Donald Trump's Scotland visit 'recipe for disaster' for struggling frontline cops
Donald Trump's visit to Scotland threatens a policing 'disaster' amid staff shortages, cop burnout and stretched budgets, rank-and-file officers warn.
The US president arrives in Scotland on Friday and stays until Tuesday, July 29.
He is set to meet Prime Minister Keir Starmer in Aberdeen and has scheduled separate talks with First Minister John Swinney.
But even a flying visit will rack up a £5million bill for taxpayers – while the threat of mass protests could strain the force further.
Police Scotland officer numbers are at near-historic lows of around 16,500 – with almost a third, about 5000, expected to be deployed or on standby for Trump's visit.
David Kennedy, general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation, said: 'It's a recipe for disaster. We don't have enough cops.
' President Trump is a magnet to certain groups. There will be protests.
"And just because the president is one place doesn't mean that's where the protests will take place.
"With this event, it is survival mode. That's the mentality that will set in.'
The Stop Trump Coalition is organising a 'festival of resistance' including a major demo in Aberdeen on Saturday.
A spokesperson said: ' John Swinney should stand with the people of Scotland and say no to a humiliating photo opportunity with the leader of the international far-right."
Trump's last presidential visit in July 2018 prompted widespread protests in Edinburgh, Glasgow and Aberdeen, at a cost of more than £3million to Police Scotland. It required 'mutual aid', with forces from around the UK were drafted in.
It sparked a cost-sharing row between Holyrood and Westminster. The UK-wide policing bill for the event topped £18million.
In his first term in office, Trump spent two nights at his Turnberry resort in Ayrshire before heading to England.
Tens of thousands protested, with an 'angry orange baby' blimp in Edinburgh and a paraglider with an anti-Trump banner sailing over Turnberry. In March, Turnberry's clubhouse was vandalised by pro-Palestine protesters.
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
This visit will mean police holidays and rest days cancelled and many landed with 12-hour shifts, Kennedy said. He added: 'We'll survive but we shouldn't have to just survive. They will need plenty of help from the UK.
'All this costs money and Police Scotland's budget is already bust. Everybody working longer hours and days has a knock-on effect for months, if not years.'
He said a raft of specialist units, including firearms officers, would need to be deployed with help from other UK forces.
Kennedy added: "We've only got so many firearms officers in Scotland so we will need more.
"Whilst you have those protecting the president, you've also got to have those protecting the public.
"We have to make sure we still have that resilience that if something goes wrong, those people are there now.
"When I'm getting told my firearms officers are having to work 12-hour shifts, I'm not happy about that.
"I think that's extremely long shifts and potentially long days for people carrying guns that may have to use them.'
Last week, the force insisted Trump's visit wouldn't 'come at the expense' of communities.
But Kennedy said it will. He added: 'We don't have enough officers now to police Scotland. This needs to be a wake-up call for the Scottish Government.'
It comes after Police Scotland's controversial move last year to downgrade 'minor' crimes to free up resources, meaning they will no longer investigate offences like vandalism and thefts where there are no leads.
The Scottish Government said Swinney's talk with Trump is 'an opportunity to promote the interests of Scotland'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
24 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Labour says Reform UK ‘trying to divide communities' ahead of Farage speech on crime
Update: Date: 2025-07-21T08:19:51.000Z Title: Farage's plans to reform criminal justice system criticised ahead of speech Content: Good morning and welcome to our live coverage of UK politics. Nigel Farage is to lay out plans that he claims would end all early release schemes for sex offenders and serious violent offenders if he were to become prime minister. In a speech in London later today, the Reform UK leader will also reportedly promise to build 30,000 new prison places to tackle the overcrowding crisis, appoint 30,000 more police officers within five years and deport 10,400 foreign offenders currently in British jails. He has not said how these policies will be funded and will likely face questions on how he would negotiate return agreements for foreign offenders. Some of his promises – like sending some of the most serious criminals to overseas jails, including in El Salavdor – will also likely face serious legal obstacles if they were ever realised. Farage, whose Reform party is leading many polls, was quoted by the Daily Telegraph as having said: Reform UK will be the toughest party on law and order this country has ever seen. We will cut crime in half. We will take back control of our streets, we will take back control of our courts and prisons. We are expecting more details on Reform's plans at around 11am. Reform's attempt to woo voters with a tough on crime message stands in contrast to the proposals recently suggested by Sir Brian Leveson, a former senior judge who was asked by the Lord Chancellor to come up with ways to reduce the backlog of cases in the criminal courts. Recommendations in the report included increased use of out-of-court resolutions, greater use of rehabilitation programmes and health intervention programmes and increasing the maximum reduction for entering a guilty plea at the first opportunity from 33% to 40%. Diana Johnson, the policing minister, said that Reform is not serious about implementing real changes to the criminal justice system as the party 'voted to try to block measures to crack down on knife crime, antisocial behaviour, shop theft and child sexual abuse'. 'They should focus more on practical solutions to support our police, combat crime, deliver justice for victims of crime, rather than chasing headlines, spouting slogans and trying to divide communities,' she added. Here is the agenda for the day. 09.45am: Sir Jon Cunliffe, Independent Water Commission chair, to give speech. 11am: Nigel Farage to make a speech in London on the criminal justice system. 13:00pm: Orgreave Truth and Justice Campaign press conference in Sheffield. 14.30pm: Keir Starmer to appear at the Liaison Committee.
The National
40 minutes ago
- The National
Keir Starmer 'hasn't responded' to John Swinney on Gaza child evacuations
Writing in The National earlier this month, the First Minister said Scotland's NHS was ready to treat injured Palestinian children. Swinney said that the Scottish Government is looking to medically evacuate children suffering from injuries caused by Israel's ongoing genocide in Gaza, but that this "requires the support of the UK Government". First Minister John Swinney (Image: PA) The First Minister revealed that he had written to Keir Starmer urging him to support the evacuations to hospitals in Scotland. However, Swinney said on Sunday that he is yet to receive a response from the Prime Minister. The First Minister said in a statement: 'It is deeply saddening that so far the UK Government has refused to even enter into a dialogue about medical evacuations for children in Gaza who, without proper medical attention, will be left to die. READ MORE: Palestine Action co-founder set to challenge UK Government terror ban 'That is the frank reality of life in Gaza under Israeli bombardment and blockade. 'The healthcare system in Gaza is on the brink of total collapse, with surgeons working day and night under artillery fire, with inadequate supplies and often no electricity. 'We know that many hospitals have been targeted and decimated by the IDF.' The First Minister added that Scotland is prepared 'to do what is required to save the lives of as many of these kids as we can'. Swinney's letter to Starmer was sparked by a meeting he had held with UN agency Unicef to discuss medical evacuations. The SNP leader wrote in The National at the time: 'With hospitals destroyed and medical supplies running out, this is an emergency and a race against time to provide specialist medical care for the children and babies suffering from injuries caused by the war. 'Scotland's world-class National Health Service stands ready to play our full part in supporting these medical evacuations and the treatment of injured Palestinian children.' He added: 'This requires the support of the UK Government, and I have asked the Prime Minister to support facilitating a transfer of these children, who need medical care to survive, to Scotland.' Swinney's predecessor, Humza Yousaf, previously said that Scottish hospitals can help treat injured Gaza civilians if they are medically evacuated. He added, however, that 'no request has been made' for the UK to receive medical evacuations from Gaza at that time. READ MORE: 3 women charged under Terrorism Act after breaching Edinburgh arms factory Since then, Israel has killed more than 58,000 Palestinians, more than half of them women and children, according to Gaza's health ministry. On Sunday, at least 73 Palestinians were killed while trying to reach desperately needed aid in Gaza. In northern Gaza, 67 people were killed near the Zikim crossing with Israel as aid trucks had just arrived. According to the UN World Food Programme (WFP), 25 trucks carrying supplies for "starving communities" entered the area but were met by large crowds that came under gunfire. A UK Government spokeswoman said: 'Since the start of the conflict, UK support has provided essential healthcare to over 430,000 people in the Occupied Palestinian Territories. 'We have helped several children with complex paediatric conditions access privately funded medical care in the UK, supporting an initiative by Project Pure Hope. 'We have been clear the situation in Gaza is intolerable and that there must be an immediate ceasefire. 'We urge Israel to let vital humanitarian aid in and allow Gazans to receive urgent healthcare, including allowing the sick and wounded to temporarily leave the Gaza Strip to receive treatment.'
Spectator
an hour ago
- Spectator
Japan's prime minister is on borrowed time
'It is a difficult situation and we have to take it very humbly and seriously'. This was the typically understated and solemnly delivered verdict of Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba after his party and their coalition partners lost their majority in the Upper House elections on Sunday. It is the kind of wording used by Japanese doctors to inform patients that their illness is terminal (they never tell you directly). Ishiba insists he will stay on as PM, but long-term, he is probably doomed. Ishiba's party, the Liberal Democrats (LDP), and their partners Komeito, needed fifty seats in yesterday's election to hang on to a majority, but managed only 47. They may need to reach out to the fragmented opposition parties for some sort of enlarged coalition or issue-by-issue cooperation agreement. It is a mess and there is no obvious solution, except a general election. The problem is that there is nothing that is both new and wholly credible available The timing is awful. Trade negotiations with America are at an acute stage – Trump's tariff deadline is 1 August and unless some sort of deal can be reached by then, a 25 per cent levy will be imposed on Japanese cars. The Japanese automobile industry employs 6 million people domestically and 1.7 million cars were sold in the States last year. The extent to which the Japanese automakers can absorb or work around the tariffs is unclear, but many here are understandably nervous. Time is running out. To be fair to Ishiba, he appears to have done what he could. His trade envoy, Ryosei Akazawa, has visited Washington seven times. And there is still time for a compromise – just (US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessant is in Japan now). But Ishiba, who had a weak hand before the election, has an even weaker one now. His immediate options are either to step down (or be stepped down – he is vulnerable to the elder statesmen in his party) or cobble together a new coalition. Either scenario would make a last-minute trade deal with the US far more difficult. It probably wasn't the Trump tariffs that really hurt the LDP, though. Two issues dominated news coverage of this election. The cost of living (rising prices and stagnant wages) was a constant theme, with the various parties either calling for tax cuts or handouts as a response. The LDP favoured the latter, with a mooted 20,000 yen (£100) payment to each citizen. This backfired, being seen as gimmicky, likely to make no difference, or even tantamount to a bribe. Then there was the issue of foreigners in Japan. This has raised the eyebrows and heckles of many expats here and caught the attention and opprobrium of the wider world, but it is important to put it in context. Although Japan still has a relatively low level of immigration (only 3.8 million foreigners reside here out of a population of 127 million) that represents a 100 per cent increase on just 13 years ago. A feeling of nervousness among some, that Japan is heading in the direction of a western European style multiculturalism that nobody consented to, is perhaps understandable. That said, some of the rhetoric, especially from one of the election's winners, the Sanseito party (usually referred to as 'far right' or 'populist' but I refuse to use these prejudicial and increasingly meaningless terms – let's call them conservative) has been provocative. Sanseito's leader, a former supermarket manager and English teacher, Sohei Kamiya, has talked of a 'silent invasion'. Sanseito increased its Upper House presence from one to 14 seats. Sanseito describe themselves as a 'Japan first party' and Kamiya has vehemently denied that this means they are anti-foreigner, only that they wish to prioritise the Japanese and end what they call the 'preferential treatment of foreigners' without specifying where this supposedly occurs. With a record 37 million visitors in 2024, foreigners are a far more visible presence in the country, but a JNN (Japan News Network) TV poll found that only 6 per cent of citizens rated immigration as a key issue, so it is not clear that is where Sanseito's appeal really lies. Just as important, perhaps, was the continuing Japanese ennui with the LDP. Years of drift, a succession of uninspiring leaders, and many, many scandals (such as the revelation that most of the LDP were in cahoots with the exceedingly murky Unification church) seem to have finally induced at least some voters (it is important not to exaggerate, the LDP remain the largest party in Japan) to try something new. The problem is that there is nothing that is both new and wholly credible available. Sanseito may not quite deserve the demonisation of the establishment, but many see them as more of a highly energised protest party than a functioning vehicle for national renewal. They are not at the gonzo end of Japanese politics – they have a sophisticated membership and vote-gathering operation – but they are very much a work in progress. Much as with the Tories and Reform, at least when it first emerged, it is still entirely not clear if voters see Sanseito as the future, or as a way to send a message to the LDP, whose condition is difficult but perhaps not terminal, to get its act together. Japan does, however, need something new – or at least a significantly improved version of something old.
