A Tush Push ban would be an incredibly weak move by the NFL
A Tush Push ban would be an incredibly weak move by the NFL
Packers now have revised their proposal to ban 'The Tush Push' at this week's league meeting in Minneapolis. Here is their revised proposal: pic.twitter.com/1olaumN0xd — Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) May 19, 2025
Good morning, Winners! This is For The Win's daily newsletter, The Morning Win. Did a friend recommend or forward this to you? If so, subscribe here. Here's Mike Sykes.
If you can't beat it, ban it.
That's the message the NFL appears poised to send with a potential tush push ban. The Green Bay Packers, who originally pushed for the ban back in March during the league's owners meetings, are bringing their cause back for the league's spring meetings. Except, this time, they've updated the language to ban all teammate pushes for ball carriers, for the tush or otherwise.
ESPN's Adam Schefter dropped the details on X. It doesn't specifically ban the Eagles' signature play. It's far broader and would ban what they call "interlocking interference."
I hope you all understand how uncool this is. Players wouldn't be able to push a pile at all. For context, this was an established rule before. Before 2005, the NFL outlawed pushing and pulling ball carriers, so it's not entirely unprecedented.
But the rule change opened up the league for some of the most fun plays we've seen over the last two decades. Plays like Marshawn Lynch dragging a pile of dudes with him into the endzone would draw a 10-yard penalty instead of a touchdown. Every "push the pile" moment that transformed plays from nothing to something would be ruled illegal. And it's not because those players were particularly problematic, but rather because the league couldn't figure out how to stop one play.
What makes it worse is that the Packers cite player safety and pace of play as reasons why these plays need to be banned, but neither is a real problem. We haven't seen significant injuries as a result of pushing the pile. As far as the pace of play goes, the clock doesn't stop. These plays don't go out of bounds. The tush push is one of the quickest plays in football — just a few seconds and it's over. There's no pace problem with it. The only problem seems to be that nobody has figured out a way to stop it outside of a straight-up ban.
If that's the case, then fine. But the Packers and other supporters of this ban should say it gives teams like the Eagles a competitive advantage instead of talking around it. The Commanders' Frankie Luvu did. He called the play a "cheat code" and argued that it's a rugby scrum based on the Eagles' cadence, giving them an advantage over the defense. That's still wack, but I can respect that more than anyone saying a potential ban is for health and safety reasons. At least it's honest.
We don't know how this will turn out. There seems to be momentum for a ban, but the Eagles are "lobbying" for the play not to be banned, according to The Athletic. We'll see how those efforts go.
But if this is the end of the tush push, at least we got to see the play win a Super Bowl. I'm sure they'll take that.
Trouble in paradise
Things were all good a couple of months ago for the Mets when the season started. They were the best team in baseball and Juan Soto seemed just fine.
Now, he's a bit moody and the Mets are 5-5 in the last 10 games. Soto's slump seems to be a big part of that.
So what's the problem? Well, according to Michael Kay, Soto wanted to be a Yankee and he isn't happy he's a Met. Details from Charles Curtis:
"But the attention on him got ratcheted up over the weekend when he returned to Yankee Stadium and heard all kinds of things yelled at him by Pinstripes fans. There were also questions about his hustle that popped up there and on Monday when he stared down a ball he thought was a home run and had to settle for a single.
Which brings us to a report from Michael Kay, who said this on his radio show on Monday (via Awful Announcing): "People that I talked to on the Mets side, and they can deny it publicly, because, of course, that's what they have to do, he is very, very glum around the clubhouse. He does not have a hop in his step. He does not smile much. I'm not gonna say he is unhappy. Because how can you be unhappy with a $765 million contract? But money is not a guarantee that you are gonna be comfortable somewhere.'
If I'm being honest, this is a bit hard for me to believe. He signed a $765 million deal with the Mets. That's a massive commitment. I don't think he does that if he doesn't want to play for that team.
But there definitely seems to be something going on with Soto right now. We have no idea what it truly is. But the good thing for Mets fans is that it's still fairly early in the season, the Mets are good and there's still time to turn this around.
A new era
The NBA Conference Finals start tonight with the Timberwolves and Oklahoma City Thunder tipping things off in the Western Conference.
I'm normally pumped about the Conference Finals in the NBA playoffs, generally speaking, because this is the best time for pure basketball. The two best teams in each conference square off for a chance to go to the NBA Finals. It's the perfect time because we don't have to worry about the narratives attached to the players and whatever legacy is on the line — we just get to watch elite basketball.
But this year is a bit more exciting for me because somebody is going to win their first championship. We've got four elite guards on each side with Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (OKC), Anthony Edwards (MIN), Jalen Brunson (NYK) and Tyrese Haliburton (IND). None of them have won a championship before. In about a month, we'll be crowning one of these dudes. I still cannot believe it.
This is only the second Conference Finals without the Warriors, the Celtics or LeBron James (lol) in the last decade. And, what's more, three of the teams competing have never won an NBA title. The Knicks have a championship, but they won it 52 years ago.
NBA Final Four Teams Since 2016: pic.twitter.com/PwgTUYn3FZ — RealGM (@RealGM) May 18, 2025
We've been asking for the future of the NBA to arrive. It's finally here. Let's enjoy this basketball, folks.
Quick hits: Don't blame Leafs fans ... White Sox x Pope Leo ... and more
— Mary Clarke says everyone should stop blaming Leafs fans for the team's Game 7 misery. It ain't their fault.
— The White Sox have already built a nice tribute for Pope Leo. Cory Woodroof has the details.
— Christian D'Andrea says Shedeur Sanders didn't take a pay cut to get to the Browns.
— Caitlin Clark is denouncing hateful acts at Fever games. I can't believe we have to do this again.
— Here's Meg Hall with WNBA power rankings. The Liberty are still at the top.
— Nikola Jokic has already diagnosed the Nuggets' biggest problem heading into the offseason. Robert Zeglinski has more.
That's a wrap, folks. Thanks so much for reading. Peace.
-Sykes ✌️
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bloomberg
31 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
Chicago Bears Weigh Sale of McKenna's Minority Stake
The Chicago Bears are exploring a sale of the minority stake owned by the late Andrew McKenna Sr., according to people familiar with the matter. The exact size of the stake isn't known. McKenna died in 2023. The descendants of George Halas, the team's founder, own approximately 80% of the team. In addition to McKenna's stake, some shares are owned by insurance billionaire Pat Ryan, 88. Ryan and McKenna originally purchased 19.7% of the club in 1990.
Yahoo
36 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Controversial Browns WR Diontae Johnson Wants to 'Change The Narrative'
Controversial Browns WR Diontae Johnson Wants to 'Change The Narrative' originally appeared on Athlon Sports. Some Cleveland Browns hoped their team would find another wide receiver with the seven picks the team utilized at the NFL Draft. Jerry Jeudy proved he could be a strong No. 1 option through the 2024 season, but his offense needs another punch in the passing game. Advertisement But they've done it another way. A controversial way. The Browns let Elijah Moore walk (he's with the Bills) after tallying 61 receptions and 538 yards in that campaign. Cedric Tillman, the next man up on the depth chart, had only 339 receiving yards a year ago. Enter Diontae Johnson, who on Wednesday spoke to the media in an effort to stem a tide of negativity. "I don't want to speak on a lot of stuff," Johnson said. "Everybody's going to have their opinions, you know what I'm saying? So at the end of the day, I'm the only one in that room that really know what's going on. They're entitled to their own opinion, so I can only go off of what I know and then try to go off what I put out there and my best effort. ... Advertisement "Last year is last year. I'm trying to change that narrative and move the right way and keep going." The Browns in late April signed Johnson, 28, to a one-year deal worth the veteran minimum ($1.17 million) that includes no guaranteed money. Johnson said the Browns were the only team that reached out to him in free agency before he signed. That tells a story. Johnson's first five seasons came with the Pittsburgh Steelers (where he had 391 catches for 4,363 yards and 25 touchdowns) before he was traded to the Carolina Panthers last March. That move preceded a subsequent trade to the Baltimore Ravens after seven games. Advertisement He spent four games with the Ravens before being placed on waivers where the Houston Texans claimed him. The Browns originally brought Johnson in for a visit last week and rumors of his intentions to join the team quickly swirled. He's bounced around the league amid behavioral concerns. Is that a "narrative''? Or an issue? "I'm still in that form," said Johnson, a 2019 NFL Draft third-round pick who made the Pro Bowl in 2021. "It's just a matter of whenever I get my opportunities to put it on film." Related: Shedeur Sanders Turning Heads With Response To Backup Reps This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 11, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Kicker Daniel Carlson and punter AJ Cole put best feet forward for Raiders
HENDERSON, Nev. (AP) — Neither took the easy path to get here. But because Daniel Carlson and AJ Cole persevered, the Las Vegas Raiders have perhaps the best kicker-punter duo in the NFL. Las Vegas showed its appreciation to Cole by signing him late last month to an extension that briefly made him the league's highest-paid punter. Advertisement Now the question is whether the Raiders will show the same kind of appreciation toward Carlson, who enters the final season of his four-year, $18.4 million deal. 'Going on year eight as a Raider now, that's essentially been my whole career,' Carlson said. "Just honored to be a part of this historic organization and excited about where we're headed this year and the direction we're going as a program. So if (an extension) happens, I'd love that, but I'm focused on the football side.' For kickers with at least 85 attempts over the past three seasons, Carlson was fifth in conversion rate at 89.3%. His 24 made field goals from 50 yards and beyond ranked fourth. He's also having to adjust to new kickoff rules for the second season in a row. The NFL changed its format last year, placing 10 kick coverage players at the opposing 40-yard line. Touchbacks put the ball at the 30. Advertisement Now touchbacks will begin possession at the 35 to encourage even more kickoff returns. 'It's going to be hard as coaches to say, 'Hey, let's just give them the ball at the 35,'' Raiders special teams coach Tom McMahon said. "I think that's the biggest thing that's going to change with that new touchback rule.' Carlson was effective in limiting the damage last season when he put the ball in play, which he did often with 68% of kickoffs resulting in touchbacks. For those with at least 30 kickoffs last season, Carlson was second in the league in allowing 23 yards per kickoff return, just behind the 22.2 average of Greg Zuerlein of the New York Jets. Advertisement 'There's almost like some soccer skills that are popping up again, where it's a little more feel, just because it's a very different kick than a field goal,' Carlson said. 'You don't want to necessarily just kick it straight to the returner or anything like that.' Adapting to new circumstances is nothing new for Carlson. As a rookie in 2018 for Minnesota, he missed three field goals — two in overtime — in a 29-29 tie with NFC North rival Green Bay. The Vikings waived him the following day. Carlson caught on with the then-Oakland Raiders — he's one of four players left who played for the team in the Bay Area — and soon began to establish himself as the one of the league's best kickers. He was a second-team AP All-Pro in 2021 and a first-teamer the next season. Advertisement Cole's path was different, but like Carlson, became one of the top players at his position when the early odds appeared against him. Cole, who also began his NFL career in Oakland, entered minicamp in 2019 hoping just to remain on the roster after those three days. He wound up beating out Johnny Townsend in training camp. 'I showed up to that minicamp and I really just felt like, 'This could be it, and I'm going to go into every single one of these three days and I'm going to get all the juice I can,'' Cole said. "I've been trying to keep that same mentality, and I'm just on absolute borrowed time. I enjoy every single day. I don't think there's anybody that has more fun at work than I do. It's just such a blessing.' Cole has averaged at least 50 yards three of the past four seasons, a feat that only Ryan Stenhouse has matched in league history. He also is third in gross punting average (48.6 yards) and eighth in net average (42.1 yards) since his first season. Advertisement Such production earned Cole first-team All-Pro in 2021 and 2023. And a contract extension. Cole was rewarded with a four-year, $15.8 million deal on May 26 that included $11 million in guaranteed money. That gave him the distinction of being the NFL's highest-paid punter, but this week was passed by two other players. Not that Cole is complaining. When asked if he planned a major purchase, he said that already had been made before signing the contract. 'All of my plants died, so we just re-landscaped our yard,' Cole said. "So I'm really excited that I get to stay here and watch those plants grow up. I don't know if you guys have bought plants before, but they're really, really expensive. "So that was the big-ticket purchase — a couple of new queen palm trees in the backyard and a couple sweet Bay laurels on the side.' ___ AP NFL:
