‘Too scared to scream': These Canadian air passengers experienced severe turbulence
Petronila Taruc has experienced turbulence every year she and her husband have flown to the Philippines from Vancouver.
But the 86-year-old retired legal secretary said one incident around 2015 stood out.
As turbulence increases globally and is projected by researchers to get worse because of climate change, Taruc was among the readers who shared with CTVNews.ca their harrowing experience with the weather phenomenon.
Deaths are rare, but incidents have shown it can be dangerous. While it's unclear what type of turbulence readers experienced, a kind of turbulence called clear-air turbulence is unpredictable and happens when wind speed or direction drastically changes.
Passengers like Taruc described the chaos. Taruc recalled how the flight crew was pouring coffee and handing out water when the turbulence started, which caused the drinks to spill.
Then she said she heard a 'sudden creaking' and felt the airplane plummet.
'I thought the airplane might just break apart, and I didn't have time to even get scared,' Taruc said in a video interview with CTVNews.ca.
A memorable flight five decades ago
George Sharpe said one encounter with severe turbulence has been etched in his mind for five decades.
He clearly recalled being on a flight to Toronto from Vancouver when turbulence struck at 37,000 feet during a thunderstorm over Moosomin, Sask., in the early morning hours on July 7, 1973. He said passengers were advised to prepare for 'some rough air.'
'All of a sudden we hit the big one just right off the bat,' Sharpe, a retired mining consultant, said in a video interview from Regina, describing how the plane went down 500 feet and then up 500 feet.
One woman suffered a neck injury while she tried adjusting her seatbelt.
He recalled the injured woman was slammed into the ceiling above her seat like a 'rag doll.'
The 76-year-old said people were holding their breath and some were praying. Objects were flying around, such as batteries, coats and hats. 'People were so scared that they were even too scared to scream,' he said, estimating the turbulence lasted about 20 minutes.
Even with his seatbelt on, Sharpe said it caused abdominal pain.
Airplane turbulence: George Sharpe
George Sharpe says he suffered abdominal pain and one woman injured her neck during severe plane turbulence that he still remembers from 1973. (George Sharpe)
'People were screaming'
John Parry, a retired technical writer from Toronto, said he was settling down to eat beef Stroganoff and drink a glass of Merlot when the plane stopped cruising at 37,000 feet and started falling.
'When we reached the end of the fall, that's when things really started to get interesting,' Parry said in a video interview with CTVNews.ca about the incident in November 2005. 'Items were falling out onto the heads of people below. People were screaming.'
'Some people were vomiting,' added the 72-year-old, who was a frequent flyer for decades. 'One of the cabin crew got knocked off her feet in the galley.'
He estimates that the severe turbulence lasted about three or four minutes.
Parry said he had a 'spreading puddle of wine' in his lap for the rest of the flight to Shanghai.
'You're sitting there, you're helpless'
Nigel Osborne from Durham, Ont., said he felt not only fear that he was going to die but also helplessness. The worst turbulence he ever experienced happened in 2005 when he and his wife were returning to Toronto from a destination wedding in Mexico.
He said the pilot warned passengers about turbulence as the plane flew into a massive thunderstorm over Florida.
'We were in the ride of our lives,' Osborne said in a video interview with CTVNews.ca, adding that it felt like being on a rollercoaster for up to 20 minutes.
Osborne said buckling up saved them from being thrown from their seats.
'There were times the plane was just plummeting,' he said. 'There was a huge bang, and then the plane would lurch up again.
'This went on for (what) seemed like an eternity,' he added. 'You're sitting there, you're helpless.'
Passengers like Osborne may feel helpless when turbulence strikes, especially with an unpredictable type of turbulence. Clear-air turbulence is projected to intensify because of climate change, according to a study published in the Geophysical Research Letters journal in June 2023.
Clear-air turbulence rose from 1979 to 2020, with the largest increases found over the busy flight regions of North Atlantic and continental United States, according to the study.
Even with these harrowing experiences shared by CTVNews.ca readers, no serious injuries or deaths were reported involving 67 turbulence incidents or accidents between January 2020 and June 2025 in the country, according to the Transportation Safety Board of Canada in an email to CTVNews.ca. It said at least 21 people suffered minor injuries, but noted that the data may be 'incomplete.'
Taruc wasn't aware of anyone in the Philippines-bound flight who was hurt, but she said the experience made her more cautious.
'Ever since, whenever I travel, no matter where, even if it's a short distance only, I always keep my seatbelts on,' Taruc said.
After the severe turbulence she experienced a decade ago, she said, she would only remove her seatbelt to go to the bathroom and stopped drinking alcohol before flying, which she used to do to calm her nerves. That way, she could be alert and prepared in case anything happened.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
17 minutes ago
- CTV News
Aug. 6 WxBlast
Edmonton Watch We'll lose the heat for the next few days as some clouds and rain move through the Edmonton area. Daytime highs will be about 10 degrees cooler than today with some wind gusts Thursday afternoon. Here's your Wednesday WxBlast video:
CTV News
17 minutes ago
- CTV News
Crews fighting wildland fire in Miramichi, N.B.
Dozens of firefighters are working to contain a wildland fire in Miramichi, N.B., on Wednesday. In a Facebook post, the Miramichi Professional Firefighters Association said crews were fighting the fire near Oldfield Road and Route 8 around 3:30 p.m. on Wednesday. According to the New Brunswick government, 35 firefighters, eight air tankers and three bulldozers were working against the fire on Wednesday evening. The fire's size is estimated to be 15-to-20 hectares. No homes are threatened and crews do not expect containment problems. The cause of the fire is under investigation. For more New Brunswick news, visit our dedicated provincial page.
Globe and Mail
17 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Ontario labour group urges more worker protections amid rising air quality concerns
An Ontario labour group says it is advocating for more robust worker protections amid growing health concerns over poor air quality as wildfire smoke blankets the province with increasing frequency. The Ontario Federation of Labour, which represents more than 55 unions across the province, says the push is part of a broader heat stress strategy looking at how climate change is impacting working conditions. Its president Laura Walton said provincial regulations outline winter temperature benchmarks to protect workers from the cold, but there are no such protections from the heat or poor air quality. The federation is working with the provincial New Democrats to introduce a motion in the legislature this fall advocating for better worker protections amid increasing extreme weather events, she said. As part of that campaign, Walton said the federation aims to provide first-hand insight into summer working conditions. Over the next six weeks, it will place instruments in workplaces across the province to collect heat and humidity readings. The federation will also survey workers about their environments, including asking them about air quality advisories issued for the area. Where in Canada are there wildfire smoke warnings? Our map tracks air quality across the country 'When we go to (the legislature) in November and people are like, 'Well, I don't know what the big deal is because it's freezing rain right now,' we actually have data to capture what was happening this summer,' she said. Environment Canada has issued numerous air quality warnings or statements in Ontario this summer due to wildfire smoke that drifts across provinces, with conditions often worsening in a matter of hours. Proper education about safe workplace environments is important so that workers know to ask for things such as air purifiers and proper ventilation systems to protect themselves from wildfire smoke, Walton said. Michael Lynk, professor emeritus of law at Western University and a former labour lawyer, said the more frequent air quality warnings should require unions to be more 'aggressive' in asserting workplace rights in the coming years. Unions are already starting to negotiate even stronger health and safety provisions through collective bargaining, which can include the right to shut down a workplace due to unsafe conditions, Lynk said. Wildfire smoke is affecting air quality across the country. Here's what you need to know He added that joint health and safety committees, required in every Ontario workplace with 20 or more employees, can also be an important tool in advocating for specific safety provisions. Currently, he said workers have the right to refuse work if they feel unsafe in extreme heat or smoke, which can send a powerful message to employers to re-examine working conditions. 'Just the threat of possibility of (refusing work), which is lawful under health and safety law, is usually enough to encourage or nudge employers to take union concerns seriously,' Lynk said. A number of large employers in the province are increasingly considering the impact of heat and poor air quality on their workforce. The City of Toronto, for example, has a heat stress policy that includes provisions such as rescheduling work to cooler times of the day, if possible, and providing cool spaces for staff. The city also has an indoor air quality policy for office environments. With extreme heat and air quality advisories expected to continue in the future, Lynk said he expects unions to be firmer in what they negotiate, as well as workers to be quicker to trigger their right to refuse work amid unsafe conditions. 'They're going to be more diligent and more assertive in compelling workers to pay attention to this,' he said.
