HC rejects Pune teacher's plea against FIR for posts against PM, country
The court held that contents of FIR and material on record 'constitute the ingredients of the alleged offences' and the plea with 'no merit' deserved to be dismissed.
In doing so, the Bombay HC said it was in 'agreement with the view' taken in the July 2 order of Allahabad HC that rejected bail plea of a man booked for objectionable posts against PM and armed forces.
The Bombay HC reiterated, 'it has become a fashion among certain groups of people to misuse social media in the garb of freedom of speech and expression by making baseless allegations against high dignitaries, posting such material that creates hatred and disharmony among the people.'
It added, 'such action shows disrespect not only against the Prime Minister of the country but also against the Indian military and its officers.'
A division bench of Justices Ajey S Gadkari and Rajesh S Patil on Tuesday passed a verdict on plea by a 46-year-old woman from Pune, seeking quashing of an FIR lodged by Kalepadal police station in Pune on May 15.
She was booked for offences punishable under sections 152 (acts endangering sovereignty, unity, and integrity of India), 196 (promoting enmity between different groups on ground of religion, race etc), 197 (imputations, assertions prejudicial to national integration), 352 (intentional insult to provoke breach of peace) and 353 (statements conducing to public mischief) of the Bharatiya Nyay Sanhita (BNS), 2023.
The FIR alleged that the petitioner and complainant reside in the same housing society and were members of a women-only WhatsApp group of nearly 380 members. On May 7, the members praised the Indian armed forces for conducting Operation Sindoor, while the petitioner allegedly claimed that the group should not be used as a National News Channel.
Another member replied it was the time to show solidarity towards the nation, to which the petitioner allegedly reacted with a laughing emoji, leading to certain exchanges of messages. Subsequently, as per FIR, she posted messages against PM and the country, based on which FIR was lodged.
Advocate Harshad Sathe said his client was not in a sound condition during exchange of messages and she deleted the same as soon as she realised reactions of other members and had apologised to the complainant. Sathe argued that the 'petitioner is already at a loss' being expelled from the school and an FIR without merit should be quashed and set aside.
The HC observed that the petitioner was a 'well educated' person and though she tendered her apology to the complainant, 'innumerable damage has already been caused' by her already circulated messages. It also referred to 'unrest in local areas' after her messages, resulting in people approaching the local police station in groups.
The court said that it was expected of a 'prudent person,' and 'well educated' petitioner teacher to consider 'pros and cons' before posting such messages and her defence that she had realised the messages being 'controversial' and were posting them due to 'deranged mental condition will not be helpful.'
The court said her 'intention becomes an essential ingredient to be judged with the kind of language she has used for India, more particularly when the whole country was feeling proud of our army' and 'she could have probably avoided reacting with a laughing emoji.'
The HC added the woman did not respond to allegations made in notice sent by police and as chargesheet is yet to be filed in the case, FIR cannot be quashed at this stage.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
2 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
BJP, Congress trade barbs as Rahul says economy is dead
Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi's claim on Thursday that mirrored US president Donald Trump's statement that the Indian economy is 'dead ' triggered a war of words with the ruling BJP, which said that the world recognizes India's achievements even as Gandhi tried to run it down. BJP, Congress trade barbs as Rahul says economy is dead 'Yes, he (Trump) is right, Everybody knows this except the Prime Minister and the Finance Minister. Everybody knows that the Indian economy is a dead economy. I am glad that President Trump has stated a fact... The entire world knows that the Indian economy is a dead economy...,' Gandhi told journalists outside Parliament. Later on, in a post on X , he listed his criteria for his view on the state of the Indian economy. Trump's overnight comments were made in the context of India and Russia's bilateral trade. After imposing a 25% tariff on Indian exports to the US and an additional penalty for buying Russian oil, Trump said on Truth Social: 'I don't care what India does with Russia. They can take their dead economies down together, for all I care…' . He also alleged that tariffs in India are 'too high' and 'among the highest in the world'. Union Culture and Tourism Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat slammed Gandhi for his comments. 'Contrary to your political career, Rahul Gandhi, India's economy is not dead — it is fully alive and moving forward with strong momentum,' he said. In his statement, Shekhawat said that during the tenure of the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government India was counted among the 'Fragile Five' countries, and today India is now counted among the 'Robust Five'. 'India's economy is not only setting new standards of stability and growth, but it is also firmly moving towards becoming the world's third-largest economy,' he added. Sambit Patra, a Lok Sabha lawmaker of the BJP, said on X, 'Rahul Gandhi has crossed all limits—publicly endorsing Donald Trump's slur that India is a 'dead economy'. Whose side is he really on?' 'While the world recognises India's aspiration, achievement, and wellbeing, Rahul Gandhi seems intent on running it down. IMF just upgraded India's growth forecast: 6.9% for 2025, the fastest among major economies.. World Bank calls India the 'standout growth story' of the decade. Inflation is at a 6-year low. PMI is at a 17.5-year high. Rahul Gandhi is attempting to chip away at India's collective spirit of its ambition & achievements but he's simply out of sync with a nation chasing its dreams with determination. Shameful!!' Patra said. While no other senior Congress leader commented on Trump's statement, party leader Jairam Ramesh said that the Indian economy has never really recovered from the twin shocks of a 'bizarre demonetisation' and a fundamentally flawed 'GST' (goods andservices tax) . 'The growth rate of the Indian economy will simply not accelerate with current levels of private corporate investment and current levels of private consumption. The Modi government's own policies are responsible for this twin deficit,' he said Congress MP Rajiv Shukla, however, took a different position and told the media, 'It is incorrect for Trump to say that the Indian economy is dead.' Shukla added that economic reforms were ushered in by the Narsimha Rao government and the UPA government and the current government has taken more steps. 'In no way, our economy is weak,' he said Parliamentary affairs minister Kiren Rijiju cited Shukla's comment and said on X, 'Now, a senior Congress leader Rajiv Shukla ji is also speaking in our country's favour! Indian economy will never be dead.' Calling the Leader of the Opposition , or LoP, an 'LoB' -- 'Leader Opposing Bharat'-- former Union minister and BJP MP Anurag Thakur said, 'Rahul Gandhi's job is only to oppose India. Anyone from around the world makes an anti-India statement, Rahul catches hold of it and starts speaking without thinking... The most popular leader in the world is PM Modi. Perhaps this is what Rahul Gandhi cannot digest, because he has only seen the 'lost decade of opportunities'. In Rahul Gandhi's language, the 'dead decade of opportunities'...'
Hindustan Times
2 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Trump increases tariff on Canada to 35% from 25%
U.S. President Donald Trump on Thursday signed an executive order increasing tariffs on Canadian goods to 35% from 25% on all products not covered by the U.S.-Mexico-Canada trade agreement, the White House said. US President Donald Trump announced a 25 per cent, plus a penalty, on Indian goods on Wednesday. (AP) Goods transshipped to another country to evade the new tariffs will be subject to a transshipment levy of 40%, according to a White House fact sheet. The increased tariff, which the White House said was the result of Canada's "continued inaction and retaliation," comes after Trump told reporters that Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney reached out ahead of an August 1 tariff deadline, but no conversations between the two took place. Trump has warned that any country that does not strike a deal with the U.S. before Friday will be subjected to higher tariffs imposed on goods. "We haven't spoken to Canada today. He's (Carney) called and we'll, we'll see," Trump told reporters during an event at the White House before the 35% rate was announced. Carney's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The Canadian leader previously said trade talks with Washington had been constructive, but the talks may not conclude by the deadline. Talks between the two countries were at an intense phase, he added, but a deal that would remove all U.S. tariffs was unlikely. Earlier on Thursday, Trump said it would be "very hard" for the U.S. and Canada to strike a deal after Ottawa moved toward recognizing Palestinian statehood. He said later on Thursday, however, that he did not view the move as "a deal breaker" in trade talks. "Well, they have to pay a fair rate - that's all. It's very simple. They have been charging very, very high tariffs to our farmers, some over 200% and they've been treating our farmers very badly," Trump said when asked about negotiations. He added that while he loves Canada, it has treated the United States "very badly" for years. U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said Trump could reconsider the tariff if Carney 'starts turning on the charm and if he takes off his retaliation.'
The Hindu
2 minutes ago
- The Hindu
In Gurugram, silence in the service lanes
Gurugram's smart buildings with glass facades don't reflect the reality of thousands of people living in their shadows. Off Golf Course Road, the city's most desired and expensive real estate, jhuggi-jhopri clusters are sprawled across several acres like a patchwork quilt in and around Sector 53. A fresh spell of rain in the afternoon has turned the narrow alleys into slippery, muddy roads. The air is heavy with the stench of rotting garbage, open sewage, and human waste. For those who live in one of the many 'luxury' homes advertised on hoardings, it is stomach-churning. For the people who have built homes here, it is a matter of survival. The shanties have somehow left space for labyrinthine paths, each house cobbled together from rusty tin sheets and tattered plastic. Many of the houses are now locked, their occupants having fled the city. In shanty no. 128, Nasira Bibi, 34, her hair prematurely grey, says her daily commute to work is filled with dread these days. The police may detain her, she fears, and take her to a holding centre for questioning. Her fears intensified after her maternal uncle, Nasimuddin, a 48-year-old from Murshidabad in West Bengal, and a neighbour, a man in his late 20s, were picked up by the police 10 days ago while returning from work in the afternoon. 'They were let off only after four days of questioning,' she says. Behind the buzzing corporate corridors, where it is business as usual, the Gurugram police have launched a large-scale verification drive aimed at identifying and deporting Bangladeshi nationals staying illegally in the city. As part of this operation, four community centres — one each in Gurugram's Sector 40 and Sector 10A, Badshahpur, and Manesar's Sector 1 — were converted into special holding centres on July 18 as per an order from the office of the District Magistrate. The order refers to a missive from the Union Home Ministry (Foreign Branch) dated May 2 that outlined the standard operating procedure for States to deport Bangladeshi nationals and Rohingya persons. Residents of the city's shanties say anyone who speaks in Bengali fears being picked up for questioning. This has triggered an exodus of Bengali-speaking migrants. Nasira says people are fleeing even if they possess all the documents required to prove their Indian citizenship. 'They usually leave under the cover of night to avoid being caught or harassed by the police,' she says. 'This morning, we woke up to find that two more families in our neighbourhood had vanished.' Most of the Bengali-speaking people who live in the shanties hail from Assam and West Bengal. They predominantly work as service support staff in offices and homes, on construction sites to build the ever-expanding city, and as gig workers in quick-service delivery businesses. The exodus of migrants in hordes from Gurugram to their home towns has caused a severe crunch of domestic workers and garbage collectors, leading to a sanitation crisis, affecting hundreds of households relying on their services. Nasira's employers in a housing society are worried. 'Madam ko kaafi chinta hai itna kachra kaun saaf karega agar hum log chale gaye. Darr se sab log ja rahe hain, toh nayi maid milna bhi mushkil hain (Madam is quite worried about who will clean up so much garbage if we leave. Everyone is leaving out of fear, so it is difficult to find a new domestic help),' she says. Around her is the cacophony of despair: the wailing of infants, barking of dogs, and the bickering of families. For an escape from this world, seemingly in a perpetual state of chaos, a person must simply walk a few hundred metres to the quickly flooding main road, where a luxury car tries to zip through a traffic snarl. The Gurugram police are yet to disclose the number of people they have detained during the drive. However, Assistant Sub-Inspector Sandeep Kumar, Gurugram Police spokesperson, says detentions were carried out based on 'intelligence' and the detainees were let off only after their credentials as Indian citizens were established through background checks by the office of the District Magistrate. 'So far, 10 Bangladeshi nationals staying here illegally have been identified and will be deported,' he says. Fleeing in fear Pointing at two tarpaulin-covered trucks parked on the roadside near the shanties, Mohammad Ismail, 66, says the vehicles carried the belongings of over 200 families that left the city by buses and trains. 'People are leaving even if they have valid documents. No one wants to get into trouble. Even those working in the city for decades have hurriedly left,' he says, adding that his friend who ran a meat kiosk was taken away by the police a week ago. 'He had been running the meat shop for several years. His family lives in Delhi. His wife and relatives came to Gurugram when they learnt about his detention. But the police have not released him yet,' he says. Ahsan Qureshi, in his mid-40s, from Nadia in West Bengal, sits on a wooden counter outside a now-closed meat shop, observing that while people living in jhuggis have faced several demolition drives before, the current situation is different. 'The police's random detentions have sparked widespread fear. The circulation of videos showing police brutality on social media is exacerbating this fear among poor migrants,' he says. Qureshi emphasises that many residents, including him, possess documents to prove their Indian citizenship: identity cards, mark sheets, and land records. He suggests a more orderly process, like a police camp where people could present their documents, so that those who may not have them readily available are allowed time to arrange for them. 'Verification drives are routine,' he notes. 'But this time, the police are taking people straight to detention centres without even asking for documents.' This is why the fear is heightened, says a man sitting beside him. Nasira's uncle Nasimuddin says his four-day experience at the detention centre in Badshahpur was 'not so bad'. He says the police picked him up on July 19 while he was on his way home from work with a friend. During his detention, he was given food and tea, and did not face any physical abuse. Nasimuddin had moved to Gurugram four months ago to work in the housekeeping department of a shopping mall. He is a trained mason, but ill health now prevents him from carrying out this work. His wife is a domestic help in an apartment complex. To supplement their income, he also cleans toilets in some houses in the evening. Though senior police officers remain tight-lipped, sources say special teams were constituted in each police station to carry out the raids, especially at jhuggi-jhopri clusters inhabited by Bengali-speaking migrants. 'The raids are being carried out for more than a month now, though the detention centres were set up only a week ago. The raids are mostly conducted late at night or in the early hours of the morning,' says a constable, who is posted at the Pataudi police station and has been part of these special teams. Residents don't resist A couple residing at Regency Park-I, Sector 43, says their domestic help and car washer suddenly left to return to their native place in Assam. Despite undergoing the police verification process two years ago when they were hired, the recent crackdown had instilled fear in them. The police verification process is a standard procedure that confirms whether the address mentioned on an individual's Aadhaar card matches their actual place of residence. According to the couple, many housing societies have made this verification compulsory for domestic workers and other staff. The couple claims that their staff informed them about a late-night police raid on their colony in Chakkarpur village, during which some migrant workers were taken away. Their landlord had also asked tenants from Assam and West Bengal to vacate, prompting their decision to leave. Abhey Poonia, senior vice president of the Gurgaon Citizens' Council, an umbrella organisation of over 80 resident welfare associations (RWAs), says many domestic workers, car washers, and garbage collectors left their jobs over the past few days. 'About 80% of domestic workers and garbage collectors have disappeared,' he says. 'Door-to-door garbage collection has stopped. Now, municipal vehicles collect trash from outside our societies every three to four days.' Despite the inconvenience, Poonia states that the council backs the initiative. Sushant Lok-II RWA president Pawan Yadav echoes his views. 'Residents are finding it difficult to manage household chores and dispose of waste, but we support the verification drive. It should have been done earlier,' he says. A contractor, who was hired by the Municipal Corporation of Gurugram for door-to-door waste collection, segregation, and composting, says half of his employees have fled the city after the verification drive was launched. 'Waste collection came to a halt for four to five days, but we supported our men while they were held in detention centres and helped them get the verification done. We have asked those who have left to send their documents for verification to us. We hope that they will return soon,' the contractor says, adding that more than three-fourths of people engaged in garbage collection belong to Assam and West Bengal; the rest are from Bihar. 'There were some instances initially where police personnel in plain clothes beat up migrants in the name of verification. They extorted money from them. Employers left them to fend for themselves. It created a sense of fear, causing the exodus,' says the contractor, who did not wish to be identified. The police, however, vehemently deny the allegations of physical abuse and extortion. Community voices Ainul Sekh, in his 50s, who stays in a single room with his wife and two adult children in Sector 15, says he works as a security guard at a college in Sector 14, but is scared to commute to work. His family had moved to Gurugram in 2012 in search of work and better education for the children. He says purported videos of migrant workers being beaten up by the police have filled him with fear. 'I don't know whether those videos are fake or real, but I'm scared. My son works as a delivery boy. For the past two days, we have told him not to leave the house.' Sekh says they have all the required documents to prove that they are citizens of India. 'There are no jobs in West Bengal. Can't we work in our own country?' says Beauty Bibi, his wife, who works as a domestic help. Barsha, in his 40s, who runs a meat shop in Chakkarpur's machhi mandi (fish market), says police teams had come to the area to verify documents, but did not pick up anyone. 'Most Bengalis in Gali No. 5 are Hindus, so they have nothing to fear,' he says. Though the drive has reportedly de-escalated over the past few days and some holding centres are empty, it has drawn criticism on a few counts. Congress MLA from Nuh and former Haryana Transport Minister Aftab Ahmed says the 'inhuman treatment' meted out to Bengali-speaking people from West Bengal and Assam, mostly Muslims, is 'shameful'. He alleges that people employed in Gurugram for years and engaged in menial jobs were beaten up and packed into vehicles like animals in order to be taken away to detention centres. He claims that in a few cases, including one in Faridabad's Ankhir, the police demanded money from some migrant workers in exchange for their release. 'Earlier, Muslims were not allowed to offer Friday prayers in Gurugram. Now, the local police are doing what Raj Thackeray's party (Maharashtra Navnirman Sena) is doing to Hindi-speaking Indian citizens in Maharashtra,' he says. Ahmed clarifies that he is not against the verification drive, but says an environment of fear is being created by the Haryana government to force migrants out of the State. The State's Trade Union Council in a memorandum to the Deputy Commissioner of Gurugram said picking up Bengal-speaking people in the name of verification, 'collecting money from them, keeping their documents in custody, and not giving any kind of information to their family members' are actions that constitute a blatant violation of human rights. In a press release, it stated, 'We have also come to know that most of the people who come in plain clothes to pick up people arrive in vehicles without registered number plates. Are they police personnel or someone else? This is a matter of serious concern. As a result, a large number of poor labourers are migrating out of fear.' Idrish Ali, in his late 50s, a tea stall owner in Carterpuri village, says, 'Hundreds of families are waiting for their monthly wages to be cleared by the first week of August before they too leave. The city might see another wave of exodus soon.' Ali, who came to Gurugram from West Bengal in 1998 in search of a better life, says, 'My brother has just reached Bengal.' For him, Gurugram is home. Edited by Sunalini Mathew
