‘Premature, speculative': NTSB chief on media reports on Air India Ahmedabad crash causes
Homendy's comments come close on the heels of reports by a few US-based publications suggesting that deliberate action by one of the pilots was most likely the cause of the crash in which 260 people died — 241 of the 242 people on board and 19 on the ground.
'Recent media reports on the Air India 171 crash are premature and speculative. India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau just released its preliminary report. Investigations of this magnitude take time. We fully support the AAIB's public appeal, which was released Thursday, and will continue to support its ongoing investigation. All investigative questions should be addressed to the AAIB,' Homendy said in a statement.
In the appeal issued on Thursday, AAIB Director General GVG Yugandhar urged the public and the media to 'refrain from spreading premature narratives' around the ongoing investigation into the tragic crash of the Air India Boeing 787-8 aircraft Ahmedabad on June 12. In the appeal, Yugandhar also said that sections of the international media are 'repeatedly attempting to draw conclusions through selective and unverified reporting', and termed it 'irresponsible' as the investigation is still on.
Yugandhar added that the preliminary report only attempts to only provide information on what happened in the crash, and that it is too early to arrive at any definite conclusions, adding that the final report will contain the root causes of the crash. Yugandhar's statement came at a time when speculation is rife over the probable causes of the accident — the worst aviation disaster involving an Indian airline in four decades.
'While the accident of this dimension has drawn public attention and shock, however, it needs to be appreciated that this is not the time to create public anxiety or angst towards safety of Indian Aviation Industry, particularly on the basis of unfounded facts,' Yugandhar said.
The AAIB DG also said that the bureau will publish updates of technical and public interest 'as and when required'. Scarce flow of official information, absence of regular updates and briefings on the investigation were flagged by a number of experts and industry watchers. According to the AAIB chief, the investigation into the crash — 'the most devastating accident in recent aviation history' — is being undertaken in a 'rigorous and most professional manner' as per AAIB Rules and international protocols.
'It is essential to respect the sensitivity of the loss faced by family members of deceased passengers, crew of the aircraft and other deceased persons on ground. It has come to our attention that certain sections of the international media are repeatedly attempting to draw conclusions through selective and unverified reporting. Such actions are irresponsible, especially while the investigation remains ongoing. We urge both the public and the media to refrain from spreading premature narratives that risk undermining the integrity of the investigative process,' Yugandhar said.
The AAIB's preliminary investigation report, released a month after the accident, said that the Air India Boeing 787-8 aircraft crashed after both its engines were starved of fuel as the two fuel control switches transitioned from 'RUN' to 'CUTOFF' position within a second of each other moments after lift-off. From the cockpit voice recorder data, the preliminary probe report notes that one of the pilots asked the other why he cut off the fuel, to which the other pilot responded saying he did not.
To be sure, the report doesn't mention that the fuel control switches — which allow and cut fuel flow to the plane's engines — moved physically, and uses the term 'transitioned' to describe the change of mode from RUN to CUTOFF. It also does not state these were moved by either of the pilots. However, the selective information presented in the report had many believing that it implicitly pointed a finger at one of the pilots.
'The purpose of the AAIB's investigation and preliminary report is to provide information about 'WHAT' happened. The preliminary report has to be seen in this light. At this stage, it is too early to reach to any definite conclusions. The investigation…is still not complete. The Final Investigation Report will come out with root causes and recommendations,' he added.
Top officials of the aviation ministry, experts, and industry insiders maintained that jumping to any conclusion at this early stage of the investigation just based on limited information in the initial report wouldn't be appropriate. There is a long way to go for the investigation and a lot could change as the probe progresses over the coming months, they said. The report, too, clearly mentions the disclaimer that it is based on 'preliminary facts and evidence', and that the information it contains is 'preliminary and subject to change'.
According to experts, the investigators should now focus on unearthing the cause behind the transitioning of the fuel control switches, which are used to allow and cut fuel supply to the engines. There is considerable speculation on whether the switches were flicked by one of the pilots — inadvertently or otherwise — or whether the transition signal to the system was due to any technical, mechanical, or software issue. The report did not issue any recommendation to other operators of the Boeing 787-8 aircraft and its GE engines, suggesting that at this stage, the investigators do not have a reason to believe that there was any issue with the plane or its engines.
Sukalp Sharma is a Senior Assistant Editor with The Indian Express and writes on a host of subjects and sectors, notably energy and aviation. He has over 13 years of experience in journalism with a body of work spanning areas like politics, development, equity markets, corporates, trade, and economic policy. He considers himself an above-average photographer, which goes well with his love for travel. ... Read More
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Indian student latest to be attacked in Dublin as India Day gets postponed
LONDON: An Indian student attacked in Ireland at the weekend said he was leaving Ireland as a result and would finish his course online from India. The man, in his 20s, was walking home from Fairview Park in Dublin at 5.30 pm local time on Sunday when he was kicked and punched by a gang of teenagers. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now One of the group took his metal water bottle and hit him above the eye, causing heavy bleeding. He was taken to hospital where he received eight stitches. Gardaí confirmed they are investigating the assault and his injuries are 'non-life threatening'. An Indian-origin woman has put a post on Reddit saying her 60-year-old father was harassed by boys, aged around seven and eight, who tried to take his wallet at a bus stop in Dublin on Aug 9. These are just the latest in a string of racist attacks targeting Indians in Ireland which have left the Indian community terrified to step outside. India Day in Ireland, which celebrates the country's cultural ties, has been postponed this Sunday owing to the wave of hate crimes. The event has been organised by the Ireland India Council since 2015. A Ficci India Day event is going ahead in Dublin on Aug 17. Indian community leaders met Ireland deputy PM Simon Harris on Monday after which he condemned the 'despicable acts of violence and racism'. Chairman of the Ireland India Council Prashant Shukla told Ireland AM: 'We weren't worried about the event itself as the Gardaí assured us about safety, but we were worried about the perception it could lead to further attacks. Our message to the Irish community is that these attacks are attacks on your economy and industry. Policing needs to go to the next level. I feel there are not proper investigations and arrests. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now We are all working, paying taxes and contributing to the economy. No one is getting a free house. People are spreading misinformation that Indians buying houses is causing house prices to go up.' President of Ireland Michael D Higgins on Tuesday also condemned the attacks. 'A lot of Indians are reconsidering their choices and may move back to India if the situation doesn't improve. It is mostly being caused by far-right groups encouraging teenagers to attack immigrants. Indians are the most visible immigrants here,' said Indian national Some Aditya Mandal, who has worked in Dublin for eight years.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
HC asks Bengal migrant to appear after he returns from Bangladesh
A day after 19-year-old Bengali migrant Amir Shiekh, who was detained by the Rajasthan Police in June and later pushed into Bangladesh, returned to India on Tuesday, the Calcutta High Court on Wednesday told his family to 'bring back the son first' before it will hear the matter. Amir's father Jiyem Shiekh had moved the Calcutta High Court last week seeking judicial intervention to bring his son back. While the state government and the Centre submitted their respective reports, the High Court upon hearing that Amir was brought back, observed, 'Bring back your son first, we will hear the matter.' Amir's counsel, on Wednesday, told the Division Bench of Justice Tapabrata Chakraborty and Justice Reetobrata Kumar Mitra that a copy of Amir Sheikh's birth certificate was enclosed with the petition, maintaining that he is a citizen of India and was a resident of Kaliachak in Malda district. 'The grandparents of Amir Shiekh has Indian passport, he has school certificates and all documents. They have not seen anything but they had just pushed him into Bangladesh. Prior to that he was tortured in Rajasthan. Now we are being told that the Border Security Force (BSF) have brought him back.' Deputy Solicitor General (DSG) Rajdeep Majumder, appearing for the MEA and the BSF told the court that Amir had attempted to cross over to Indian territory from Bangladesh on August 12. As he could not produce appropriate documents as regards his identity, he was apprehended and handed over to the officer-in-charge, police station-Basirhat, by the BSF. But no formal case has yet been registered against Amir, he added. He submitted that if the petitioner approaches the police authorities, Amir would be handed over to the petitioner subject to production of all necessary records and upon execution of undertaking, if any. TMC MP Samirul Islam posted on X, 'This evening, Amir Sheikh was handed over to his family from the Basirhat police station. Nearly a month after being unlawfully pushed back to Bangladesh by the BSF, Amir is happy to be back on Indian soil — and his family is equally happy to have him home.' While he questioned the authorities' claims regarding Amir Sheikh's deportation, he posted, 'Amir Sheikh was deported to Bangladesh by the Rajasthan Police with the help of the BSF… we stood by his family.. helped Amir's father filed a Habeas Corpus petition in the Calcutta High Court. Under this pressure, the BSF has brought Amir back to West Bengal. The BSF has already handed him over to the Basirhat Police. Today, the court has asked the police to hand over Amir to his father. Yet strangely, they are now claiming that Amir was never deported! Then what happened? How did he end up in Bangladesh?' 'Don't worry—they have another explanation. They claim Amir 'inadvertently' went to Bangladesh on his own!…The same BJP leaders who scream that hordes of infiltrators are flooding India from Bangladesh now want us to believe that Amir willingly crossed… into that very country through illegal routes! Do they have no sense of shame? Or do they simply think the people of Bengal are fools? If it's the latter, let me tell you, anti-Bengal forces — Bengal's people will give you a fitting lesson. How much lower will you stoop?' he said.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Shilpa Shetty, husband Raj Kundra booked in Rs 60 crore cheating case
MUMBAI: Actor Kundra, her businessman husband , and an unknown person were booked by Economic Offences Wing (EOW) for allegedly cheating a Mumbai-based businessman of Rs 60.4 crore in connection with a loan-cum-investment deal involving their now-defunct company, Best Deal TV Pvt Ltd. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The offence was registered at Juhu police station against Shilpa Shetty and Raj Kundra under IPC sections of cheating and forgery. Since the amount involved is more than Rs 10 crore, the case was transferred to the EOW. The FIR follows a preliminary enquiry by the EOW into a complaint filed by Deepak Kothari. Kothari (60), a Juhu resident and director of Lotus Capital Financial Services, an NBFC. Kothari said one Rajesh Arya introduced him to Raj Kundra and Shilpa Shetty, who were directors of Best Deal TV Pvt Ltd, a home shopping and online retail platform. At the time, the couple reportedly held 87.6% shares in the firm. The accused allegedly sought a loan of Rs 75 crore at 12% interest but later persuaded him to route the funds as an "investment" to avoid higher taxation, while assuring monthly returns and repayment of principal. Kothari claims he transferred Rs 31.9 crore in April 2015 under a share subscription agreement, followed by another Rs 28.53 crore under a supplementary agreement in Sept 2015. The FIR says despite providing a personal guarantee in April 2016, Shetty resigned as director in Sept 2016. Kothari later discovered insolvency proceedings were on against the company in 2017 for defaulting on another agreement.
