Fishing chiefs furious over Sir David Attenborough 'propaganda'
The Scottish Fishermen's Federation (SFF) denounced it as a work of 'anti-fishing propaganda'.
And it accused its makers of using 'the full panoply of Hollywood tear-jerk techniques'.
The movie is called Ocean, with David Attenbourough.
It's co-produced by two Bristol-based companies, Silverback Films and Open Planet Studios.
Silverback's impressive roster also includes BBC shows Wild Isles, The Hunt and The Mating Game. It's also the firm behind Netflix wildlife successes including Our Planet, Our Planet II and A Life on Our Planet.
Ocean was released as a 'global cinema event' on May 8, Sir David's 99th birthday.
The film is now available on National Geographic, Disney+ and Hulu streaming channels.
But its narrative on 'destructive' fishing techniques has triggered fury at the SFF.
A statement from the Granite City-based federation said: 'Once again the fishing industry is in the position of defending its legitimate business activity in the face of a fresh onslaught from environmental non-governmental organisations (NGOs) designed to influence delegates to the UN Ocean Conference in Nice, France from June 9-13.
'The spearhead this time is a film, Ocean, made by Silverback and narrated by Sir David Attenborough.
'Despite being voiced by someone who is regarded as a national treasure, and whose former association with the BBC means he is almost universally perceived as being impartial and unbiased, the film is a work of anti-fishing propaganda that wholly blames the industry for the poor state of the planet's oceans.
'Astonishingly, it singles out fishing from every other form of human impact on our seas.
'It also omits to mention the necessity of protein-rich, healthy food to feed the planet, and fishing's relatively low impact on greenhouse gas emissions, compared with other modes of food production.'
SFF added: 'Deploying the full panoply of Hollywood tear-jerk techniques, from beautiful imagery to, by turns, uplifting and depressing music, and additional narration by individuals who give an unchallenged, one-sided perspective on a variety of case studies from around the world, it has been carefully crafted to damage the industry.'
The federation continued: 'Scottish fishermen have been committed to improving sustainability and sensible conservation measures for decades.
'It is due to the efforts of these fishermen that 70% of stocks in the North Sea and West of Scotland are fished sustainably. Yes, there is still more to do, but fishermen have made huge changes over the last 30 years to ensure we have stocks that are sustainable for the future.'
SFF went on: 'Ours is a very heavily regulated industry, and our focus in working with governments is to find the right balance between conservation and sustainable harvesting.
'By providing jobs and income, a sustainable industry assures the future of many coastal and island communities that depend on seafood for their viability.
'No form of food production anywhere on the planet is without impact, as a glance at our farmed and grazed landscapes attests only too well.
'The unbalanced and unfair light shone on fishing in Ocean does a huge disservice to the skilled, knowledgeable and responsible men and women who make up our industry and, sadly, is a wasted opportunity to inform the public.'
Meanwhile, SFF chief executive Elspeth Macdonald has warned the Scottish Government not to follow the path of Westminster proposing a ban on trawling in English Marine Protected Areas (MPAs).
Banning fishing in such an arbitrary and ignorant fashion will deprive hard-working people of their jobs.' Elspeth Macdonald, CEO, Scottish Fishermen's Federation
Ms Macdonald said: 'It is extremely disappointing the UK Government seems to have caved to the emotional, unevidenced siren calls of the environmental NGOs and Sir David Attenborough, and announced a ban on trawling in English MPAs.
'We are sure the Scottish Government will take a much more intelligent, grown-up and responsible approach to the rules and regulations around fishing in Scotland's MPAs.'
She added: 'Banning fishing in such an arbitrary and ignorant fashion will deprive hard-working people of their jobs and cost very often marginal communities much-needed income.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
23 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Two Doors Down Christmas spoiler leaked as exciting pics reveal major plot twist
It comes after the show was 'axed' following the death of co-creator Simon Carlyle LABOUR OF LOVE Two Doors Down Christmas spoiler leaked as exciting pics reveal major plot twist Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) TWO Doors Down is set to deliver a new neighbour this Christmas — as telly couple Alan and Michelle become parents. The 'secret' plotline leaked after Joy McAvoy, 43, was seen on set with screen partner Graeme 'Grado' Stevely, 37 — and a baby bump. Sign up for the Entertainment newsletter Sign up 7 Joy McAvoy and on-screen partner Graeme 'Grado' Stevely are set to become parents Credit: Steve Welsh 7 Arabella Weir and Alex Norton return as put-upon Beth and Eric Credit: Steve Welsh 7 The Scots stars play telly favourites Alan and Michelle in the sitcom Credit: BBC 7 Elaine C. Smith in costume as foul-mouthed neighbour Christine Credit: Steve Welsh We told how the BBC sitcom's cast reunited in Hamilton last week for the first time in two years to film scenes for their festive special. And our Two Doors Down photos show Joy sporting a large prop bulge underneath her maroon top as she meets up again with Grado, who is wearing a tracksuit and trainers. A telly insider said: 'Bosses were desperate to keep Michelle and Alan's baby joy under wraps but the cat's out of the bag now. 'The last series had left viewers on the edge of their seats after Alan popped the question in Vegas.' It was feared we'd seen the last of the Latimer Crescent crew when the show's co-creator Simon Carlyle died in August 2023, aged 48. But we exclusively revealed in March that fellow writer Gregor Sharp, 54, had penned a one-off episode. The BBC was asked for comment. Elsewhere on location, Elaine C. Smith - who plays foul-mouthed Christine - arrived in sandals, black trousers, white jumper and dark shades. Arabella Weir and Alex Norton were all smiles as they bring back put-upon neighbours Beth and Eric. Grado was seen beaming as he greeted locals and posed for photos with some fans of the award-winning series. Meanwhile, Doon Mackichan reprises her role as permanently sozzled neighbour Cathy. Gregor Sharp, who has written the new Christmas special, said: 'It's really exciting to be revisiting Latimer Crescent with all the regular cast for this new episode. "Christmas is a time for getting together with friends and family and then becoming low-level irritated by them, so it feels like they're the perfect group to celebrate the season with.' BBC director of comedy, Jon Petrie, added: 'There's something comforting about having the neighbours round for Christmas, even if they bring minor chaos." 7 Much-loved Two Doors Down creator Simon Carlyle tragically passed away 7 A Two Doors Down Christmas spoiler has been leaked revealing a major plot twist Credit: BBC
Powys County Times
28 minutes ago
- Powys County Times
BBC Radio Scotland's Bryan Burnett to return to airwaves after cancer treatment
BBC Radio Scotland presenter Bryan Burnett will return to the airwaves on Thursday after undergoing cancer treatment. The broadcaster announced in June he would step back from his programme Get It On to receive care for appendix cancer. Fellow presenter Grant Stott, who stepped in during his absence, announced his return to listeners on Tuesday night. He said: 'In what must have been a terrible time for Bryan and his family and close friends, I'm just delighted I was able to help by looking after something that is very precious to Bryan; Get It On and his listeners. 'Getting to do the show over this time has shown me just how close the audience is to Bryan and vice versa. 'I know they will be delighted to get their radio teatime pal back.' Burnett said his treatment had been successful and thanked those who had wished him well throughout his recovery. Commenting on his return, he said: 'I am delighted to be returning to work following successful treatment for appendix cancer. 'Over the past few months I have been focused on my recovery and have been supported by an incredible medical team, my family and friends, and the overwhelming kindness of so many BBC Radio Scotland listeners who have reached out with encouragement and well-wishes. 'Their messages, cards and kindness have meant so much. 'My team at the BBC have also been a huge support and I want to thank Grant Stott, who has been sitting in for me and done such a great job looking after the show. 'My return to work will be gradual to ensure I maintain my health and energy. Cancer has given me a renewed perspective on what matters most and I am excited about the road ahead and grateful for the opportunity to return to doing what I'm passionate about.' Hayley Valentine, director BBC Scotland, said: 'Like the Get it On listeners, everyone at BBC Scotland is delighted to be welcoming Bryan back to the studio following what has been a tough couple of months for him. We look forward to seeing and hearing him back where he belongs.' Stott will share Get it On presenting duties with Bryan during his phased return.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
In Flight star Stuart Martin's life off screen with Rivals actress wife
Stuart Martin is back on our screens tonight in the gritty drama In Flight but away from the world of TV, he has a happy family with an actress who starred in Rivals last year Stuart Martin is back on our screens tonight in the gritty drama In Flight. The actor, 39, stars as menacing gang leader Cormac in the new Channel 4 drama, who coerces flight attendant Jo Conran (Katherine Kelly) into using her job to repeatedly struggle drugs, in order to save the life of her son, who is currently behind bars for a murder he claims he did not commit. The TV star has actually been something of a mainstay on screens for well over a decade, having initially played guest roles in shows such as Taggart in 2009 and a handful of episodes of the now-defunct Scottish soap River City. In 2014, he starred as Lannister Soldier in an episode of the HBO series Game of Thrones and then landed the more regular role of PC Tony Forbes in Babylon. From 2017 until 2019, he appeared in all 24 episodes of Jamestown as Silas Sharrow, and then landed what is possibly his most famous role as Detective Inspector William Wellington on Miss Scarlett and the Duke. He played this part from 2020 until 2024, at which point the series continued on without him. On film, he has starred in both instalments of the space opera franchise Rebel Moon alongside the likes of Djimon Hounsou and Sofia Boutella. But away from his life on screen, Stuart is married to actress Lisa McGrillis. They celebrated their 10th wedding anniversary together, and are parents to Josh, eight, as well as four-year-old Cleo. Lisa has also starred in a number of television favourites, having first risen to prominence with her role as Vicki Pearson on the sitcom Hebburn alongside Chris Ramsey. Following that, she achieved further acclaim for her role as Sergeant Rachel Coles on Inspector George Gently, and was seen on the BBC drama series from 2014 until 2017. Since 2022, she has held the main role of Courtney on Avoidance, but last year she starred as Valerie Jones on the smash-hit Disney+ comedy drama that was based on the book by Jilly Cooper and also featured the likes of Emily Atack, Danny Dyer and David Tennant. Lisa met her husband at the National Theatre's bar more than a decade ago, but admitted that she became a 'nervous wreck' when their first child came along. She told The Sunday Post: "I was so busy for the first seven or eight months of my son's life and by the end I was a nervous wreck, so jittery and tired. The two things don't align – family life and filming. I look in the mirror and I've gone from looking like a spring chicken five years ago to a shrivelled old shoe." The couple often wow followers with their social media presence as they attend glamorous showbiz events together. In 2023, when Stuart starred in Rebel Moon, Lisa took to Instagram to write: "What a feast for your eyes, very proud of my action hero husband," and emblazoned her gushing post with several heart emojis. More recently, the couple attended the Mediterrane Film Festival together, and shared a loved-up picture from the red carpet. Lisa captioned that post: "Thank you for the most beautiful evening celebrating film and the rich culture of Malta, what a stunning evening that was." And the post did not go unnoticed by their celebrity friends, as her Rivals co-star Emily Atack wrote: "I can't quite handle how ft you both are," whilst Emmerdale actress Chelsea Halfpenny simply wrote: "Hotties," and left behind a heart emoji to boot. During the COVID-19 lockdowns, Stuart admitted that a lot of work 'suddenly went off the table' as the pandemic took hold but even though he thought it was a 'worrying and upsetting time for everyone' in his industry, but found comfort in being able to spend time with his family. He told the Scotsman at the time: "Usually you're going 'right, up in the morning, got to do this!, and you're distracted. Now, you're really spending that time with each other. And the community stuff that's coming out of it is lovely. There could definitely be a re-set for us all after this." At the same time, he admitted: "I'd have to say my wife and lad. But if I can have another? Actually no, I'm not sure I could live locked in a house for two months with anyone else. Or they could live with me. I'll stick with my lockdowns. I wouldn't inflict that on anyone, alive or dead." In Flight comprises six hour-long episodes, with the first set to air on Channel 4 on Tuesday, 12 August at 9pm. For viewers so taken in by the series, all episodes are available to view on the online streaming service on Tuesday or if episodes will be broadcast weekly on the channel. Alongside Katherine, who is perhaps best known for her portrayal of diamond-in-the-rough Becky Granger on Coronation Street but has starred in a string of dramas since them, Stuart also features alongside Ashley Thomas, also known by his stage name Bashy. He plays will play customs officer Dom Delaney, Jo's ex, in the thrilling drama. Some might recognise Ashley as Jermaine Newton from Top Boy. His acting credits include appearances in Black Mirror, Great Expectations, and The Serpent Queen. Completing the In Flight ensemble are Bronagh Waugh playing Melanie, Harry Cadby as Sonny, Corinna Brown portraying Kayla, and Ambreen Razia in the role of Zara.
