Big Supreme Court Order In 2023 Custodial Torture Case In J&K's Kupwara
In an important ruling against custodial violence this morning, the Supreme Court has ordered a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) inquiry into the alleged torture of a police constable back in 2023 at a Joint Interrogation Centre (JIC) in Jammu and Kashmir's Kupwara.
The accused officials involved in the alleged custodial violence must be arrested within a month, said a bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta, drawing up a one-month deadline for the federal agency to complete its probe.
The Jammu and Kashmir administration has also been ordered to pay a compensation of Rs 50 lakh to Khursheed Ahmad Chohan, who had sought legal remedy against custodial torture, for the violation of his fundamental rights.
The court has asked the CBI to constitute a Special Investigation Team (SIT) to probe the custodial violence allegedly occurred at the Kupwara JIC during February 23-26, 2023.
The latest ruling reinforces the constitutional safeguards against custodial violence that constitutes violations of fundamental rights. It sets aside a high court ruling that had refused to quash charges under Section 309 (suicide attempt) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) against Mr Chohan.
The constable had alleged that he was illegally detained for several days at JIC Kupwara in February 2023, during which he faced inhuman treatment that even included mutilation of his private parts.
Quashing the FIR against Mr Chohan, Justice Mehta wrote in his judgment that continuing criminal proceedings against him under Section 309 (IPC) would be a travesty of justice. The court also ordered the CBI to look into the "systematic issues" at the JIC Kupwara, highlighting the need to assess the causes that led to the custodial abuse.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
21 minutes ago
- Hans India
AI-based monitoring for BC hostels soon
Vijayawada: BC welfare minister S Savitha announced that Artificial Intelligence (AI) will soon monitor Backward Classes (BC) hostels across the state to enhance accountability and service quality. A dedicated mobile app is being developed for this purpose, she revealed during a review meeting with hostel welfare officers (HWOs) and BC welfare officers here on Wednesday. The meeting focused on hostel maintenance and government initiatives to improve student facilities. Minister Savitha emphasised the need for efficient hostel management and directed officials to complete student admissions by August 5. She also addressed issues with the Facial Recognition-based Attendance System (FRS), instructing officers to report disruptions to higher authorities promptly. Highlighting the NDA government's commitment, the minister noted that pending bills have been cleared swiftly. She mandated that HWOs reside in hostels at night to ensure continuous monitoring and better care for students, urging them to treat students like their own children. Additionally, she has been conducting surprise inspections of BC hostels and MJP schools across various districts. The minister instructed district BC welfare officers to conduct regular hostel visits, stay overnight when possible, and submit a tour diary to the state office by the 5th of each month. She also announced that repair works in BC hostels, funded with Rs 13 crore, are underway. Toilets are being constructed using Swachhandhra Corporation funds, with all projects targeted for completion by August 30. Officials were urged to submit bills promptly to expedite fund releases. To enhance health and safety, RO water plants and CCTV cameras will be installed in all BC hostels. Chandrasekhar Raju, director of BC welfare, Madhavilatha, secretary of MJP schools, and other officials attended the meeting.
Hindustan Times
28 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
CJI Gavai to set up bench to hear justice Varma's plea
Chief Justice of India Bhushan R Gavai on Wednesday said he would constitute a bench to hear the petition filed by Allahabad High Court judge Justice Yashwant Varma, but clarified he would not be part of it. Justice Yashwant Varma (PTI) Justice Varma sought an expedited hearing of his plea challenging the findings of a Supreme Court-appointed in-house inquiry panel that concluded there was 'strong inferential evidence' of his 'covert or active control' over a stash of charred cash found at his official residence in Delhi (when he was posted at the Delhi high court) earlier this year. Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for Justice Varma, mentioned the matter before the CJI and urged for early listing, citing important constitutional issues involved in the case. The CJI agreed but said it would not be proper for him to be part of the hearing bench, given his previous involvement in internal discussions surrounding the case.'I think it will not be proper for me to take up that matter because I was part of that conversation,' remarked the CJI, but assured that a bench would be constituted to take it up. The development comes even as the central government plans to bring an impeachment motion in Parliament to remove Justice Varma from office. As the monsoon session of Parliament is underway and political momentum builds for his removal, 145 Lok Sabha MPs and 63 Rajya Sabha lawmakers submitted separate notice in their respective Houses for impeachment of Justice Verma on July 21 – the first day of the current session. As reported first by HT, Justice Varma moved the apex court on July 17, filing a writ petition challenging the May 3 report by a three-member judicial inquiry panel and the subsequent May 8 recommendation by then CJI Sanjiv Khanna urging Parliament to initiate impeachment proceedings against him. Terming the panel's report 'unsustainable' and the process 'perverse,' the petition alleged grave violations of natural justice and accused the committee of functioning with an 'outcome-driven approach' based on a 'preconceived narrative.' The panel, Justice Varma said, failed to investigate foundational facts such as ownership, authenticity, and actual recovery circumstances of the charred cash allegedly found on March 14 at his Delhi residence following a fire. While acknowledging that some currency may have been recovered from the outhouse, the judge maintained that further inquiry was essential to establish culpability. Instead, the panel concluded its proceedings hastily, the petition claimed, reversing the burden of proof and placing the onus on the judge to disprove misconduct. The inquiry committee, comprising then high court chief justices Sheel Nagu (Punjab & Haryana), GS Sandhawalia (Himachal Pradesh), and Justice Anu Sivaraman (Karnataka high court), was formed on March 22 and submitted its findings to CJI Khanna on May 3. Justice Varma's petition also challenged the then CJI's May 8 recommendation to Parliament, arguing that it was based solely on an inquiry report that violated constitutional protections afforded to sitting judges. The Supreme Court's May 8 press note confirmed that Justice Varma had submitted a written response to the inquiry report, reiterating his denial of any wrongdoing and terming the allegations a 'conspiracy.' However, the top court noted that the judge had essentially restated his earlier stand. During the in-house inquiry, Justice Varma was divested of all judicial work and transferred back to his parent high court in Allahabad. He was serving on the bench of the Delhi High Court when the Marc 14 incident took place. The 64-page inquiry report cited 'strong inferential evidence' to conclude that Justice Varma had 'covert or active control' over the charred cash. While admitting that no direct evidence linked him to the currency, the panel held that his conduct 'belied the trust' reposed in a constitutional judge and warranted impeachment proceedings. 'The burden shifted upon Justice Varma to account for the money by giving a plausible explanation, which he failed to do, except projecting a flat denial and raising a bald plea of conspiracy,' the report said. The committee concluded that even if the money had been stored without his explicit knowledge, its presence in his official residence 'eroded public trust' and constituted judicial misconduct of a grave nature. As first reported by HT on June 18, Justice Varma had earlier rejected CJI Khanna's suggestion to resign or opt for voluntary retirement. In a detailed letter dated May 6, the judge accused the panel of procedural violations and asked the then CJI to reconsider both the process and the outcome. The fire incident at Justice Varma's residence on March 14 triggered the entire sequence of events. According to officials, sacks filled with charred currency notes were found at the outhouse of his Delhi bungalow by firefighters. Chief justice of Delhi High Court flagged the issue to the CJI, leading to the formation of the inquiry panel.
India.com
an hour ago
- India.com
Ghaziabad's Fake Embassy Mastermind Busted: Meet Harsh Vardhan Jain, The Man Behind A Phantom Diplomatic Empire
Ghaziabad (Uttar Pradesh): The house at KB-45 in the middle of a residential lane in Ghaziabad's Kavi Nagar looked like just another villa in the neighbourhood. But behind its closed gates, a bizarre and elaborate charade was playing out. A fake embassy, complete with flags, diplomatic insignia and even morphed photographs of the prime minister and former presidents, had been operating under the nose of the authorities. On July 22 night, the Uttar Pradesh Special Task Force (STF) raided the property and arrested one Harsh Vardhan Jain, the man behind the entire set-up. He was not only playing dress-up. Inside that rented house, he had created a world of lies stitched together with forged stamps, fake passports and piles of cash. He called himself an 'Ambassador' to four obscure or fictitious nations, West Antarctica, Saborga, Paulovia and Ladonia. Two of them do not even exist on any official map. The others are micronations with no formal recognition. And yet, for those who entered his circle, Harsh Vardhan sold a dream of foreign jobs, overseas businesses and lavish international access. Photos found in the house hint at a past riddled with shadows. His wall displayed images of himself with Chandraswami, the late controversial godman with known political links, and Adnan Khashoggi, the infamous international arms dealer. Whether those associations were real or part of the act, the police are still investigating. But what the STF did confirm is startling – four luxury cars with diplomatic number plates, 12 fake diplomatic passports, fake documents branded with the Indian foreign ministry's forged seals, fake press cards, two PAN cards under different names, stamps from 34 companies and countries, currency from multiple nations, 18 false number plates and Rs 44 lakh in cash stacked inside the premises. It does not end there. The STF says Harsh Vardhan also ran shell companies, which they believe were used for hawala transactions that are an informal and often illegal system of money transfer. Those who came into contact with him were lured in by a promise of influence and connections, only to be caught in a labyrinth of lies. This was not his first brush with the law. Back in 2011, he was booked for illegally possessing a satellite phone, something typically restricted to military or government use. That case too had emerged from Kavi Nagar, the very area where his latest plot unravelled. The STF's Noida unit conducted the raid, acting on a tip-off. It is a case of diplomatic fantasy, engineered with stunning precision and executed just a few kilometres from the national capital. Officials say the case raises troubling questions. How long had this fake embassy been functioning? How many people fell into his trap? And just how many documents in circulation today bear the fingerprints of Harsh Vardhan's forgery empire? As investigators dig deeper, one thing is certain that this was no small con. This was a parallel world of power, illusion and deception, all built within the walls of a quiet home in Ghaziabad.
