong objections to China and Hong Kong on the broad and extraterritorial application of Hong Kong's national security legislation, and we will continue to do so." SBS News has reached out to the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade for comment. Hong Kong's national security law Feng has told SBS News that, while he feels safe being in Australia, the federal government must remain cautious in its interactions with China. "So we need to be fully aware of the nature of (China's) authoritarian regime when dealing with Xi Jinping or the People's Republic of China." He says many of his friends in Hong Kong have been jailed due to the state's national security law, which makes perceived political subversion a serious offence. Critics of the national security law say authorities are using it to stifle dissent. Chinese and Hong Kong officials have repeatedly said the law was vital to restore stability after the city was rocked for months by sometimes violent anti-government and anti-China protests in 2019. "I feel quite sad that the autonomy of Hong Kong, of basic human rights in Hong Kong, and democracy in Hong Kong have all been destroyed by the implementation of the national security law," Feng said. Police reiterated that national security offences were serious crimes with extraterritorial reach and urged the wanted individuals to return to Hong Kong and turn themselves in. "If offenders voluntarily give up continuing to violate the crime, turn themselves in, truthfully confess their crimes, or provide key information that helps solve other cases, they may be eligible for reduced punishment," they said in a statement. Police also warned that aiding, abetting, or funding others to participate in the "Hong Kong Parliament" could be a criminal offence. Additional reporting by Wing Kuang and the Reuters News Agency.

‘Brown-noser': Crass statue appears outside Richard Marles electoral office in Geelong
‘Brown-noser': Crass statue appears outside Richard Marles electoral office in Geelong

The Australian

time9 hours ago

  • The Australian

‘Brown-noser': Crass statue appears outside Richard Marles electoral office in Geelong

A crass piece of political art has accused Richard Marles of being 'Australia's biggest brown-noser' as the defence minister signed a 50-year treaty alongside his UK counterpart. The installation, outside Mr Marles electoral office in Geelong, depicted a large nose with an apparent fecal smear. Affixed to a light post by chain, the work is attributed to The New Radicals and names Mr Marles. A piece of protest art was left in the Geelong CBD labelling Richard Marles "Australia's biggest brown-noser" on the day of the signing of the Geelong treaty. Picture X / @maximum_chips The art was cleaned up promptly and gone by 5pm. Picture: Supplied The protest art comes as Mr Marles signed a new five-decade treaty with the United Kingdom to cement the AUKUS submarine pact in his home city. Dubbed 'The Geelong Treaty', the defence minister said the agreement would enable co-operation on the SSN-Aukus submarine. 'In doing this, AUKUS will see 20,000 jobs in Australia. It will see, in building submarines in this country, the biggest industrial endeavour in our nation's history, bigger even than the Snowy Hydro scheme,' Mr Marles said. 'In military terms, what it will deliver is the biggest leap in Australia's military capability, really, since the formation of the navy back in 1913.' Deputy PM Richard Marles and UK Defence Secretary John Healey sign the Geelong Treaty. Picture: NewsWire / Luis Enrique Ascui The two men later enjoyed a Saturday beer. Picture: NewsWire / Luis Enrique Ascui The new treaty was announced following the annual AUKMIN talks in Sydney on Friday. Alongside his counterpart, UK Secretary of State for Defence John Healey, the two men celebrated the treaty with a beer at a Geelong brewery. Spotted in Geelong's CBD on Saturday afternoon, the piece has vanished by 5pm. Liam Beatty Journalist Liam Beatty is a court reporter with NCA NewsWire. He has previously worked in newsrooms in Victoria and Western Australia. Liam Beatty

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store