Analysis-Italy's referendum flop bolsters Meloni, reveals divide on left over citizenship
ROME (Reuters) -Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni snubbed a referendum on easing citizenship laws but has emerged stronger from the vote as the leftist opposition failed to mobilise mass opposition to her right-wing government after nearly three years in power.
A coalition of political parties, unions and civil society groups had promoted the five-question referendum. The proposals included halving the period of residence required to apply for Italian citizenship by naturalisation to five years from 10 as well as strengthening job protection rules.
The 'Yes' vote prevailed but only around 30% of eligible voters cast their ballots, far fewer than the required 50% plus one of the electorate needed for the referendum to be valid, meaning Meloni can ignore the results.
Key government ministers had encouraged their supporters to boycott the referendum while the opposition had hoped that a strong turnout could help build momentum in favour of political change and challenge Meloni's domination of Italian politics.
"It has been a big defeat for the left, that strengthens the government," said Antonio Tajani, the deputy prime minister and leader of Forza Italia party, one of the coalition parties.
Meloni, who took office in October 2022 at the head of a right-wing coalition, remains popular. A poll from SWG institute on Tuesday put her Brothers of Italy party at just above 30%, up from the 26% it won in a 2022 national election, while the main opposition centre-left Democratic Party (PD) was on 23%.
"This was an attempt to deal a blow (to the government) and it seems to me that it has failed. I think there was hope among the promoters of a stronger anti-Meloni mobilisation," said Lorenzo Pregliasco, from YouTrend polling agency.
YouTrend figures showed an average 12.9 million electors voted 'Yes' on the labour questions - slightly more than those who backed the centre-right coalition in 2022 - which the opposition hailed as the first building block of an alternative.
Italy's next national election is not scheduled until 2027.
DIVISION ON CITIZENSHIP RULES
Tallies showed differences in voting between the labour-related measures and the question about easing citizenship rules, which was far more contentious given Meloni's hard line against mass migration.
More than 85% of those who took part in the two-day vote backed stronger protection for workers but roughly a third opposed speeding up the procedures for gaining citizenship, indicating divisions also among progressive voters on the issue.
"There is a part of the more moderate left-wing electorate that does not share the (progressive) parties' positions on migrants. They are not against them, but they want laws that can limit entry and citizenship," said polling expert Antonio Noto.
Noto added that the data suggested some of Italy's right-leaning voters had defied calls from their parties' leaders to boycott the referendum and had likely helped boost the "No" vote on citizenship.
Pollsters say the wealthy centres of cities including Milan and Turin strongly backed reforming the citizenship rules, while the number decreased in the suburbs, indicating that lower-income voters are more conservative on the issue.
The failure of the referendum has dealt a major setback for groups fighting for the integration of migrants. Promoters complained of confusion and overlap with other issues, including the management of migratory flows and illegal arrivals.
"The lack of information and misinformation on the citizenship question certainly affected the result, in terms of abstentions and votes against," said Anna Lisa Mandorino, who heads civil rights group Cittadinanzattiva.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
28 minutes ago
- The Hill
7 in 10 fear AI causing permanent job loss: Poll
More than 7 in 10 Americans are concerned that the improvements within artificial intelligence (AI) will spark permanent job losses for a large number of people in the U.S., according to a new poll that was released Tuesday. The new Reuters/Ipsos survey found that 71 percent of U.S. adults are worried that AI will put 'too many people out of work permanently.' The large majority of respondents, 77 percent, said they have concerns that, as AI technology improves, it could be utilized to provoke political turmoil. Americans also have reservations about the government's potential use of AI in warfare, according to the survey. Nearly half of Americans, 48 percent, said the federal government should never utilize AI to locate a potential target of a military attack. Around a quarter, 24 percent, said that the government should use AI to locate targets for military strikes, while another 28 percent were not sure when asked. Other topics respondents were polled about include energy and interpersonal relationship concerns. More than 6 in 10 Americans, 61 percent, have expressed concerns about the amount of electricity necessary to power AI. Around two-thirds of Americans in the survey said they are concerned people will flee relationships with other individuals and pivot to relationships with digital AI characters. On the education front, respondents were split on whether AI will help improve the field. About 4 in 10, 40 percent, said that AI will not improve education, while another 36 percent argued it will. Some 24 percent were not sure when asked. A January survey from the World Economic Forum's (WEF) 'Future of Jobs Report' found that 41 percent of employers worldwide said they are likely to cut jobs as AI continues to improve. The Reuters/Ipsos poll was conducted among 4,446 Americans and had a margin of error of around two percentage points.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
India's complex GST tax and how Modi's reform will make goods cheaper
(Refiles to remove duplicated word and fixes a grammatical error in first paragraph.) By Nikunj Ohri NEW DELHI (Reuters) -Prime Minister Narendra Modi has proposed India's biggest tax reform in eight years to lower consumption levies on everyday goods and small cars from October, in a move seen as boosting his image amid trade tensions with Washington. The structure of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) is complex, with states and the federal government sharing the revenue collected. Here are details of the tax system and the planned reform: WHAT IS THE GOODS AND SERVICES TAX (GST)? India adopted the GST in 2017, sweeping in more than a dozen domestic state taxes in a bid to unify the economy on the principle of "one nation, one tax, one market". It was hailed as the biggest tax reform since independence from Britain in 1947. The new system had four tax slabs, of 5%, 12%, 18% and 28%, with scores of goods in each category. An additional levy was imposed above the tax of 28% on some items, such as cigarettes, luxury cars and high-end motorcycles. But it was criticised for being too complex. Pre-packaged salted popcorn is taxed at 12%, but caramel one at 18%, India said last year, triggering a dispute in which one online user questioned how a "salt caramel" variant would be taxed. Similarly, plain Indian flatbreads attract a 5% tax, but the flaky, multi-layered variety faces a levy of 18%. WHAT'S THE REFORM ALL ABOUT? The government plans to abolish the 28% slab that applied to products such as cars, air-conditioners and refrigerators. About 99% of products now taxed at 12%, such as butter, fruit juices, and dry fruit, would also shift into the 5% bracket. Reuters has reported small cars will be taxed at 18% down from 28% earlier. India collected $224 billion last year from the levies. IDFC First Bank says the new reform will hit government collections by $20 billion. WHICH SECTORS AND COMPANIES COULD BENEFIT? Taxes are likely to be lower on personal care items such as hair oil and toothpaste. Taxes on construction goods like cement could also be lowered, boosting demand for homes and infrastructure. Prices of air conditioners, televisions and refrigerators are also likely to be slashed as tax rates fall, benefiting manufacturers such as Samsung and LG Electronics. WHAT IS THE MACROECONOMIC IMPACT? The 18% category contributed the most - 67% - to GST collection, and that will not change. The tax cuts would damp inflationary pressures, and boost he chances for further interest rate cuts by the central bank, economists say. However, they are expected to boost consumption, which contributes roughly 60% of India's GDP. IDFC FIRST estimates India's nominal GDP increasing by 0.6 percentage points over 12 months. IS IT A DONE DEAL? No. Making changes to the GST framework is not easy. The plan will need approval from the GST Council, chaired by Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman and with representation from all Indian states, before it can roll out nationwide. Economists estimate tax cuts will affect state government finances more than the federal government, as goods and services tax form a large part of their revenues. In the past, states have pushed back on fixing rates on casinos, lotteries and online gaming. Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Zohran Mamdani supporters unfazed by Trump's 'communist' label, defend the candidate's affordability fight
Since Zohran Mamdani's primary upset earlier this summer, the New York City Democratic mayoral nominee has been branded a "communist" by President Donald Trump. Mamdani supporters, who spoke to Fox News Digital at a canvass launch in Prospect Park on Sunday, dismissed the term, arguing that his primary win represented more than arbitrary labels. "It's not necessarily communism that won the New York City primary, but the vision that he's delivering for a more affordable New York," Nina, a door-knocker wearing an "Educators for Zohran" T-shirt, said. "That's what people voted for, and that's what he won on, and that's what he's going to win on." Mamdani is a self-described democratic socialist who has been endorsed by progressive leaders, including Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y. Trump was quick to label him a "100% Communist Lunatic" after Mamdani declared victory in June. Zohran Mamdani Launches Anti-trump Tour Across Five Boroughs In New York City Perry, another Brooklyn canvasser, flipped the script on Trump's nickname for Mamdani, telling Fox News Digital to "look at the people who are saying he can't do it or who are calling him a socialist or communist." Read On The Fox News App Ny Dems Who Have Yet To Endorse Mamdani Unite In His Defense Against Trump Bridget, a New York City teacher, and Perry both shook their heads in disagreement when asked if those labels worry them. "It's not about ideology," Nicholas, a Mamdani supporter who volunteered in Prospect Park on Sunday for the campaign's canvass launch, said. "It's not trying to demonize these terms, communism and socialism, which, quite frankly, I think the American public does not have a very good idea of what those terms exactly mean." Nicholas said Mamdani's campaign is "much bigger than that." Among the few dozen supporters who attended the canvass launch, many were teachers. "I want a mayor who's going to stand up for students," Bridget said, telling Fox News Digital that it's critical New York City has a mayor who is "going to fight against the Trump administration for the rights and safety of our students." Mamdani concluded his "Five Boroughs Against Trump" tour across New York City last week, visiting a borough a day to spotlight how the Trump administration's sweeping second-term agenda, on key issues including immigration and the economy, is impacting everyday New Yorkers. "I have a lot of students coming from immigrant backgrounds who are worried about their safety, about their parents' safety," Nicholas said. "I have kids who are worried that ICE agents will come into the school and take them out of the classroom." Nicholas explained that's why having a candidate like Mamdani, who is committed to protecting immigrant communities from "what Trump and his cronies are trying to do, in disappearing people," is so important to him. "Having a mayor who stands up against that firmly and boldly, that's why I'm out here," he added. "That's why I want Zohran to be mayor." Perry said she supports Mamdani because he "has a large vision for the city," particularly on housing. "Let's be big again," Perry added, telling Fox News Digital that she loves his "upbeatness" and "openness," the likes of which she said, "We haven't seen in a while." Mamdani has vowed to freeze rents if elected this November. He has accused Adams of appointing Rent Guidelines Board members to raise rents on stabilized apartments. Former Mayor Bill de Blasio's board voted to freeze the rent three times during his tenure. Former Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who lost the primary to Mamadani, called the socialist's plan to freeze rent "politically convenient posture," and said such a move would hurt landlords, who would be "unable to maintain their buildings." Nina said Mamdani's campaign promises, including fast and free buses and universal child care, "address the affordability crisis in New York City" that creates a trickle-down impact on New Yorkers, like her high school students. "I'm out here as an educator," Nina said. "I'm here as a New Yorker who was raised here, who wants to stay here." Under Mamdani's leadership, Nina said she believes it's article source: Zohran Mamdani supporters unfazed by Trump's 'communist' label, defend the candidate's affordability fight Solve the daily Crossword
