logo
Pay for play: How DJs, donors and dharma fuel India's outcome obsession

Pay for play: How DJs, donors and dharma fuel India's outcome obsession

Time of India04-05-2025
'What gets measured gets managed,' noted Peter Drucker wisely, In the world of projects, infrastructure and government schemes, measurement and management is difficult. The challenge lies in effectively measuring outcomes to ensure resources are allocated efficiently and lead to meaningful impacts.
#Pahalgam Terrorist Attack
India much better equipped to target cross-border terror since Balakot
India conducts maiden flight-trials of stratospheric airship platform
Pakistan shuts ports for Indian ships after New Delhi bans imports from Islamabad
Arthashastra, Chankaya's 4th c. BCE treatise on statecraft and economic policy, prescribed results-linked rewards for state officials, ensuring efficiency and accountability. This was an early manifestation of today's
outcome-based financing
(OBF). Mahabharata mentions Yudhishthir's 'Rajasuya yajna', which allocated responsibilities and honours based on demonstrated contributions, mirroring modern principles of disbursement-linked indicators (DLI).
Even temple economies functioned on an outcome-driven model, where grants were contingent upon their societal impact, much like today's output-outcome monitoring framework (OOMF). The gurukul system also followed a performance-linked structure, where 'guru dakshina' of students was determined by the practical impact of their learning, a la today's programme-for-results (
PforR
) funding in education and skill development.
No doubt the terminology has evolved. But the fundamental concept remains the same: financial disbursements should be tied to measurable results. Today,
multilateral donor agencies
like
World Bank
,
Asian Development Bank
(ADB) and African Development Bank (AfDB) have embraced these principles, using OBF instruments to drive efficiency, accountability and sustainable impact across infrastructure and development projects.
OBF has been particularly successful in large-scale infra projects, where defined, tangible outcomes ensure that financing leads to real-world impact. Multilateral donor agencies increasingly rely on PforR, DLI and OOMF to ensure projects deliver on their promises.
Live Events
Take World Bank's PforR initiative in Tanzania, where financing has been directly linked to improved road quality, maintenance efficiency and rural connectivity. Funds are disbursed only when specific milestones, like length of roads upgraded, safety enhancements and improved access for local communities are achieved. This has minimised project delays, reduced corruption and ensured long-term sustainability.
Egypt's AfDB-backed urban transport modernisation programme deployed DLI-based financing to enhance metro expansion and integrate intelligent transport systems. By tying financial releases to milestones like improved passenger capacity, less travel time and emission reductions, the programme has led to significant upgradations in urban mobility.
In Brazil, results-based financing in water supply and sanitation infra has been instrumental in expanding pipeline networks and wastewater treatment facilities. Rather than disbursing funds based on project inputs, financial flows were tied to measurable improvements in water quality, service accessibility and sustainability indicators. This model has ensured that investments translate into real benefits for communities, rather than just fulfilling construction targets.
In India, under the World Bank-supported PforR in AMRUT 2.0 (Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation), funds were released to states based on achievements across indicators like universal water supply coverage, energy-efficient water systems and improved service-level benchmarks. The performance-based disbursement structure has encouraged states to prioritise outcomes over inputs, leading to faster implementation and enhanced citizen-centric results.
As governments face pressure to optimise resources and ensure value-for-money investments, integrating OBF into future transportation, energy, water and urban development projects is imperative. Applying this mechanism to social sector programmes requires a more nuanced and cautious approach. Unlike roads, bridges or power grids where results can be measured within a fixed timeline, social impact outcomes are often long-term, qualitative and influenced by multiple external factors.
In education, improvements in student learning, literacy rates or employability may take years, if not decades, to materialise. Similarly, in public health programmes, interventions aimed at reducing child malnutrition or improving maternal health require continuous, multi-year investments.
This poses a fundamental challenge for OBF mechanisms like PforR, which prioritise measurable, time-bound indicators. If not carefully designed, these models may promote short-termism, prioritising quick wins over long-term systemic change. An education programme tied to immediate improvements in test scores may lead to teaching-for-exam strategies, rather than fostering deep, conceptual learning.
National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 recognises such complexities, and emphasises outcome-oriented learning, foundational literacy and skill-based education. While not structured as an OBF programme, it lays the groundwork for
performance-linked financing
by promoting competency-based assessments and measurable learning outcomes. This alignment opens up opportunities to design future education programmes that balance long-term systemic reform with results-driven accountability.
To integrate OBF in the social sector, financing frameworks must be more flexible, incorporating qualitative assessments, longer evaluation horizons and mixed funding approaches that account for both immediate results and long-term impact.
Development institutions must also recognise that in healthcare, education and social protection, success is often incremental and dependent on behavioural and systemic shifts. As resources become increasingly linked to results, creating effective, inclusive and sustainable OBF models will be crucial for driving real change in communities.
Pachori is director, ministry of education, GoI, and Jha, is associate director, KPMG
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

DUSU polls to be held on September 18, results next day
DUSU polls to be held on September 18, results next day

The Hindu

time6 minutes ago

  • The Hindu

DUSU polls to be held on September 18, results next day

The Delhi University Students' Union (DUSU) polls will be held on September 18, DU Registrar Vikas Gupta announced in a notification on Wednesday. As per the notification, the last date for submitting nomination papers is September 10. On the same day, the list of duly nominated candidates will be published. The withdrawal of documents has been scheduled for September 11, and the final list will be issued on the same day. Polling will take place on September 18 and votes will be counted on September 19. The announcement comes amid protests by student outfits against the university's decision mandating that the candidates deposit a ₹1-lakh bond at the time of filing nomination promising not to deface public properties while campaigning. The ₹1-lakh bond is part of DU's anti-defacement measures, issued a year after the Delhi High Court came down heavily on the university for property defacement. Student groups, such as RSS-affiliated Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP), Congress-backed National Students' Union of India (NSUI) and Aam Aadmi Party's Association of Students for Alternative Politics (ASAP), have opposed the move and termed it 'undemocratic'. Earlier in the day, the ABVP submitted a memorandum to the university demanding the withdrawal of the bond. 'Imposing a ₹1-lakh bond to contest the elections is not only undemocratic but also a malicious attempt to limit the elections to only the affluent students,' it said. ABVP national media convener Harsh Attri said they held a meeting with the Registrar, and he assured them of 'looking into their demands'. Reviewing options: DU The Registrar told The Hindu that they are considering alternatives to the anti-defacement measure. 'We are in the process of looking into possible alternatives, such as a guarantee from students instead, after multiple requests from students. We had introduced the measure in pursuance of the Delhi High Court's recommendations,' he said. Terming the anti-defacement measure a 'Tughlaqi farman', Kuldeep Bidhuri, the Delhi unit president of ASAP, described it as a 'conspiracy to directly block middle-class students from contesting elections'. Meanwhile, the NSUI staged a demonstration on the campus demanding 12 days of menstrual leave per semester for women students.

West Bengal migrant worker repatriated from Bangladesh after family moves Calcutta HC
West Bengal migrant worker repatriated from Bangladesh after family moves Calcutta HC

The Hindu

time6 minutes ago

  • The Hindu

West Bengal migrant worker repatriated from Bangladesh after family moves Calcutta HC

Amir Sheikh, a 19-year-old migrant worker from Kaliachak in West Bengal's Malda district who was allegedly detained from Rajasthan in May and 'pushed back' into Bangladesh, was reunited with his family on Wednesday. Mr. Amir's family members said the Border Security Force (BSF) personnel handed him over to the Basirhat police in the State's North 24 Parganas district. Earlier this month, Ziyem Sheikh, the father of Mr. Amir, had filed a habeas corpus petition before the Calcutta High Court. The matter was heard before the Division Bench of Justices Tapabrata Chakraborty and Reetobroto Kumar Mitra. The counsel appearing for the BSF said Mr. Amir attempted to cross over to Indian territory on Tuesday and since he could not produce appropriate identification documents, he was apprehended and handed over to the officer in charge of the Basirhat police station. Speaking to The Hindu, his family contested the BSF's claims. 'I got a call this morning asking me to pick up my son from Basirhat. All this is happening because we approached the court,' Mr. Ziyem said. Refuting BSF's claims Trinamool Congress MP and chairperson of the West Bengal Migrant Welfare Board Samirul Islam also refuted the BSF's claims of the migrant worker 'inadvertently crossing the border'. He said an attempt was being made to 'cover up the pushing back of the migrant worker into Bangladesh by the BSF and the Union government by repatriating him'. 'Amir Sheikh from Kaliachak in Malda was deported to Bangladesh by the Rajasthan police with the help of the BSF. From the very beginning, we stood by his family. We helped Amir's father file a habeas corpus petition in the Calcutta High Court. Under pressure, the BSF has brought Amir back to West Bengal,' the MP said, adding that they even have the video Mr. Amir had recorded from Bangladesh. 'He was deported' 'We will legally prove that Amir was deported by the BSF and that he did not go there voluntarily,' Mr. Islam said. He also pointed out that the migrant worker was in the custody of Bangladeshi authorities and had the family not approached the court, he would have continued to languish in detention in the neighbouring country. The matter will come up for hearing on August 27. Hundreds of Bengali-speaking migrant workers have faced alleged detention and harassment in different States and asked to produce documents to prove they are not Bangladeshi nationals. Some migrant workers from West Bengal have claimed that they were 'pushed into' the neighbouring country but later repatriated with the help of Indian authorities.

IndiGo stands ready to resume flights to China: CEO Pieter Elbers
IndiGo stands ready to resume flights to China: CEO Pieter Elbers

Economic Times

time9 minutes ago

  • Economic Times

IndiGo stands ready to resume flights to China: CEO Pieter Elbers

IndiGo CEO Pieter Elbers announced the airline's readiness to resume direct flights between India and China, which were suspended due to the coronavirus pandemic in early 2020. Prior to the suspension, IndiGo operated daily flights from Delhi to Chengdu and Kolkata to Guangzhou. Negotiations between India and China are reportedly in an advanced stage to re-establish these direct air services. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads New Delhi: IndiGo CEO Pieter Elbers on Wednesday said the airline stands ready to resume direct flights between India and Tuesday, people familiar with the matter said India and China are in an "advanced stage" of negotiations to resume direct flights between the two countries said IndiGo operated daily flights between India and China prior to the coronavirus pandemic."The airline stands ready to resume these services as soon as bilateral arrangements between the two countries allow," he said in a statement on also said that guided by its entrepreneurial spirit, the airline remains committed to identifying and pursuing commercially viable was operating daily flights from Delhi to Chengdu till February 6, 2020, and from Kolkata to Guangzhou till February 1, flights were operational between the two countries till early 2020 before getting suspended due to the coronavirus pandemic. Both Indian and Chinese carriers had direct services remained suspended in view of the eastern Ladakh border India also had flights from Delhi to Shanghai, and those were also suspended in early January 27 this year, India and China in principle agreed to resume direct air services between the two countries as part of certain people-centric steps to "stabilise and rebuild" the bilateral ties.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store