logo
University of Michigan denounced for using private investigators to surveil student protesters

University of Michigan denounced for using private investigators to surveil student protesters

Yahooa day ago

Pro-Palestinian protest on the UM campus on February 20, 2025 | Photo by Erick Diaz Veliz
Josiah Walker has one year left until he graduates from the University of Michigan. However, since last summer, his college life had undergone an abrupt change when he realized he was being followed and recorded by several people while going about his daily activities on campus and around Ann Arbor.
As it turns out, he wasn't the only one.
According to The Guardian, they all shared the same pattern: the pro-Palestinian movement on campus.
On Friday, The Guardian published a report in which a group of students accused the University of Michigan of hiring private undercover investigators from the Detroit-based firm City Shield to conduct covert surveillance both on and off campus of student pro-Palestinian activist groups.
Walker is among the five U of M students who were interviewed in the report. They declared that they were trailed, eavesdropped on, recorded, and verbally harassed by what they considered intimidation tactics from the university. They said they recognized dozens of investigators, often working in teams, who were behind their steps around campus and Ann Arbor, sometimes sitting at nearby tables at cafes and bars.
'The same people and vehicles kept popping up everywhere I went on and even off campus. Each individual would execute some combination of recording and following me,' Walker told the Advance.
The Guardian investigation determined that the private investigators are employees of City Shield. According to university spending records from June 16, 2023, through September 15, 2024, the university paid at least $850,000 to City Shield's parent company, Ameri-Shield.
'The university had used a lot of its own resources to uplift my previous involvements and accomplishments. Now, I'm on the other side where the university is using those same resources to try to destroy my future and, quite frankly, seriously injure or kill me,' Walker told the Advance.
These students started to record, identify, and confront the undercover investigators by themselves, resulting in tense interactions recorded on video.
Katarina Keating, also one of the students interviewed by The Guardian, is a PhD candidate and a member of the Graduate Employees' Organization. She recounted to the Advance that she noticed she was being followed in early November last year. She said she started seeing the same person following her after protests or events, and even weekly in the last months.
Walker said he began to feel watched last year when he noticed that many people were continuously recording and following him; therefore, he started to record them in return.
He shared the videos of those encounters with the Advance, also posted in the report, of himself recognizing and confronting those The Guardian reported are undercover investigators, including an interaction in which the alleged investigator, who is white, appears to falsely accuse Walker, who is Black, of trying to steal his wallet.
During another of those interactions, he says a car from where he was being recorded almost hit him, making him fear for his life since then.
'The threat has already presented itself. This is what City Shield employees or university contractors were willing to do on camera when it was very obvious that I was recording them as I was holding my phone at chest level. There's no telling what they're willing to do off-camera,' Walker said to the Advance.
Another video Walker shared with the Advance shows the same man sitting inside his parked vehicle and initially pretending to be hearing impaired, including speaking in an impeded manner, before switching to a normal voice.
Michigan Advance requested an interview with a university spokesperson, but instead were directed to a public email from the interim university President, Domenico Grasso, regarding the investigation.
'At the University of Michigan, simultaneously keeping our campus safe and welcoming is a top priority,' Grasso said. 'We recently learned that an employee of one of our security contractors has acted in ways that go against our values and directives. What happened was disturbing, unacceptable, and unethical, and we will not tolerate it.'
Additionally, Grasso said the university was terminating all contracts with vendors to provide plainclothes security on campus.
The university also provided a campus security statement issued Sunday, saying that 'recent media reports have mischaracterized the role of contract security personnel who were engaged solely to support campus safety efforts,' and denying that the university had requested the services of private investigators to monitor U of M students on or off campus.
Both statements explained that as part of a 'security strategy' during 2024, the university augmented contracts with outside firms of plainclothes security personnel in order to 'provide discreet awareness of potential illegal activities without escalating tensions,' said the updated statement.
Grasso recommended reporting any inappropriate behavior by contractors or employees to campus police or the Equity, Civil Rights, and Title IX Office.
'It's certainly not 'safe and welcoming' for the dozens of students and community members who have been banned from campus for participating in protests. Grasso should reverse these campus bans next,' said Keating to the Advance in response to the statements.
Walker declared to the Advance that, as of the time of publication of this report, U of M has not reached him to offer support or in response to the investigation by The Guardian, and so far, he believes he is still being monitored.
'It's really unfortunate. There's no doubt that if City Shield operatives or university police see me, they're going to continue to monitor me. They'll probably just try to be more discreet about it,' said Walker.
The student accusations come as part of a series of rifts in the already strained relationship between the university administration and pro-Palestinian groups, including accusations of vandalism against individuals in the groups, and alleged selective targeting by authorities.
Walker was among a group of students charged in September 2024 with trespassing and/or resisting university police during the raid on the pro-Palestinian encampment at the Ann Arbor campus' Diag in May 2024. The trespassing charges were later dismissed.
In April, the pro-Palestinian activist group, TAHRIR coalition, alleged that some of their members were targeted in raids by the FBI at the houses where they live, authorized by Attorney General Dana Nessel. The raids were carried out in Ypsilanti, Canton, and Ann Arbor by unmarked vehicles accompanied by the Michigan State Police and local police officers.
Pro-Palestinian activists were also accused by the university police earlier this month of damaging and vandalizing hundreds of flowers at the university's famed peony gardens after they found papers signed with pro-Palestinian slogans.
'The university has 100% selectively prioritized rights such as freedom of expression and movement. If a cause has even a remotely favorable view of Palestine or Palestinians, one can expect fierce university opposition,' Walker told the Advance.
Despite the actions of the university and its contractors being publicized, Walker doesn't feel completely at ease because he worries the university could still take various measures against him.
'On one hand, it feels liberating to be able to raise awareness about what's been happening,' Walker told the Advance. 'On the other hand, I can't help but know that the university police department and City Shield are probably looking for ways to retaliate against me.'
Both Walker and Keating say college life is no longer the same and that they no longer socialize freely, to the point that Walker warns his close friends to be careful around him so they don't endanger themselves, while Keating is always watching people around her.
'My life has changed in that I'm on high alert any time I am walking around campus, which is essentially every workday. I'm always looking around to see if someone is watching or following me,' Keating said.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The Justice Department wants to end an agreement it reached with a Pa. bank it accused of redlining in Philly
The Justice Department wants to end an agreement it reached with a Pa. bank it accused of redlining in Philly

Miami Herald

timean hour ago

  • Miami Herald

The Justice Department wants to end an agreement it reached with a Pa. bank it accused of redlining in Philly

Two years ago, the U.S. Department of Justice accused a Pennsylvania bank of redlining - avoiding lending in majority-Black and Hispanic neighborhoods in and around Philadelphia. ESSA Bank & Trust, based in Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania, denied the accusations but entered into a settlement agreement with the federal government in which the bank had to give more than $2.9 million in loan subsidies to homebuyers in formerly redlined communities. The bank also agreed to devote resources to soliciting mortgage applications from Philadelphia residents in neighborhoods it was accused of ignoring, to include Philadelphians in its program for low- and moderate-income homebuyers, to work with local groups to provide homebuyer education, and to target historically excluded neighborhoods with its advertising. On Friday, the Justice Department asked the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania to allow it to end the five-year agreement three years early. The court filing is in line with other recent Justice Department moves across the country to end similar fair-housing and antidiscrimination settlement agreements. Lisa Rice, president and CEO of the National Fair Housing Alliance, said in a statement that by taking these actions, "this administration is empowering bad actors and leaving millions of our nation's most vulnerable unprotected and exposed." The Justice Department said in its motion Friday that ESSA Bank "has demonstrated a commitment to remediation," including disbursing required loan subsidies, and is "substantially in compliance" with other terms of the court order. The bank did not respond to a request for comment Tuesday. The department noted that its motion was "unopposed." But on Monday, the National Fair Housing Alliance and local civil rights organizations filed a motion asking to join the case and opposing cutting short the legal agreement. "This effort would strip West and Southwest Philadelphia communities of the hard-won protections they were promised just two years ago," Rachel Wentworth, executive director of the nonprofit Housing Equality Center of Pennsylvania, said in a statement. "For decades, banks of all kinds have used redlining to deny neighborhoods of color access to wealth and opportunity, and ending this consent order sends a devastating message to these communities." The Philadelphia-based Public Interest Law Center and the law firm Stapleton Segal Cochran LLC, which has offices in Philadelphia and Marlton, are representing the Housing Equality Center, the National Fair Housing Alliance, and POWER Interfaith, the Pennsylvania faith-based community organizing network, as they oppose the Justice Department's motion to end the agreement. Eli Segal of Stapleton Segal Cochran said in a statement that "the rule of law demands more here than vague assurances of 'substantial compliance.' It demands court-ordered action." Olivia Mania, attorney and Penn Carey Law Catalyst Fellow at the Public Interest Law Center, said in an interview that "communities in and around Philadelphia deserve access to a lending market that's free from discrimination." "This isn't just about one bank," Mania said in a statement. "It's about whether the federal government will honor its role in dismantling structural racism in the housing market - or walk away when the cameras are off. The parties should be held to the terms of the consent order to ensure real, lasting change." Copyright (C) 2025, Tribune Content Agency, LLC. Portions copyrighted by the respective providers.

China chows on US fast food at London trade talks
China chows on US fast food at London trade talks

New York Post

time2 hours ago

  • New York Post

China chows on US fast food at London trade talks

China's trade negotiators surrendered at the end of the second day of US trade talks in London — by feasting on American fast food, The Post has learned. The famished Chinese delegation ordered a delivery of McDonald's, Burger King and KFC after the day-long negotiations at just after 7:30 p.m. local time, sources said. Team Trump — featuring Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and Trade Representative Jamieson Greer — also turned to a fast-food option. However, they dined on takeout from Pizza Express, a British chain specializing in handmade pizzas, the sources told The Post. 4 Chinese officials were left humiliated at the end of trade talks against Trump's team by ordering takeout made up entirely of US fast food. The president, seen above during the campaign last year, is a known aficionado of McDonald's meals. Getty Images One insider branded Beijing's gastronomic choices as 'a total cultural victory' for the United States, even though there was no deal announced on ending the tariff trade spat in sight. 4 The Trump administration team dined out on handmade pizzas from the British restaurant chain Pizza Express, sources said. SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images A spokesman for China's embassy to the UK did not respond to The Post's request for comment. The US and China meting at Lancaster House to try and build on negotiations in Geneva last month that agreed to a 90-day suspension of most of the 100%-plus tariffs they had imposed on each other in an escalating global trade war. Lancaster House, an 18th-century mansion a stone's throw from Buckingham Palace, is close to the upmarket neighborhood of Mayfair that is home to some of the British capital's best restaurants. The move by Chinese officials, led by Vice Premier He Lifeng, may be seen as a blow to the host country, which has repeatedly seen its culinary capabilities derided by snooty foreigners throughout history. Insiders refused to be drawn in on whether the meals of choice for Beijing's top brass could raise the chances of success for a possible agreement with Washington. 4 Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who called the talks 'productive', has left London to appear in Congress on Wednesday. REUTERS Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who is on the way back to DC and will debrief Congress on Wednesday, called the meeting 'productive.' On Monday, President Trump told reporters: 'We are doing well with China. China's not easy.' The commander-in-chief is known to be a fast food aficionado and even served diners at a McDonald's drive-thru during a campaign stop in the swing state of Pennsylvania in October. 4 Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng and his team snubbed some of London's finest restaurants on Tuesday. REUTERS His preferred order at the Chicago-based fast food chain is two Big Macs, two Filet-o-Fish sandwiches, and a chocolate milkshake, according to a 2017 book written by two former campaign staffers. The 'Let Trump Be Trump: The Inside Story of His Rise to the Presidency' tome was penned by Corey Lewandowski and David Bossi. On the table for trade talks, aside from the fast food, are the levies slapped on semiconductors that power artificial intelligence, visas for Chinese students at American universities, and rare earth minerals that are vital to carmakers and other industries. The negotiations were sparked by the threat of Trump's so-called Liberation Day reciprocal tariffs, which he threatened to slap on countries that he believed had been treating the US unfairly.

Sultan of Brunei in talks to buy NYC's iconic Pierre Hotel: sources
Sultan of Brunei in talks to buy NYC's iconic Pierre Hotel: sources

New York Post

time2 hours ago

  • New York Post

Sultan of Brunei in talks to buy NYC's iconic Pierre Hotel: sources

The Sultan of Brunei is in talks to buy New York City's storied Pierre Hotel — where Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick owns a stunning triplex penthouse apartment, the Post has learned. Hassanal Bolkiah, who is both sultan and prime minister of the tiny kingdom in Southeast Asia, is partnering with Essam Khashoggi, brother of the late Saudi arms dealer Adnan Khashoggi, according to a source close to the situation. Khashoggi is the uncle of the late Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi, who was slaughtered inside the Saudi consulate in Turkey in 2018. 6 The Sultan of Brunei is in talks to buy New York City's storied Pierre Hotel — where Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick owns a stunning triplex penthouse apartment, the Post has learned. Annie Wermiel/NY Post Advertisement The landmarked hotel at 795 Fifth Ave. overlooking Central Park – which was put on the market last year – has been a favorite of A-listers and titans of industry since it opened its lavish doors in 1930. The sale of the hotel's 189 rooms, retail space and restaurants is complicated and far from a done deal, a source close to the situation told The Post. The sultan is a 'strong contender, but there are others,' the source said. The 41-story limestone-clad building – featuring neo-Georgian architecture modeled after Versailles – also has about 80 co-ops. Advertisement The sale could be for the whole property, which is valued at around $2 billion, the source said. The deal could involve some of the co-ops, or all of them. 'At this point, no one is sure how it will play out, but it is heading into one of those directions,' the source said. The Post reached out to the Brunei prime minister's office, its UN Mission in New York and its embassy in DC for comment. Advertisement 6 The landmarked hotel at 795 Fifth Ave. overlooking Central Park – which was put on the market last year – has been a favorite of A-listers and titans of industry since it opened its lavish doors in 1930. Angel Chevrestt The shareholders own the property and have leased the Pierre to India-based Taj Hotels Resorts and Palaces since 2005. While Lutnick is a shareholder, he is not a member of the board, sources told The Post. Lutnick and his wife, Allison, bought the Pierre penthouse triplex, the building's crown jewel, in 2017 for $44 million — which was $81 million off its original asking price. The 12,000 square-foot skypad first hit the market in 2013 for $125 million. The couple has never lived in the building, according to sources.. Advertisement 6 The sale could be for the whole property, which is valued at around $2 billion, the source said. Real estate broker Newmark Group, led by Doug Harmon, co-head of capital markets for the firm, is advising on the sale of the Pierre, sources told The Post. Harmon recently led the Newmark team that sold the Pierre's neighbor, 800 Fifth Ave., a 33-story luxury apartment building, to the Naftali Group for close to $820 million earlier this year. Harmon's top deals include selling Peter Cooper Stuyvesant Town for $5.45 billion and Starrett City for $905 million. Harmon declined to comment on the Pierre deal. Lutnick was the largest individual Newmark Group shareholder. 6 Hassanal Bolkiah, who is both sultan and prime minister of the tiny kingdom in Southeast Asia, is partnering with Essam Khashoggi, brother of the late Saudi arms dealer Adnan Khashoggi. via REUTERS Newmark, which is now a publicly traded company, is a spin-off of its former parent company, BGC Partners, and a majority of the voting power of BGC Partners is held by Cantor Fitzgerald. Lutnick headed the Wall Street financial services heavyweight for three decades, tragically losing his brother at the World Trade Center during the 9/11 terror attacks. Last month, Lutnick handed over the reins to his children 'who are in positions of learning,' as he serves in the Trump administration, the Wall Street Journal reported. Cantor Fitzgerald did not return requests for comment. Sources told The Post that whoever buys the hotel will determine the fate of the co-op owners, who will have to approve the deal. Advertisement The new owner could shut down the hotel and kick out the co-op owners for a period of time — or forever. 6 Lutnick and his wife, Allison, bought the Pierre penthouse triplex, the building's crown jewel, in 2017 for $44 million — which was $81 million off its original asking price. REUTERS 'It will all be flushed out in the wash. But nothing will happen without the shareholders voting on it,' the source said. If the co-op owners are booted for an extensive renovation, it could be five years before they are back, sources say. Advertisement It took the Chinese-government owned Waldorf Astoria hotel eight long years to renovate. The hotel is finally planning to reopen this September after multiple delays. 'Everybody is scared and no one is talking,' another source said, referring to the co-op owners. However, the insider added that while some owners do not want to leave, the compensation they will receive will be worth it. 'Whatever the disruption will be, it will be worth their while,' the source said. Advertisement The Pierre has always been associated with glamour and sophistication. 6 The shareholders own the property and have leased the Pierre to India-based Taj Hotels Resorts and Palaces since 2005. Christopher Sadowski Coco Chanel stayed here during her first visit to the Big Apple in 1932. Sophia Loren also enjoyed staying at the hotel. Other stars who called the Pierre home included Audrey Hepburn, who celebrated her 1954 Oscar for 'Roman Holiday' at the hotel. In addition, apartment owner Elizabeth Taylor married Eddie Fisher there in 1959. Advertisement Guests over the years have included Barbra Streisand, Joan Collins, Yves Saint Laurent and Karl Lagerfeld. The iconic venue has also been in films like 'Oceans Eight,' where Anne Hathaway's character checks in to get ready for the Met Gala. John Paul Getty, founder of Getty Oil, bought the Pierre in 1938, reportedly calling it his only 'above-ground asset.' He converted part of the hotel into co-ops. Today, its other high profile co-op owners include fashion designer Tory Burch, media heiress Shari Redstone, musician Art Garfunkel and former Disney boss Michael Eisner.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store