'A scrap of paper': Philippine VP Duterte wants impeachment complaint dismissed
Philippine Vice-President Sara Duterte has described the impeachment complaint against her as "nothing more than a scrap of paper" in her formal response to the Senate, saying the case was baseless and should be dismissed for being unconstitutional.
The impeachment, widely seen as a test of political alliances, comes amid an acrimonious falling out between Duterte and President Ferdinand Marcos Jr that has sparked a broader power struggle ahead of the 2028 presidential election.
Marcos, who has distanced himself from the case, is limited to a single term but is expected to groom a successor to run. Duterte, the daughter of former President Rodrigo Duterte, is viewed as a strong rival contender if she avoids impeachment.
"The Vice-President enters a plea of not guilty, without waiving any of her jurisdictional and other objections over the charges," Duterte said in a submission dated June 23.
She dismissed the accusations against her as baseless, calling them "exaggerations and speculations that are not supported by evidence" in the 34-page response to the Senate. In February, the House of Representatives voted to impeach Duterte for betrayal of public trust and high crimes, sending the case to the Senate. On June 11, the Senate returned the case to the House shortly after convening as an impeachment court. The Senate also ordered Duterte to respond to the allegations in the case, including that she had plotted to assassinate Marcos and others based on a statement she made in November about hiring an assassin.
She is also accused of misusing public funds both as vice president and during her stint as education secretary.
As well as saying there was nothing substantive for her to answer in the case, Duterte argued the impeachment complaint was the fourth filed against her, with the three earlier ones not acted on by the lower house. This, she said, violated a constitutional safeguard against more than one impeachment proceeding against the same official within a year, reiterating the arguments she used in asking the Supreme Court to dismiss the complaint. That case is ongoing.
"There are no statements of ultimate facts in the Fourth Impeachment complaint. Stripped of its 'factual' and legal conclusions, it is nothing more than a scrap of paper," Duterte's reply said.
She faces a lifetime political ban if convicted.
Congresswoman Gerville Luistro, a member of the impeachment prosecution panel, confirmed the lower house had received Duterte's reply to the Senate on Monday.
"The entire prosecution team is currently studying each and every allegation contained in the answer. Certainly, we will be filing a reply within 5 days from receipt as provided in the rules," Luistro said in a phone message.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
UAE Moments
12 hours ago
- UAE Moments
AFP on Standby to Help Repatriate Pinoys from Israel & Iran
The Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) has confirmed it is ready to assist with the possible repatriation of Filipinos from Israel and Iran as tensions continue in the region. Monitoring Situation Closely AFP spokesperson Colonel Francel Margareth Padilla said on Tuesday that the military is closely monitoring developments related to the Iran-Israel conflict. She noted that while the situation is evolving, the AFP is prepared to mobilize immediately if ordered. 'Should the need arise, the AFP stands ready to assist as directed,' Padilla said during a press briefing at Villamor Air Base in Pasay City. Coordination with Government Agencies Padilla stressed that the military will work closely with other government agencies once President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. issues the official directive for evacuation. 'With the President at the helm, we are ready to act swiftly and in sync with other agencies,' she said. 'All of our assets are ready for deployment depending on the mandate.' Voluntary Repatriation in Progress The Philippine government is currently processing around 200 voluntary repatriations. Migrant Workers Secretary Hans Leo Cacdac is in Jordan to assist Filipinos traveling home from nearby conflict zones. President Marcos Jr. earlier reiterated that repatriation from Israel and Iran remains voluntary at this stage. Thousands of Filipinos in Affected Regions According to the Department of Migrant Workers (DMW), there are approximately 30,000 overseas Filipino workers in Israel and around 1,180 in Iran, most of whom are married to Iranian nationals. The AFP has a history of assisting in the evacuation of Filipinos during international crises and stands ready to do so again, should the situation escalate.
Khaleej Times
12 hours ago
- Khaleej Times
'A scrap of paper': Philippine VP Duterte wants impeachment complaint dismissed
Philippine Vice-President Sara Duterte has described the impeachment complaint against her as "nothing more than a scrap of paper" in her formal response to the Senate, saying the case was baseless and should be dismissed for being unconstitutional. The impeachment, widely seen as a test of political alliances, comes amid an acrimonious falling out between Duterte and President Ferdinand Marcos Jr that has sparked a broader power struggle ahead of the 2028 presidential election. Marcos, who has distanced himself from the case, is limited to a single term but is expected to groom a successor to run. Duterte, the daughter of former President Rodrigo Duterte, is viewed as a strong rival contender if she avoids impeachment. "The Vice-President enters a plea of not guilty, without waiving any of her jurisdictional and other objections over the charges," Duterte said in a submission dated June 23. She dismissed the accusations against her as baseless, calling them "exaggerations and speculations that are not supported by evidence" in the 34-page response to the Senate. In February, the House of Representatives voted to impeach Duterte for betrayal of public trust and high crimes, sending the case to the Senate. On June 11, the Senate returned the case to the House shortly after convening as an impeachment court. The Senate also ordered Duterte to respond to the allegations in the case, including that she had plotted to assassinate Marcos and others based on a statement she made in November about hiring an assassin. She is also accused of misusing public funds both as vice president and during her stint as education secretary. As well as saying there was nothing substantive for her to answer in the case, Duterte argued the impeachment complaint was the fourth filed against her, with the three earlier ones not acted on by the lower house. This, she said, violated a constitutional safeguard against more than one impeachment proceeding against the same official within a year, reiterating the arguments she used in asking the Supreme Court to dismiss the complaint. That case is ongoing. "There are no statements of ultimate facts in the Fourth Impeachment complaint. Stripped of its 'factual' and legal conclusions, it is nothing more than a scrap of paper," Duterte's reply said. She faces a lifetime political ban if convicted. Congresswoman Gerville Luistro, a member of the impeachment prosecution panel, confirmed the lower house had received Duterte's reply to the Senate on Monday. "The entire prosecution team is currently studying each and every allegation contained in the answer. Certainly, we will be filing a reply within 5 days from receipt as provided in the rules," Luistro said in a phone message.
Khaleej Times
a day ago
- Khaleej Times
Philippine VP Duterte responds to impeachment trial summons
Philippine Vice-President Sara Duterte r esponded Monday to her Senate impeachment trial summons hours before the deadline, demanding the case against her be dropped. The House of Representatives impeached Duterte in early February on charges of graft, corruption and an alleged assassination plot against one-time ally and former running mate President Ferdinand Marcos. A guilty verdict in the Senate would result in her removal from office and permanent disqualification from politics. A copy of Duterte's reply to the summons delivered by messenger to House prosecutors on Monday afternoon called the complaint against her an abuse of the impeachment process. "There are no statements of ultimate facts in the (impeachment complaint). Stripped of its 'factual' and legal conclusions, it is nothing more than a scrap of paper," the response read. It goes on to deny the allegations made against her as "false" and state that the Senate's decision to remand the case to the House earlier this month removed her responsibility to answer them. Duterte is currently on a trip to Australia where she is meeting with Filipino supporters. Her summons was issued on June 10 after an hours-long Senate session that saw lawmakers convene as an impeachment court only to send the case back to the House, a decision one lawmaker called a "functional dismissal". Barely 24 hours later, the House complied with the senior body's order to "certify" the constitutionality of the impeachment. Duterte allies in the Senate had argued that earlier complaints heard in the House without a vote counted as multiple impeachment hearings within a single year, a violation of the country's 1987 constitution. House prosecutors now have five days to respond to the vice president's answers. Her trial is not expected to start until the new Senate convenes on July 28.
