Indian state bans travel agents from advertising overseas roles
Photo:
Supplied
An immigration advisory body hopes a local government order in India - banning travel agents from offering help with overseas employment - will help curb immigration fraud in New Zealand.
The New Zealand Forum for Immigration Professionals welcomed the recent state government's advisory in the Indian state of Punjab, directing local authorities to monitor travel agents in the region and ensure they don't offer or advertise any recruitment-related services.
Local authorities in Punjab were also directed to obtain self-declarations from travel agents each month that state they were not engaged in any recruitment services.
Enforcement drives against illegal travel agents and awareness campaign on legal migration would also be carried out, the directive said.
The advisory follows a missive sent by the Indian government to Punjab's state government that highlighted repeated violations of India's Emigration Act (which bans travel agents from advertising assistance in securing jobs overseas) by travel agents in the state.
The issue assumes significance after several cases of alleged exploitation, in which workers were brought to New Zealand through the accredited employer work visa scheme, could be
traced to Punjab
.
"This decisive move is a positive step in combating illegal migration and immigration fraud," said Jagjeet Singh Sidhu, president of New Zealand Forum for Immigration Professionals.
"We acknowledge that many individuals invest their hard-earned money in dubious agents in India with the hope of a better life abroad, only to be misled and disappointed," he said.
"Such practices undermine the integrity of New Zealand's immigration system. ... [It] is a crucial step toward safeguarding the interests of genuine applicants."
Narinder Singla, chairman of the Indian Association of New Zealand Manukau's crime group
Photo:
Supplied
Narinder Singla, chairman of the Indian Association of New Zealand Manukau's crime group, hoped the move would be a deterrent for travel agents who sent people from India with dubious or fake job offers.
"We believe it will have some sort of impact," Singla said. "[Travel agents] who were indulging in such things will at least be scared now."
Arunjeev Singh, an immigration lawyer based in the South Auckland suburb of Papatoetoe, was sceptical the directive would make a difference.
"I don't think it will make any difference unless the New Zealand government stops education agents [in India] from doing student visas," Singh said.
Sidhu agreed.
"The current laxity within the New Zealand Immigration Act 2009 permits offshore agents to act on behalf of applicants for student visas only," he said. "This situation often leads to confusion among applicants, who, due to a lack of knowledge, are unaware whether their representatives are authorized by the New Zealand government.
"We believe that legislative reforms are necessary to prohibit offshore agents from lodging student visa applications, ensuring that only authorized, licensed immigration advisers manage these processes."
Sidhu advised migrants who wished to relocate to New Zealand to exercise due diligence.
"We encourage prospective migrants to consult New Zealand lawyers or licensed professionals listed on www.iaa.govt.nz, where they can find qualified immigration advisers to assist them in lodging their applications securely and legitimately," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
16 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Retail NZ says members will be 'devastated' by theft incidents not being investigated
Retail New Zealand chief executive Carolyn Young. Photo: Supplied Retail New Zealand says its members will be devastated that while police were directed not to investigate reports of shoplifting below $500, retailers reported almost 5500 incidents of shoplifting that fell into that category. As a result, they were never investigated. The shoplifting complaints were made between March and May this year while the police directive was in place not to investigate reports of shoplifting valued at below $500. Other crimes police were directed not to investigate included general thefts of below $200, petrol drive offs, $150, online fraud and scams of under $1000 and other fraud, $500. But after RNZ reported the directive it was walked back by Police Commissioner Richard Chambers who launched a review to establish how many reports of retail crime were filed away under the controversial directive. That figure has been revealed by RNZ as 5454. Retail New Zealand chief executive Carolyn Young said shop owners were disappointed at the number. "I'm sure they're absolutely devastated that the impact that's happened in their store has not had any follow up and we know from our research that our members have told us that 40 percent of retail crime is not reported and one of the reasons they give is 'cos they think nothing will happen. "So if there was 5400-odd incidents in that two month period, add another 40 percent on and you're probably at the right level of what was occurring. "It just reiterates how big a crime issue is when you say that's the level below $500." She said it was a systemic problem with a devastating impact on the retail system. Young said while it was disappointing when retail crime was not followed up, Retail NZ understood it came down to resourcing. "Whilst we are always really disappointed that the police are unable to follow up on every incident that occurs, we know that one of the principle problems that we've got is resourcing and we just need more police." Young said shoplifting was often repeated by the same offenders and when police didn't investigate the cumulative harm was greater. "One of the things that we know is there is a lot of small level offending. You think about drive-offs at the petrol station - invariably that's under $500 but someone offends five or six times, it's a significant amount of money." "And when you have people that are offending in a supermarket or an apparel store three or four times a week the cumulative factor of that adds up and so the dollar value is not the material piece. "It's actually what harm is that individual doing and how often are they offending and how can we stop that individual person." She said the Police Commissioner had acted swiftly and made a commitment to combating retail crime and Retail NZ was working closely with the police on it. Retail Crime Ministerial Advisory Group chairperson Sunny Kaushal called the number of uninvestigated shoplifting complaints "a shocking figure". "That's why it was so important that Commissioner Chambers responded so quickly to our call for it to be reversed at the earliest opportunity." He said the directive was clearly having an impact on investigations. "Shoplifting is costing New Zealand $1.4 billion a year, and the bill is being paid by every hard working Kiwi through increased prices at the till. "Shoplifting of any value is not okay. Offenders need to know that police will investigate any and all cases reported to them." He also said the Police Commissioner planned to make retail crime a key priority for police. "Retailers are now seeing the benefit of this change in priority, especially in areas that now have a dedicated retail crime team. "I encourage police to scale these efforts so that every area across the country can benefit from the great work of those teams." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
16 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Concerns not enough candidates for local elections as nominations draw close
File photo. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Regional and Unitary Councils Aotearoa is concerned there aren't enough candidates putting their names forward for the 2025 local elections. With nominations closing tomorrow, several councils across the country do not have enough candidates to fill the positions that need to be filled in certain electorates, or have vacancies that will go uncontested. As of Wednesday afternoon across the country's 16 regional and unitary councils, 47 regional council seats either wouldn't have an election, or would trigger a by-election because of the lack of candidates. Te Uru Kahika was calling for more New Zealanders to put their names forward for the 2025 local elections. New Zealand's longest serving regional council chair and current chair of Bay of Plenty Regional Council Doug Leeder was encouraging people who were considering standing to go for it. "This is about democracy being exercised by people in the community," he said. Regional and unitary councils make critical decisions that affect the environment, public transport, water quality, land use, flood protection, and climate resilience. "If you want a say in how your region prepares for climate change, manages rivers and lakes, or invests in public transport, this is your opportunity to step up," he said. "Councillors don't need to be experts, but they do need to be people who can listen, think about the issues, and want to make their communities and environment a great place to be. Leeder said if there was not enough candidates to fill a council's vacancies then a by-election was called. Leeder could not recall that happening in his 24 years in local government. Leeder himself will not be standing for re-election. Across the 16 regional and unitary councils Horizons Tonga Māori Regional Constituency and the Tasman District Council's Te Tai o Aorere Māori Ward have no candidates. While all 16 councils have constituencies or wards with either less nominations than vacancies or uncontested vacancies. A number of district councils also appear to be a few candidates short. Election management services company is tracking candidates for a number of councils. As of Wednesday afternoon data published on its website showed no nominations had been received for the Mayoralty vacancy at the Rotorua Lakes Council, while Central Hawke's Bay District Council, Chatham Islands Council, Hurunui District Council, Manawatū District Council and Selwyn District Council all had just one nomination. Several council at large or ward vacancies, as well as community boards also had less candidates than vacancies or were uncontested. Among them is Carterton District Council which had four nominations for eight council seats and Chatham Islands Council which had three nominations for eight council seats. In 2022 Local Government New Zealand (LGNZ) also noted "concerningly low" nominations in some parts of the country. On Tuesday, LGNZ chief executive Susan Freeman-Greene said electoral officers were reporting that overall candidate nomination numbers were generally on par with the same time last election. "[We] know from past elections that many candidates choose to wait until the final week to submit their nominations," she said. "We strongly encourage candidates not to leave things to the last day, to allow time for information to be checked and any issues resolved." Nominations close at noon on Friday, 1 August. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
16 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Councillors to vote on new agreement of Lake Taupō and the Upper Waikato River with local iwi
Lake Taupō. Photo: RNZ / Rebekah Parsons-King Councillors in Taupō will vote on a new joint management agreement of Lake Taupō and the Upper Waikato River with local iwi Ngāti Tūwharetoa today. The legally required agreement has attracted controversy with one councillor calling in lobby group Hobson's Pledge to raise his concerns to a wider audience. The purpose of the draft Joint Management Agreement (JMA) is to protect the water of Lake Taupō (Taupō Moana) and the Upper Waikato River. It would see the council and Tūwharetoa Māori Trust Board collaborate on work such as monitoring and enforcement, district plan reviews, resource consent application assessments, and enabling customary activities. Tūwharetoa Māori Trust Board chair John Bishara said it's a very important day for both the board and council and he is looking forward to a positive result. "What [the JMA] does is reaffirms our relationship and partnership with our wai and inclusion of the Taupō District Council." The JMA is a legal requirement under the Ngāti Tūwharetoa, Raukawa, and Te Arawa River Iwi Waikato River Act 2010 (also known as the Upper Waikato River Act 2010), which mandates agreements between local authorities and Waikato River iwi trusts. The council already maintains agreements with Te Arawa River Iwi Trust (signed in 2017) and Raukawa Settlement Trust (signed in 2013). The council said "this agreement will enable the shared protection and restoration of these waterways for future generations." "While the council could manage these responsibilities independently, protecting and restoring the environment is a shared responsibility. Ngāti Tūwharetoa, as mana whenua and legal owners of the beds of Lake Taupō, the Upper Waikato River, and many of the tributaries, have both the cultural and legal right to be involved." But in a written statement Taupō District Councillor Duncan Campbell said he was concerned by the agreements financial implications, "treaty-framed governance language" and a lack of public consultation. "The agreement should be subject to public consultation and independent legal review - not because I oppose partnership, but because I support good governance." However Bishara said the Trust Board and council had been working together on the agreement for many years. "There's always room for consultation, however I don't think that consultation is going to improve the document that we already have worked with the council. Look I see the council as being the governors like we are, they represent their people." The Trust Board is the owner of the bed of Lake Taupō, including the Waikato River to Huka Falls and tributaries flowing into the lake, on behalf of ngā hapū o Tūwharetoa. "We believe that the ownership of the lake and the water column above it is Ngāti Tūwharetoa's, so we have huge rights and interests," Bishara said. Bishara said there has been opposition to bringing Lake Taupō into the agreement as the Upper Waikato River Act only covers the Waikato River, but he said it makes more sense to treat it as one connected system. "It's indivisible... to distinguish them separately wouldn't be appropriate. I believe that the council do agree with that but it is an extension of the Waikato River Settlement." Bishara said it has been a long journey and there a still many things to work out with the council, but he believes the board will get approval for the Joint Management Agreement. Campbell said his concerns with the JMA weren't with the Treaty itself, but with the ambiguity and breadth of language used throughout the agreement, particularly clauses that speak to 'shared responsibilities', 'partnership' and decision-making influence without precise boundaries. "When unelected parties are embedded in planning, consenting, enforcement, and land management processes, the line between co-management and co-governance blurs." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
