Deputy: Driver in Swan Boat Club tragedy smelled of alcohol, had trouble with balance
Testimony about the demeanor of a Monroe County woman, including what she said and how she acted, after she drove her SUV through a wall at the Swan Boat Club and into a child's birthday party was a focus of day 2 Tuesday in her trial in Monroe County Circuit Court.
Marshella Chidester, 67, is charged with two counts of second-degree murder, two counts of operating while intoxicated causing death and five counts of operating while intoxicated causing serious injury in the April 20 incident at the boat club in Newport, about 30 miles south Detroit.
Eight people, including a Frenchtown fire department captain and seven members of the Monroe County Sheriff's Office, testified Tuesday morning with prosecutors showing video of Chidester's blood draw and the test kit at the hospital as well as an interview with a deputy as she sat in the back of a patrol car about 20-30 minutes after the crash.
Deputy Steven Schmidt testified he could smell the odor of intoxicants on Chidester, that she had bloodshot, watery eyes and that she consented to sobriety tests.
He told jurors that Chidester was having problems with balance when she got out of the patrol vehicle and used his arm to hold herself up as he walked her to the rear. He said Chidester told him she had neuropathy in her hands and feet.
Zayn Phillips, 4, and his sister, Alanah, 8 were killed in the crash while attending another child's birthday party and numerous other people were injured, some severely.
Law enforcement officials said previously that Chidester had a blood alcohol level of 0.18, more than twice the legal limit to be considered legally drunk, at the time of the crash. The charges read in court Monday accused her of being impaired by a combination of alcohol and Gabapentin, an anticonvulsant and nerve pain medication.
Schmidt testified that when he conducted a horizontal gaze test, Chidester was not able to focus on his finger and she couldn't complete the test, adding "she was just staring directly at me."
He said Chidester successfully recited the alphabet, but skipped numbers in counting backward from 100 to 88. He testified that she counted from 100 to 91, then up to 100. She skipped 88 and counted into the 70s, descending from 78 to 72. He arrested her and handcuffed her in front because she said she had a wrist injury from the crash.
Schmidt testified he took Chidester to a hospital, where her blood was drawn shortly after 6:30 p.m., more than three hours after the crash.
Schmidt testified that Chidester was cooperative and that he did not perform a Breathalyzer test on her because given the serious injuries "we potentially had ... I wanted to make sure we did a blood draw."
Sheriff's Deputy Cody Carena testified that he interviewed Chidester, with video from his body-worn camera shown. He testified there was an odor of intoxicants from the back of the patrol vehicle and that she had bloodshot eyes. His body camera video showed him reading Chidester her Miranda rights and her saying: "I'm hoping no one was hurt."
Chidester told Carena that she was taking Gabapentin and other medications. She told him she went to lunch at Verna's with some friends around noon, ate chili, a fish sandwich and had a glass of wine and came home.
When asked if she remembered what happened, Chidester said in the video "No, not really." She told Carena that she has seizures, but was cleared to drive with a card in her purse, which she did not have in the back of the patrol vehicle.
She is heard on the video telling him that her last seizure was in March and she was hospitalized for it. When asked if she has a lapse of memory when she has a seizure, she replied, "Yes." When asked on a scale of zero to 10, with zero being sober and 10 being passed-out drunk, where she was right now, Chidester replied "7." She's also heard saying in the video: "I wouldn't want to drive."
Sheriff's Detective Sgt. Jeff Hooper testified that he obtained video from a search warrant at Chidester's home two days after the incident. Some video was shown in court, including showing Chidester walking down the stairs and away from home as well as her backing out her vehicle, with it curving before speeding forward down the road.
Hooper testified that authorities learned through the video that Chidester was involved in another crash April 20, crashing "into her neighbor's truck with enough force to push it back over a fence." He also told jurors that she crashed into a small pine tree in front of the truck. She then drove about 550 feet to the boat club, where she crashed into the building.
One juror was missing Tuesday, but it was not explained in court why she was not present. The jury was comprised of four men and nine women. Only 12 are needed for deliberations after testimony concludes.
The trial is expected to last five to seven days, with dozens of possible witnesses. Prosecutors have called 16 witnesses so far including people who attended the party, some who were hurt, boat club members and first responders.
Contact Christina Hall: chall@freepress.com. Follow her on Twitter: @challreporter.
Support local journalism. Subscribe to the Free Press.
Submit a letter to the editor at freep.com/letters.
This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Swan Boat Club crash: Day 2 of trial for Monroe woman
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Motion hearing in Lily Peters murder case set for Monday
CHIPPEWA FALLS — When will the trial for Carson Peters-Berger take place, and where? Will the case be moved to a different county in the state, or will a jury be brought to Chippewa County? Those are the questions that will likely be resolved Monday at a motion hearing in the murder case. The hearing is expected to last the entire day. Peters-Berger, who turned 17 in March, is accused of killing and then sexually assaulting his 10-year-old cousin, Lily Peters, in April 2022. Peters-Berger is charged in Chippewa County Court as an adult with first-degree intentional homicide and two counts of sexual assault. He was 14 at the time. The motion hearing is set to begin at 8:15 a.m. Monday before Judge Steve Gibbs and could take the entire day. Because a trial is likely to go a week or more, and because all the witnesses and experts will need to clear their schedule, it is expected Gibbs will set a trial for some point in 2026. In May, Gibbs issued an order that precludes all media from live-streaming the proceedings, in any way, of all pretrial evidentiary hearings. Media also will be barred from recording any live testimony, and 'all media may not directly quote the testimony of the witnesses,' but may 'summarize the content of the testimony.' An offender will face contempt proceedings. A flurry of motions and letters have been filed with the court this week in advance of the hearing. Defense attorney Michael Cohen filed a motion to suppress Peters-Berger's interview with police, contending that Peters-Berger's 'statements were taken in violation of his Miranda rights, and the second claim being that the statements were involuntary.' Cohen contends that Peters-Berger believed he was not free to leave the interview. However, District Attorney Wade Newell countered that 'the only issue is whether the defendant was in custody,' and Newell contends that Peters-Berger was not formally arrested at the time of his questioning. 'No arrest-like restraints were placed on the defendant,' Newell wrote in a new court filing. 'He was not handcuffed; no weapons were drawn; the defendant was not frisked. He was simply shown the way to the interview room.' Newell added: 'The defendant was told that he was not being forced to be there, and could leave whenever he needed to. In fact, to make it clear to him, the investigator point blank told him that he was not under arrest.' Newell also stressed that all comments made by Peters-Berger to police were voluntary. Gibbs granted a request to seal the transcript of the interview recording with police and a flash drive that contains video of the interview. Cohen also has requested the trial be moved out of Chippewa County, citing news reports in the Leader-Telegram, WEAU and WQOW, among others. 'A jury in this matter will obviously be compromised, if kept within the county of Chippewa, of a significant portion of people that have friends, neighbors, co-workers, family members, etc., that have strong concerns and emotions and feelings and opinions about this case,' Cohen wrote. 'It is unfathomable and unrealistic to think that jurors can just set aside all of their own emotions, anxieties, concerns about being known within the public for being on the jury if the jury were to find in contrast to what public opinion thinks the verdict should be.' Newell also filed a new letter, arguing against a motion to have the trial moved to a different county. 'While the defense is correct that the defendant need not prove actual prejudice exists, vague allegations of improper and prejudicial publicity and inconclusive evidence thereof do not make a showing that the community was so infected with passion and prejudice as to make it likely that a fair trial could not be had,' Newell wrote. 'All we have at this point is speculation as to what effects the pretrial publicity or memorial activity will have on any potential jurors. The state still contends the best way to determine if the community has been so infected with passion and prejudice, is with a well-written jury questionnaire that will determine individual juror biases or prejudices. This will ensure that an impartial jury is impaneled.' Cohen countered with a new letter, saying he will be asking for a pretrial questionnaire, but that is 'separate and distinct' from any request for a change of venue. As the Leader-Telegram reported earlier this year, only two cases — both murders — have been moved out of Chippewa County in the past 25 years. Because of all the motions that will be discussed, Cohen has requested the hearing be split into two different days. Cohen had previously argued that the case should not be in adult court because Peters-Berger is a juvenile. However, Judge Gibbs ruled on Jan. 22, 2024, that the case would remain in adult court, rejecting the defense's petition to have it moved to a juvenile proceeding. The Court of Appeals later agreed with Gibbs. Gibbs has since unsealed the name of the suspect. Peters-Berger has been held in the Northwest Regional Juvenile Detention Center in Eau Claire on a $1 million cash bond since his arrest. Lily Peters was killed on April 24, 2022, in Chippewa Falls. Her body was discovered the next morning. When interviewed by investigators, Peters-Berger told police he punched Lily in the stomach, struck her on the head three times with a heavy stick, then strangled her until she was dead. He then had sex with her body. He went home and put his dirty clothes in the laundry, but later returned to the scene, dragged her body a few feet, and covered her body with leaves.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Family of slain Gulfport teen sues Grindr
A family member of a Gulfport teen who police say was tortured, killed and dismembered by a man she met on Grindr is suing the owner of the platform, alleging that its features and lack of safeguards for minors contributed to the girl's death. The lawsuit, filed last month in federal court against Grindr LLC by a representative of Miranda Corsette's estate, alleges that the 35-year-old man who killed the teen was able to target her through Grindr's app due to its 'lax age verification and hyper-precise geolocation.' 'The trauma inflicted upon M.C. (Miranda) and the irreparable harm to her family are direct consequences of Grindr's reckless disregard for the safety of minor children who are routinely preyed upon by adult predators who use Grindr's platform and design as a trap,' the suit states. The plaintiff is identified in court filings by the initials D.W. and listed as an executor of Miranda's estate. Lorne Kaiser, a South Florida attorney for the plaintiff, declined in an interview to identify the plaintiff or the plaintiff's relationship to Miranda because he didn't have permission from his client to do so. Grindr LLC has not yet filed a response to the suit. The West Hollywood-based company's press office did not respond to two emails from the Tampa Bay Times seeking comment for this story. Launched in 2009, Grindr markets itself as the world's largest social networking apps for LGBTQ+ people, but it attracts a 'sexually diverse' userbase that include people looking to prey on minors, according to the lawsuit. The complaint includes many of the details that have come to light about the investigation that led to the arrest of Steven Gress, 35, and Michelle Brandes, 37, on first-degree murder and other charges. Authorities say that Miranda met Gress on Grindr on or about Feb. 14. Gress went to pick up the teen at or near the Gulfport home where she lived with her grandmother and brought her back to the apartment he shared with Brandes on 27th Avenue North in St. Petersburg. Gress told detectives that he was told she was 21 but later learned she was 16, according to an arrest affidavit. Gress took Miranda back to Gulfport and at some point she returned to the St. Petersburg apartment. Gress said he became convinced Miranda had stolen his ring and, for the better part of a week, 'lumped her up,' the affidavit states. It ended Feb. 23. A witness said Brandes wrapped the girl's head in plastic. Gress told her not to cover her nose, but Brandes did, the witness said. Miranda suffocated. Gress described Brandes shoving a billiard ball into Miranda's throat and covering her face in plastic wrap. He said he couldn't get to her quickly enough to poke holes in the plastic so she could breathe, according to the affidavit. After Miranda died, they drove to Brandes' mother's house in Largo, where Gress used a chainsaw to dismember Miranda's body, according to police. They put the remains in trash bags and the next day left them in a dumpster in Ruskin. Police learned the contents of the dumpster likely went to the county's incinerator. Police said there is no evidence Miranda took the ring, and Brandes later claimed to have found it in Gress's car. Gress and Brandes have pleaded not guilty to murder and kidnapping charges. Prosecutors will seek the death penalty if they are convicted. 'Long before February 14, 2025, it was clear to Grindr that it was only a matter of time before its app, as Grindr marketed it and designed it, would cause the torture, rape, and murder of a child,' the lawsuit states. The complaint says that the app requires only a self-reported birthdate to confirm users are at least 18, with no cross-checking against official documentation or third-party verification at sign-up. Miranda's death 'exposes the platform's gross negligence in relying on a farcical self-reported age verification system,' the suit states. 'This performative gesture, as absurd as a bar or strip club asking teenagers to state their age without checking ID, allowed a minor to access an adult-oriented platform with foreseeable catastrophic consequences.' The company could institute measures such as government-issued identification verification or facial age estimation system but has not done so, according to the complaint. 'The company had the means to keep minors off its platform, but it withheld them to preserve easy onboarding and avoid disrupting user growth, even when the cost is the safety of children,' the suit states. The app's geolocation services 'deliver hyper-precise, real-time geolocation tracking — accurate to within a few feet — designed to facilitate immediate sexual encounters,' the suit states. 'As such, Grindr arranges user profiles based on their distance from other users for instant and spontaneous sexual hookups creating a uniquely hazardous environment for minors.' The lawsuit, which notes that Miranda had a son, alleges nine counts including wrongful death, negligence, infliction of emotional distress, participating in a sex trafficking venture and deceptive and unfair trade practices. It seeks a jury trial and compensatory and punitive damages. The complaint also asks the court to order Grindr to implement more robust age verification measures and to cease what the lawsuit alleges are misleading claims about the app's safety. Kaiser said the lawsuit is meant to hold Grindr accountable for its role in Miranda's death just as prosecutors are holding Gress and Brandes accountable through the criminal justice process. 'Without Grindr, we believe that Miranda would have never met this Steven Gress character, and she'd still be alive,' Kaiser said. 'This was a completely foreseeable event. Grinder has been warned for years and years about children and minors getting on this platform, and it's obviously a dangerous platform for children.'
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
MCSO deputy recovering from injury while responding to ‘disturbances' at Ontario Beach Park
ROCHESTER, N.Y. (WROC) — A deputy was injured after fights broke out at Ontario Beach Park Wednesday night, according to the Monroe County Sheriff's Office. Investigators said they responded to the area to help with reports of 'disturbances' breaking out in the large crowds. Ontario Beach Park hosted the first Concerts by the Shore Wednesday evening. Deputies said they became involved in an 'active crime' — where a deputy was then injured in the hand while he was taking a suspect into custody. The deputy's injury was treated. MCSO said the criminal investigation is ongoing. Stay with RochesterFirst for the latest. Check back with News 8 WROC as we will continue to update this developing story. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
