logo
Navigating the complexities of insurance claims in South Africa

Navigating the complexities of insurance claims in South Africa

IOL News4 days ago
Explore real-life stories of insurance claim disputes in South Africa, highlighting the challenges faced by policyholders and the importance of understanding your rights.
Image: SAPS
It seems that everyone has a story to tell about insurance companies seemingly trying to get out of settling claims.
One recent one involved someone who was hijacked. If that isn't traumatic enough, the jacker then went on a joy ride around the Alexandra township, near Sandton in Johannesburg, completely writing off the car before stripping it bare.'
There was no car left to recover. And the only reason it was recovered was because she phoned the tracking company. The insurance company had insisted that she use a policy-mandated tracking device.
To use a tired cliché, to add insult to injury, that person's insurance company tried to argue that the car was written off instead of forcefully stolen. Many policies have a clause saying that you have to give permission for someone else to drive your car, and this statement looked suspiciously like the insurance company trying to get out of paying her.
There are two obvious things wrong with this. The first is that the accident wouldn't have happened had the car not been hijacked, while the insured also argued back that permission was given. Through coercion. At knife point. A point confirmed with a broker.
Yet, Jaco Rupping, COO and shareholder at ASI Financials, says: 'In South African contract and insurance law, consent obtained through intimidation or threat of harm is not true consent'.
Another example I have heard is when an insurance company refuted a claim from a homeowner to fix damage because a wall had fallen over. In this instance, the company argued that they had never inspected the structure. The same structure, they never asked to look at.
Then there is the case of a laptop that was insured for replacement value under all risks and was accidentally damaged beyond economic repair. Laptops are fairly mission-critical, and it took a week for the insurance company to start actually working on the claim after the laptop was inspected. Twice: once by their service provider and once by the client's.
When the insured lost her temper with the insurance company, they insisted they needed to get a quote first, which had somehow recently become policy and was, despite the device being insured, in line with common sense, for replacement value. The claim was eventually paid out, two weeks after being lodged.
Rupping says turnaround times in claim assessments should always be reasonable. 'In this case, once a device has been confirmed beyond economic repair by both the client and the insurer's external assessor, it would be expected that the insurer act without undue delay,' he notes.
There are likely many more similar stories out there.
However, Hannes Bester, Manager of Adjudication at the National Financial Ombud Scheme, tells Personal Finance that the ombud hasn't seen 'a significant number of overturns on declined claims'. This, says Bester, may be attributed to most insurers conforming to principles of treating customers fairly.
The Ombud's 2024 annual report shows that most of the complaints resolved during the year were about motor vehicle insurance, which was followed by issues related to homeowners' insurance, and then other types of complaints, including house contents.
Rupping says many of the complaints stem not from outright 'rip-offs', but rather from breakdowns in communication, mismatched expectations, or poor claims handling from both parties.
'That being said, insurers have a legal and ethical obligation to act in good faith, and clients are fully within their rights to escalate claims they believe are being unfairly denied or unreasonably delayed,' he says.
Bester explains that an insurer can decline a claim if the insured is in breach of a condition or warranty entrenched in the policy agreement. Other reasons for declining a claim include an exclusion in a policy that will result in cover being denied for that sort of claim.
As an example: 'The policyholder is involved in an accident, and he was driving the vehicle whilst intoxicated. The policy agreement specifically excludes cover if the driver is under the influence of alcohol.' Bester says that, under these circumstances, the insurer can decline the claim. The same would go for if the damage was caused by a lack of maintenance or if premiums weren't paid, for example, he says.
Rupping notes that: 'Insurers are entitled and, in fact, obligated to investigate the circumstances of a loss'.
Bester says, in instances where claims are denied, consumers should first engage with the insurance company's complaints department. 'If this proves to be unsuccessful, the insured may explore other forums such as obtaining legal advice with a view to litigate,' or approach the ombud, he says.
PERSONAL FINANCE
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

No raid conducted at Dudu Myeni's house: police call out fake social media post
No raid conducted at Dudu Myeni's house: police call out fake social media post

The Herald

timean hour ago

  • The Herald

No raid conducted at Dudu Myeni's house: police call out fake social media post

Police have dismissed claims the national intervention unit (NIU) raided the KwaZulu-Natal home of the late former SAA chair Dudu Myeni. This comes after a social media post claimed: 'The NIU raided Dudu Myeni's house and allegedly found R18m in a safe.' Police spokesperson Athlenda Mathe said no raid was conducted. 'The SA Police Service (SAPS) warns against the spread of fake news about a NIU raid in which R18m was found in a safe at a house in Richards Bay. 'The SAPS calls for responsible social media reporting and for users to verify information before sharing. 'No raid was undertaken by any unit.' Myeni died in 2024 after battling cancer. She served on the SAA board from 2009 until 2017, while Jacob Zuma was president, and was its chair for the last five of those years. Her role at SAA was marred by fraud and corruption allegations stemming from the commission of inquiry into state capture and she was said to have been instrumental in the crippling of the airline. She allegedly received R300,000 from Bosasa, supposedly for the Jacob Zuma Foundation. TimesLIVE

G20 SA 2025: a defining moment for the nation and the continent
G20 SA 2025: a defining moment for the nation and the continent

TimesLIVE

time2 hours ago

  • TimesLIVE

G20 SA 2025: a defining moment for the nation and the continent

Johannesburg, as host city, will become a strategic hub of diplomacy, business exchange, and cultural showcase. While the summit itself is a high-level, closed-door affair, South Africans can expect a wave of public engagement, community-driven programmes, investment conversations, and national pride as the event draws near. 'The G20 presidency is a powerful opportunity for SA to place Africa's priorities at the heart of global decision-making. We are committed to driving an inclusive agenda that ensures no country, and no person, is left behind,' says President Cyril Ramaphosa. For the South African government, this is more than ceremonial. It is an opportunity for G20 members to transform commitments into lasting action. Key issues remain a challenge in the country and on the continent, and there is a call for greater accountability to drive tangible progress in the global pursuit of gender equality SA's G20 presidency is also an opportunity to elevate African perspectives, strengthen international alliances, and advance sustainable development goals. It is a chance to reinforce SA's commitment to multilateralism and global co-operation at a time when unity is more important than ever. As preparations intensify in the coming months, all eyes will be on SA not just as a host, but as a bridge between developed and developing economies. The 2025 G20 Leader's Summit is more than just a gathering of nations. It is a moment for SA to lead with purpose, to shape global consensus, and to drive transformation that begins on the continent but resonates across the globe.

Bad news for meat prices ahead of pay day weekend
Bad news for meat prices ahead of pay day weekend

The South African

time2 hours ago

  • The South African

Bad news for meat prices ahead of pay day weekend

South African households are feeling the pinch at the dinner table, with the price of meat – especially beef- emerging as a major driver of consumer inflation in June. According to the latest data from Stats SA, the annual food inflation rate climbed to 5.1%, marking a 15-month high, and meat was the leading contributor. This spike helped push the overall Consumer Price Index (CPI) up from 2.8% in May to 3.0% in June. The standout statistic: stewing beef prices skyrocketed by 21.2% year-on-year – the highest increase recorded since Stats SA's current CPI series began in 2017. Other beef cuts, such as mince and steak, also saw sharp monthly and annual increases, capping off a three-month streak of rising meat prices. The steep increases are being driven by several factors: Supply constraints , with the country's cattle herds still recovering from previous drought conditions. , with the country's cattle herds still recovering from previous drought conditions. Higher feed prices , driven by global grain market fluctuations. , driven by global grain market fluctuations. Increased input costs across the meat production chain. Meat is a staple in most South African diets, particularly among lower- and middle-income households. With meat making up a large share of household food budgets, the recent price hikes are disproportionately impacting vulnerable consumers. Economists warn that if the trend continues, families may be forced to: Shift to cheaper protein sources like chicken, eggs, or plant-based alternatives Buy smaller portions or lower-grade cuts Reduce meat consumption altogether 'Consumers are likely to start adjusting their buying habits. Meat, especially beef, is becoming a luxury,' said consumer analyst Thabo Mokoena. While other food categories like dairy and cereals have seen minor relief, meat inflation shows no sign of slowing. The trajectory of meat prices will be a key factor to watch in the next CPI report due in August. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store