Asking Eric: Friends didn't send my daughter a wedding gift
Dear Eric: My daughter got married a year ago and decided to have a wedding with immediate family members only due to the huge family on the groom's side (the wedding was still about 100 people). It was planned on the West Coast (we are on the East Coast).
Some of my friends sent them a gift, knowing why they were not invited but three of my close friends didn't send anything (even a card would have been thoughtful). I've sent their kids very generous gifts.
One, I couldn't attend (it was during Covid and the other was far away and very expensive to get to).
One of the other ones, we traveled to her daughter's wedding, spent a fortune to stay in a hotel and gave her a generous cash gift. I mean, really, nothing from her? She wouldn't have gone to the wedding if she had been invited. I'm so disappointed. I feel like even a small gift would have been nice. They have known my daughter since she was little. I'm having trouble letting it go. It just feels cheap. Some of my friends are shocked that they didn't do anything.
– Giftless
Dear Giftless: You're right, it would have been nice if they'd sent a gift. When it comes to children and grandchildren of friends, wedding gifts and other gestures for special occasions can become extensions of the central friendship. A gift to your kid is also (perhaps, primarily) a gift to you. So, I can see why this stings.
The answers to two questions might help de-escalate this situation.
First, did your daughter send out wedding announcements? Even if other people know about a wedding or other special event, it simply may not occur to them to send a gift without the trigger of a piece of cardstock in the mail. It's a weird system, perhaps, but an announcement can serve as an indication that the couple is open to gifts, and help guests figure out where to send them. Without it, life can get in the way and gifts can fall to the wayside.
So, if your friends didn't receive announcements, this may not be a one-to-one comparison with the weddings to which you were invited.
The second question is, does your daughter have any feelings about this? Often, in life's biggest events, the gifts you get feel so thoughtful and generous that one doesn't really think about the gifts that one didn't get. Is it possible that your daughter doesn't have the same expectations of your friends?
If so, you're still perfectly within your right to hold them to a different standard. But, for the sake of peace of mind, it's important to remember that everyone's expectations of themselves and of others are different.
Dear Eric: This is not an earth-shattering question, yet I'd appreciate an opinion. We
call our firstborn son by his middle name because his first is the same as his father's middle, who also goes by his middle name. This practice goes back generations on my husband's father's side. Imagine my confusion, years ago, when I learned of the tradition and discovered that our as-yet-unconceived son had already been given a first name (but we could choose the middle).
I've made my peace with the tradition despite its oddness (personal opinion). Now our son is going on four, ripe for learning and spelling his entire name and I'm worried he'll be confused and in turn confuse others when we try to explain that his real first name is actually his daddy's. I'm already cringing. I may or may not have noticed your name as an example of an elegant solution, but is it?
– Name Game
Dear Name: Well, the elegance of my nomenclature is up for debate. In high school, when I first started using my first initial, a teacher told me, 'Eric, there's a thin line between class and pretension.' Can you believe that? The audacity still makes me laugh and laugh.
Suffice it to say, your son will have plenty of opportunity to choose class, pretension or something else on his journey of self-expression. If you call him by his middle name, he may eventually choose to use his first. If you call him by his first name, he may choose his middle name. If he becomes a pop star later in life, he may choose a whole new name. All of those are just fine. But, for now, he'll be able to understand the concept of a full name and that some parts of the name are used conversationally and others aren't.
A name is an offering from a parent. And like all the myriad offerings of parenthood, one hopes that it is of use. But even if that use changes, it doesn't make it less valuable.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
8 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Asking Eric: Son suddenly cut me out of his life
Dear Eric: Five years ago, on Mother's Day, my adult son suddenly cut me out of his life. He told me he no longer wanted contact because he didn't like the way he was raised and considered me a negative presence. I didn't agree with his reasons, but I respected his choice. I've honored his no-contact request ever since. I've never reached out to him directly, except once early on to his wife, and when one of my grandchildren turned 18, I sent a short letter letting him know I loved him and that now he could choose for himself, as an adult, whether to have a relationship with me. I didn't hear back, but I plan to do the same for the others when they come of age. My question is: if I become terminally ill – or find myself on my deathbed – would it be wrong to send my son a letter asking if he'd want to be notified when the time comes? Or would that be crossing a line, even in the face of death? When I had cancer a few years ago, I didn't contact him, but I did tell my daughter to let him know if I passed. Thankfully, I made it through, but I know I'm living on borrowed time. – A Mother Who Still Loves Her Son Dear Mother: I'm sorry that it's come to this between you and your son. Estrangement is so hard and can be so confusing. I'm curious, however, if there's a deeper need that you're trying to address with this question. It's clear that your son's decision is painful and you feel helpless to fix it. And so, the mind naturally goes to a scenario that might get a response. But getting his permission to notify him in the event of your death is not going to fully satisfy you. What you're reaching for is a connection with your son. Or, at the least, reassurance that there is still something left in your relationship. Both are understandable. And I believe that's something you'll need to address in life. Your son doesn't need to give you permission to have someone notify him when you pass. It's also possible he wouldn't respond to that letter either, which would make you feel worse. Your daughter has already agreed to do it, and I can't see why she wouldn't follow through. Also, if you have a will, he'd be contacted by the executor of your estate. If you want to reset or repair your relationship because of your sense of borrowed time, you should. Now, that might involve some deeper soul-searching, some work with a counselor or some amends. And you have to go into acknowledging that your son still may not respond at all. But do the work you can in life; it will provide you more comfort. Dear Eric: When my husband and I disagree, the fight often comes down to him saying, 'You just look for reasons to be mad at me.' It is so demeaning to me. And it relieves him from responsibility: because if my grievances are simply imaginary, he doesn't need to do anything. We don't have many disagreements, but neither do we make progress when they happen. I wish for some more understanding. Can you provide some advice? – Tired of Fighting Dear Tired: You're right on the money: it takes any onus off of him and makes his behavior your responsibility, and your problem. It's helpful, in a calm moment, to communicate this to him using 'I' statements. Explain how it feels when he says it, and how you wish it to be different. Now, the big caveat is that you may say that even this is a reason you're finding to be mad at him. Here's the thing about being mad at a partner: sometimes you really don't have to go looking for it. And that can be OK – we're human; we don't always see eye to eye. But if he can't acknowledge your feelings as valid, even if he doesn't agree, he's giving you another reason to be mad. And worse, he's undermining you. This is an unhealthy way to argue. Many couples benefit from tackling this issue in couples' therapy. It may seem a little backwards to go into therapy with the stated desire to argue better. But therapy isn't always about getting you to a place where you never argue. It's about getting you to a place where, when arguments happen, they're rooted in clear, productive communication, so that you can move through it, rather than getting stuck in it. He's latching on to a narrative about you that is getting both of you stuck. Talking about your process for disagreement with a therapist will help untangle the narrative and write a new one.
Washington Post
9 hours ago
- Washington Post
Asking Eric: Mother unsure whether to contact estranged son
Dear Eric: Five years ago, on Mother's Day, my adult son suddenly cut me out of his life. He told me he no longer wanted contact because he didn't like the way he was raised and considered me a negative presence. I didn't agree with his reasons, but I respected his choice. I've honored his no-contact request ever since.
Business Insider
a day ago
- Business Insider
I quit my dream job to be a stay-at-home dad, while my wife works full time. It's the best arrangement for us.
Last year, I quit my dream job to be a stay-at-home dad while my wife worked full time. It was the best decision for our family, and I've loved every minute of it. My wife has always been the primary breadwinner of the family, so we decided I could step back from my career to work part time as a freelance writer and — most importantly — take care of our two little ones, a 3-year-old girl and a 5-year-old boy. It has been challenging in ways I couldn't have predicted, but I wouldn't have it any other way. We spent years trying to build two careers and a family I have been a healthcare journalist for nearly a decade, mostly working as a full-time editor or staff writer for various media companies. I have always loved this kind of work, and every new opportunity felt like a dream job. But everything started to change after my wife and I had our first kid at the end of 2019. The COVID-19 pandemic turned me into a work-from-home dad with a 4-month-old boy. I was suddenly a full-time editor and a full-time caretaker. In those days, my wife worked on the front lines of the pandemic as a physician assistant, while my son and I were trapped in a small two-bedroom apartment in New Rochelle, NY. It was the first time I had to suffer through the split focus of working and parenting full time. Even after the pandemic began to subside, my wife continued to work more than 50 hours a week at the hospital. So, I eventually settled into my role as a stay-at-home, work-from-home dad, with the help of grandparents and a local day care. But this was only the beginning of my work-life struggles. Working and caring for my kids only got more stressful By the end of 2022, a lot had changed for my family. We relocated to the Atlanta area. My wife took a new job at a local hospital that demanded slightly fewer hours. I landed an exciting new position as a medical reporter for a national publication, while our little girl was turning 1 year old. It was a happy time for our family, but the pressure to be a successful reporter and an always-available father started to become too much for me. Even though my wife's new role offered better hours, she still didn't have the flexibility to leave work at a moment's notice. We always knew it would be my responsibility to take care of any sudden, unexpected issues for the family. On sick days, I would balance trips to the pediatrician's office with phone interviews with sources. When holiday calendars between day care and work didn't match, I would serve snacks in between typing up paragraphs for my next article. It was a difficult balancing act. My new job required much of my mental energy, and the kids always needed more attention than I could give during workdays. It became clear that our family needed to make a change. It was time to put my family and my wife's career first After two years of balancing work and family needs with mixed success, my wife and I decided it was time for me to quit my job to focus on our family. The change had an immediate impact on all our lives. Now, I no longer have to split my attention between my kids and my work. When they get sick, I can drop everything to take them to the doctor, then bring them home to take care of them. I also have plenty of time to focus on chores to keep the house clean, cook healthy meals, and spend time with my kids and my wife without worrying about falling behind at work. I never have to worry about misaligned holiday schedules or hiding in my office to finish work assignments. It was nerve-racking to leave full-time employment after nine years, but after seven months of being a stay-at-home dad, I can't imagine doing it any other way.
