In Indonesia, fears grow that dark past may be rewritten with government's new history books
In Indonesia, fears grow that dark past may be rewritten with government's new history books
JAKARTA - The Indonesian government's plan to release new history books has sparked concerns that some of the country's darkest chapters could be recast to show President Prabowo Subianto and late authoritarian ruler Suharto in a favourable light.
The 10-volume series would have an Indonesia-centric narrative and aims 'to reinvent the Indonesian identity,' Culture Minister Fadli Zon told Reuters in an interview.
Several historians said the commissioning of the books presents an opportunity for historical revisionism at a time when Indonesia's younger generations - largely responsible for Mr Prabowo's resounding election victory in 2024 - have little or no memory of Suharto's 1966-1998 New Order era.
Mr Prabowo openly praises Suharto, who was once his father-in-law, and is increasingly turning to the military to carry out his government's vision.
Mr Prabowo has also been accused of rights abuses while in the military, including involvement in the kidnapping of student activists during riots in 1998 - allegations he has repeatedly denied and which Mr Fadli said had been debunked.
Mr Asvi Warman Adam, a leading historian who used to work at the National Research and Innovation Agency, said he was calling on academics to lobby lawmakers to scrutinise what he said would be 'propaganda'.
'I suspect there is an intention to legitimise the ruling regim ... such as by excluding gross human rights violations in 1998 linked to Prabowo,' he said, adding that he expected the government would soon confer the posthumous title of 'National Hero' on Suharto.
Asked about concerns by some analysts and historians that the books could be used as propaganda, be politicised and omit human rights abuses that have been linked to Mr Prabowo and Suharto, Mr Fadli said: 'History will be written correctly'.
The president's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the new books.
Mr Prabowo has previously said that former activists were his supporters.
Mr Fadli, who has authored a book that defended Mr Prabowo's actions as a special forces commander during Suharto's 32-year rule, added that neither he nor Mr Prabowo would be involved in the editorial process.
The books, which Mr Fadli said were commissioned in 2024, will chronicle the history of humankind in Indonesia from homo erectus to Dutch colonisation to Prabowo's election.
They will be authored and edited by about 100 historians, and Mr Fadli says he wants them ready by August 17, Indonesia's Independence Day.
Mass killings in focus
Mr Made Supriatma, a visiting fellow at the Iseas-Yusof Ishak Institute in Singapore, said he believes the government will use the same playbook as Suharto, who released a six-volume book series in 1975 titled 'The National History of Indonesia' that he said glorified the military and was fraught with inaccuracies.
'Prabowo's history within this republic is not good, to be frank... Do they dare to write that?' said Mr Made.
Mr Jajat Burhanuddin, a historian involved in the project, said so far there has been no state intervention.
The 1998 kidnappings and torture of student activists would be included, he said, although he declined to say whether Mr Prabowo would be mentioned in those accounts.
Another key focus for historians will be how the books portray the mass killings of communists and sympathisers in 1965 and 1966, led by military and Islamic leaders. Some historians estimate more than half a million people were killed.
No investigation has been conducted into the killings, which were in response to the murder of generals by the communist party in an abortive coup.
Suharto rose to power in the aftermath and remained president until 1998, when he stepped down during a popular uprising and economic crisis after allegations of corruption and nepotism.
The 1965 events continue to be debated in Indonesia.
Mr Fadli said the new books would not take a deeper look into the massacres.
Mr Fadli, who was among the student activists who demonstrated against Suharto, now speaks highly of the former ruler, highlighting economic achievements in his early presidency, including slashing poverty and tackling inflation.
'My opinion has always been for a long time that Suharto should be considered a national hero,' he said. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Ukraine brings back 84 POWs including dozens of civilians
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox FILE PHOTO: Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy speaks during a press conference on the first day of the two-day Ukraine Recovery Conference (URC2025), on plans for the reconstruction of Ukraine, in Rome, Italy, July 10, 2025. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane/File Photo KYIV - Ukraine brought home 84 prisoners of war in its latest exchange with Russia that included dozens of civilians, Ukrainian officials said on Thursday, at least one of whom had been held for more than a decade. Thursday's swap included 33 soldiers and 51 civilians, according to the Ukrainian state committee in charge of POWs, which added that one of the prisoners had spent more than 4,000 days in captivity. Another was a primary school teacher captured by Russian-backed separatists in 2019. "Among the civilians released today are those who had been held by the Russians since 2014, 2016, and 2017," President Volodymyr Zelenskiy wrote on X. "Among the military released today are the defenders of Mariupol." Kyiv and Moscow have carried out regular swaps during the 3-1/2-year-old war despite no lulls in fighting, with Ukraine returning more than 5,000 POWs since the Kremlin's February 2022 invasion. REUTERS
CNA
an hour ago
- CNA
New Indonesia capital or ghost town? President Prabowo's lack of urgency towards Nusantara fuels debate, fears
JAKARTA: Ahead of Indonesia's Aug 17 Independence Day last year, Nusantara was abuzz with activity as construction crews worked round the clock to make sure the future capital was presentable to the throng of senior government officials, foreign dignitaries and journalists in attendance. Despite various hiccups stemming from the lack of accommodation and basic public infrastructure, Nusantara hosted its first Independence Day ceremony. Many Indonesians assumed that future celebrations would be held there. This Sunday (Aug 17), however, the ceremony to mark Indonesia's 80th year of independence will return to familiar territory: Jakarta's Merdeka Palace. President Prabowo Subianto's decision not to host celebrations in Nusantara, coupled with other moves that observers say signal a muted interest in the capital relocation, has raised doubts about the East Kalimantan city's future in the minds of observers and various political parties. Placing Nusantara on the backburner could spell backlash for Prabowo ahead of the 2029 presidential election by creating a rift with his predecessor Joko 'Jokowi' Widodo, observers said. It could also hurt investor confidence in the project, observers said. Taking into account Indonesia's recent deployment of a modern short-range ballistic missile system in East Kalimantan that would help safeguard Nusantara from a range of threat scenarios, experts told CNA that only time will tell if the capital relocation takes place as planned. CONTROVERSIAL TO BEGIN WITH In 2019, Jokowi mooted the idea to move Indonesia's administrative centre, arguing that Jakarta's crippling traffic congestion, regular flooding, polluted air and sinking land surface made it no longer fit to be the nation's capital. A new city needed to be built somewhere in Kalimantan, the Indonesian portion of Borneo, that was free of natural disasters and geographically positioned near the literal centre of the country, he said. Jokowi also hoped relocating the capital would correct the deep economic imbalance between the archipelago's well-developed western provinces and its long-neglected eastern frontiers. But the project struggled to win the hearts and minds of many Indonesians and criticism poured in from multiple fronts even before the project broke ground in 2022. Environmentalists warned of irreparable damage to Kalimantan's delicate rainforest ecosystem. Indigenous communities worried that they might be displaced or have their traditional way of life impacted. Experts questioned the viability of pumping tens of billions of dollars into a project that might not yield the promised returns. Tellingly, the very people meant to bring the new capital to life, Jakarta's civil servants, were reluctant to relocate. A survey in 2019 showed that 94 per cent of public workers said that they would rather resign or apply for early retirement than move to the new city. Indonesia passed a law in 2022 which serves as a basis for the construction of a new capital as well as a guideline on how the new capital should be managed and designed. The law, however, stipulates that when the move will commence is to be detailed further in a presidential decree, which hasn't been signed by the president, despite expectations that it would be done shortly after Prabowo was sworn into office last October. 'Prabowo realised that the project is quite controversial and public support for the project is not all that great,' Siti Zuhro, a political expert at the Indonesian Research and Innovation Agency (BRIN), told CNA. This means there is little public pressure for the president to move the capital any time soon. Meanwhile, Prabowo has other things in mind. 'Prabowo's vision is to build economic resilience from the ground up. That's why he has programmes like establishing village cooperative s and poverty alleviation initiatives like the free meal programme,' Siti said. Prabowo's plan to develop 80,000 cooperatives in almost every rural area across Indonesia comes with a US$25 billion price tag while the free meal initiative is expected to cost Indonesian taxpayers US$7 billion annually. Prabowo's other programmes include free health checks, free boarding schools for low income families and building one million affordable homes annually. His approach is very different from that of Jokowi, who believed that economic development could be achieved through megaprojects, Siti said. 'The current government clearly wants to prioritise its own programmes ... which also require a massive amount of funds at the expense of legacy programmes from the previous administration,' said Adi Prayitno, a political expert from Jakarta's Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University. IMPACT ON INVESTORS The hefty price tags of these programmes meant there was less for the Nusantara project. While Jokowi poured 89 trillion rupiah (US$5.5 billion) into Nusantara's development between 2022 and 2024, Prabowo has pledged only 48.8 trillion rupiah between 2025 and 2029. Government funding for the megaproject was put on hold between January and April this year as Prabowo introduced a series of austerity measures to free up billions of dollars needed for his flagship programmes and policies. Senior officials close to Prabowo had to reaffirm in recent weeks the government's commitment to relocate the capital by around 2029, after the National Democratic Party (NasDem) urged it to clarify its policy direction. NasDem, one of only two political parties outside of Prabowo's big-tent coalition, had called on the president to either speed up the issuance of the relocation decree, or suspend the project entirely. Meanwhile, a coalition member, the National Awakening Party, called for the project not to be 'left idle for too long', while the Democratic Party – also part of the coalition – said development could be accelerated by having some ministries begin to operate there. During a parliamentary hearing on Jul 30, Basuki Hadimuljono, head of the Nusantara Capital Authority, said his office has completed 'phase one' of Nusantara construction and will soon be moving to 'phase two'. Phase one of the project includes building a presidential palace, offices for 15 ministries and 47 apartment towers for thousands of civil servants. It also includes basic infrastructure like fresh water supply, a sanitation system and electricity supply. Basuki said for the second phase, his office will start working on offices for the parliamentary and judiciary branches of the government along with 97 apartment towers and a solar farm. This phase is expected to be completed in 2029. In total, there are five phases planned stretching all the way to 2045, Indonesia's 100th year celebration. State Secretary Minister Prasetyo Hadi said on Aug 4 that Prabowo is still committed to 'building Nusantara as fast as possible' after he announced this year's Independence Day celebration would be in Jakarta. Prabowo, he said, is waiting for the completion of buildings for all branches of the government before signing a decree formalising the capital's move. 'Based on our estimate, over the next three years all the facilities needed to run the functions of a government, be they executive, legislative and judiciary, will be completed. These are the facilities which we feel must be available before the president signs a decree on moving the capital,' the minister said. But the lack of investors remains an obstacle, observers said. The government wanted private investors to foot most of the US$35 billion cost to build Nusantara from the ground up. But as of April, only 42 companies, mostly Indonesia-based, agreed to put money in Nusantara and build schools, hospitals and other facilities worth a total of US$3.8 billion. There are investors who have pledged to contribute to the project but have not signed any formal agreement, let alone begin construction. Among them is Prabowo's brother Hashim Djojohadikusumo, who promised to build a US$330 million water treatment and distribution network. Hashim made the pledge in 2022 but there is no sign yet that the project is moving forward. On Aug 2, Hashim announced that his company, Arsari Group, would be supplying water to the nearby city of Balikpapan instead but told reporters he is still ready to extend his water network to Nusantara if needed. 'Investors would want a guarantee that the capital move will indeed happen. That (guarantee) can come in the form of a decree formalising the capital move or the government putting in more money to show just how serious they are,' said Djayadi Hanan, executive director of think-tank Indonesian Survey Institute (LSI). 'But none of this is happening right now.' Any significant change in plans for Nusantara will hurt investor confidence, he said. 'Investors will be more careful about putting money in Indonesia because backing away from a project of this magnitude sends a message that Indonesia is not a place where policies are consistent and commitments are honoured,' Djayadi said. A positive signal, military experts recently told CNA, is Indonesia's deployment of the recently-purchased KHAN short-range ballistic missile system in East Kalimantan, near the future capital. Although Indonesia has not confirmed the deployment is related to the capital move, military experts said the location would make it ideal for defending one of Indonesia's most important shipping routes and the future seat of government from a range of threat scenarios including potential long-range precision missile strikes. NEW CAPITAL OR 'GHOST TOWN'? Delaying the relocation to Nusantara will have political implications for Prabowo in terms of his relationship with Jokowi and his proximity to Indonesia's political elites, experts said. Unless all of the parties in his coalition agree to move their headquarters from Jakarta to the new capital, moving to Nusantara would keep Prabowo away from the de facto political centre of Indonesia, they noted. Prabowo cannot afford to stay too far from his circle of political elites if he wants to run for re-election in 2029, but delaying the move would mean displeasing his political patron Jokowi, who still has legions of loyal supporters, they said. 'Prabowo rose to power because of Jokowi's support, which led many of Jokowi's fans to vote for Prabowo. If Prabowo can show that he can be as popular as Jokowi through his populist programmes, he might go against Jokowi's wishes and not move the capital,' Hendri Satrio, a political expert from Jakarta's Paramadina University, told CNA. 'Prabowo has also appointed Jokowi's loyalists to strategic positions. So I think Prabowo's popularity in the eyes of Jokowi supporters will be maintained.' It is too early to say how Jokowi will react if Prabowo backtracks on his promise to continue the legacy project, Hendri said. One option is to have his son, current Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka, break away from Prabowo and contest the 2029 presidential election on his own. 'But of course (Jokowi) will make a political calculation of his own and see what the chances of Gibran defeating Prabowo in the election are - unless, of course, Prabowo decides to run with a different running mate,' Hendri said. Despite promises from Prabowo's camp to sign a decree once a parliamentary complex and court houses are completed, experts are still unsure if he will move the capital eventually. 'Prabowo could still argue that the new capital is not ready and more needs to be done,' said Adi of Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University. 'He has the final say and the criteria are completely subjective.' The future of Nusantara depends on what happens politically in the next three to four years, Hendri said. 'Will it truly become Indonesia's new capital or a ghost town? Only time will tell.'
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
War crimes likely committed in Syria's coastal massacres, UN commission says
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox FILE PHOTO: A drone view shows the predominantly Druze city of Sweida, following deadly clashes between Druze fighters, Sunni Bedouin tribes and government forces, in Syria July 25, 2025. REUTERS/Khalil Ashawi/File Photo GENEVA - War crimes were likely committed by interim government forces as well as by fighters loyal to Syria's former rulers during sectarian violence that culminated in a series of massacres in March, U.N. investigators said on Thursday. Some 1,400 people, mainly civilians, were reported killed during the violence in coastal areas that primarily targeted Alawites, and reports of violations such as abductions continue, according to a report by the U.N. Syria Commission of Inquiry. "The scale and brutality of the violence documented in our report is deeply disturbing," said Paulo Sérgio Pinheiro, Chair of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Syrian Arab Republic, in a statement released with the report. Murder, torture and inhumane acts related to the treatment of the dead were documented by the U.N. team, which based its 56-page report on more than 200 interviews with victims and witnesses as well as visits to three mass grave sites. Most victims were Alawite men aged between 20-50 but women, and children as young as one, were also killed, the report said. Sometimes the killers, who went door to door looking for members of Assad's minority Alawite sect, filmed the executions themselves, it said. Perpetrators were members of the interim government forces as well as private individuals operating or in proximity to them. Fighters loyal to the ousted Assad government also committed violations, it said. The report is not all-encompassing since incidents in Homs, Latakia and Tartus are still being investigated by the commission, set up by the U.N. Human Rights Council in 2011. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Bukit Merah fire: Residents relocated as town council carries out restoration works Singapore askST: What to do in the event of a fire at home Singapore Jalan Bukit Merah fire: PMD battery could have started fatal blaze, says SCDF Singapore askST: What are the fire safety rules for PMDs? Asia AirAsia flight from KL to Incheon lands at wrong airport in South Korea Opinion Could telco consolidation spell the end of attractive mobile plans? Singapore Change in law proposed to pave the way for public-private sector data sharing Singapore From quiet introvert to self-confident student: How this vulnerable, shy teen gets help to develop and discover her strength The incidents along the coast were the worst violence to hit Syria since the fall of President Bashar al-Assad last year, prompting the interim government to appoint a fact-finding committee. "The Syrian Arab Republic values these efforts and reaffirms its commitment to incorporating the recommendations into the ongoing process of institution-building and the consolidation of the rule of law in the new Syria," Foreign Minister Asaad Hassan al-Shibani said in a letter responding to the report, which it said aligned with its own findings. There was no immediate public comment from former Syrian officials, many of whom have left the country. U.S. Special Envoy for Syria Tom Barrack welcomed the report and said it was a "serious step" towards assessing responsibility for violations. The administration of President Donald Trump is gradually lifting Syria sanctions dating back to Assad's rule. A Reuters investigation last month found nearly 1,500 Syrian Alawites had been killed and identified a chain of command from the attackers directly to men who serve alongside Syria's new leaders. New Syrian President Ahmed al-Sharaa has previously denounced the violence as a threat to his mission to unite the country and promised to punish those responsible. The commission acknowledged in its report the commitment of Syria's interim authorities to identify those responsible but said the scale of the violence warranted further steps. "Guarantees of non-repetition of the violations should be at the heart of Syria's transition," the report said. REUTERS
