
Letters to the Editor, June 9th: On relatives in Gaza, minding your manners and Elvis
Sir, – Each morning after digesting updates of the relentless escalation of massacres in Gaza I go to work to continue my job as a junior doctor.
I paint a smile on my face and feign optimism to help those in our hospitals with their own illnesses. I tell myself that I am doing all I can to help those around me, both here and abroad. I push the thoughts of the inhumane killing of thousands of babies out of my mind, while I focus on what, and who, is in front of me.
I reassure myself that this is the right thing to do; the patients here also require my care and attention.
As I greet my colleagues throughout the morning I cannot but be ashamed when looking in the eyes of one particular friend and colleague. This young doctor is from Palestine and moved to Ireland a number of years ago while his family remain trapped in Gaza.
READ MORE
I once again suppress the anger and disgust that I feel for our Government by our lack of action.
Why should this young doctor continue to treat and care for our families while we are sitting watching his burn? – Yours, etc,
GRÁINNE YOUNG,
Ranelagh,
Dublin 6.
Sir, – Paul Kearns's article ('
The beaches here in Israel are full. Just an hour's drive away, Palestinians are starving',
June 7th,) is telling, frightening and saddening.
The evidence he cites from his conversations with his Israeli friends about what is going on in Gaza displays a powerful ideological complex at work.
Many Israelis, on Mr Kearns's evidence, believe that there 'are no innocents in Gaza', 18,000 dead children notwithstanding.
Many Israelis believe that Hamas uses 'human shields' and they deduce from this that Palestinians and Hamas in particular do not value human life as much as Israel does.
Even if that is the case, how then does one explain the ferocious ratio the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) is prepared to tolerate of civilian to combatant deaths. Dozens, even hundreds, of Palestinian deaths are permissible to kill one Hamas leader.
One is led to conclude, with the great American philosopher Judith Butler, that Palestinian lives are much less valuable than Israeli lives.
Many Israelis believe that Hamas 'brought this upon themselves'. This 'argument' does two kinds of work.
It detaches the current catastrophe from the longer history of the Gaza Strip and of the Occupation. And it exculpates Israel.
This exculpation has been around for a long time.
One remembers that Golda Meir, prime minister of Israel in the early 1970s, reckoned that none of the wars Israel fought were its fault.
One remembers her declaration that there is no such thing as Palestinians. And one remembers her statement that 'we will perhaps in time be able to forgive the Arabs for killing our sons, but it will be harder for us to forgive them for having forced us to kill their sons'.
Israel kills tens of thousands of people but it's the fault of those people. – Yours, etc,
CONOR McCARTHY,
Valletta,
Malta.
Standards of care
Sir,– For families, the recent disclosures about poor standards of care for sick children in Ireland raises concerns about trust in our healthcare system.
For families of children with intellectual disability it is a double whammy. Not only is their child a sick child requiring State care and services for life, but also intellectually disabled children are disproportionately included among the numbers affected by the series of revelations about hip and spinal surgeries.
For children with intellectual disability and, in particular, children with cerebral palsy, hip and spine problems are significant issues causing pain and complications which reduce quality of life.
Surgery has been the primary treatment for hip dysplasia related to muscle spasticity and for scoliosis of the spine in children with cerebral palsy.
Intellectually disabled children and their families are one of the most vulnerable groups in Ireland, and depend on many forms of State service, including the very limited therapeutic interventions, day and respite services and residential care.
Families are continuously campaigning for improved services. Following on from the HSE failure to meet the demand for assessment of need, the revelations from Children's Health Ireland (CHI) about unacceptable standards of surgery adds a further burden to the worries and stresses of families of disabled children. Furthermore, it has taken up to 10 months for families to be informed.
It is now time for accountability and transparency on how the huge variation in clinical practices have continued for so long. Families need to be reassured about future clinical oversight and governance.
It is unacceptable and very unfair that intellectually disabled children are so disenfranchised in terms of all forms of State services, and any outcomes of the CHI inquiries and reports must acknowledge this and make special provision for vulnerable children. – Yours, etc,
PROF SEAMUS COWMAN,
Inspire,
Trustee and board member,
Castleknock,
Dublin.
Exceptional service
Sir, – I unfortunately had to visit a major Dublin hospital very recently through the emergency department.
From the first person I met and throughout my stay and treatment the care I received can only be said to have been exceptional.
Our health service often gets rough press and undoubtedly there are issues mainly in management and governance. But at floor level, on the ward you could not be in a better place.
About 90 per cent of the staff who cared for me were not originally from Ireland but have made it their home. I believe we need them even more than they need us.
Literally our lives depend on them. Keep it in mind when you meet them on the street.
I am sure many have had the same experience as I have had.
On my way home now but thank you St Vincent's and all your wonderful staff. – Yours, etc,
PAUL MULLIGAN,
Dublin 6.
Minding your manners
Sir, – I am over 66 years of age and entitled to free travel which I regularly avail of and enjoy.
Last year I boarded the busy Maynooth train which had no seats available. I didn't mind and was happy to stand with my earphones in, listening to music. I vaguely noted the young man beside me raising his voice. He did so a second time and I heard him say: 'Is nobody going to give the old lady a seat?'
I looked around and was horrified to realise that he was referring to me. He repeated his plea a third time and a passenger got up and gave me the seat. My young man looked at me and said: 'There you are love. Your feet must be killing you.'
I was mildly amused and regaled my friends with the story for weeks afterwards.
Last week I returned from a hillwalking holiday in England and boarded the packed Maynooth train again.
I was overdressed for the hot Irish afternoon, wearing my hiking boots, hiking coat and long trousers.
Once again there was no seat available. My wheelie case and small backpack were a nuisance at every stop and I was hot and bothered.
To add insult to injury a young woman beat me to a seat which became vacant along the route.
I reflected on my experience a year ago and wondered where my gallant hero was when I needed him. – Yours, etc,
MARY FOLEY,
Leixlip,
Co Kildare.
Sir, – As I approach my 68th birthday this August, I find myself reflecting on an incident that occurred this week aboard the Luas.
I took the last available seat, only to be loudly berated by a young woman in her early 20s for, in her words, 'not being a gentleman'.
Over the years, like many others, I've tried to be considerate – offering my seat when someone clearly needed it more.
But now, with age making its presence felt in my knees, back and balance, I wonder at what age is a man allowed to sit down without being judged?
Courtesy should go both ways. Perhaps we should teach our young people that respect isn't just something to be demanded – it's also something to be given, especially to those who've earned it over a lifetime. – Yours, etc,
DONAL McKENNA,
Naas,
Co Kildare.
Trump and Musk
Sir, – As a self-professed empathetic, honourable, peace-loving, self-aware but mostly super smart person, Donald Trump erred bigly when he gave Elon Musk the house key.
But if they kiss and make up, which in their mutual interest they surely must, I suggest they fulfil their stated desire to go to Mars.
For all our sakes let it be a one-way ticket. – Yours, etc,
EITHNE MacFADDEN,
Carrigart,
Co Donegal.
Elvis is back in the building
Sir, – My tenacity has finally paid off and my 18-inch statue of Elvis at 13, previously owned by Priscilla Presley, is now on show in the U2 room of the Little Museum of Dublin.
The original life-sized bronze statue of Elvis at 13 is located quite close to Elvis's birthplace in Tupelo, Mississippi, at my suggestion in a letter to the mayor, Larry Otis.
A great coup for Ireland.
The story appeared in The Irish Times and the Daily Journal of Tupelo etc, way back in 2002.
So forgive me Bono.
Elvis is back in the building. – Yours, etc,
MAURICE COLGAN,
Swords,
Co Dublin.
Planning regulations
Sir , – I refer to Margaret Farrell's letter of June 7th, complaining bitterly about the proposed relaxation of some planning regulations.
I suggest if she was a 30 year old still living in her childhood bedroom, she might have a different view. – Yours, etc,
JOHN LOMBARD,
Goatstown,
Dublin 14.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
One year later, work on epilepsy medication inquiry is yet to begin
Work has yet to begin on an inquiry into the prescribing of epilepsy medicine, a year after a chairperson for the probe was appointed — on a 12-month contract. Affected families want to know what has caused the delay to the inquiry beginning its work in full. The role of chairperson was advertised early last year, and when the inquiry was publicly launched and the chairwoman confirmed in June 2024, it was understood that a certain amount of time was needed to lay the groundwork. At the time, then health minister Stephen Donnelly said work would begin 'within weeks'. This led families to understand the chairwoman, barrister Brid O'Flaherty, would be supported to begin work quickly. Recruitment notices advised a chairperson would 'sign a contract for services for a period of 12 months with the possibility of extending by a further six months'. Asked whether this contract is being extended now, a department spokeswoman said they cannot comment on individual contracts, adding: However, once the inquiry formally commences, a time commitment of between 12 and 18 months is envisaged for the chair to conduct an independent, fair, and rigorous process. Ms O' Flaherty has met patient group the Organisation for Anticonvulsant Syndromes (OACS) Ireland for initial discussions. However they do not know when her wider work with individual families can start. Solicitor for the group, Ciara McPhillips, partner at Michael Boylan LLP, said the department's stance raises more questions than it answers. 'The questions now point back to the department, did they appoint the chair prematurely before they had their groundworks done, or has some unforeseen problem arisen,' she said. The department previously cited work on data regulations as one reason for the delays. However Ms McPhillips said OACS Ireland were told in October 2023 this work had already started. The families have requested a meeting with minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill but are yet to hear when this might happen. They have questions. This is why we need to meet with the minister to understand and get answers as to what is the hold-up. Ms O'Flaherty was unavailable for interview, a spokeswoman said. She added: "she has conveyed that the public-facing elements of the inquiry will commence shortly after the Department has finalised the regulations.' No date was given for when this might be. They confirmed she has been working, saying she did 'significant work' on practical arrangements for when the inquiry starts. The HSE now advises girls and women not to get pregnant while taking this medication, brandname Epilim containing Valproate, and to discuss pregnancy plans with their doctors. Read More Parents finding it harder to look away from scandals at CHI — if they ever could


Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Autistic man (23) ‘trapped' in psychiatric unit for five years as HSE fails to secure accommodation
A 23-year-old autistic man has been in a psychiatric unit for the last five years as the Health Service Executive (HSE) has been unable to source an appropriate care facility for him, his mother has claimed. Robert Brady, from Walkinstown, Dublin 12, has been 'trapped in a psychiatric unit for years with no end in sight', Anne Dillon said. His family is not permitted to visit him at the moment and are only allowed to receive phone calls from him inside the facility, Ms Dillon said, leaving them feeling 'crushed, devastated and broken'. Mr Brady was diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder in 2019 while under the care of the Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services at the Linn Dara inpatient facility in Ballyfermot, Dublin 10. READ MORE Ms Dillon, said he 'was abruptly removed' from this facility 'and taken on the morning of his [18th] birthday to Tallaght [University Hospital] psychiatric unit', where he has lived ever since. This is 'an environment that is not suitable for his needs', as he is non-violent and not suffering from serious mental illness, Ms Dillon said. She added that this has led to a stark deterioration in his mental and physical wellbeing. [ 'This is a very posh prison': Living in a nursing home since the age of 46 Opens in new window ] 'Nobody in his care disputes the fact that this is not a suitable environment,' she said, citing high sensory overload in a clinical setting and being 'full of people who are in the most disturbed phase of their illness'. Ms Dillon has petitioned the HSE for the past five years to secure a place in an appropriate care facility for her son. The HSE told The Irish Times that although it 'cannot comment on individual cases, we can confirm that the appropriate services are engaging directly with this service user and their family'. 'Multidisciplinary care planning for all patients is holistic and includes discharge planning', it said. In email correspondence seen by The Irish Times, Minister of State with responsibility for Mental Health Mary Butler's office wrote to Ms Dillon in April 2025 that 'the HSE indicate that [ ...] identifying an appropriate placement for him has been challenging'. Ms Butler told The Irish Times 'my priority is that anyone experiencing mental health difficulties has timely access to, and the appropriate level of care they require from our mental health services'. 'The Government is committed to ensuring that all those accessing all aspects of our health services are receiving treatment and care appropriately,' she said. [ Opinion: Children experiencing mental illness can't afford to wait for reform to happen by magic Opens in new window ] Ms Butler said she cannot comment on individual cases, but 'the HSE works in close partnership with families to identify solutions to ensure care and treatment is achieved for all patients'. Sinn Féin Senator Chris Andrews raised the case in Seanad Éireann on Tuesday, saying Mr Brady 'was completely failed by our mental health and disability services' and a 'horrendous catalogue of failures' from the State. 'His complex condition is now used to justify claims that no suitable placement exists,' he said. This is 'a situation directly caused by the State's inaction and unwillingness to provide early intervention care'. Fine Gael Seanad leader Seán Kyne, replying for the Government, said Mr Brady's was a 'specific case' that Mr Andrews should raise under a different Seanad format.


Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Ireland saw dramatic improvement in mortality in 20-year period, data shows
Ireland experienced a dramatic improvement in mortality across the 20-year period from 1985 to 2005, according to data from the Central Statistics Office (CSO). Heart attacks were the main cause of death in nearly two out of every 10 deaths for men and women in Ireland in 1985, and that rate reduced to just one out of every 10 deaths in 2005. The crude death rate per 100,000 of population stood at a 'very high level' at 938.2 in 1985 and had reduced by 4.5 per cent to 895.8 in 1995, the CSO figures show. The following 10-year period witnessed a further 23.7 per cent reduction in the rate, where it stood at 683.6 deaths per 100,000 of population in 2005. READ MORE From 1985 to 2005, there was a 60 per cent decrease in the mortality rate of children aged between five and nine years, while the mortality rate of those aged 15 to 19 years increased by 12.7 per cent. Over the 20-year period, crude mortality rates in infants and children up to nine years of age saw the largest decreases, while rates in those aged 15-24 years increased. Heart attacks were the number one cause of death for both males and females in 1985. Nearly one out of every four deaths for males that year was due to a heart attack, while by 2005, this had decreased to one out of every 10 deaths for males. For females, deaths due to heart attacks accounted for just under two out of every 10 deaths in 1985 and by 2005, this had fallen to one out of every 10 deaths. While deaths due to heart attacks reduced over the 20-year period, other forms of chronic ischaemic heart disease, which can include deaths due to coronary atherosclerosis and aneurysms, saw an increase in proportion of all deaths.