
‘Then There Was One:' A Book Review
The book is set in the future. Humankind has spread into Space. Earth has been left behind but not forgotten. Planets have been terraformed, and humans are colonising deep space.
'The Pinnacle' is a reality TV game show that draws millions of viewers. It has a huge cash prize and will change the winner's life forever. It is also supposed to be non-lethal. Contestants are eliminated, but not eliminated .
The story is told from the viewpoint of three contestants, starting before they are taken to the game's secret location. Each of them has a burning desire to win the money, and a hinted-at secret. Two of the three are wealthy, with parents high up in the echelons of political power. The third, Raya, is a street kid on a mining planet, where the miners are exploited by their rich overlords.
The three join the other seven contestants and are taken to a beautiful desert island. Before filming starts the next morning, they're told to make themselves comfortable at a table laden with food. It's at that point that things start to go wrong.
This is a fun survival, cat-and-mouse thriller. One of the entrants to the Pinnacle dies from eating poisoned food at the banquet. Who was responsible? Was it one of the contestants or a sinister move by the TV production company? The teenagers in the show assume that people will arrive in the morning and help them out. Except they don't.
Instead, the bodies pile up. What is going on? Who is behind the killings, and what secrets are lying behind the eyes of the wannabe winners of The Pinnacle?
Discovering the answers to these questions makes Then There Was One a fun journey. There are some great tense set pieces, and as the field narrows, it is genuinely perplexing who the perpetrator is. If I had a criticism, I'd say that the novel lacks the depth of similar offerings. There's no burning social commentary here, much beyond 'rich people often aren't always very nice,' but not every book has to be deep. A compelling story is enough to make an entertaining read.
While the book doesn't have the visceral thrill of The Hunger Games , Wendy Cross has created a world with greater logical consistency. The dystopian regions of The Hunger Games always bugged me, but there is no such irritation here.
The denouement, when it comes, is a clever piece of misdirection, though the clues are there as we read through. And There Was One is a solid addition to a burgeoning genre. It's not going to redefine our expectations of what dystopian fiction can do, but it does deliver an intriguing mystery with an interesting conclusion.
If you would like to pick up a copy of Then There Was One, you can do so here in the US and here, in the UK. (Affiliate Links)
If you enjoyed this review, check out my other book reviews, here.
I received a copy of this book in order to write this review. Liked it? Take a second to support GeekDad and GeekMom on Patreon!
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CTV News
16 hours ago
- CTV News
Judge Frank Caprio, known for viral ‘Caught in Providence' series, dies at 88
In this Aug. 10, 2017 photo, Providence Municipal Court Judge Frank Caprio sits on the bench in Providence, Rhode Island. (AP Photo/Michelle R. Smith) American judge and reality TV star Frank Caprio has died at the age of 88, according to his official Facebook and Instagram accounts. 'Judge Frank Caprio passed away peacefully at the age of 88 after a long and courageous battle with pancreatic cancer,' according to a statement posted to his Instagram account. 'Beloved for his compassion, humility, and unwavering belief in the goodness of people, Judge Caprio touched the lives of millions through his work in the courtroom and beyond,' read the statement. 'His warmth, humor, and kindness left an indelible mark on all who knew him.' For nearly 40 years, Caprio served as a judge for the Providence Municipal Court, retiring in 2023. In his later years, he was known for his show 'Caught in Providence," which earned him multiple Daytime Emmy Award nominations. Caprio was affectionally known as the 'Nicest Judge in the World' after clips from his show went viral on TikTok. He held a significant online presence, with more than three million followers on Instagram and 1.6 million on TikTok.


Geek Dad
a day ago
- Geek Dad
Review – The New Gods #9: Betrayal on Earth
The New Gods #9 cover, via DC Comics. Ray: This series continues to be one of the most inventive DC is putting out right now, with a cosmos-and-eons-spanning take on the New Gods that covers the eras far beyond this one. The villains are getting ready to move on Earth, and a Green Lantern seeks to alert the heroes of the planet of what's coming. He's nearly caught – but gets an unexpected assist from Forager, who is leading his bug army against the resurgence of Apokalips' forces. After all, the bugs suffered as much as anyone across Darkseid's reign, and they're not letting that happen again. But back on Earth, as soon as the heroes get the alert, they prepare their secret weapon – Karim, the child rescued from Orion in India before the truce was carved out. Karim trusts his savior Scott Free, but he's also deeply traumatized and wants to be assured he won't have to fight. And that makes him deeply vulnerable to manipulation. War games. Via DC Comics. Of course, while the heroes don't know this, the forces of Apokalips are on Earth as well – and they've formed a pact with Maxwell Lord, who has been corrupted by Apokalips and is more than willing to sell out his own planet. And they have a mole within the New Gods – the trickster Serifan. As the New Gods ask Orion to take up Highfather's mantle, the son of Apokalips and New Genesis decides instead to carve his own path and become a different kind of leader for the lost civilization. But as Serifan makes his move, the stakes are raised again. While regular artist Evan Cagle is only on a few pages at the beginning, that actually works because the setting here is so different on Earth. We now know this series is wrapping up with 12 issues, and there's so much ambition here that it's hard to imagine this wrapping up in only three more issues, but I can't wait for the last act. To find reviews of all the DC issues, visit DC This Week. GeekDad received this comic for review purposes Liked it? Take a second to support GeekDad and GeekMom on Patreon!


Geek Dad
13-08-2025
- Geek Dad
Review – Superman: The Kryptonite Spectrum #1
Superman: The Kryptonite Spectrum #1 cover, via DC Comics. Ray: Ice Cream Man is one of the most unique and bizarre comics of the last few decades – a truly surreal comic centering around a mysterious and demonic figure, told in anthology format with issues that defy the limits of how a comic can be read. So the creative team doing a Superman story was highly unexpected – and one of the most intriguing new projects out of DC in a long time. This issue starts with a simple concept – a massive new rock of Kryptonite has landed on Earth, containing four new variants of the deadly minerals with unexpected effects. Superman doesn't know what they do – and neither does Lex Luthor, who is determined to get his hands on them along with his long-suffering assistant Emil Hamilton. Superman consults Batman, who wants to destroy them – but Superman sees them as part of his heritage. So he comes up with the idea to test them – on himself. Dark remnants. Via DC Comics. While I don't think the Rainbow Kryptonite will do what it did in an issue of Supergirl by Peter David, this is a fascinating concept – and this first issue hints at its potential. First up is purple kryptonite, and it has the unique effect of dilating time. This means that while Superman is in the present day, his eyes and ears are picking up moments from across recent time. So when Luthor releases Solomon Grundy to lure Superman out, Superman sees that battle in strange fragments that he has to put together. There's a segment towards the end of the issue that feels like a jigsaw puzzle, which is our first hint of the kind of madness that Prince and Morazzo have waiting for us. I'm a little less sure about the personal subplots, which involve a Superman who seems unwilling to commit and a Lois Lane in her 40s who wants a child before it's too late, but this is the kind of project you just take a ride with and see where it takes you. To find reviews of all the DC issues, visit DC This Week. GeekDad received this comic for review purposes Liked it? Take a second to support GeekDad and GeekMom on Patreon!