Meta torrented 82TB of pirated books for AI training
Listen to article
Meta, the parent company of Facebook, is embroiled in a class action lawsuit accusing the tech giant of copyright infringement and unfair competition related to the use of pirated content in training its artificial intelligence models, including LLaMA.
Court records, obtained by vx-underground and revealed in an X (formerly Twitter) post, show that Meta allegedly downloaded 81.7TB of pirated data from shadow libraries such as Anna's Archive, Z-Library, and LibGen.
Photo: @vxunderground on X
The evidence, drawn from internal communications, sheds light on concerns within Meta about the use of such materials.
In October 2022, one senior AI researcher expressed discomfort, saying, 'I don't think we should use pirated material. I really need to draw a line here.
' Another researcher echoed similar concerns, stating, 'Using pirated material should be beyond our ethical threshold,' and compared platforms like SciHub, ResearchGate, and LibGen to piracy sites such as PirateBay for distributing copyright-protected content without permission.
In January 2023, Mark Zuckerberg reportedly attended a meeting in which he pushed to 'move this stuff forward' and find a way to unblock the use of the pirated materials.
By April 2023, a Meta employee raised concerns over the company's use of corporate IP addresses to load pirate content, noting that 'torrenting from a corporate laptop doesn't feel right,' followed by a laughing emoji.
The court documents suggest that Meta took deliberate actions to conceal its involvement, ensuring its infrastructure wasn't directly linked to the pirated downloads or seeding activity.
This case is part of a larger pattern of legal battles in the AI sector.
In 2023, OpenAI was sued by novelists for using their books to train its language models, and The New York Times followed suit in December. Similarly, Nvidia faced legal action from writers after it used over 196,000 books to train its NeMo model.
A former Nvidia employee also revealed that the company scraped more than 426,000 hours of video daily for AI training purposes.
OpenAI is also investigating allegations that DeepSeek may have illegally sourced data from ChatGPT.
The legal proceedings against Meta are ongoing, and it remains to be seen whether the company will be found liable for copyright infringement.
Given Meta's financial resources, it is expected that the company will appeal any unfavorable ruling, which could delay a final decision for months, if not years.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
11 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PM's aide on crypto Bilal Bin Saqib meets Elon Musk's father
Minister of State for Crypto, Blockchain and CEO of the Pakistan Crypto Council Bilal Bin Saqib Listen to article Special Assistant to Prime Minister (SAPM) on Crypto and Blockchain Bilal Bin Saqib, held a notable meeting in New York with Errol Musk, father of billionaire entrepreneur Elon Musk. The minister shared a photograph of the meeting on social platform X, in which Errol Musk is seen greeting him warmly. The image quickly gained attention, particularly given the growing relevance of blockchain discussions in global finance. Met Elon Musk's dad. Requested that the markets finally have great momentum - let's not mess it up! The world needs Tesla and Trump in the same group chat! 🙏 Peace and Build — Bilal bin Saqib MBE (@Bilalbinsaqib) June 6, 2025 According to Saqib, Errol Musk remarked during the meeting, 'The market has finally picked up. Let's not ruin it.' The quote was seen by observers as a subtle reference to ongoing global economic volatility and the importance of responsible innovation in tech and finance. Bilal Bin Saqib added in his post that the world desires greater alignment between powerful innovators and decision-makers. 'The world wants Tesla and Trump in the same group chat for peace and progress,' he wrote, suggesting that coordinated global dialogue is vital for technological and geopolitical stability. The meeting is being viewed as a symbolic moment as Pakistan seeks to strengthen its positioning in emerging technologies, particularly in the areas of digital assets and blockchain. Read More: Pakistan is establishing 'Strategic Bitcoin Reserve A day earlier, SAPM on Crypto and Blockchain Bilal Bin Saqib met with over a dozen key US government officials and lawmakers this week in Washington to strengthen cooperation in the areas of digital assets, blockchain regulation and financial innovation. The visit also served to share Pakistan's initiatives — including the recent announcement of its Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, efforts to build a virtual asset regulatory framework, and the use of stablecoins to improve remittances and expand financial access. The exchanges highlighted the need for closer global coordination and the role emerging markets like Pakistan can play in shaping the next chapter of the digital economy. Last week, the Ministry of Finance reported that Pakistan allocated 2,000 megawatts of electricity for Bitcoin mining and AI data centres as part of a national initiative to make Pakistan a leader in digital innovation. Read more: IMF seeks explanation on Bitcoin, AI initiatives This initiative, led by the Pakistan Crypto Council (PCC), aims to use excess electricity, create high-tech jobs, and attract foreign investment. The allocation marks the first phase of a broader digital infrastructure rollout. Future developments are expected to include renewable energy-powered facilities, global partnerships with blockchain and AI firms, and the establishment of fintech and innovation hubs. On the other hand, the federal government and the central bank reiterated on Thursday that the use of cryptocurrencies was illegal and anyone dealing in these currencies was liable to be investigated by the Financial Monitoring Unit (FMU) and the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA). The statements were made by Federal Finance Secretary Imdad Ullah Bosal and State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) Executive Director Sohail Jawad during a meeting of the National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance. Read more: Crypto currencies' use is illegal, National Assembly told The development also came a day after the newly appointed Special Assistant to the Prime Minister on crypto and blockchain, Bilal Bin Saqib, made a pitch for the promotion of cryptocurrencies during his visit to the United States. Crypto is not a legal currency in Pakistan, said Bosal. He recommended that the committee invite the Pakistan Crypto Council (PCC) for further briefing. SAPM Bilal Bin Saqib is also the chief executive officer of the PCC. "The work on the crypto currencies is at a very, very preliminary stage and whenever the government decides to take it further, we would recommend to first have a comprehensive legal and regulatory framework for it," Bosal said, adding that so far, there was no such framework.
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
PHMA slams plan of distributing 2,000MW power to Bitcoin mining
LAHORE: The government's proposed plan of distributing 2,000 megawatts of excess power to Bitcoin mining and artificial intelligence (AI) data centers has faced harsh resistance from industrialists, merchants, and farmers, who contend that the power should be distributed among productive sectors to increase employment and economic growth. Sardar Usman Ghani, Central Chairman of the Pakistan Hardware Merchants Association, expressed serious reservations about the decision, saying that making available cheap electricity to a 'non-productive, speculative industry' is not justifiable when industry, agriculture, and labour-intensive industries are facing an energy crunch. It is shocking to learn that the government plans to export excess electricity to speculative activities such as Bitcoin mining rather than encouraging the productive industries' Ghani informed Business Recorder. 'The decision will not create jobs or drive actual economic growth. It will just promote a privileged group at the expense of industries, traders, farmers, and workers,' he added. The row is based on the government's alleged talks with Bitcoin miners and AI companies to provide them with electricity at subsidised tariffs to leverage surplus power generation capacity. Critics, however, say Pakistan's persistent energy shortfalls make such an allocation irresponsible, especially when industrial and agricultural sectors suffer intermittent outages. Industrialists and economists have raised questions regarding the economic logic of the decision, pointing to the specious nature of crypto currency markets. Bitcoin mining is extremely power-guzzling, and with electricity costs accounting for a large percentage of operating costs, critics say that the government stands to incur massive losses if prices of crypto currencies plummet. Additionally, the opacity in tariff fixation and the void of a proper regulatory structure for crypto currencies have further acted as repellents. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has also asked for explanations from Pakistani officials, requesting information on electricity tariffs and the legal status of crypto mining. Virtual talks between Pakistani authorities and the IMF will soon be initiated to sort these issues out. Usman Ghani said that industrial sector of Pakistan has been known to face an unreliability of power supply, and allocating 2,000 MW for Bitcoin mining might be doing it harm. Business owners contend that giving higher preference to speculative activities over manufacturing, agriculture, and small business hampers the allocation of resources, which could dampen sector growth in areas generating jobs. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
OpenAI appeals data preservation order in NYT copyright case
OpenAI is appealing an order in a copyright case brought by the New York Times that requires it to preserve ChatGPT output data indefinitely, arguing that the order conflicts with privacy commitments it has made with users. Last month, a court said OpenAI had to preserve and segregate all output log data after the Times asked for the data to be preserved. 'We will fight any demand that compromises our users' privacy; this is a core principle,' OpenAI CEO Sam Altman said in a post on X on Thursday. OpenAI to open office in Seoul amid growing demand for ChatGPT 'We think this (The Times demand) was an inappropriate request that sets a bad precedent.' U.S. District Judge Sidney Stein was asked to vacate the May data preservation order on June 3, a court filing showed. The New York Times did not immediately respond to a request for comment outside regular business hours. The newspaper sued OpenAI and Microsoft in 2023, accusing them of using millions of its articles without permission to train the large language model behind its popular chatbot. Stein said in an April court opinion that the Times had made a case that OpenAI and Microsoft were responsible for inducing users to infringe its copyrights. The opinion explained an earlier order that rejected parts of an OpenAI and Microsoft motion to dismiss, saying that the Times' 'numerous' and 'widely publicized' examples of ChatGPT producing material from its articles justified allowing the claims to continue.
