AI looms large as judge weighs remedies in Google Search antitrust case
Why it matters: At the endpoint of a historic tech antitrust case, there are still key questions about how online search works, what AI's role is and what Google owes its competitors in a landscape that has changed dramatically since the case was filed in 2020.
Federal Judge Amit Mehta, residing over the case, has a gargantuan task in front of him: decide how to fix Google's search monopoly in an ever-changing market being upended by AI.
The big picture: The case's conclusion is coming at a critical juncture as generative AI changes how people search the web and as Google shifts its main focus from traditional web search to AI products.
It's also part of Trump administration continuing to flex its anti- Big Tech muscle in a case that has bipartisan support.
Google has repeatedly argued people use Google Chrome because they like it; and that the companies it enters into exclusive distribution contracts with, like Mozilla, Samsung and Apple, benefit greatly.
The government wants the judge to force Google to spin off Chrome, ban it from using its AI tools to further entrench its monopoly and to stop having exclusive browser and smartphone deals.
What they're saying:"Do you think someone is going to come off the sidelines and build a new general search engine in light of what we are now seeing happen in the AI space?" Judge Mehta asked DOJ lawyer David Dahlquist.
He asked Dahlquist if products like OpenAI, Claude and Perplexity fall outside the search engine market. Dahlquist said they do fall outside the market at question in this case, but feels that will change in the future.
The other side:"Generative AI companies are not trying to out-Google Google," said Google attorney John Schmidtlein. "They are not general search engines... they are something else."
"I would imagine [companies like OpenAI] are telling all of their large, massive investors, they're not a general search engine," Schmidtlein said.
Inside the room:"This is a market that's been frozen in place for the best part of two decades," a senior DOJ official told reporters outside the courtroom, adding that a Chrome divestiture should be considered.
"There's sufficient evidence there for a Chrome divestiture, and the judge has already found them liable. In the general search market, 30% of search queries go through that Chrome browser... So to me, it's a logical remedy," the official said
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
13 minutes ago
- Fox News
DOJ official vows to 'get to the bottom' of DC police's alleged fake crime data
Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche has the latest on the Justice Department's investigation into Washington, D.C.'s, crime data and warns what's next for sanctuary cities that continue to defy the DOJ on 'The Ingraham Angle.'
Yahoo
16 minutes ago
- Yahoo
California State University Bets $17 Million on ChatGPT for All Students and Faculty
California State University Bets $17 Million on ChatGPT for All Students and Faculty originally appeared on L.A. Mag. California State University, the nation's largest public four-year system, will make OpenAI's ChatGPT available to all students and faculty starting this year. The effort is controversial, costing CSU almost $17 million, despite already having a $2.3 million budget gap, even with combative measures such as a tuition increase and spending cuts that have decreased course offerings for students. Across its 23 campuses, some CSU students are paying for personal ChatGPT subscriptions, so University officials say their decision to provide AI tools is a matter of equity. CSU wants each student to have equal access to tools and learning opportunities regardless of means or which campus they attend. The rise of AI has altered how students learn and professors teach, as each assignment is at risk of AI overpowering a student's knowledge. AI's ongoing influence has led professors to question the originality of student work, with a dramatic increase in academic misconduct claims, whether a student used the tool or not. AI has also threatened the potential of students in tech majors, making it essential for them to become fluent in ChatGPT. But if you can't beat them, join them. Universities across the country have been establishing deals with OpenAI, even some public institutions. Among these universities are the CSU schools that serve nearly half a million students and have devoted more resources to generative AI than any other public university, both in terms of funding and reach. ChatGPT Edu, an OpenAI chatbot designed for college settings, is provided and tailored to each campus it serves. The academic chatbot offers a diverse range of tools for students and faculty, including access to ChatGPT-5, the company's flagship model, and the ability to make custom AI models. Researchers at Columbia University in New York City even built a prediction tool to assist with decreasing overdose fatalities, which, without the platform, would have taken weeks of research rather than mere seconds. ChatGPT Edu can also be used as a classic study catalyst, assisting students and faculty with their academic needs. The company suggests using personalized tutoring for students, helping with writing grant applications, and assisting faculty with anyone can have a version of ChatGPT for free, the academic version's possibilities are limitless, and the data is kept private and is not used to train future models. More advanced ChatGPT Plus versions range from $20 to $200 a month. In the first half of this year, CSU paid $1.9 million to grant ChatGPT Edu to 40,000 users. Starting in July, the university system paid $15 million for a year's use for 500,000 users, securing a lower cost-per-student than other universities. Despite the major discount, CSU professors still have their concerns. 'For me, it's frightening,' said Kevin Wehr, a sociology professor at Sacramento State and chair of the California Faculty Association's bargaining team. 'I already have all sorts of problems with students engaging in plagiarism. This feels like it takes a shot of steroids and injects it in the arm of that particular beast.'Wehr also cautions that chatbots can often generate 'hallucinations' or inaccurate information, with many responses spreading racial and gender bias. CSU's financial struggles are also still in question. 'We are cutting programs. We are merging campuses. We are laying off faculty. We are making it harder for students to graduate,' Wehr said. And instead of using that money to ameliorate those issues, he added, 'we're giving it to the richest technology companies in the world."However, CSU is hopeful that the new addition will provide equitable access and prepare all students for a digitally advanced future. This story was originally reported by L.A. Mag on Aug 19, 2025, where it first appeared. Solve the daily Crossword
New York Post
41 minutes ago
- New York Post
Google lands major nuclear energy deal to power it's massive AI data centers with 50 megawatt capacity
Google, Kairos Power and the Tennessee Valley Authority have agreed to supply 50 megawatts of nuclear power to data centers in Tennessee and Alabama. The companies say the deal will help meet rising U.S. energy demand and advance the nation's role in next-generation nuclear power. Under the agreement, Kairos's Hermes 2 Plant in Oak Ridge will feed up to 50 megawatts into the TVA grid that serves Google's facilities. The deal makes TVA the first utility to purchase power from a GEN IV reactor. It also marks the first deployment of Hermes 2 under Kairos' broader pact with Google to deliver 500 megawatts by 2035. Kairos plans to boost Hermes 2's output from 28 to 50 megawatts beginning in 2030. In October, Google signed a deal with Kairos to buy nuclear power from 'multiple' small modular reactors under development. The reactors 'will be sited in relevant service territories to supply clean energy to Google data centers' beginning in 203, Kairos Power said at the time. Google said this week the reactor will supply electricity to its data centers in Montgomery County, Tennessee, and Jackson County, Alabama. 'With this next step, we are creating a three-party solution where energy customers, utilities, and technology developers work together to advance new technologies that can help meet the world's growing energy needs with reliable, affordable capacity,' Google said. A new agreement will lead to Google, Kairos Power, and the Tennessee Valley supplying 50 megawatts of nuclear power to data centers in Tennessee and Alabama. Kairos 'In this initial phase of the collaboration, we will procure clean energy attributes from the plant through TVA to help power our data centers in the region with locally sourced clean energy, every hour of every day,' the company added. Big Tech's energy-hungry data centers, fueled by generative artificial intelligence, require massive amounts of electricity. Those record energy needs have pushed U.S. power consumption to new highs and fueled demand for next-generation nuclear. The Google-Kairos deal will ultimately support 500 megawatts of advanced nuclear capacity—enough to power about 350,000 homes. The contract will specifically feed Kairos's Hermes 2 Plant in Oak Ridge, Tennessee, through the TVA grid, which serves Google's facilities. Kairos Google isn't alone in turning to nuclear. Microsoft struck a 20-year power purchase agreement with Constellation last year that could restart Three Mile Island's Unit 1 reactor in Pennsylvania. Amazon announced three nuclear-focused deals in October with Energy Northwest, X-energy and Dominion Energy. A GridStrategies report projects U.S. electricity demand will rise 15.8% by 2029, driven by data centers, manufacturing and electrification. The International Energy Agency expects U.S. data center electricity use to jump 130% between 2024 and 2030. FOX Business' Aislinn Murphy and Reuters contributed to this report.
