Report on CEO pay at commercial state bodies hits out at lack of ‘cost of living adjustments'
A REPORT REVIEWING the pay of CEOs at commercial state bodies such as RTÉ, ESB, and Uisce Éireann has hit out at a lack of 'cost of living adjustments'.
The report
also called for the reintroduction of bonuses, which were paused in 2011.
The report is in response to a request last year from the Department of Public Expenditure to carry out a review of the remuneration arrangements for CEOs at commercial state bodies (CSBs).
Since 2011 there has been no systematic review of CEO pay, any increase in salary since that time has taken place on a case-by-case basis.
The Senior Posts Remuneration Committee in its report concluded that the current remuneration 'is not optimal in serving the interests of the CSB, the State or the taxpayer'.
The Committee said CEO packages at CSBs have 'fallen out of alignment with the market', with 'no adjustments for cost of living, significant changes to the role, or to the size or nature of the business'.
It added that this 'inflexible fixed-point salary model does not reflect market trends'.
The Committee called for CEO pay to 'recognise and reward performance, and attract the best prospective candidates into the future'.
This would include the reintroduction of bonuses, which were paused in 2011, to a limit of 25% of the CEO's basic salary.
Advertisement
It also called for 'sufficient headroom' between the pay of CEOs and the executive-level team.
However, the report did note that pensions arrangements and annual leave allowances for CEOs of CSBs are 'generally more generous than arrangements in place for comparable organisations in the private sector'.
Survey results show that the median employer pension contribution rate is 25%, while the median annual leave entitlement for CEOs is 30 days.
The Committee said the pay package for CEO should 'take account' of the superior value of pensions and annual leave allowance.
It has recommended a CEO salary range of 80-120% of the market median for each respective band.
Finance Minister Jack Chambers said the report 'raised a number of vital issues which are currently being faced by our Commercial State Bodies at leadership level'.
'In the coming years many CSB CEOs will be required to deliver significant projects whilst managing the funding and financing of these projects,' said Chambers.
He said the Government has agreed 'an approach to address a number of the issues raised in the report' and that thus 'new approach' will bring a 'more structured and consistent process' to CEO remuneration.
He said a banded salary structure will be implemented for CEOs ranging from their current salary to the market median.
He added that there will be no backdating of any changes to pay and that any salary proposals or changes will be 'subject to governance and scrutiny, with approval required by the relevant Minister, and with my consent'.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
2 days ago
- The Journal
Dozens of politicians' print requests refused, including 2,000-page document for Simon Harris
TDS AND SENATORS have had dozens of print jobs refused by the Oireachtas over the last few years. Politicians at Leinster House are entitled to have tens of thousands of items printed for free every year to help promote their work. However, a strict policy is in place that covers only 'parliamentary duties' and not material related to elections, political parties, or fellow candidates. Between 2022 and 2024, a total of 125 print jobs were rejected by the Oireachtas for a variety of different reasons. Records released under FOI show that Fianna Fáil were behind more than half the refused batches – 67 in total. Fine Gael had 22 print jobs refused, Labour 11 and Sinn Féin 8; there were also lower numbers recorded for other smaller groupings or Independents. High-profile political figures were among those who had printing rejected with three jobs refused for Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers. Little detail was provided on the reasons why, with Oireachtas records simply saying they were not in line with the 'service level agreement.' Both Tánaiste Simon Harris and Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan had a single print job refused. Harris' 2,000-page-print job was rejected as outside the bounds of the 'service level agreement' while Mr O'Callaghan's newsletter was declined due to 'overtelectioneering.' Advertisement Former Taoiseach Leo Varadkar also had a 5,000-batch constituency update refused during 2023 – it was simply marked 'rejected' in the Oireachtas files with no further information provided. There were other reasons for refusal too with one newsletter denied because it breached rules about the promotion of a business. A note said this was based on: 'Material which is or could be construed as being related to or promoting a private commercial endeavour, for example a newsletter which promotes, whether directly or indirectly, a company, business or product.' Another was refused because it was considered to be promotion of a political party. It said that was covered by rules covering a ban on 'political party/independent members' corporate material e.g. headquarter type printing, such as application forms for party membership; material which is either directly or indirectly aimed at party fundraising; information notes to party members.' Other jobs were rejected for more banal reasons including faulty file types, defective documents, and one case where a senator exceeded their monthly printing allowance. One job for a batch of 1,500 printed leaflets was refused because it contained information on an upcoming referendum. A note on the file said: 'It is the responsibility of the members and qualifying political parties to ensure that items printed in the printing facility that could be said to be designed to influence voters on how to vote in a Referendum are not distributed after the passage of a [bill].' Fianna Fáil's John Lahart, who had four separate jobs refused, said: 'I don't remember the specific ones offhand, but it often relates to materials about councillors. 'We have had generic material sent back and generally where that might be about the Fianna Fáil team in our area and they would have come back and said that wasn't allowed.' Under Leinster House's printing policy, jobs can also be declined where they have information that could be considered a crime or encouraging others to commit a crime. However, there were no refusals under that section according to the documents that were released. Asked about the records, the Oireachtas said it had no further comment to make. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
3 days ago
- Irish Times
Provision of almost 1,000 extra prison places to be fast-tracked
The construction of almost 1,000 new prison places is being fast-tracked, as the Republic's overcrowding crisis worsens, under a plan Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan is to present to Cabinet on Wednesday. He believes a new arrangement, specifically for construction projects to increase capacity at several jails, agreed with Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers , will reduce the delivery timelines by between 12 and 18 months. The agreement has been reached as the number of prisoners being released early, to make space in overcrowded jails for new committals, was continuing to increase. The Irish Times recently revealed the number of prisoners in Mountjoy Prison, Dublin, had exceed 1,000 for the first time , including more than 100 men sleeping on the prison floors. Overall, the prison system is permanently far above 100 per cent capacity. READ MORE A shooting incident in Carlow town last weekend, during which gunman Evan Fitzgerald died, has also renewed calls for the granting of bail to be restricted, which would exert further pressure on the system. Fitzgerald (22), from Carlow, was on bail, having been charged with firearms and explosives offences last year. Mr O'Callaghan has secured permission for some of the construction projects at the jails to bypass the initial approval stage of the State's infrastructure guidelines, which are designed to provide oversight of public investment projects and ensure value for money. He believes the track record of the Irish Prison Service in delivering big projects on time and within budget means it will responsibly manage the works at six prisons, with oversight from the Department of Justice. The projects include construction works to create 180 extra spaces at the Midlands Prison, Portaloise, 150 extra spaces at Mountjoy and 330 at the old Cork Prison. The department believes the new fast-tracking, for 960 new spaces, will result in delivery times being shortened by at least 12 months for all of the projects and by up to 18 months in some. Meanwhile, there are to be changes to the Defective Concrete Blocks Grant Scheme under proposals to be brought to Cabinet by Minister for Housing James Browne . Concrete blocks containing excess mica and pyrite minerals caused defects in some 7,000 properties in Donegal, Mayo, Limerick, Clare and Sligo. Families affected by mica in Donegal are facing huge bills as talks with the Government over redress have stalled. Video: Enda O'Dowd The Government introduced the defective blocks scheme to fund remediation of the homes several years ago. The maximum sum on offer was increased from €420,000 to €460,000 last October. However, under the current law, this increase applies only to eligible homeowners that are yet to receive a determination in relation to a remediation option and grant amount. Similarly, the per square metre rates that are used in the scheme to calculate the grant amount were increased in November by between 7.4 per cent and 8.7 per cent. Mr Browne will seek Cabinet approval for the priority drafting of a Bill that will ensure the increased grant cap, and rates will apply retrospectively to more homeowners affected by construction cost increases who incurred eligible costs since March 29th, 2024. In another development, Ministers are expected to be updated on proposals to relax planning rules on cabins and modular homes in back gardens . The proposals being developed by Minister of State for Planning John Cummins would allow such structures to be exempt from planning permission. Mr Browne is to tell Ministers that an interdepartmental consultation on the plan is 'substantially complete' and there will be public consultation this month. Updated exempted development regulations are expected to follow. The intention is for the measure to be introduced this year.
Irish Examiner
3 days ago
- Irish Examiner
Justice minister to accelerate building of nearly 1,000 prison spaces across the country
A plan to build nearly 1,000 more prison spaces before the end of the decade is to be accelerated, the justice minister will tell Cabinet today. Jim O'Callaghan will inform ministers that the Irish Prison Service can deliver 150 additional spaces at Castlerea, 180 at the Midlands Prison, 50 spaces at the Dóchas Centre women's prison, 100 at Wheatfield, and 150 at Mountjoy — all 12 months ahead of schedule. Meanwhile, the rebuild of the Old Cork Prison site will see 230 additional male spaces and 100 for women. That facility is due to finish at the beginning of 2031. Jim O'Callaghan has engaged with public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers to allow for the acceleration of prison projects — reducing delivery timelines by up to 18 months in some cases. The Minister will inform government that the prison estate as a whole is currently operating at 115% over capacity with a new record high of 5,394 in prison in mid-April — an 11% rise in 12 months and over 1,100 more people in prison than in January 2023. Overcrowding creates "an increasing level of risk for the Irish Prison Service, its staff and the people in its custody including rises in assaults, pressure on all ancillary services, threats to staff safety, and insufficient capacity to respond effectively to emergencies", he is set to tell cabinet. He also intends to introduce an electronic tagging pilot programme in the coming months. Meanwhile, housing minister James Browne will bring to cabinet a memo updating ministers on the progress of plans to exempt modular homes in existing gardens. Planning minister John Cummins has been pursuing changes to provide exemptions for detached cabin or modular-style structures at the back of properties. Currently, planning exemptions are in place for a 40sq m extension that is attached to a property. Cabinet will hear that an interdepartmental consultation is "substantially complete" with 11 government departments making submissions. A public consultation will take place this month and finalisation of exempted developments regulations will follow. Sources said that the plan would increase the ability to "expand and improve existing planning exemptions" and it is understood that the review has identified areas that are in need of updating to enable the quicker delivery of certain education, health, and utility infrastructure. Minister for social protection Dara Calleary will announce the expansion of the Wage Subsidy Scheme which aims to help more disabled people get and retain jobs. Enterprise minister Peter Burke will also tell Cabinet that he is setting up a new group with the sole aim of reducing the cost of running a business. The Cost of Business Advisory Forum will hold its first meeting on June 11 and will bring together business owners, retailers, tourism operators, accounting professionals and representative groups—alongside regulators and state agencies. Also at Cabinet, minister for higher Education James Lawless will request cabinet note his plans to launch a further call for applications under the Technological Sector and Specialist Colleges Enhancement Fund (TEF) which funds initiatives aimed at developing Technological Universities (TU's), Institutes of Technology (IOTs) and publicly-funded specialist colleges.
