Labor's debt bombshell after court ruling
The Federal Court handed down its decision on Tuesday that the method the government had been using since 2020 to calculate and collect debt was valid.
The Department of Social Services (DSS) had paused debt repatriation for social security employment checks received before 2020 as it awaited the key court judgment, but the department secretary Michael Lye said the court decision affirmed his 'legal position' and assessment activities would resume.
'Now there is certainty to the legal position, assessment activities will recommence in line with the court's decision and my obligations as secretary,' Mr Lye said.
The department could now reassess the debt of up to 160,000 people as far back as 1979, reportedly worth $1.1bn.
But the Australian Financial Review reported that government officials were aware that Social Services Minister Tanya Plibersek was considering options on the overpayments, going as far as to forgive the debts. Tanya Plibersek is reportedly considering forgiving decades-old welfare debts. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia
Greens questioning in senate estimates earlier this year revealed that Services Australia was chasing billions of dollars in decades-old debt.
Data showed that up to $4.9bn in unpaid debts were being pursued from more than 829,000 customers.
Ms Plibersek did not comment beyond a joint statement released with Katy Gallagher on Tuesday.
'The Albanese Labor government acknowledges the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court in Matthew Chaplin v Secretary, Department of Social Services,' the statement read.
'Income apportionment is a historical practice which ran from the early 1990s to 2020. It is not used today. It has never been used by the Albanese Labor government.
'Income apportionment was a method used by Centrelink to calculate debts in circumstances where they did not have detailed information about days and hours worked.
'This methodology reduced unreasonable reporting burdens and paperwork on welfare recipients and was a genuine misinterpretation of the law.
'The Chaplin decision has reconfirmed that the process of income apportionment was not lawful. It also confirmed that the process used to calculate debt since 2020 is valid.
'The government will now evaluate its impact and develop a suitable response.' Greens senator Penny Allman-Payne criticised the government for 'aggressively targeting' welfare recipients. NewsWire / Sarah Marshall Credit: News Corp Australia
Greens social services spokeswoman Penny Allman-Payne criticised the government for 'aggressively targeting income support recipients with cruel and ridiculous debt notices based on dubious data matching methods'.
'Income support payments are already below the poverty line, meaning thousands of income support recipients are making tough choices between skipping meals or paying the rent,' she said.
'The last thing they need is the government hounding them to disprove a dodgy debt notice, sometimes from decades ago.
'The Greens will be urging Labor to act to protect welfare recipients and finally put the Robodebt era behind us.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
38 minutes ago
- Perth Now
‘Betray': Ley not ‘fair dinkum' on Gaza
A Labor MP leading calls in Canberra to recognise a Palestinian state has slammed Sussan Ley for refusing to say civilians are starving in Gaza. Ed Husic was among the 90,000 people who marched through Sydney's CBD and across the Harbour Bridge on Sunday. The son of Bosnian Muslim immigrants, the former minister has been outspoken on the plight of innocent Palestinians in Gaza since losing his cabinet seat in factional infighting earlier this year. Asked about the Opposition Leader's refusal to acknowledge starvation in Gaza, Mr Husic said on Monday any 'pro-family' conservatives who did not recognise the dire situation 'betray' the values they claimed to hold. Labor MP Ed Husic (centre) is leading calls in Canberra for Palestinian statehood. Tom Parrish Credit: News Corp Australia 'I think conservatives who argue that they are pro family and cannot find a way to reflect on the suffering that has been wrought on innocent Palestinian families really betray whether or not they're fair dinkum on the cause,' he told the ABC. He said he thought 'everyone gets' the horrors Hamas inflicted on Israel in its October 7 attacks in 2023 and those responsible 'need to be held to account'. Mr Husic also said that Israelis taken hostage 'should be released and the people who had mistreated them fundamentally should be held to account as well'. 'But 60,000 innocent Palestinians, half of which have been women and children, that have been killed through the Netanyahu government's actions – they did not deserve that,' he said. 'They deserve to be able to carry on with their lives and do the type of things that they want to do in their lives, like we do in our families. 'So I think the Coalition would do themselves better credit if they recognised the impact on innocent families.' Some 90,000 people gathered in Sydney's CBD to protest the war in Gaza. NewsWire / Damian Shaw Credit: News Corp Australia Health officials in Gaza said overnight six more people died from starvation, bringing the total toll to 175. While supplies have started trickling into the war-ravaged Palestian territory in slightly higher amounts, humanitarian groups have said it is nowhere near enough to prevent further deaths from a lack of food. The mild relief has been helped in part by countries air-dropping aid. But the Israeli government continues to keep a chokehold on the aid flow via land crossings. The Albanese government on Sunday announced a $20m support package for Gaza. The funds will go to humanitarian agencies best placed to co-ordinate aid delivery, including the UN's World Food Program and The International Committee of the Red Cross. More to come.
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
Australia news and politics live: Emissions reduction ‘central' to boosting productivity
Scroll down for the latest news and updates. Labor MP Ed Husic says the recognition of Palestinian statehood would undermine the terrorist organisation Hamas. 'On the point of whether or not this rewards Hamas, I would put it differently…I would actually say it fundamentally undermines them and undercuts their standing,' he told ABC Radio National Breakfast on Monday. 'And the fact that you've set up a state, reformed the democracy and the Palestinian Authority, demilitarised Hamas, I think undercuts it significantly.' 'So I would actually say for people who want to see Hamas removed out of the equation, this is the way to go. Recognition is the way to go.' Labor MP Ed Husic, who took part in the pro-Palestine march across the Sydney Harbour Bridge on Sunday, described the protest as a 'tremendous example of a peaceful assembly'. Speaking to ABC Radio National, Mr Husic said the demonstration sent a powerful message to politicians, many of whom have 'underestimated' the depth of feeling among Australians regarding the crisis in Gaza. Among the prominent figures marching alongside Mr Husic were notable figures such as Julian Assange, Bob Carr, Mehreen Faruqi and Craig Foster. 'It was a tremendous example…of people coming out in force to let governments know how deeply they feel and how much they want governments to act on the concerns they have, triggered by horrific images we've seen out of Gaza,' he said. He added, 'I think people in particular believe it's just not right. Not only is it not legally right under international humanitarian law to treat kids in the way that they've been treated in Gaza, but it offends our values as people, and so people turned up in large number.' 'I think this is a wake-up call for Australian politics.' Australia's defence force is growing for the first time in years with applications rising and retention rates improving. Defence enlisted more than 7000 full-time personnel in 2024/25, which is the highest annual intake in more than 15 years, and a 17 per cent increase from 2023. The Federal Government aims to reach 69,000 permanent defence force personnel by the early 2030s and has introduced targeted initiatives to address declining recruitment. Significant investments had helped support current defence workers and grow the force for the future, Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles said. 'In 2025, the ADF is now growing again for the first time in almost four years, (and) while there is much more work to do, we are confident these positive trends will continue.' Read the full story here. Nationals MP Barnaby Joyce says net zero is a 'lunatic policy' that is hurting the poorest Australians due to increasing power prices. 'It's outrageous, and it's premised around this lunatic policy called net zero. We're not going to achieve net zero. We are going to deindustrialise Australia. We are going to smash the Australian economy,' he told Sunrise. Social Services Minister Tanya Plibersek questioned Mr Joyce on his solution to cheapen energy prices. 'What is his alternative?... What is his plan? If he doesn't want renewables, what does he want?' 'I will go back to coal-fired power,' Mr Joyce responded. Mr Joyce also slammed the Productivity Commission's report, which called for an expansion of the safeguard mechanism. 'It's going to make it harder for manufacturing to come to Australia and heavy industries to come to Australia,' he said. Legal experts have warned that Sunday's demonstration on the Sydney Harbour Bridge could result in further disruptions, with no law preventing future applications for protests. Social Services Minister Tanya Plibersek was asked on Sunrise if the pro-Palestine rally, which had a turnout of over 90,000 people, sets a precedent for other advocacy groups. 'I think Australians understand that the peaceful right to protest is important in our democracy, but we wouldn't want to see the Harbour Bridge shut down every weekend,' she said. 'I think Australians do want to send a message that there has been too much death, too many people have lost their lives, and we want to see the hostages return, we want to see humanitarian access to Gaza, we particularly don't want to see children starving to death as a result of this conflict,' she added. On the other hand, Nationals MP Barnaby Joyce said that the protest will start a precedent. 'Once you've got one issue saying, 'this is really important to us,' and I don't doubt for one second how important this is, everyone wants to see an end to the war, but you create a precedent for other groups,' he said. 'That's not how it's supposed to work.' An answer to Australia's languishing productivity lies in its response to the threat of climate change, an independent government advisory body has found. Adapting to growing climate-related risks while also reducing emissions and transitioning to clean energy will enable higher productivity growth and living standards, according to an interim report by the Productivity Commission. The findings come as Treasurer Jim Chalmers prepares to convene a roundtable in search of a solution to the nation's lagging productivity. 'Australia's net zero transformation is well under way,' commissioner Barry Sterland said. 'Getting the rest of the way at the lowest possible cost is central to our productivity challenge.' Read the full story here .
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
Government says record recruits and 1.9 per cent increase to ADF headcount ‘rebuilding' the nations forces
A 17 per cent increase in the number of Australian Defence Force recruits in 12 months is being hailed by the Albanese Government as proof it's 'rebuilding' depleted miliary ranks. New ADF enlistments grew to 7,059 last financial year up from 6,041 over the previous 12 months, and the largest increase since 2009. 'It is essential that Australia has the Defence Force it needs to help protect its strategic interests,' Deputy Prime Minister Richard Marles said. 'That is why we have made significant investments to support our current Defence workforce and grow it for the future. When the Albanese Government came to office we inherited a personnel crisis. Throughout the near-decade the Coalition was in office, the ADF grew by just 2,000 people.' Headcount data release by the Albanese Government shows there were 59,550 ADF personnel in 2009 - that fell to 56,909 in 2012 before recovering and climbing to 61,336 in the 2020/21 financial year. Upon taking office in 2022, the Labor government inherited a slightly smaller defence force of just over 60,000 personnel, which it had grown by 1.9% to 61,189 last financial year. That's still more than 1500 short of the ADF's authorised strength of of 62,700 permanent members. 'Thanks to our recruitment and retention initiatives the Australian Defence Force is seeing increased applications, enlistments and more people staying in service,' Minister for Defence Personnel, Matt Keogh said. 'A stabilised and strengthened workforce is the foundation that we need to continue to grow, to reskill and transform to have the future workforce required to deliver against the 2024 National Defence Strategy.' Minister Keogh said the government had introduced a series of reforms including expanding health care services for ADF personnel boosting the Defence Assisted Study Scheme and broadened the recruitment system. All of the measures were contributing to lower attrition and higher enlistments.
