Consumers demand audit before tariff hike
Listen to article
Consumers have called for an audit of power distribution companies (DISCOs), following the latter's request to the regulator to approve the collection of Rs455 billion through an increase in electricity rates.
The regulator — the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra) — conducted a public hearing on Friday to consider the interim tariff applications of eight DISCOs. They have asked for approval of a total revenue of Rs455 billion for the next financial year, to be recovered from electricity consumers.
"Before giving the go-ahead to the interim tariff increase, the regulator should conduct an audit of these companies," the interveners said during the hearing.
Tanveer Bari, a representative of the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI), stressed that the companies should present their investment plans. He noted that DISCOs were incurring higher losses compared to the targets set by Nepra, adding that the government was going to impose a surcharge for five years to reduce circular debt.
The petitions, under the multiyear tariff (MYT) regime covering the period from financial year 2025-26 to 2029-30, have been filed by the Gujranwala Electric Power Company (Gepco), Multan Electric Power Company (Mepco), Quetta Electric Supply Company (Qesco), Sukkur Electric Power Company (Sepco), Hyderabad Electric Supply Company (Hesco), Peshawar Electric Supply Company (Pesco), Tribal Areas Electric Supply Company (Tesco) and Hazara Electric Supply Company (Hazeco).
The revenue requirements of DISCOs show a significant financial burden in the upcoming fiscal year, which may be passed on to consumers. Mepco has cited the highest interim revenue requirement of Rs139.1 billion, followed by Pesco at Rs81.4 billion, Gepco Rs67.8 billion, Sepco Rs58 billion, Qesco Rs50.1 billion, Hesco Rs39.4 billion, Hazeco Rs12.3 billion and Tesco Rs7.3 billion.
Mepco has also made a higher demand on account of operation and maintenance (O&M) cost at Rs63.1 billion, largely driven by staff pay and allowances of Rs22.3 billion, post-retirement benefits of Rs29 billion and repair and maintenance expenses of Rs7.8 billion.
Gepco has estimated O&M cost at Rs35.3 billion, including Rs16.6 billion for pay and allowances and Rs13.8 billion for retirement benefits. Pesco has put its O&M cost at Rs37 billion, with Rs32.7 billion for salaries.
Other companies have also quoted sizeable O&M allocations. Hesco has mentioned Rs25.1 billion, Sepco Rs22.2 billion, Qesco Rs17 billion, Tesco Rs3.8 billion and Hazeco Rs7.8 billion.
Depreciation and the return on rate base (RORB) form another significant part of the cost buildup. Mepco has again topped the list with Rs8.9 billion worth of depreciation and Rs16.3 billion in RORB. Gepco follows with Rs4.8 billion in depreciation and Rs8.8 billion in RORB.
Pesco has sought Rs5.6 billion and Rs12.3 billion under the same heads while Hesco has demanded Rs3.2 billion in depreciation and Rs6.8 billion in RORB. Qesco's RORB is estimated at Rs15.7 billion alongside Rs297 million for depreciation.
Some DISCOs have sought adjustments for prior years as well, which results in an increase in their revenue requirements. Mepco has claimed Rs59.5 billion, Pesco Rs29.3 billion, Gepco Rs24.4 billion and Sepco Rs25.6 billion. Qesco and Hesco have requested Rs16.3 billion and Rs5.8 billion, respectively, while Tesco and Hazeco have not included prior year adjustments.
Tesco and Sepco have also factored in bad debt provisions, with Rs1.6 billion and Rs5.6 billion, respectively. Sepco has estimated Rs1.6 billion in finance costs.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
14 hours ago
- Business Recorder
PD uncertain on power tariff changes from July 1
ISLAMABAD: The Power Division stated on Friday that it currently has no definitive estimate of whether electricity tariffs for distribution companies (Discos) will increase or decrease from July 1, 2025, as this depends on the approval of cost components already submitted to the regulator. These remarks were made by Additional Secretary (Power Finance) Mehfooz Bhatti during a public hearing on the interim distribution and supply tariffs of eight Discos for FY 2025-26 under the Multi-Year Tariff (MYT) regime. The statement came in response to a query raised by textile sector representative Aamir Sheikh. Eight Discos—GEPCO, QESCO, MEPCO, SEPCO, HESCO, PESCO, TESCO, and HAZECO—have submitted tariff petitions under the MYT framework for the five-year period from FY 2025-26 to FY 2029-30, seeking National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA)'s approval of a combined revenue requirement exceeding Rs 455.6 billion for the upcoming fiscal year. 'I have no indication at all of what the industry tariff will be from July 1, 2025,' said Aamir Sheikh. 'Our tariff for B3 has dropped to Rs 31/32 (about 11 cents) per unit currently, and the government has committed to reducing it further. We have already booked export orders for the next quarter based on these rates. It's imperative for NEPRA, the Power Division, and the Government of Pakistan to ensure tariffs do not increase beyond May/June levels.' The hearing was briefly suspended by NEPRA Chairman Waseem Mukhtar, who demanded representation from a senior Power Division official. Mehfooz Bhatti eventually joined the session, replacing the Joint Secretary, whose presence NEPRA deemed insufficient. Bhatti, who liaises directly with the Finance Division on power sector subsidies, appeared uncertain regarding the projected tariff changes. 'There is an indication of Rs 250 billion in the budget for Targeted Distribution Subsidy (TDS) for 2025-26. We've already presented seven scenarios to the Regulator. Once the distribution margins are determined under MYT, we'll be in a better position to outline consumer tariffs after incorporating the government's subsidy. At this point, I can't provide figures, but rebasing will take effect from July 1, 2025,' he said. The Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) strongly opposed any additional financial burden on consumers for the losses incurred by Discos under the MYT, until comprehensive reforms are implemented. The FPCCI argued that the burden of inefficiencies—including high technical and commercial losses, pension liabilities, and poor governance—is being unfairly transferred to consumers. Rehan Jawed from Karachi raised concerns about the poor performance of Hyderabad Electric Supply Company (HESCO), prompting NEPRA to announce that a verification team will visit HESCO upcoming Monday to investigate consumer complaints. Tanveer Barry of the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) criticized Discos for rising losses due to operational inefficiencies, stating that consumers across Pakistan are unfairly burdened with the DSS surcharge on Power Holding Limited (PHL) loans. 'Discos' technical and commercial losses are worsening, and their recoveries fall short of NEPRA's targets. They haven't submitted investment and distribution plans, and the MYT submissions are incomplete,' Barry said. He emphasized that with power generation capacity projected to increase to 46,605 MW, resulting in higher capacity payments, the Time of Use (ToU) mechanism for industrial consumers should be abolished. He also called for third-party audits of Disco losses to present an accurate picture to NEPRA. CEOs and CFOs of the eight Discos presented details of their proposed distribution margins and expenditures. According to the tariff petition, GEPCO has sought approval of revenue requirement of Rs 67.821 billion of which Rs 16.598 billion is on account of pay & and allowances, Rs 13.815 billion post-retirement benefits, other expenses Rs 4.909 billion (total O&M cost Rs 43.446 billion), depreciation Rs 4.792 billion, RORB Rs 8.750 billion and other income negative Rs 5.418 billion other income and Prior Year Adjustment (PYA) Rs 24.375 billion. MEPCO has sought NEPRA's approval for revenue requirement of Rs 139.106 billion of which, pay and allowances are Rs 22.302 billion, post-retirement benefits Rs 29.384 billion, repair and maintenance, Rs 7.869 billion, travelling allowance Rs 1.936 billion, vehicles maintenance, Rs 1.161 billion, other expenses Rs 507 million (total O&M cost Rs 79.653 billion), depreciation Rs 4.792 billion, RORB Rs 8.750 billion, other income negative Rs 8.731 billion and Prior Year Adjustment Rs 79.453 billion. QESCO's total proposed revenue requirement for FY 2025-26 is Rs 50.120 billion which includes, pay and allowances Rs 9.947 billion, post-retirement benefits, Rs 3.044 billion, repair and maintenance, Rs1.496 billion, travelling allowance, Rs 1.936 billion, vehicles maintenance, Rs 797 billion, other expenses Rs 1.356 billion, (total) O&M cost Rs 17.100 billion), depreciation, Rs 2.944 billion, RORB Rs 15.696 billion, other income negative Rs 1.950 billion and PYA Rs 16.298 billion. SEPCO has sought total revenue requirement of Rs 58.053 billion, of which O&M cost is Rs 22.226 billion, Distribution Margin/Supply Margin, Rs 25.3032 billion, PYA Rs 25.522 billion. TESCO's revenue requirement for FY 2025-26 is estimated to be Rs 7.303 billion of which Rs O& M expense is Rs3.883 billion and DM/SM Rs 5.629 billion. PESCO's total revenue requirement for FY 2025-26 is Rs 81.449 billion which includes O&M expense Rs 37 billion, DM/ SM- Rs 52 billion and PYA Rs 29.344 billion. Hazara Electric Supply Company (HAZECO) which has been bifurcated from PESCO also presented its one-year revenue requirement. HESCO's total revenue requirement for FY 2205-26 is Rs 39.448 billion of which O& M expense is Rs 25.130 billion, DM/SM Rs 33.693 billion and PYA Rs 5.755 billion. HESCO's total revenue requirement is Rs 12.320 billion for the FY 2025-26, which includes O&M Rs 7.883 billion, depreciation, Rs 831 million, RORB Rs 3.028 billion, advance tax Rs 1.129 billion and other income negative Rs 550 million. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
15 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Consumers demand audit before tariff hike
Listen to article Consumers have called for an audit of power distribution companies (DISCOs), following the latter's request to the regulator to approve the collection of Rs455 billion through an increase in electricity rates. The regulator — the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra) — conducted a public hearing on Friday to consider the interim tariff applications of eight DISCOs. They have asked for approval of a total revenue of Rs455 billion for the next financial year, to be recovered from electricity consumers. "Before giving the go-ahead to the interim tariff increase, the regulator should conduct an audit of these companies," the interveners said during the hearing. Tanveer Bari, a representative of the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI), stressed that the companies should present their investment plans. He noted that DISCOs were incurring higher losses compared to the targets set by Nepra, adding that the government was going to impose a surcharge for five years to reduce circular debt. The petitions, under the multiyear tariff (MYT) regime covering the period from financial year 2025-26 to 2029-30, have been filed by the Gujranwala Electric Power Company (Gepco), Multan Electric Power Company (Mepco), Quetta Electric Supply Company (Qesco), Sukkur Electric Power Company (Sepco), Hyderabad Electric Supply Company (Hesco), Peshawar Electric Supply Company (Pesco), Tribal Areas Electric Supply Company (Tesco) and Hazara Electric Supply Company (Hazeco). The revenue requirements of DISCOs show a significant financial burden in the upcoming fiscal year, which may be passed on to consumers. Mepco has cited the highest interim revenue requirement of Rs139.1 billion, followed by Pesco at Rs81.4 billion, Gepco Rs67.8 billion, Sepco Rs58 billion, Qesco Rs50.1 billion, Hesco Rs39.4 billion, Hazeco Rs12.3 billion and Tesco Rs7.3 billion. Mepco has also made a higher demand on account of operation and maintenance (O&M) cost at Rs63.1 billion, largely driven by staff pay and allowances of Rs22.3 billion, post-retirement benefits of Rs29 billion and repair and maintenance expenses of Rs7.8 billion. Gepco has estimated O&M cost at Rs35.3 billion, including Rs16.6 billion for pay and allowances and Rs13.8 billion for retirement benefits. Pesco has put its O&M cost at Rs37 billion, with Rs32.7 billion for salaries. Other companies have also quoted sizeable O&M allocations. Hesco has mentioned Rs25.1 billion, Sepco Rs22.2 billion, Qesco Rs17 billion, Tesco Rs3.8 billion and Hazeco Rs7.8 billion. Depreciation and the return on rate base (RORB) form another significant part of the cost buildup. Mepco has again topped the list with Rs8.9 billion worth of depreciation and Rs16.3 billion in RORB. Gepco follows with Rs4.8 billion in depreciation and Rs8.8 billion in RORB. Pesco has sought Rs5.6 billion and Rs12.3 billion under the same heads while Hesco has demanded Rs3.2 billion in depreciation and Rs6.8 billion in RORB. Qesco's RORB is estimated at Rs15.7 billion alongside Rs297 million for depreciation. Some DISCOs have sought adjustments for prior years as well, which results in an increase in their revenue requirements. Mepco has claimed Rs59.5 billion, Pesco Rs29.3 billion, Gepco Rs24.4 billion and Sepco Rs25.6 billion. Qesco and Hesco have requested Rs16.3 billion and Rs5.8 billion, respectively, while Tesco and Hazeco have not included prior year adjustments. Tesco and Sepco have also factored in bad debt provisions, with Rs1.6 billion and Rs5.6 billion, respectively. Sepco has estimated Rs1.6 billion in finance costs.
Business Recorder
5 days ago
- Business Recorder
Solar net-metering capacity in Pakistan jumps to 2,813MW
Solar net-metering capacity in Pakistan has jumped to 2,813 megawatts (MW) as of March 31, 2025, according to the Pakistan Economic Survey 2024-25, reflecting a 12% increase over the first nine months of the current fiscal year. This represents a rise of over 300MW from the previous fiscal year, when the capacity stood at around 2,500MW, as per NEPRA's State of the Industry Report 2024. The 300MW jump in net-metering capacity is largely attributed to a sharp fall in solar panel prices and the financial incentives net-metering offers to consumers. China exports more solar panels to Pakistan than to many G20 nations in 5 years: report The system allows consumers to install rooftop solar panels, sell surplus power generated during the day to distribution companies (DISCOs), and purchase electricity at night — offsetting monthly bills and contributing to the national grid. Experts say the expansion has also improved voltage stability and reduced transmission and distribution losses, showcasing tangible benefits to the power system. Despite the growth, net-metering still accounts for a fraction of the total potential. Pakistan is estimated to have imported solar equipment capable of producing 20,000–22,000MW in recent years, most of which is installed off-grid — particularly in agriculture, residential, and industrial settings. The surge in clean energy coincides with broader developments in the country's power sector. As of March 2025, Pakistan's total installed electricity generation capacity reached 46,605MW, up 1.6% from 45,888MW a year earlier. This includes the operationalisation of the 884MW Suki Kinari Hydropower Project, and progress on new solar, wind, and bagasse-based projects, as well as the termination of power purchase agreements (PPAs) with some independent power producers (IPPs). Of the total capacity, 44.3% now comes from hydel, nuclear, and renewable sources, marking a continued shift away from thermal power, which now accounts for 55.7% of the energy mix. Renewable energy data reveals that hydel sources contribute 24.4%, nuclear power 7.8%, and solar and wind (including net-metering) 12.2% to the installed capacity. Meanwhile, Khalid Waleed, an energy expert at the Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI), warned against proposed tariff reductions for net-metering. From crisis to clean energy: Pakistan emerges as top solar market in 2024 The government is considering slashing the current Rs27 per unit buyback rate to Rs10, which Waleed argued would 'disincentivise clean energy' and reverse recent gains. Instead, he recommended a phased reduction to Rs15-18 per unit to maintain investor and consumer interest. The Indicative Generation Capacity Expansion Plan (IGCEP) 2022-31 set a target to add 3,420MW under net-metering by 2031. NEPRA believes this goal can be met — or even exceeded — if distribution companies avoid obstructing the ongoing rooftop solarisation momentum.
