With Notre Dame football now officially off and running for 2025, one key question lingers
Those school-record 14 wins after playing a program-record 16 games? History. A postseason run that included a win in the first College Football Playoff on-campus game in history and a major bowl victory (and then another) for the first time since 1993? Already in the rearview.
Pieces in Place: What's left on the Notre Dame football national championship checklist heading into 2025?
That season was special in so many ways, but that season is so over. Put a period on those plays and those players and catalog 2024. Time to begin a new book and start the first chapter of memories in 2025.
'Two-thousand 24 has nothing to do with this 2025 team,' head coach Marcus Freeman said.
Preach. It doesn't. It won't.
Family Matters: Notre Dame football coach Marcus Freeman is disappointed for Charles Jagusah, not upset with him
Still, as the pre-practice stretch lines ran a half dozen or so deep inside the Irish Athletic Center, 2024 in some ways felt like it had ended just last month. In others, it felt like forever. Another team at another time did all of that. This is a new team in a new year with a new direction. The same goal that's been around these parts since 1988 remains – win the school's 12th national championship.
It didn't take long on Thursday to realize that everything about Notre Dame football feels different than this time last year. Just look at the most critical position on the field.
All eyes were on those guys in red (don't-touch) jerseys. Except those that were watching the wideouts that at least – finally – look the part. Or on a defense that (whisper voice) might be even better than last season. Or along the offensive line that has some seriously massive men.
'It's a deep room,' Freeman said of the O-line, though he could say that about four or five rooms in the Gug in 2025. These Irish are loaded.
With Thursday the only day for media to observe a practice from start to finish, your head had to be on a swivel. Watch this guy and those guys and that group. It was eclipse-like viewing. Look, but don't look too long.
It would've been easy for Freeman to step to the front of the Notre Dame Stadium interview room early Thursday afternoon following the 90-minute workout and deliver a whopper of an opening statement.
But what would classify as a one?
For this team, for this season, it would be naming a starting quarterback before Notre Dame again opens on the road, again over Labor Day, this time at Miami (Fla.), site of its final win in, wait for it, 2024.
Going that easy route (this is our guy) would go against everything Freeman has preached since he burst through that locker room door on the other side of the stadium tunnel in December 2021, not long after being named the 30th coach in program history.
Choose Easy? Not Freeman. Not ever. Choose Hard. His first season and his second, and even his third were hard. His fourth will be. Nothing is ever easy about Notre Dame football.
Instead of naming a starting quarterback, Freeman said ... nothing. No starter named. No starter hinted at. Even off the record, those around the program won't say. Let the process progress. It wasn't going there on Thursday.
When might it? Deep breaths. Give it time. The next time Freeman is scheduled to meet the media is Sunday, August 17. Two weeks before that opener under the moon in Miami, Notre Dame should have its starter at quarterback.
No commitment to a quarterback Thursday likely came as a slight surprise to some (we see you). When Steve Angeli announced before the end of spring practice that he was going into the transfer portal and eventually going to Syracuse, the assumption was that freshman C.J. Carr was set to be QB1. He still could be.
When it was time to go seven-on-seven on Thursday, sophomore Kenny Minchey ran with the No. 1s. When it was time to go 11-on-11, there again was Minchey running with the ones. It might just be the way the reps were split on Thursday. On Friday, Carr could get the first call.
Still, Thursday wasn't nothing. Maybe it's something.
An open and shut competition looks open, even after safety Tae Johnson did his best Kyle Hamilton/first day of practice impersonation (Culver, 2019) and picked off Carr twice on throws into the middle of the field. The day ended with a Karson Hobbs interception of a Carr pass that receiver K.K. Smith bobbled.
Freeman reserved judgment on Carr until he could return to his office and break down exactly what happened. One day, good or bad, won't decide this starter. Give it a few more days, a few more reps, and see where it goes. If it was Minchey on Thursday, it might be Carr on Friday. Both of them on Saturday. Neither of them on Sunday.
Let the process progress.
'It's going to be consistency,' Freeman said of what will push one guy ahead of the other at the depth chart finish line. 'They will determine the starting quarterback.'
And determine the course of a 2025 season that's officially off and running. One day down, many more to go. Where does this all lead? Who leads it? Whatever happens, we already know this:
It won't be easy.
Follow South Bend Tribune and NDInsider columnist Tom Noie on X (formerly Twitter): @tnoieNDI. Contact Noie at tnoie@sbtinfo.com
This article originally appeared on South Bend Tribune: Will it be C.J. Carr or Kenny Minchey at quarterback for Notre Dame football?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Hernández: Lakers' commitment to Luka Doncic raises questions about LeBron James' role
Near the conclusion of the news conference to address his contract extension with the Lakers, Luka Doncic detailed the training program that contributed to his striking weight loss. When he was finished talking about how he lifted weight and refrained from playing basketball for a month, general manager Rob Pelinka made it a point to offer some thoughts. 'Luka's done all the work,' Pelinka said, 'but it's important to have a support system around you to help you do the great work.' Pelinka went on to praise Doncic's trainer, Anze Macek, and physiotherapist, Javier Barrio. He remarked how Macek and Barrio have 'worked seamlessly' with the Lakers' staff. He name-checked Doncic's agent, Bill Duffy, and business manager, Lara Beth Seager. Read more: 'Just the beginning': Luka Doncic on why he agreed to a three-year, $165-million contract extension These weren't garden-variety compliments. This was a pledge of allegiance. Shortly after Doncic was traded by the Dallas Mavericks to the Lakers last season, stories emerged about tensions between his inner circle and former team. Pelinka's words contained an indirect message: We will support you the way Mavericks didn't. This is your team. The commitment was formalized on Saturday, the Lakers signing the 26-year-old Doncic to a three-year, $165-million contract extension. The news conference ended with seven Lakers players and coach JJ Redick emerging from the back to take a picture with Doncic as he held up his jersey. A couple of the players, center Deandre Ayton and guard Marcus Smart, were personally recruited to the team by Doncic. Doncic is now officially the center of the Lakers' universe, and as inevitable as that seemed from the moment Pelinka acquired him, the dynamic intensifies a question that was initially raised last season: What does this mean for LeBron James? Too much shouldn't be made of James' absence from the news conference on Saturday, as Austin Reaves wasn't there either. However, James is under contract for just one more season and Doncic for at least three more, and how will James deal with not being the focal point of his franchise? James is a player who is used to exercising boundless influence over teams that employ him, enough to where the 17-time NBA champion Lakers drafted his undersized son. While the Lakers once had visions of Anthony Davis replacing James as the face of their franchise, the imaginary baton was never passed. The Lakers didn't make as big a deal of Davis' extension two years ago as they did with Doncic's on Saturday, for which a Doncic-themed photo gallery was erected for the news conference. There's an uneasy feeling about the situation, in large part because James hasn't clearly communicated his thoughts. When James exercised his player option for the upcoming season, his agent said that because James wanted to play for championships and the Lakers were 'building for the future,' their camp wanted 'to evaluate what's best for LeBron at this stage in his life and career.' The 40-year-old James will have a say in what happens, as his deal includes a no-trade provision. Asked how James viewed the Lakers' summer and whether he thought James would retire with the team, Pelinka replied, 'So all the interactions we've had with LeBron and his camp, [agent Rich Paul] in particular, have been positive and supportive. So very professional and Rich has been great. The dialogue with him has been open and constant. 'In terms of LeBron's career, I think the number one thing we have to do there is respect he and his family's decision in terms of how long he's going to play. I think that's first and foremost and we want to respect his ability to come up with his timetable on that. I think that's really important, but if he had a chance to retire as a Laker, that would be great." In other words, there wasn't enough clarity for Pelinka to be able to say with any degree of certainty, yes, he thought James would retire a Laker. Doncic accepted an offer from the Lakers to be their next headliner. That was an important development for them. But for them to be able to properly showcase their next act, they will have to close their previous one, whether it's by him accepting a supporting role or deciding to take his talents elsewhere. Sign up for our weekly newsletter on all things Lakers. This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Lionel Messi exits Inter Miami match with apparent injury
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. (AP) — Lionel Messi exited Inter Miami's Leagues Cup match against Necaxa on Saturday night after suffering an apparent injury in the opening minutes. Messi appeared to get tripped going for the ball in the eighth minute, fell to the ground and slammed his fist in frustration before walking toward midfield as play continued. He then sat on the pitch as trainers came and worked on his upper leg/right thigh area for a couple of minutes. He was subbed out in the 11th for Federico Redondo and immediately headed to the locker room. Miami went up 1-0 a couple minutes later on a goal by Telasco Segovia, which was assisted by Rodrigo De Paul. ___ AP soccer: The Associated Press
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Top of the order breaks out as Mets snap losing streak with 12-6 win over Giants
The Mets snapped their losing streak with a 12-6 win over the San Francisco Giants on Saturday afternoon at Citi Field. Here are some takeaways... - One of the biggest reasons behind the Mets' four-game losing streak coming into the day was the lack of production from the top of their order. The Fab 4 of Brandon Nimmo, Francisco Lindor, Juan Soto, and Pete Alonso have been struck in brutal slumps at the plate -- but some of them delivered on Saturday. - Alonso got the scoring started by crushing a 1-2 Kai-Wei Teng fastball for a three-run homer in the bottom of the first. The big man has now left the yard on back-to-back days to bring him just two away from tying Darryl Strawberry's all-time franchise record. - The Mets' offense was relatively quiet after Alonso's homer, but then Nimmo and Lindor took things over. The bottom of the order started rallies in the fourth, sixth, and seventh innings and the dynamic duo at the top came through each time to deliver run-scoring hits. Nimmo, Lindor, and Alonso finished the day a combined 8-for-12 with five runs scored and 10 RBI. - Cedric Mullins played a part in each of those rallies, picking up his first Met hit in the fourth before stealing second and then scoring on Nimmo's RBI hit. The CF had a chance to make another highlight reel play in the first, but he just mistimed his jump. - Brett Baty was on-base three times with two walks and a hit, he also scored each time. - Kodai Senga struggled mightily for the fourth consecutive outing since returning from the IL. The right-hander worked around a pair of baserunners in the top of the first, but the Giants were able to get to him in each of his next three innings of work. He loaded the bases with a double and two walks in the second, but limited the damage to just one run with some help from a double play. Senga appeared to put together his first clean inning in the third, but he issued a two out walk and then former Met Dom Smith evened things up with his third homer of the season. San Fran then took their only lead in the fourth on a Jung Ho Lee double and Grant McCray single. Senga was able to get through that frame without any further damage, but he still closed his book with four runs allowed on five hits and three walks with four punchouts across just four innings of work. - With the new depth in the bullpen, Reed Garrett was brought in behind Senga in the fifth. After Garrett put together a clean inning and then retired the first batter in the sixth, Gregory Soto came on and struck out back-to-back left-handed hitters. Tyler Rogers threw a scoreless inning in his first outing as a Met, then with the score out of hand Brooks Raley put up a zero in the eighth, and Rico Garcia allowed a two-run homer but put the finishing touches on the victory and strong effort from the revamped bullpen. - With the Phillies falling to the Tigers, the Mets have jumped back into first place in the NL East. Game MVP(s): Top of the order Nimmo, Lindor, and Alonso carried the weight for the offense in this one. Highlights What's next Frankie Montas takes the mound against rookie Carson Whisenhunt in the series finale at 1:40 p.m.
