Najeeb Ahmed: Delhi court closes investigation into JNU student's disappearance
On the night of 14 October, 2016, Mr Ahmed reportedly got into a scuffle with a group of students affiliated to ABVP who were campaigning for hostel elections. JNU is known for its vibrant and intense student politics, with ideological groups often clashing over campus issues.In his testimonies to the CBI, his roommate Mohd Qasim said that Mr Ahmed got injured in the altercation and had to be taken to a public hospital, where he was allegedly refused treatment. The doctors told him they could not treat his wounds without a formal crime complaint having been made to the police, his roommate alleged.According to the court order, Mr Ahmed chose not to file a complaint and returned to campus. He went missing the next day, leaving behind his phone, wallet, and clothes in his hostel room.A CBI report says Mr Ahmed last used his phone and laptop around 10am the day he disappeared. A hostel warden told the agency that he saw Mr Ahmed getting into a tuk-tuk in the morning and leaving campus. Ms Nafees, who had been informed of the scuffle over phone by Mr Ahmed's roommate, was on her way to Delhi to see her son. She arrived in the morning and upon finding him missing, filed a missing persons complaint on 15 October 2016. For days, there was no progress. Protests erupted on campus as students and activists accused authorities of inaction.In November 2016, Ms Nafees filed a petition in the Delhi High Court, accusing the police of being "slow, misdirected and subjective" and called for a court-monitored probe.A month later, Delhi Police conducted two extensive searches using sniffer dogs across JNU's sprawling campus - but again, nothing was found. In May 2017, the court handed over the investigation to the CBI. A year later, the CBI told the court it had exhausted all possible leads - and asked the bench to close the case. The agency said it had examined more than 500 witnesses, collected information from taxi, bus, train and flight operators, and searched hospitals and morgues, but had found nothing.A one million rupees [$11,600; £8,600] reward for information about Mr Ahmed also failed to yield results, investigators argued. The case dragged on for two more years, when in 2020, Ms Nafees returned to court, this time to challenge the CBI's conclusions. She alleged the agency failed to properly probe the students involved in the scuffle with her son. She said they had a "clear motive", had threatened him, and should have been arrested. The CBI denied all allegations saying they had left "no stone unturned" in looking for Mr Ahmed.The agency said it had tracked the phone locations of the nine students involved in the fight with Mr Ahmed that night, but found no evidence linking them to his disappearance.
Explaining its decision to finally shut the case, a court in Delhi said that the CBI has investigated "all plausible avenues" thoroughly but "no credible information" could be received about Mr Ahmed's whereabouts.The judge dismissed Ms Nafees' plea, noting that while witnesses confirmed verbal threats, there was no "direct or circumstantial" evidence linking Mr Ahmed's disappearance to the fight with ABVP members."Such scuffles and exchanges are not unheard of" in the charged atmosphere of JNU, the order added.The court, however, added that the CBI could reopen the case if new information comes to light.The order has been a huge blow for Mr Ahmed's family and well-wishers. Colin Gonsalves, who represented Ms Nafees in the Delhi High Court in 2018, said he still questioned the investigation. "The police routinely arrest people for minor crimes in India. It's shocking then, that none of the students were taken into custody for questioning," he said. Ms Nafees alleges that her son's religion had affected the seriousness of the investigation."If the victim had been a Hindu boy, would the police have responded the same way?" she asked. "They would have demolished the houses of those suspected," she alleged, referring to the rising instances where homes of individuals accused of crimes are bulldozed by Indian authorities. The BBC has reached out to the CBI for comment. However, the agency has consistently maintained that they have carried out the probe impartially. In 2018, the Delhi High Court had said that they had found no evidence that CBI investigated the case unfairly or "under political compulsions". Ms Nafees says she's not done fighting. Every 15 October, the day her son vanished, she joins a candle march at JNU in his memory. The hope has dimmed, but the wait continues."Sometimes I wonder if I should put a nameplate outside our house," said Nafees Ahmed, his father. "Our house has been renovated. What if he comes, but can't recognise it?"Follow BBC News India on Instagram, YouTube, Twitter and Facebook.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Police launch murder probe after body of woman, in her 20s, found in Batley after supermarket 'robbery'
A murder probe has been launched as a woman's body was found after a supermarket robbery. Police were called to reports of an armed robbery in Asda last night in Dewsbury, West Yorkshire. Officers arrested a 37-year-old man at the scene on suspicion of murder and seized a knife. West Yorkshire Police said he told them there was a dead woman, in her 20s, at a property in Batley which was later found in Norfolk Street. She is yet to be formally identified. Forensic specialists were seen at the address and streets in the area have been cordoned off as they carried out their investigation. Police have warned that two other people, a man and woman, 'may have come to harm.' as a desperate hunt for the two continues. Detective Chief Inspector Dan Bates said: 'This is clearly a very serious incident, where a young woman has lost her life. Forensic specialists were seen at the address and streets in the area have been cordoned off as they carried out their investigation 'There is a heightened police presence in Dewsbury today as we work to establish the full circumstances surrounding this incident. 'Our immediate priority is to identify and locate the two people and establish whether or not they have come to any harm. 'A murder investigation is also under way [but] we do not believe there is any wider risk to the public at this time.'
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Toddler is found dead on popular Greek tourist beach: Police working to identify little girl
A toddler has been found dead on a beach in Greece as police work to identify the little girl as young as two years old. She was found by a horrified passerby on the popular tourist spot Eden Beach in Paleo Faliro, near Athens. The child is believed to be two or three years old and was discovered today in the early hours of the morning. A man from Egypt saw the little girl's body on the shore and called the emergency services, local reports say. The toddler's body was rushed to the Agia Sofia Children's Hospital via ambulance, where doctors pronounced her dead. She is said to have been wearing a full-zip swimming costume and did not have any arm bands on, according to Greek newspaper Protothema. They added she did not have any obvious signs of abuse. An autopsy will be carried out to determine the cause of death. No child matching her description had been reported missing in the area. Investigations are ongoing to determine the girl's identity and how she died. It comes after a British four-year-old boy died in May after being pulled from a hotel swimming pool in Tenerife. The heart-breaking incident took place in San Miguel de Abona, a popular holiday spot in the south of the island. Emergency services rushed to José Miguel Galván Bello Avenue shortly before 5pm local time following reports of a child in cardiac arrest. According to Spanish broadcaster Telecinco, the child was rescued from the water by a lifeguard but was found to be unresponsive. Two advanced life support ambulances and a medical helicopter were sent to the scene. However, despite the best efforts of paramedics, who carried out advanced resuscitation procedures, the child could not be saved.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Mother of British victim of Air India crash left ‘heartbroken' by casket error
The mother of one of the British victims of the Air India crash says her family is 'heartbroken' after the wrong remains were sent home in his casket. Air India's London-bound Boeing 787 Dreamliner crashed into a medical college hostel seconds after taking off from Ahmedabad on 12 June, killing 241 people onboard. The dead included 52 British nationals, making it one of the deadliest plane crashes in terms of the number of UK fatalities. Among the British victims were Fiongal Greenlaw-Meek, 39, and his husband Jamie, 45, who were returning to Britain after celebrating their wedding anniversary in India. Greenlaw-Meek's mother, Amanda Donaghey, flew to India to find her son's remains, providing a DNA sample at Ahmedabad's civil hospital to help the identification process. A match was made on 20 June and she returned to the UK with Greenlaw-Meek's coffin. But on 5 July, police told Donaghey that DNA tests carried out in the UK showed her son's remains were not in the coffin. 'We don't know what poor person is in that casket,' she told the Sunday Times. 'I had my doubts but to be told that was heartbreaking. This is an appalling thing to have happened.' The revelation emerged as the families of Greenlaw-Meek and his husband prepared to bury the couple together. Donaghey urged the UK government to do everything in its power to find out what happened to his remains 'and bring Fiongal home'. Lawyers for a number of the British victims said last week that at least two of the 12 caskets returned to the UK contained misidentified remains. James Healy-Pratt, whose firm Keystone Law is representing families of crash victims, said: 'We know that 12 caskets were repatriated from India to the UK. Of those 12, two had been mishandled, misidentified. 'And so if you extrapolate that sample, you're looking at 40 mishandled remains out of 240. That's a very large number, but we simply don't know.' Sign up to Headlines UK Get the day's headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning after newsletter promotion Healy-Pratt said families of victims were asking the Foreign Office and Keir Starmer, the prime minister, to intervene because the Indian authorities had 'not been transparent or helpful'. 'The families are waiting to hear, first thing next week, about what actions are really being done in India to provide some degree of assurance,' he told Times Radio. The coffin of 71-year-old Shobhana Patel, another British victim, is said to have contained the remains of several people. She died with her husband Ashok, 74, as they returned to the UK from a Hindu religious trip. Their son, Miten Patel, told the Sunday Times: 'There may have been a mistake. But for religious reasons we need to make sure my mother is my mother and not somebody else's remains. Knowing 100% that it is my mum is very important to us.' A preliminary report found the plane's fuel switches had been moved to cut-off, deepening the mystery of what happened and leaving families distressed and seeking answers.
