Prisoners and ghosts claim overtime: meet SA's worst-run province
The Free State has been named the worst-run province in South Africa by the auditor-general (AG) due to its underperforming 16 municipalities plagued by poor financial reporting, non-compliance with legislation and deteriorating infrastructure.
The cooperative governance and traditional affairs (Cogta) portfolio committee heard that things are not improving in the province, but instead are worsening. The committee, led by Dr Zweli Mkhize, held an oversight visit in the province in late July, which revealed that urgent intervention by national and provincial authorities is needed.
Municipalities in the province fail to give residents quality service delivery due to corruption, mismanagement and bloated staff.
ALSO READ: Government intervention worsened Mangaung municipality crisis, but recovery underway — mayor
Staff taking overtime
The committee found maladministration includes irregular appointments, unpaid Eskom bills and deceased individuals claiming overtime.
At the centre of staff claiming overtime is the Mangaung metro municipality, headquartered in Bloemfontein. Sello More, Mangaung city manager, revealed that the metro spent R39 million on overtime in the 2023/24 financial year.
Some employees were found to have worked up to 120 hours overtime a month. Among those claiming overtime are ghost workers and prisoners. However, More said the metro has implemented a system that will cap or minimise overtime by staff.
Internal investigation about overtime
Gregory Nthatisi, Mangaung mayor, said investigations revealed that there were employees in the upper echelons of the municipality who approved people who were not even in the Free State, who were not employed by the municipality and some who were in jail to receive a salary, including overtime.
He assured that disciplinary action had been taken against those implicated by the investigation. Nthatisi says he has faith the new system will work successfully to reduce overtime abuse, but there might be challenges with the system, as it is still new.
The committee were told that staff issues, including employee shortages, equipment shortages and other problems significantly affect service delivery for the metro. However, R61 million has been set aside to fill vacant positions.
ALSO READ: Municipalities: It's time to hold mayors to account – AG
Issues in the province
The AG's Consolidated General Report on Local Government Audit Outcomes for 2023/24 named Free State as the worst-run province, followed by Northern Cape and North West.
Things have worsened in the province, as the AG noted that six municipalities failed to submit their financial statements for the 2023/2024 financial year, an increase from four in the previous year. However, not one of the municipalities in the province received a clean audit.
Making matters worse, performance reports from 13 municipalities in the province were deemed unreliable.
Eskom debt in the province decreased from R6.47 billion to R6.22 billion. However, the AG highlighted this was mainly due to Eskom's debt-relief programme.
Recipe for disaster
Professor Daniel Meyer, from the University of Johannesburg's School of Public Management, told Newzroom Afrika the report found that 16 municipalities in the province had unfunded budgets, meaning they budgeted without having the income to back it up. 'That is a recipe for overspending and deepening debt.'
Commenting on the province's debt level, he believes Matjhabeng municipality will never recover from the more than R8 billion debt it is in. Meyer said that the root of the problem lies in the absence of accountability.
'There's overtime being paid well above what labour regulations allow. In Mafube, the municipality collects pension contributions but doesn't pay them out to workers who retire. That's financial misconduct on another level.'
NOW READ: Mangaung municipality in spending crisis after exceeding budget
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
12 hours ago
- IOL News
The risks of omitting pending criminal cases in job applications
The Labour Court ruled in favour of the Office of the Chief Justice for not recommending a candidate for a job as court manager. Image: File The failure to disclose a pending criminal case when asked to do so during a job application can have dire consequences, as an applicant who applied for the position of a court manager discovered. Siphephelo Luthuli applied for two posts in the Eastern Cape as court manager. He was recommended as he was deemed the best candidate. He denied on his application form that he had a criminal record or any pending cases against him. But it was later discovered that there was a pending case relating to alleged driving under the influence of alcohol. The Office of the Chief Justice (OCJ) then withdrew its recommendation that Luthuli get the job. Luthuli took the matter on review before an arbitrator, who ruled in his favour and found that the OCJ was guilty of unlawful labour practice. The OCJ was ordered to compensate him by paying him R61,000, but the office took the matter on review to the Gqeberha Labour Court. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading The court was told that in 2019, the OCJ advertised two positions for court managers at the Bhisho and Mthatha High Courts. Luthuli applied, and he was required to indicate if he had ever been convicted of a criminal offence or whether any cases were pending, and his response was 'no'. The OCJ, however, subsequently established that he was arrested in respect of a case of driving a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol. Luthuli conceded that he knew about the matter but relied on the fact that the matter was not enrolled by the prosecutor's office. According to the police, the matter was still under investigation. The panel that interviewed him considered the matter and felt he had to disclose that the matter was still pending. As a result, they withdrew their recommendation for his appointment. The arbitrator found this to be irrational, arbitrary, and capricious and ordered that the OCJ compensate Luthuli. The arbitrator found that the definition of 'pending case' or 'pending' was not informed by an objective definition either provided for in legislation or policy.
IOL News
2 days ago
- IOL News
Eskom highlights 200 public electricity-related injuries and deaths in the past year
Eskom has reported 200 injuries and fatalities linked to electricity incidents in the past year, revealing a troubling trend exacerbated by unreported cases due to illegal connections. Image: Independent Newspapers Archives Eskom reported 200 public injuries and fatalities related to electricity incidents in the past year, highlighting ongoing risks associated with electricity use across South Africa. These figures are believed to be underreported, as many cases go unrecorded due to communities protecting illegal connections. August has been designated Electricity Safety Month to raise awareness about the dangers posed by electricity and to promote safe practices at home, in workplaces, and within communities. The initiative aims to reduce the risk of harm to the public, as well as to employees and contractors working with electrical systems. 'Many electricity-related injuries and deaths go unreported to Eskom because communities feel compelled to protect the illegal connections responsible for these incidents,' said Miranda Moahlodi, Eskom's senior manager for Health and Safety. She also noted the rise in criminal activities targeting electricity infrastructure, including vandalism, cable theft, and attacks on Eskom staff. Illegal connections and exposed wiring present serious threats to public safety and infrastructure. Moahlodi urged the public to report these hazards without delay. 'Poorly installed or tampered electrical lines are leading causes of fires in informal settlements and residential areas,' she said. 'By reporting hazards early, we can prevent fires that devastate homes and disrupt people's lives.' The campaign stresses that community safety is a shared responsibility. Residents are encouraged to remain vigilant and report risks such as low-hanging wires, open electrical boxes, or unsafe connections on streets, rooftops, or trees. 'We appeal to communities to help us curb the aggression and violence that Eskom employees are subjected to,' added Moahlodi. 'Like everyone else, we also have families waiting for us at home after work.' Eskom advises the public to regularly inspect their electrical systems, follow safety guidelines, and promptly report any hazards to help prevent accidents. Reports of illegal connections or exposed wiring can save lives, especially those of children or others unaware of the risks. To report crimes or illegal activities impacting Eskom infrastructure, the public can contact the Eskom Crime Line at 0800 11 27 22. THE MERCURY
The Citizen
5 days ago
- The Citizen
Prisoners and ghosts claim overtime: meet SA's worst-run province
Among those claiming overtime are ghost workers and prisoners. The Free State has been named the worst-run province in South Africa by the auditor-general (AG) due to its underperforming 16 municipalities plagued by poor financial reporting, non-compliance with legislation and deteriorating infrastructure. The cooperative governance and traditional affairs (Cogta) portfolio committee heard that things are not improving in the province, but instead are worsening. The committee, led by Dr Zweli Mkhize, held an oversight visit in the province in late July, which revealed that urgent intervention by national and provincial authorities is needed. Municipalities in the province fail to give residents quality service delivery due to corruption, mismanagement and bloated staff. ALSO READ: Government intervention worsened Mangaung municipality crisis, but recovery underway — mayor Staff taking overtime The committee found maladministration includes irregular appointments, unpaid Eskom bills and deceased individuals claiming overtime. At the centre of staff claiming overtime is the Mangaung metro municipality, headquartered in Bloemfontein. Sello More, Mangaung city manager, revealed that the metro spent R39 million on overtime in the 2023/24 financial year. Some employees were found to have worked up to 120 hours overtime a month. Among those claiming overtime are ghost workers and prisoners. However, More said the metro has implemented a system that will cap or minimise overtime by staff. Internal investigation about overtime Gregory Nthatisi, Mangaung mayor, said investigations revealed that there were employees in the upper echelons of the municipality who approved people who were not even in the Free State, who were not employed by the municipality and some who were in jail to receive a salary, including overtime. He assured that disciplinary action had been taken against those implicated by the investigation. Nthatisi says he has faith the new system will work successfully to reduce overtime abuse, but there might be challenges with the system, as it is still new. The committee were told that staff issues, including employee shortages, equipment shortages and other problems significantly affect service delivery for the metro. However, R61 million has been set aside to fill vacant positions. ALSO READ: Municipalities: It's time to hold mayors to account – AG Issues in the province The AG's Consolidated General Report on Local Government Audit Outcomes for 2023/24 named Free State as the worst-run province, followed by Northern Cape and North West. Things have worsened in the province, as the AG noted that six municipalities failed to submit their financial statements for the 2023/2024 financial year, an increase from four in the previous year. However, not one of the municipalities in the province received a clean audit. Making matters worse, performance reports from 13 municipalities in the province were deemed unreliable. Eskom debt in the province decreased from R6.47 billion to R6.22 billion. However, the AG highlighted this was mainly due to Eskom's debt-relief programme. Recipe for disaster Professor Daniel Meyer, from the University of Johannesburg's School of Public Management, told Newzroom Afrika the report found that 16 municipalities in the province had unfunded budgets, meaning they budgeted without having the income to back it up. 'That is a recipe for overspending and deepening debt.' Commenting on the province's debt level, he believes Matjhabeng municipality will never recover from the more than R8 billion debt it is in. Meyer said that the root of the problem lies in the absence of accountability. 'There's overtime being paid well above what labour regulations allow. In Mafube, the municipality collects pension contributions but doesn't pay them out to workers who retire. That's financial misconduct on another level.' NOW READ: Mangaung municipality in spending crisis after exceeding budget
